Eleven years on, has Maddie been given up for dead?

[Brietta]

I agree that neither the Policia Judiciaria or Scotland Yard have 'given up' on Madeleine.  In my opinion that is self evident.

In my opinion had she not been written off with so much indecent haste in 2007 her story might well have had a different outcome at that time.

[Angelo222]

In the McCann case it appears to be to spend eleven million quid but not look at everything that has gone on.  It will be very interesting to hear what the PJ have to say about my own Investigations into criminal conduct post disappearance.

ETA. I wouldn't waste my time asking the Met to look into them given what we already know.

[Robittybob1]

In the McCann case it appears to be to spend eleven million quid but not look at everything that has gone on.  It will be very interesting to hear what the PJ have to say about my own Investigations into criminal conduct post disappearance.

ETA. I wouldn't waste my time asking the Met to look into them given what we already know.

Sounds interesting.  Have you told the forum about it at all?

[Mr Gray]

In the McCann case it appears to be to spend eleven million quid but not look at everything that has gone on.  It will be very interesting to hear what the PJ have to say about my own Investigations into criminal conduct post disappearance.

ETA. I wouldn't waste my time asking the Met to look into them given what we already know.

It will be very interesting to hear what they have to say... I agree... When do you intend to ask them

Eta... I would think you would get the same answer from both... Subject to correct translation

[John]

Redwood said it was his belief that Madeleine had been taken by a stranger.

Redwood was probably correct in that assertion, however, the question arises as to where this stranger encountered the child and the evidence here points only one way.

[barrier]

Redwood said it was his belief that Madeleine had been taken by a stranger.

Four years on yet to be proved right,11 yrs on from Amarals theory which is yet to be proved wrong,c'est la vie.

[Mr Gray]

Four years on yet to be proved right,11 yrs on from Amarals theory which is yet to be proved wrong,c'est la vie.

No one has to prove him wrong... The onus of proof is on him.. And he cant... But he thought he could.

[faithlilly]

I wonder when we’ll hear from Nicola Wall ?

[Venturi Swirl]

I wonder when we’ll hear from Nicola Wall ?

2108

[barrier]

Snip
Scotland Yard is calling for the investigation into Madeleine McCann's disappearance to be reopened, as detectives revealed there is evidence to suggest she might be alive.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/apr/25/madeleine-mccann-case-reopen-call

IMO that evidence obviously never lead any where with Rowley last April unable to confirm if she was dead or alive,but just remember the crock of ***** offered by the newspapers.

Mark Rowley:There are odd headlines and odd stories in newspapers on a regular basis and most of those are nonsense.

[Mr Gray]

IMO that evidence obviously never lead any where with Rowley last April unable to confirm if she was dead or alive,but just remember the crock of **** offered by the newspapers.

Mark Rowley:There are odd headlines and odd stories in newspapers on a regular basis and most of those are nonsense.

Snip
Scotland Yard is calling for the investigation into Madeleine McCann's disappearance to be reopened, as detectives revealed there is evidence to suggest she might be alive.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/apr/25/madeleine-mccann-case-reopen-call

SY said maddie may still be alive...they cannot say either way....you can speculate as much as you wish....we will know more when grange ends...but what we do know is that both investigations have clearly stated the mccanns are not suspects

[barrier]

SY said maddie may still be alive...they cannot say either way....you can speculate as much as you wish....we will know more when grange ends...but what we do know is that both investigations have clearly stated the mccanns are not suspects

Nor is any one else,so hardly a unique position.

[Mr Gray]

Nor is any one else,so hardly a unique position.

you seem to underestimate the importance of the stateemnt by PDC  and Grange

[Miss Taken Identity]

Redwood was probably correct in that assertion, however, the question arises as to where this stranger encountered the child and the evidence here points only one way.

ah but that evidence doesn't fit with the McCanns version of the whoooshing big drama event

[Venturi Swirl]

I choose not to accept posters on here assertion's that there is evidence.

Same difference. IMO There IS evidence whether you take my word for it or not, the proof of this is that this is the line Op Grange is taking.