The last video taken of Madeleine McCann.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Please feel free to expand on that theme.

Why?  What’s to discuss?

[jassi]

Why?  What’s to discuss?

I got the impression that you thought there, but that it was being ignored. Why mention it otherwise?

[jassi]

The thread wasn't about Maddie, but whether the video clips were recorded with a mobile phone. That was resolved early on and then the thread wandered - as they do.

[Robittybob1]

The thread wasn't about Maddie, but whether the video clips were recorded with a mobile phone. That was resolved early on and then the thread wandered - as they do.

They are allowed to wander as long as they don't go off topic!

[Brietta]

As the children stumble on their way up the aircraft steps two booms can be heard ... appx 0:09 ... in my opinion not what would have been heard as part of an original recording.

[faithlilly]

As the children stumble on their way up the aircraft steps two booms can be heard ... appx 0:09 ... in my opinion not what would have been heard as part of an original recording.

That is definitely Gerry’s voice.

[Brietta]

That is definitely Gerry’s voice.

What a terribly strange response to my post ... "As the children stumble on their way up the aircraft steps two booms can be heard ... appx 0:09 ... in my opinion not what would have been heard as part of an original recording."

"BOOM!"  "BOOM!"  Quite clearly a sound effect.  Did even that sound Glaswegian to you?

[Robittybob1]

That is definitely Gerry’s voice.

Saying what?

[G-Unit]

What a terribly strange response to my post ... "As the children stumble on their way up the aircraft steps two booms can be heard ... appx 0:09 ... in my opinion not what would have been heard as part of an original recording."

"BOOM!"  "BOOM!"  Quite clearly a sound effect.  Did even that sound Glaswegian to you?

Was Basil Brush with them?

[faithlilly]

What a terribly strange response to my post ... "As the children stumble on their way up the aircraft steps two booms can be heard ... appx 0:09 ... in my opinion not what would have been heard as part of an original recording."

"BOOM!"  "BOOM!"  Quite clearly a sound effect.  Did even that sound Glaswegian to you?

Not strange at all. I watched the video and commented on the dialogue. What is strange about that ? That I ignored your attempt to further suggest that the video had somehow been tampered with is my attempt to spare the forum more speculation without substance.

That you find a sound suspicious when in all the hubbub of getting on a plane it more than likely has a very rational explanation is strange to me. You are desperately trying to convince members that the video has somehow been tampered with when there is not a scintilla of evidence that it was.

[Robittybob1]

As the children stumble on their way up the aircraft steps two booms can be heard ... appx 0:09 ... in my opinion not what would have been heard as part of an original recording.

That is the sound of Madeleine foot and knee hitting the stairs IMO.  What makes you think otherwise?

[Brietta]

That is the sound of Madeleine foot and knee hitting the stairs IMO.  What makes you think otherwise?

I don't know what the two clear "BOOMS" are intended to signify but in my opinion they are foreign to any original soundtrack if one ever existed.
Just listen to it very carefully.

[slartibartfast]

I don't know what the two clear "BOOMS" are intended to signify but in my opinion they are foreign to any original soundtrack if one ever existed.
Just listen to it very carefully.

You are making myths, IMO

[Brietta]

You are making myths, IMO

Your opinion and mine seldom coincide particularly where the facts re concerned.  It is my opinion that the two 'booms' heard on the soundtrack as the girls stumble on the stair is not an original soundtrack but is an addition to it and listening to it is sufficient to endorse that view.

[faithlilly]

Your opinion and mine seldom coincide particularly where the facts re concerned.  It is my opinion that the two 'booms' heard on the soundtrack as the girls stumble on the stair is not an original soundtrack but is an addition to it and listening to it is sufficient to endorse that view.

Not sure why you think the booms prove the soundtrack is not authentic. Surely even you can appreciate that while individuals are boarding a plane and baggage being loaded there is multiple reasons why you would hear loud noises.

Why do you find it so difficult to believe that Gerry did actually swear ? Surely that’s a more logical explanation than the added soundtrack conspiracy you are trying to push ? It does however explain your behaviour. If you can’t stomach the idea that Gerry would swear, hearing that he may have been involved in his daughter’s disappearance must bring you to apoplexy.