The last video taken of Madeleine McCann.

[G-Unit]

I provided a link to the photo in the files.The request was not for the provenance of said photo.
Perhaps you would provide the relevant links to all the holiday photos uploaded by Gerry onto disc & given to the PJ - or is their absence from the files proof that none exist?

You did indeed. I just clarified it's provenance. I think the link you are requesting was also provided; the holiday photos from the CD's are certainly in the files.

[misty]

AFAIK neither photograph was given to the PJ when the other photos were handed over by Gerry McCann and Michael Wright on or around 9th May 2007;
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/HOLIDAY-PHOTOS-LIST.htm

You don't actually know that or indeed when the PJ obtained all the photos from Kate's camera.

[misty]

Thank you Misty, do you have the last photo link too? 

I haven't seen a copy of the last photo in the files.

[G-Unit]

You don't actually know that or indeed when the PJ obtained all the photos from Kate's camera.

I know that the holiday photos were given to the PJ on two CD's just before the second round of interviews. I have seen nothing to suggest that any other photos were handed in.

[G-Unit]

The facts as I see them.

28th May 2007. The Yorkshire Post announces the release of the mobile phone footage and describes it. The soundtrack is mentioned and described.

At some point two videos are placed on You Tube. One has the soundtrack described and the other doesn't.

It makes sense to deduce that the video had a soundtrack originally but it was removed subsequently.

[Erngath]

The facts as I see them.

28th May 2007. The Yorkshire Post announces the release of the mobile phone footage and describes it. The soundtrack is mentioned and described.

At some point two videos are placed on You Tube. One has the soundtrack described and the other doesn't.

It makes sense to deduce that the video had a soundtrack originally but it was removed subsequently.

There does seem to be some dubiety about the soundtrack.
My own take on it is that the person speaking as Madeleine trips is most certainly not Gerry and I am not yet convinced that the expletive is in a Glaswegian accent.
Further to that, I do wonder that a father who corrected his little daughter when she said huhah would then use such an expletive in front of her.

[G-Unit]

There does seem to be some dubiety about the soundtrack.
My own take on it is that the person speaking as Madeleine trips is most certainly not Gerry and I am not yet convinced that the expletive is in a Glaswegian accent.
Further to that, I do wonder that a father who corrected his little daughter when she said huhah would then use such an expletive in front of her.

There's plenty of 'dubiety' but no evidence, just opinions.

[faithlilly]

There does seem to be some dubiety about the soundtrack.
My own take on it is that the person speaking as Madeleine trips is most certainly not Gerry and I am not yet convinced that the expletive is in a Glaswegian accent.
Further to that, I do wonder that a father who corrected his little daughter when she said huhah would then use such an expletive in front of her.

And it doesn’t bother you that the source of the video being questioned is Reuters ?

[Sunny]

There does seem to be some dubiety about the soundtrack.
My own take on it is that the person speaking as Madeleine trips is most certainly not Gerry and I am not yet convinced that the expletive is in a Glaswegian accent.
Further to that, I do wonder that a father who corrected his little daughter when she said huhah would then use such an expletive in front of her.

The person that speaks when Madeleine falls is David Payne not Gerry.

[Eleanor]

Absolute rubbish. She does however at best turn a blind eye to abuse dished out to others and at the worst is  the instigator of much of it.

I will not have abuse of a Senior Moderator and will delete any such.  Nor will I tolerate any further insults from anyone.  I will delete any comment in full if it contains an insult to anyone.  So don't waste your time hiding behind some sort of spurious comment.

[G-Unit]

The person that speaks when Madeleine falls is David Payne not Gerry.

I watched and thought it was his daughter who kind of goes down first in fact.

[Brietta]

And it doesn’t bother you that the source of the video being questioned is Reuters ?

Actually the source ... and owner ... of the video, is not Reuters.

[faithlilly]

Actually the source ... and owner ... of the video, is not Reuters.

The video is reposted but the original source of the video is most certainly Reuters. Further the soundtrack mirrors exactly the soundtrack detailed in the Yorkshire Post.

[Robittybob1]

The facts as I see them.

28th May 2007. The Yorkshire Post announces the release of the mobile phone footage and describes it. The soundtrack is mentioned and described.

At some point two videos are placed on You Tube. One has the soundtrack described and the other doesn't.

It makes sense to deduce that the video had a soundtrack originally but it was removed subsequently.

I can accept that as being most likely.

[Brietta]

The video is reposted but the original source of the video is most certainly Reuters. Further the soundtrack mirrors exactly the soundtrack detailed in the Yorkshire Post.

I really do not understand your reasoning here.

Please explain in which way the source of the video is Reuters?