UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on April 10, 2015, 11:53:17 PM
-
Of course we have discussed at length what Redwood and company may or may not have done to discover Madeleine's fate. However from 2007 until 2011 at least 3 private detective agencies costing probably close to two million pounds had been employed by the McCanns to the same end and yet the evidence available seems to tell us that there was very little achieved in that time to find the child.
Did the organisations employed bring anything to the case or was their employment merely an ill-advised use of precious funds ?
-
Considering that it provided the McCanns with plenty of PR opportunities, without actually finding anything, it might be considered to have been an excellent use of funds.
-
Of course we have discussed at length what Redwood and company may or may not have done to discover Madeleine's fate. However from 2007 until 2011 at least 3 private detective agencies costing probably close to two million pounds had been employed by the McCanns to the same end and yet the evidence available seems to tell us that there was very little achieved in that time to find the child.
Did the organisations employed bring anything to the case or was their employment merely an ill-advised use of precious funds ?
It's like the billions of pounds spent on ill patients who eventually die..is that a waste
-
It's like the billions of pounds spent on ill patients who eventually die..is that a waste
...or the billions spent on bogus remedies every year?
-
Worth every penny when one considers the hours and hours of endless pleasure people have had using them as another opportunity to criticise Madeleine McCann's parents and ... the fund ... who really cares if using them has saved time by eliminating avenues of investigation for the present professional teams to follow ... who cares if their investigations have indicated possible avenues to the professional investigators who where given their files.
-
The disgrace of the situation is that it was ever necessary to employ PIs in the first instance.
Madeleine McCann's human rights were denied when her case was archived and the official search for her suspended.
-
The disgrace of the situation is that it was ever necessary to employ PIs in the first instance.
Madeleine McCann's human rights were denied when her case was archived and the official search for her suspended.
The parents didn't need to hire PI's. All they had to do was to cooperate with the police investigation.
You seem to forget that Madeleine's parents did nothing to stop the case from being shelved and I believe that Kate even said that they were even relieved when it was archived. Any of the arguidos could have asked for the "fase de instrução" and none did.
-
The parents didn't need to hire PI's. All they had to do was to cooperate with the police investigation.
You seem to forget that Madeleine's parents did nothing to stop the case from being shelved and I believe that Kate even said that they were even relieved when it was archived. Any of the arguidos could have asked for the "fase de instrução" and none did.
I'm unclear why misleading statements that demean the McCanns are allowed.
The McCanns were never in a position to stop the case from being shelved.
All leads were (considered) exhausted.
The McCanns fought hard for a second enquiry, and were ultimately successful in that.
-
The parents didn't need to hire PI's. All they had to do was to cooperate with the police investigation.
You seem to forget that Madeleine's parents did nothing to stop the case from being shelved and I believe that Kate even said that they were even relieved when it was archived. Any of the arguidos could have asked for the "fase de instrução" and none did.
Why was the case archived by the Portuguese authorities? Don't give me the utterly ridiculous one of the 'reconstitution' ... it didn't hold water at the time ... and at this remove it holds even less.
-
All the P.I.'s employed were wastes of space.
If the people who donated their hard earned money to the mccanns had known what it was goiung to be used for and wasted upon, the coffers would have been empty.
-
Just another bash the McCann thread by the troof seekers because the McCanns have been ruled out by SY
-
All the P.I.'s employed were wastes of space.
If the people who donated their hard earned money to the mccanns had known what it was goiung to be used for and wasted upon, the coffers would have been empty.
So the Drs McCann's and their friends shouldn't have bothered putting the money awarded for the scurrilous press coverage they received into Madeleine's fund ... oh well then, that's your opinion and you are entitled to it.
However the fact that Operation Grange chose to utilise the work provided by the Private Investigators rather flies in the face of your first sentences.
Op Grange Remit
The support and expertise proffered by the Commissioner will be provided by the Homicide & Serious Crime Command - SCD1.
The activity, in the first instance, will be that of an ‘investigative review’. This will entail a review of the whole of the investigation(s) which have been conducted in to the circumstances of Madeleine McCann’s disappearance.
The focus of the review will be of the material held by three main stakeholders (and in the following order of primacy);
The Portuguese Law Enforcement agencies.
UK Law Enforcement agencies,
Other private investigative agencies/staff and organisations.
The investigative review is intended to collate, record and analyse what has gone before.
It is to examine the case and seek to determine, (as if the abduction occurred in the UK) what additional, new investigative approaches we would take and which can assist the Portuguese authorities in progressing the matter. Whilst ordinarily a review has no investigative remit whatsoever- the scale and extent of this enquiry cannot permit for such an approach. It will take too long to progress to any “action stage” if activity is given wholly and solely to a review process.
The ‘investigative review’ will be conducted with transparency, openness and thoroughness.
The work will be overseen through the Gold Group management structure, which will also manage the central relationships with other key stakeholders and provide continuing oversight and direction to the investigative remit.
End
http://content.met.police.uk/Article/Operation-Grange/1400005508791/35434
-
Just another bash the McCann thread by the troof seekers because the McCanns have been ruled out by SY
I agree wholeheartedly. It is becoming tiresome as they have nothing new to add.
-
Worth every penny when one considers the hours and hours of endless pleasure people have had using them as another opportunity to criticise Madeleine McCann's parents and ... the fund ... who really cares if using them has saved time by eliminating avenues of investigation for the present professional teams to follow ... who cares if their investigations have indicated possible avenues to the professional investigators who where given their files.
What were those 'eliminated avenues of investigation ' Brietta. The sightings in Morocco that Meyodo3 attempted to buy or the request by Edgar for the forensic material to be subjected to the LCN technique. Of course he didn't seem to be aware this had already been done.
Of course there was the efits and report by Oakley but the McCanns didn't seem too keen that SY follow that "avenue of investigation'. In fact SY had to specifically ask for the report before they were granted access to it
-
So the Drs McCann's and their friends shouldn't have bothered putting the money awarded for the scurrilous press coverage they received into Madeleine's fund ... oh well then, that's your opinion and you are entitled to it.
However the fact that Operation Grange chose to utilise the work provided by the Private Investigators rather flies in the face of your first sentences.
Op Grange Remit
The support and expertise proffered by the Commissioner will be provided by the Homicide & Serious Crime Command - SCD1.
The activity, in the first instance, will be that of an ‘investigative review’. This will entail a review of the whole of the investigation(s) which have been conducted in to the circumstances of Madeleine McCann’s disappearance.
The focus of the review will be of the material held by three main stakeholders (and in the following order of primacy);
The Portuguese Law Enforcement agencies.
UK Law Enforcement agencies,
Other private investigative agencies/staff and organisations.
The investigative review is intended to collate, record and analyse what has gone before.
It is to examine the case and seek to determine, (as if the abduction occurred in the UK) what additional, new investigative approaches we would take and which can assist the Portuguese authorities in progressing the matter. Whilst ordinarily a review has no investigative remit whatsoever- the scale and extent of this enquiry cannot permit for such an approach. It will take too long to progress to any “action stage” if activity is given wholly and solely to a review process.
The ‘investigative review’ will be conducted with transparency, openness and thoroughness.
The work will be overseen through the Gold Group management structure, which will also manage the central relationships with other key stakeholders and provide continuing oversight and direction to the investigative remit.
End
http://content.met.police.uk/Article/Operation-Grange/1400005508791/35434
I asked what have the PIs added to the sum of our knowledge not did SY, understandably, include them in their review.
-
The fund is there to help the search for Madeleine and if the McCann's thought that once the case was shelved by the Portuguese police the way forward was to hire PI's then I really don't blame them for doing so using the fund money.
They were not to know they would be let down by them were they?
The PI's followed sightings, especially the one where they were tipped off about a man and a woman who visited an isolated building, they followed these people, they were seen buying clothes for a young child when they didn't have a young child of their own and childish drawings were found in a bin by the building.
It turned out to be a false lead, but then again they could have been hiding Madeleine.
They did do some investigating.
-
I agree wholeheartedly. It is becoming tiresome as they have nothing new to add.
Then why are you here Brietta ?
-
I asked what have the PIs added to the sum of our knowledge not did SY, understandably, included them in their review.
To answer that question we would need to have a running commentary on the case. We have been told from the beginning that we will not be getting one. IMO without being privy to a great deal more information than is available - no-one can answer your question.
-
To answer that question we would need to have a running commentary on the case. We have been told from the beginning that we will not be getting one. IMO without being privy to a great deal more information than is available - no-one can answer your question.
I don't think I have ever heard of a police investigation into a missing child being deplored as this one is or being subject to so many FOI requests with attendant demands for a blow by blow account for evidence while an investigation is under way.
-
To answer that question we would need to have a running commentary on the case. We have been told from the beginning that we will not be getting one. IMO without being privy to a great deal more information than is available - no-one can answer your question.
Omitted from my previous post ...
Has there ever been a missing child case which was shelved or archived within two years?
In how many other cases of missing children has it been incumbent on the child's parents to employ PIs to look for him/her?
-
Just another bash the McCann thread by the troof seekers because the McCanns have been ruled out by SY
No, just more hysterics on this thread from the mccann supporters.
-
Then why are you here Brietta ?
I think Brietta is quite right...it is becoming tiresome with the same things being trotted out time and time again. I'm looking forward to the result of the libel trial...SPs documentary...there will be some news from SY in the coming months...then I think the whole thing will start to fade away and end up like the amazon forum
-
To answer that question we would need to have a running commentary on the case. We have been told from the beginning that we will not be getting one. IMO without being privy to a great deal more information than is available - no-one can answer your question.
The PIs were in place four years before Operation Grange was instigated. What did they discover in those four years ?
Certainly not Jane Tanner's 'father with child'.
Nor Gail Cooper's 'charity man '.
Nor the ' Victoria Beckham' lookalike though to be fair it doesn't seem as if Edgar and co actually spent much time or energy investigating that one.
So what exactly did they uncover to justify the millions of pounds spent ?
-
I thought Metodo-3 were on the case before it was shelved?
-
No, just more hysterics on this thread from the mccann supporters.
What hysterics?
Can you answer this truthfully Stephen - If SY were going down the same route as Amaral, and was going to investigate the McCann's as having been guilty of the involvement in their daughters disappearance would the millions of pounds spent be an annoyance to you? Would you want them to end the investigation?
-
The PIs were in place four years before Operation Grange was instigated. What did they discover in those four years ?
Certainly not Jane Tanner's 'father with child'.
Nor Gail Cooper's 'charity man '.
Nor the ' Victoria Beckham' lookalike though to be fair it doesn't seem as if Edgar and co actually spent much time or energy investigating that one.
So what exactly did they uncover to justify the millions of pounds spent ?
I don't know and neither do you or anyone else. We can only speculate. For instance how many 'leads' were followed up and ruled out etc? The work they carried out may well have reduced the workload that SY would have been faced with - had it not been for the PI's contribution.
You appear to be criticising them for following up leads which came to nothing. Isn't that what detectives/policemen do all the time as normal procedure during their investigations? i.e. investigate and eliminate etc etc. They can't see into the future.
Hindsight has 20/20 vision - and IMO this thread is yet another example of it being used merely to find fault.
The only outcome which could have been guaranteed beforehand is if no re-investigations at all had taken place - but then that would have removed all hope of finding out what happened to Madeleine. She deserves better than that IMO.
-
I don't know and neither do you or anyone else. We can only speculate. For instance how many 'leads' were followed up and ruled out etc? The work they carried out may well have reduced the workload that SY would have been faced with - had it not been for the PI's contribution.
You appear to be criticising them for following up leads which came to nothing. Isn't that what detectives/policemen do all the time as normal procedure during their investigations? i.e. investigate and eliminate etc etc. They can't see into the future.
Hindsight has 20/20 vision - and IMO this thread is yet another example of it being used merely to find fault.
The only outcome which could have been guaranteed beforehand is if no re-investigations at all had taken place - but then that would have removed all hope of finding out what happened to Madeleine. She deserves better than that IMO.
The PIs had no power to compel witnesses to answer their questions and no power of arrest so exactly what was the point of employing them ?
-
I suppose the answer depends on why and by whom they were employed. I have a list, please feel free to add to it if you know of any others.
An anonymous benefactor is said to have employed Control Risks on around 12th May 2007 after the disappearance.
Brian Kennedy was heavily involved with the hiring and payment of Metado 3 in September 2007.
Brian Kennedy also involved in the hiring of Oakley International from April to September 2008, although Metado were still involved I believe, particularly in relation to Morocco.
Alpha Investigations featuring Arthur Cowley is owned by Alphaig, which was registered by Kennedy's company.
Dave Edgar hired November 2008?
Daniel Krugel July 2007. Was he paid?
-
What hysterics?
Can you answer this truthfully Stephen - If SY were going down the same route as Amaral, and was going to investigate the McCann's as having been guilty of the involvement in their daughters disappearance would the millions of pounds spent be an annoyance to you? Would you want them to end the investigation?
It has become very apparent, there are no useful leads in this case.
It has come to a dead end.
It did so in Portugal, it has done so here.
I know others are going to disagree for different reasons,but this investigation is going nowhere, and it probably will be quietly closed down after the election.
-
The PI's were a waste of space and a waste of money, You can't blame the Parents for trusting people at their word.
But, there seems to be a sinister implication that the parents wanted to find out what could be found out- which could harm their 'innocent' case.
Just saying...
-
The PIs had no power to compel witnesses to answer their questions and no power of arrest so exactly what was the point of employing them ?
To help find their missing daughter?
To provide potentially useful information to the police to supplement their overwhelmed investigation?
-
Of course we have discussed at length what Redwood and company may or may not have done to discover Madeleine's fate. However from 2007 until 2011 at least 3 private detective agencies costing probably close to two million pounds had been employed by the McCanns to the same end and yet the evidence available seems to tell us that there was very little achieved in that time to find the child.
Did the organisations employed bring anything to the case or was their employment merely an ill-advised use of precious funds ?
If you had a missing child that the police had given up on searching for and a million plus quid in the bank, what would you do? Would you ensure that you only employed PIs that you knew in advance would find your child and if so how would you go about ascertaining this in advance?
-
If you had a missing child that the police had given up on searching for and a million plus quid in the bank, what would you do? Would you ensure that you only employed PIs that you knew in advance would find your child and if so how would you go about ascertaining this in advance?
I'd certainly ask questions with regard to their successes in other cases of missing children cases. Neither Oakley or Metodo3 seem to have had any.
-
I'd certainly ask questions with regard to their successes in other cases of missing children cases. Neither Oakley or Metodo3 seem to have had any.
Had neither enjoyed any success at all in locating missing persons? Would you perhaps be able to suggest a company that the McCanns should have used instead?
-
Had neither enjoyed any success at all in locating missing persons? Would you perhaps be able to suggest a company that the McCanns should have used instead?
Plenty of reputable PI companies in the UK.
-
If you had a missing child that the police had given up on searching for and a million plus quid in the bank, what would you do? Would you ensure that you only employed PIs that you knew in advance would find your child and if so how would you go about ascertaining this in advance?
First, the million plus quid was mostly donated, so there is a duty of care to spend it sensibly I would have thought. Second, I would use that tried and tested method we are advised to use when employing anyone to do a job of work. Get references from others who have used them. Stage payments. Demand regular updates (writing on a piece of scrap paper that there are between 1-10 people on the investigation as Kevin Halligan is alleged to have done wouldn't have been acceptable to me). To be fair to the McCanns Brian Kennedy didn't help. as a businessman he was taken in just as much as they were, and he was paying these cowboys too.
-
Had neither enjoyed any success at all in locating missing persons? Would you perhaps be able to suggest a company that the McCanns should have used instead?
No success at all.....unless you know differently ?
-
I'm unclear why misleading statements that demean the McCanns are allowed.
The McCanns were never in a position to stop the case from being shelved.
All leads were (considered) exhausted.
The McCanns fought hard for a second enquiry, and were ultimately successful in that.
Maybe you are afraid of true statements that you feel that demean the parents. The McCanns, in accordance with Portuguese law, could have very well asked for the "fase de instrução" to stop the case from being shelved but they chose not to. Ask them why.
BTW, the McCanns did not ask for an inquiry, they asked for a review so that they could get their hands on the evidence in the files that they did not know about.
-
Maybe you are afraid of true statements that you feel that demean the parents. The McCanns, in accordance with Portuguese law, could have very well asked for the "fase de instrução" to stop the case from being shelved but they chose not to. Ask them why.
BTW, the McCanns did not ask for an inquiry, they asked for a review so that they could get their hands on the evidence in the files that they did not know about.
Exactly!! They wanted to find out what the police had....or could find out.
-
Exactly!! They wanted to find out what the police had....or could find out.
[/quote
Hence serving a disclosure order gained on 22nd May 2007 on Leicestershire Police in order to see what evidence they had.
-
Maybe you are afraid of true statements that you feel that demean the parents. The McCanns, in accordance with Portuguese law, could have very well asked for the "fase de instrução" to stop the case from being shelved but they chose not to. Ask them why.
BTW, the McCanns did not ask for an inquiry, they asked for a review so that they could get their hands on the evidence in the files that they did not know about.
absolute rubbish..nothing unusual
-
Exactly!! They wanted to find out what the police had....or could find out.
[/quote
Hence serving a disclosure order gained on 22nd May 2007 on Leicestershire Police in order to see what evidence they had.
Indeed! they were told where to go.. no.. infact um.. something about one or both being implicated..aw perhaps one of the supporters will help with that quote- they love accuracy- and I forget it.
-
First, the million plus quid was mostly donated, so there is a duty of care to spend it sensibly I would have thought. Second, I would use that tried and tested method we are advised to use when employing anyone to do a job of work. Get references from others who have used them. Stage payments. Demand regular updates (writing on a piece of scrap paper that there are between 1-10 people on the investigation as Kevin Halligan is alleged to have done wouldn't have been acceptable to me). To be fair to the McCanns Brian Kennedy didn't help. as a businessman he was taken in just as much as they were, and he was paying these cowboys too.
I'm not aware of PI agencies specialised in the stranger abduction of children. Some do appear to have been competent in parental ones... but because there are clear leads to follow (financial traces, family members, photos, known history, etc). In this case, there were none.
-
absolute rubbish..nothing unusual
Totally agree. You would have to be stark raving mad to push for a case to be reviewed or re-investigated if you were guilty of the crime yourself. And what about their friends who supposedly colluded with them? Would they agree to such an insanely dangerous course of action - when there was no need for anyone to do anything except keep their heads down and wait for it to disappear into obscurity? Not a chance.
Mega straw-clutching IMO.
-
Indeed! they were told where to go.. no.. infact um.. something about one or both being implicated..aw perhaps one of the supporters will help with that quote- they love accuracy- and I forget it.
It caused extreme alarm because the police had visions of having to release evidence in other cases I expect. The order was altered to exclude law enforcement agencies.
Here is a link; http://www.mccannfiles.com/id130.html
-
No success at all.....unless you know differently ?
So both companies had no track record whatsoever in locating missing people? Metodo 3 claimed to have reuinited 27 missing children and teenagers with their parents. Of course they could have been exaggerating or lying, how is anyone to know? Now, you tell us which company the McCanns should have used.
-
I'm not aware of PI agencies specialised in the stranger abduction of children. Some do appear to have been competent in parental ones... but because there are clear leads to follow (financial traces, family members, photos, known history, etc). In this case, there were none.
There simply are no agencies with experience in child stranger abductions
-
There simply are no agencies with experience in child stranger abductions
There was no abduction.
The agencies and parties employed were blatantly incompetent.
-
First, the million plus quid was mostly donated, so there is a duty of care to spend it sensibly I would have thought. Second, I would use that tried and tested method we are advised to use when employing anyone to do a job of work. Get references from others who have used them. Stage payments. Demand regular updates (writing on a piece of scrap paper that there are between 1-10 people on the investigation as Kevin Halligan is alleged to have done wouldn't have been acceptable to me). To be fair to the McCanns Brian Kennedy didn't help. as a businessman he was taken in just as much as they were, and he was paying these cowboys too.
And just how much do you know about the McCanns' process for choosing the PIs? Do you know that they didn't get references?
-
Totally agree. You would have to be stark raving mad to push for a case to be reviewed or re-investigated if you were guilty of the crime yourself. And what about their friends who supposedly colluded with them? Would they agree to such an insanely dangerous course of action - when there was no need for anyone to do anything except keep their heads down and wait for it to disappear into obscurity? Not a chance.
Mega straw-clutching IMO.
Unless you had reason to believe that it would only review the case as an abduction, criticise the Portuguese investigation of the abduction and conclude that it wasn't possible to find the abductor due to the passage of time and Portuguese mistakes.
-
There was no abduction.
The agencies and parties employed were blatantly incompetent.
Hardly! they [Metodo3 and Oakley International] seem to have been fairly adept at parting folk from their money.
Neither lasted more than a few months on the McCann case though it would seem.
-
Unless you had reason to believe that it would only review the case as an abduction, criticise the Portuguese investigation of the abduction and conclude that it wasn't possible to find the abductor due to the passage of time and Portuguese mistakes.
And how would they have known this in advance?
-
Unless you had reason to believe that it would only review the case as an abduction, criticise the Portuguese investigation of the abduction and conclude that it wasn't possible to find the abductor due to the passage of time and Portuguese mistakes.
...When climbing in and out of the window with Maddie, he must have left some hairs or other bits of DNA. Scuff marks? footprints on the soil below? It is things like these which seem to throw people off that scent. What possible information could the PI's get that would be used to have someone arrested?
-
If someone can tell me the details of the contents of the files constructed by the PIs then I'll be able to form some opinion on this topic's question.
-
If someone can tell me the details of the contents of the files constructed by the PIs then I'll be able to form some opinion on this topic's question.
I doubt that is available to us mere mortals. If one turns it on its head a bit; the objectives, at face value that is, were to find a missing child, identify those responsible for causing the child to be missing and bring them to justice. Did the PI's achieve all or any of those objectives before being given the bums rush?
-
Unless you had reason to believe that it would only review the case as an abduction, criticise the Portuguese investigation of the abduction and conclude that it wasn't possible to find the abductor due to the passage of time and Portuguese mistakes.
How could they guarantee that if they were guilty? Once the investigation began it was out of their hands which direction it would go in. No guilty person would take such a massive - and more importantly - such an unnecessary risk unless they were off their rockers - and that includes their friends too.
Can you imagine their friends agreeing to a course of action which meant they had to spend every day wondering whether SY would find something which would prove they were accomplices in a heinous crime - and so be constantly waiting for a knock on the door? No-one would choose to live under that kind of pressure. But that is what you are suggesting IMO.
Common sense please.
-
How could they guarantee that if they were guilty? Once the investigation began it was out of their hands which direction it would go in. No guilty person would take such a massive - and more importantly - such an unnecessary risk unless they were off their rockers - and that includes their friends too.
Can you imagine their friends agreeing to a course of action which meant they had to spend every day wondering whether SY would find something which would prove they were accomplices in a heinous crime - and so be constantly waiting for a knock on the door? No-one would choose to live under that kind of pressure. But that is what you are suggesting IMO.
Common sense please.
This is a very important point which I would dearly love to see a "sceptic" respond to with a logical, plausible explanation. Of course, they can't because there isn't one! So instead, they will simply sidestep or ignore this thorny matter and carry on their "scepticizing" regardless.
-
This is a very important point which I would dearly love to see a "sceptic" respond to with a logical, plausible explanation. Of course, they can't because there isn't one! So instead, they will simply sidestep or ignore this thorny matter and carry on their "scepticizing" regardless.
That was the problem, the McCanns weren't counting on the review becoming an investigation.
-
That was the problem, the McCanns weren't counting on the review becoming an investigation.
The McCann's were hoping the case would be re opened, that is why they wanted a review.
-
I doubt that is available to us mere mortals. If one turns it on its head a bit; the objectives, at face value that is, were to find a missing child, identify those responsible for causing the child to be missing and bring them to justice. Did the PI's achieve all or any of those objectives before being given the bums rush?
Seems like a reasonable set of objectives.
Quite clearly, finding Madeleine etc has not been achieved.
Exactly what was achieved, and what may sit in the PI files I do not know.
Given that the money was donated to advance the investigation, if I don't know whether it has (or has not) advanced that investigation, then I can't answer the thread question. I am sure some people can - the McCanns, SY plus some others. Just not us folks on this forum.
-
How could they guarantee that if they were guilty? Once the investigation began it was out of their hands which direction it would go in. No guilty person would take such a massive - and more importantly - such an unnecessary risk unless they were off their rockers - and that includes their friends too.
Can you imagine their friends agreeing to a course of action which meant they had to spend every day wondering whether SY would find something which would prove they were accomplices in a heinous crime - and so be constantly waiting for a knock on the door? No-one would choose to live under that kind of pressure. But that is what you are suggesting IMO.
Common sense please.
They asked for a review of the evidence regarding the abduction and they got one. Perhaps they never thought it would become an investigation, but so long as the original remit remained it was OK because they didn't abduct their daughter. What makes you think their friends were consulted?
-
They asked for a review of the evidence regarding the abduction and they got one. Perhaps they never thought it would become an investigation, but so long as the original remit remained it was OK because they didn't abduct their daughter. What makes you think their friends were consulted?
Good question.
-
Seems like a reasonable set of objectives.
Quite clearly, finding Madeleine etc has not been achieved.
Exactly what was achieved, and what may sit in the PI files I do not know.
Given that the money was donated to advance the investigation, if I don't know whether it has (or has not) advanced that investigation, then I can't answer the thread question. I am sure some people can - the McCanns, SY plus some others. Just not us folks on this forum.
We could say the primary objectives were not achieved so in that respect it was a failure and possibly a waste of money. If however lurking in the PI files is a bit of evidence that is later used to bring the guilty party or parties to justice then it could be deemed to be successful, the job's a goodun and the money well spent .
Watch this space maybe?
-
They asked for a review of the evidence regarding the abduction and they got one. Perhaps they never thought it would become an investigation, but so long as the original remit remained it was OK because they didn't abduct their daughter. What makes you think their friends were consulted?
Common sense? After all - according to some - they are all supposed to have been party to the disposal of a dead childs body. If the McCanns go down so do the others - so I think they might have wanted a say in it. Don't you? And of course the McCanns would consult them anyway. If they were guilty and their friends knew - then they would want to keep them on board - not do something to make their lives a misery and risk turning them against them.
Sorry - but the suggestion that the McCanns didn't want an investigation is just so devoid of common sense it borders on irrational IMO.
IMO everything the McCanns have done since their return to the UK is the exact opposite of what guilty people would do and you have to throw all semblance of common sense, logic and reasoned thought out of the window to come to any other conclusion.
-
Common sense? After all - according to some - they are all supposed to have been party to the disposal of a dead childs body. If the McCanns go down so do the others - so I think they might have wanted a say in it. Don't you? And of course the McCanns would consult them anyway. If they were guilty and their friends knew - then they would want to keep them on board - not do something to make their lives a misery and risk turning them against them.
Sorry - but the suggestion that the McCanns didn't want an investigation is just so devoid of common sense it borders on irrational IMO.
IMO everything the McCanns have done since their return to the UK is the exact opposite of what guilty people would do and you have to throw all semblance of common sense, logic and reasoned thought out of the window to come to any other conclusion.
Of course you are going to say that.
You back them 100%.
That is why you post on here.
P.S. For most of these years they asked for a 'review', where they would have access to all the files.
On the subject of collusion, that is exactly what they did when they all met up in the 'Rothley'.
To 'discuss' the case.
-
If someone can tell me the details of the contents of the files constructed by the PIs then I'll be able to form some opinion on this topic's question.
Exactly so, Shining, but it is a mark of Madeleine McCann's case that the most in depth discussion takes place on the basis of no information or the flimsiest of information ... the prerequisite of the case being that everyone is to be believed with the exception of the Drs McCann.
The PIs employers obviously valued some of the investigative work carried out by them as they saw fit to pass on files to operation Grange who included them with Portuguese Law Enforcement agencies and UK Law Enforcement agencies as stakeholders, as detailed in Op Grange Remithttp://content.met.police.uk/Article/Operation-Grange/1400005508791/35434
-
This is a very important point which I would dearly love to see a "sceptic" respond to with a logical, plausible explanation. Of course, they can't because there isn't one! So instead, they will simply sidestep or ignore this thorny matter and carry on their "scepticizing" regardless.
I think by the time the review was requested the course of this case was well and truly out of the friend's of the McCanns hands. They had become immeshed in something that they hadn't quite understood the implications of at the time and were, by 2011, in far too deep to extracate themselves without doing great harm to themselves.
Having said that I think since the review began at least one and possibly more of the friends have started to tell the truth. Whether my assumptions are correct only time will tell.
-
Common sense? After all - according to some - they are all supposed to have been party to the disposal of a dead childs body. If the McCanns go down so do the others - so I think they might have wanted a say in it. Don't you? And of course the McCanns would consult them anyway. If they were guilty and their friends knew - then they would want to keep them on board - not do something to make their lives a misery and risk turning them against them.
Sorry - but the suggestion that the McCanns didn't want an investigation is just so devoid of common sense it borders on irrational IMO.
IMO everything the McCanns have done since their return to the UK is the exact opposite of what guilty people would do and you have to throw all semblance of common sense, logic and reasoned thought out of the window to come to any other conclusion.
I have never said that the McCanns wanted an investigation and neither have they. I said the McCanns wanted a review and got one which meets their needs. The remit given to Operation Grange was to review the case as if the abduction took place in the UK. As the review was looking only at an abduction the parents would not be investigated or examined and neither would their friends. So long as the aim was to look at an abduction Madeleine could be assumed to be alive and the search could continue.
-
I have never said that the McCanns wanted an investigation and neither have they. I said the McCanns wanted a review and got one which meets their needs. The remit given to Operation Grange was to review the case as if the abduction took place in the UK. As the review was looking only at an abduction the parents would not be investigated or examined and neither would their friends. So long as the aim was to look at an abduction Madeleine could be assumed to be alive and the search could continue.
The raison d'être for every action taken by the Drs McCann since Madeleine's disappearance is to have her found ... the only way this was ever going to be achieved was by the re-opening of her case and an investigation by the appropriate police authorities ... in this case the Portuguese.
It is risible that there are those who are in complete denial of every positive move this couple make ... not only risible but very mean spirited also.
**snip
Original Source: EXPRESSO: 01 MAY 2010
1Expresso_1may2010
Main heading:
The McCanns want to reopen the 'Maddie case'.
The picture caption reads:
Gerry and Kate McCann state that they have new leads about the disappearance of their daughter and are going to formally request the reopening of the case.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/37may10/EXPRESSO_01_05_2010.htm
-
The raison d'être for every action taken by the Drs McCann since Madeleine's disappearance is to have her found ... the only way this was ever going to be achieved was by the re-opening of her case and an investigation by the appropriate police authorities ... in this case the Portuguese.
It is risible that there are those who are in complete denial of every positive move this couple make ... not only risible but very mean spirited also.
**snip
Original Source: EXPRESSO: 01 MAY 2010
1Expresso_1may2010
Main heading:
The McCanns want to reopen the 'Maddie case'.
The picture caption reads:
Gerry and Kate McCann state that they have new leads about the disappearance of their daughter and are going to formally request the reopening of the case.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/37may10/EXPRESSO_01_05_2010.htm
And do we know if they ever asked for the case to be re-opened ?
-
That was the problem, the McCanns weren't counting on the review becoming an investigation.
What nonsense. Why ask for a review then? Assuming they are guilty how does a review benefit them?
-
What nonsense. Why ask for a review then? Assuming they are guilty how does a review benefit them?
As we know, the re-opening of the case would only be considered when new evidence could be considered.
We know that the case was re-opened by the Portuguese only after SY re-opened it and there was great uncertainty whether the Portuguese would follow suit or not.
It is therefore preposterous to suggest that the Drs McCann could have influenced the re-opening of the case by Portugal when it was touch and go if the Portuguese would do so even when SY had the evidence to warrant it at their end.
From the previous post I have made "Gerry and Kate McCann state that they have new leads about the disappearance of their daughter"
If they had new leads where did the information come from?
The source certainly was neither the PJ or SY.
Which leaves only one investigative body looking for evidence on Madeleine's disappearance ... that is the Private Investigators employed by the fund.
The fact that their files were taken seriously enough to be considered by Operation Grange suggests to me they may very well have been worth their salt.
-
As we know, the re-opening of the case would only be considered when new evidence could be considered.
We know that the case was re-opened by the Portuguese only after SY re-opened it and there was great uncertainty whether the Portuguese would follow suit or not.
It is therefore preposterous to suggest that the Drs McCann could have influenced the re-opening of the case by Portugal when it was touch and go if the Portuguese would do so even when SY had the evidence to warrant it at their end.
From the previous post I have made "Gerry and Kate McCann state that they have new leads about the disappearance of their daughter"
If they had new leads where did the information come from?
The source certainly was neither the PJ or SY.
Which leaves only one investigative body looking for evidence on Madeleine's disappearance ... that is the Private Investigators employed by the fund.
The fact that their files were taken seriously enough to be considered by Operation Grange suggests to me they may very well have been worth their salt.
The PI files were included in the material to be examined before SY had even looked at them so please don't insult other members intelligence by pretending the information they contained was valued by SY (except the efits of course but that's another story ! ).
-
The PI files were included in the material to be examined before SY had even looked at them so please don't insult other members intelligence by pretending the information they contained was valued by SY (except the efits of course but that's another story ! ).
So you think the McCanns pressed for a review of the case, knowing that such a review would draw on material accumulated by PIs which would include photofits of a man that allegedly resembled Gerry because...?
-
We know that the review requested by the parents developed into an investigation, which they didn't request. They expected a paper-based review of the information held by British and Portuguese police authorities, according to Clarence Mitchell;
"We are very grateful for the comprehensive review by the Met and clearly what was supposed to be just a paper exercise has transpired to be something more proactive.
Did they expect the Met. to ask for the Metado 3 and Oakley International files? We don't know. Maybe, maybe not.
Dear Prime Minister,
As a devoted father and family man, you know the importance of children. Our beloved eldest child, Madeleine, was abducted from Praia da Luz, Portugal, four years ago. Since then, we have devoted all our energies to ensuring her safe return.
Today we are asking you - and the British and Portuguese governments - to help find Madeleine and bring her back to her loving family.
We live in hope that Madeleine will be found alive and returned to us. One call might be all that is needed to lead to Madeleine and her abductor.
To this end, we are seeking a joint INDEPENDENT, TRANSPARENT and COMPREHENSIVE review of ALL information held in relation to Madeleine's disappearance. Thus far, there has been NO formal review of the material held by the police authorities - which is routine practice in most major unsolved crimes. It is not right that a young vulnerable British citizen has essentially been given up on. This remains an unsolved case of a missing child. Children are our most precious gift.
Please don't give up on Madeleine.
Kate & Gerry McCann
-
We know that the review requested by the parents developed into an investigation, which they didn't request. They expected a paper-based review of the information held by British and Portuguese police authorities, according to Clarence Mitchell;
"We are very grateful for the comprehensive review by the Met and clearly what was supposed to be just a paper exercise has transpired to be something more proactive.
Did they expect the Met. to ask for the Metado 3 and Oakley International files? We don't know. Maybe, maybe not.
Dear Prime Minister,
As a devoted father and family man, you know the importance of children. Our beloved eldest child, Madeleine, was abducted from Praia da Luz, Portugal, four years ago. Since then, we have devoted all our energies to ensuring her safe return.
Today we are asking you - and the British and Portuguese governments - to help find Madeleine and bring her back to her loving family.
We live in hope that Madeleine will be found alive and returned to us. One call might be all that is needed to lead to Madeleine and her abductor.
To this end, we are seeking a joint INDEPENDENT, TRANSPARENT and COMPREHENSIVE review of ALL information held in relation to Madeleine's disappearance. Thus far, there has been NO formal review of the material held by the police authorities - which is routine practice in most major unsolved crimes. It is not right that a young vulnerable British citizen has essentially been given up on. This remains an unsolved case of a missing child. Children are our most precious gift.
Please don't give up on Madeleine.
Kate & Gerry McCann
Portuguese law states that the investigation cannot be reopened without new evidence. The McCanns could not therefore ask for the case to be reopened. They could ask for a review which might lead to new evidence being discovered that would allow the reopening...again you are trying to make the facts fit your agenda
-
Portuguese law states that the investigation cannot be reopened without new evidence. The McCanns could not therefore ask for the case to be reopened. They could ask for a review which might lead to new evidence being discovered that would allow the reopening...again you are trying to make the facts fit your agenda
Still trying to make excuses! The McCanns had the right to keep the case from being shelved and they did nothing. They could have asked the Portuguese police to reopen the case, even if they thought that nothing would come of it. The wanted a review to see what evidence the police had against them, simple.
-
Still trying to make excuses! The McCanns had the right to keep the case from being shelved and they did nothing. They could have asked the Portuguese police to reopen the case, even if they thought that nothing would come of it. The wanted a review to see what evidence the police had against them, simple.
The McCanns didn't want the case investigated by the Portuguese because they had already been shown to be totally inept..it was SY investigation they wanted and it's A SY investigation they have got
-
The McCanns didn't want the case investigated by the Portuguese because they had already been shown to be totally inept..it was SY investigation they wanted and it's A SY investigation they have got
If you want to get away with "murder", the first thing you do is to call the police investigating you "inept, corrupt, fools, etc." and diss any evidence they have gathered. That's what the McCanns have done.
-
If you want to get away with "murder", the first thing you do is to call the police investigating you "inept, corrupt, fools, etc." and diss any evidence they have gathered. That's what the McCanns have done.
are you suggesting the McCanns are trying to get away with murder...don't be foolish...No one can deny the PJ carried out an inept operation..why else are SY there now
-
We could say the primary objectives were not achieved so in that respect it was a failure and possibly a waste of money. If however lurking in the PI files is a bit of evidence that is later used to bring the guilty party or parties to justice then it could be deemed to be successful, the job's a goodun and the money well spent .
Watch this space maybe?
That is what I was thinking as well.
-
are you suggesting the McCanns are trying to get away with murder...don't be foolish...No one can deny the PJ carried out an inept operation..why else are SY there now
I put quotation marks around the word murder because of the phrase "getting away with murder". Do you understand? In your eyes the PJ was inept because they did not follow the McCanns fairy tale and followed the evidence which lead them to the McCanns. You so conveniently forget that the British police were working together with the PJ. Furthermore, why did Leicestershire police refuse to hand over their files to the McCanns when the parents went to court for them? Perhaps it had to do with the fact that they had not been eliminated from the investigation as LP stated. The McCanns have been desperate to get their hands on the evidence against them.
-
I put quotation marks around the word murder because of the phrase "getting away with murder". Do you understand? In your eyes the PJ was inept because they did not follow the McCanns fairy tale and followed the evidence which lead them to the McCanns. You so conveniently forget that the British police were working together with the PJ. Furthermore, why did Leicestershire police refuse to hand over their files to the McCanns when the parents went to court for them? Perhaps it had to do with the fact that they had not been eliminated from the investigation as LP stated.
PJ ..inept investigation focussing on the McCannns...SY ..proper investigation ...McCanns not suspects having been ruled out
-
PJ ..inept investigation focussing on the McCannns...SY ..proper investigation ...McCanns not suspects having been ruled out
Yes, life is so simple for some people.
-
Has Employing PIs Been Worth the Money Paid ?
I wonder when The Met aka SY became PIs &%+((£
-
PJ ..inept investigation focussing on the McCannns...SY ..proper investigation ...McCanns not suspects having been ruled out
No it wasn't inept.
Thousands of man hours were spent in searching for Madeleine and for evidence of abduction.
No results in either case.
-
Yes, life is so simple for some people.
It was certainly a simple conception for Amaral: choose the McCanns as culprits and shoehorn the evidence to "fit".
-
It was certainly a simple conception for Amaral: choose the McCanns as culprits and shoehorn the evidence to "fit".
Rubbish.
-
It was certainly a simple conception for Amaral: choose the McCanns as culprits and shoehorn the evidence to "fit".
That's exactly what he did...lazy policing...Amaral went even further...by leaking lies to the public he convinced the gullible that the parents were guilty
-
We know that the review requested by the parents developed into an investigation, which they didn't request. They expected a paper-based review of the information held by British and Portuguese police authorities, according to Clarence Mitchell;
"We are very grateful for the comprehensive review by the Met and clearly what was supposed to be just a paper exercise has transpired to be something more proactive.
Did they expect the Met. to ask for the Metado 3 and Oakley International files? We don't know. Maybe, maybe not.
Dear Prime Minister,
As a devoted father and family man, you know the importance of children. Our beloved eldest child, Madeleine, was abducted from Praia da Luz, Portugal, four years ago. Since then, we have devoted all our energies to ensuring her safe return.
Today we are asking you - and the British and Portuguese governments - to help find Madeleine and bring her back to her loving family.
We live in hope that Madeleine will be found alive and returned to us. One call might be all that is needed to lead to Madeleine and her abductor.
To this end, we are seeking a joint INDEPENDENT, TRANSPARENT and COMPREHENSIVE review of ALL information held in relation to Madeleine's disappearance. Thus far, there has been NO formal review of the material held by the police authorities - which is routine practice in most major unsolved crimes. It is not right that a young vulnerable British citizen has essentially been given up on. This remains an unsolved case of a missing child. Children are our most precious gift.
Please don't give up on Madeleine.
Kate & Gerry McCann
and a review without a re-opening of the investigation would have served their purposes how exactly? You're an intelligent person I can't believe you actually believe what you're writing.
-
I put quotation marks around the word murder because of the phrase "getting away with murder". Do you understand? In your eyes the PJ was inept because they did not follow the McCanns fairy tale and followed the evidence which lead them to the McCanns. You so conveniently forget that the British police were working together with the PJ. Furthermore, why did Leicestershire police refuse to hand over their files to the McCanns when the parents went to court for them? Perhaps it had to do with the fact that they had not been eliminated from the investigation as LP stated. The McCanns have been desperate to get their hands on the evidence against them.
The final PJ report was dated 30.06.08.
The legal summary leading to the archiving of the case was dated 21.07.08.
The court hearing in the UK, presided by Judge Hogg, took place two weeks prior to the legal summary on 7.07.08.
Technically a) they were still arguidos at that hearing and b) full disclosure of items held by LP may well have raised the thorny topic of establishing legal precedence.
Even if the McCanns had thought that they could still be charged at that late stage, as arguidos they were entitled to be informed of the evidence against them (although the legislation changed a week or so after they acquired arguido status to clarify / improve on the Article in question). They did not need LP for that.
-
Portuguese law states that the investigation cannot be reopened without new evidence. The McCanns could not therefore ask for the case to be reopened. They could ask for a review which might lead to new evidence being discovered that would allow the reopening...again you are trying to make the facts fit your agenda
Yes.
There was one legal provision which, IMO, has been misunderstood - possibly deliberately by some - that could have kept the investigation open temporarily was if there had been a specific element, presented within 20 days, that hadn't been considered but which could overturn the ruling.
That makes sense if you've been charged and have been desperately trying to find proof that you were somewhere else and therefore shouldn't have been charged in the first place.
In the McCanns' case, it would have been impossible to present a comprehensive list of concrete elements within that timeframe (even though it was extended due to summer recess) of investigative possibilities that hadn't been fully explored, particularly when most files were in Portuguese.
-
I think by the time the review was requested the course of this case was well and truly out of the friend's of the McCanns hands. They had become immeshed in something that they hadn't quite understood the implications of at the time and were, by 2011, in far too deep to extracate themselves without doing great harm to themselves.
Having said that I think since the review began at least one and possibly more of the friends have started to tell the truth. Whether my assumptions are correct only time will tell.
Good grief. ...... ''something they hadn't quite understood the implications of at the time''?? ....... Are you actually being serious? We are talking about intelligent adults - not 5yr olds - or the mentally challenged.
Sorry Faith - but in terms of 'wishful thinking' - your whole post is off the Richter scale IMO.
-
the McCanns got exactly what they wanted...the case re opened with SY involved. Where is the evidence that they did not want the case re opened...it's absolutely stupid to suggest anything else
-
They couldn't ask for the case to be re opened........there would have to be new evidence found first...hence the review first.
Instead of giving press conferences about Victoria Beckham look a likes in Barcelona why didn't the McCanns' PIs hand over this information to the PJ or SY? It might have helped get the case reopened. But perhaps that was never their intention, creating smoke screens was more their style.
-
the McCanns got exactly what they wanted...the case re opened with SY involved. Where is the evidence that they did not want the case re opened...it's absolutely stupid to suggest anything else
Yet again, very politely.
Now where is their evidence they wanted the case reopened ?
I have asked you and other mccann supporters the same question, on previous occasions.
For once, try giving an answer which makes sense, and not insulting others, which is a sign of weakness and avoiding the question.
-
Yet again, very politely.
Now where is their evidence they wanted the case reopened ?
I asked you first..where is the evidence that they did not want it reopened...by asking for a review they knew that any new evidence found would cause reopening...posters claim they did not want the case reopened..wheres the evidence
-
I asked you first..where is the evidence that they did not want it reopened...by asking for a review they knew that any new evidence found would cause reopening...posters claim they did not want the case reopened..wheres the evidence
I've no intention of playing your childish games.
You contend the mccanns wanted the case re-opened.
Now cite your evidence.
-
this Thread is about Employing PIs. Not about Reopening The Case.
-
Well we already know.
The P.I.'s employed, wasted the donated money, all the way down the drain, with nothing to show for it.
NEXT............................
-
I'm not sure where I lie witht this situation. There are at least two scenarios for the PI's
1. despareate parents wanting to find the fate of their daughter
OR
2. Wanting to find out what could be found out, to arm themselves with a defence.
Hmm
Either way they would not want to imploy incompetents...they were duped into that in my opinion.
-
Well we already know.
The P.I.'s employed, wasted the donated money, all the way down the drain, with nothing to show for it.
NEXT............................
How can SY or any PI know that a potential lead will come to nothing if they don't investigate it first? Nothing came of the excavations which took place a while back in the search for Ben Needham. According to your logic I presume you think that as nothing was found - they were wrong to excavate in the first place - as it was money down the drain. The fact that they have eliminated one possibility re Ben's whereabouts - appears to be beyond your comprehension.
I've never heard such back-to-front logic.
-
How can SY or any PI know that a potential lead will come to nothing if they don't investigate it first? Nothing came of the excavations which took place a while back in the search for Ben Needham. According to your logic I presume you think that as nothing was found - they were wrong to excavate in the first place - as it was money down the drain. The fact that they have eliminated one possibility re Ben's whereabouts - appears to be beyond your comprehension.
I've never heard such back-to-front logic.
The P.I.'s employed by the mccanns were incompetent.
They found nothing.
They wasted peoples donated money.
For once, if you can, admit the truth.
-
The P.I.'s employed by the mccanns were incompetent.
They found nothing.
They wasted peoples donated money.
For once, if you can, admit the truth.
If the PJ had been "doing its job properly", , the McCanns would never have felt compelled to engage the Barcelona private investigation agency Metodo 3, on which the Find Madeleine campaign has already spent £200,000. "Not a penny would have been spent on the private investigators,"
well said Clarence
-
The P.I.'s employed by the mccanns were incompetent.
They found nothing.
They wasted peoples donated money.
For once, if you can, admit the truth.
To employ a bunch of crooks once can be put down to sheer bad luck but to repeat it immediately was incompetence. Who was advising them at the time and who brought Haligen and Metodo 3 to the trough?
-
'Windows' Kennedy was closely involved, I believe.
-
The P.I.'s employed by the mccanns were incompetent.
They found nothing.
They wasted peoples donated money.
For once, if you can, admit the truth.
The PI's indirectly brought you the Smithman efits. Now surely that was worth its weight in gold to the sceptics.
-
'Windows' Kennedy was closely involved, I believe.
Indeed, there appears to have been a blurring of the demarcation lines.
-
The P.I.'s employed by the mccanns were incompetent.
They found nothing.
They wasted peoples donated money.
For once, if you can, admit the truth.
Your logic appears to be that SY and PI's should not investigate or follow up any potential leads because they may not lead anywhere - and so it would be a waste of money. How can 'nothing' incriminating be found if no investigations take place? What sort of logic is that?
-
To employ a bunch of crooks once can be put down to sheer bad luck but to repeat it immediately was incompetence. Who was advising them at the time and who brought Haligen and Metodo 3 to the trough?
Do you think all their clients were'' incompetent'' - or just the McCanns? What special knowledge/information did the McCanns have that other clients didn't have - to enable them to suss out anything 'dodgy' beforehand and so not employ them?
Halligen was an accomplished [moderated] who successfully pulled the wool over many people's eyes - one being a lawyer IIRC.
I don't know what Metodo 3's 'crime' was - but why anyone would expect the McCanns to know anything about it before they employed them - I have no idea.
The McCanns would have no expertise when it came to employing PI's and would have to rely on advice from others. This would inevitably involve a substantial degree of trust on their part.
-
It is a matter of record that these criminal private investigators were generating false leads in order to justify their own existence. People were being intimidated and bribed by these unscrupulous thugs.
Marcos Correia was paid by them to represent Leonor Cipriano in what was clearly an attempt to pervert the course of justice with the hope that it would spill over into the McCann case.
www.miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4719.msg166882#msg166882
-
Do you think all their clients were'' incompetent'' - or just the McCanns? What special knowledge/information did the McCanns have that other clients didn't have - to enable them to suss out anything 'dodgy' beforehand and so not employ them?
Halligen was an accomplished [moderated] who successfully pulled the wool over many people's eyes - one being a lawyer IIRC.
I don't know what Metodo 3's 'crime' was - but why anyone would expect the McCanns to know anything about it before they employed them - I have no idea.
The McCanns would have no expertise when it came to employing PI's and would have to rely on advice from others. This would inevitably involve a substantial degree of trust on their part.
So are you going to suggest the McCanns didn't know what was going on in the name of the Madeleine Fund?
Regardless of whether Kennedy had employed them or who was funding them surely the McCanns would have been fully au fait as to what was going on?
-
Do you think all their clients were'' incompetent'' - or just the McCanns? What special knowledge/information did the McCanns have that other clients didn't have - to enable them to suss out anything 'dodgy' beforehand and so not employ them?
Halligen was an accomplished [moderated] who successfully pulled the wool over many people's eyes - one being a lawyer IIRC.
I don't know what Metodo 3's 'crime' was - but why anyone would expect the McCanns to know anything about it before they employed them - I have no idea.
The McCanns would have no expertise when it came to employing PI's and would have to rely on advice from others. This would inevitably involve a substantial degree of trust on their part.
It is not impossible for anyone, to be conned, especially with recommendations and a smart representative giving them their polite blarney.
What chance did the McCanns have, when they were chosen and recommended by someone else who saw them as the best?
-
Forget for a moment surnames which in the this case tend to cloud the issue with emotion.
I have never understood why, with respect to Metodo3 and Oakley International, a basic principle of business was not followed. That is if one is considering letting a high value contract to a company it is pretty much obligatory and a simple matter to check their finances, obtain references from previous clients and find out how many are on the payroll. Even two out of three would be better than not bothering. In my book it defies description not withstanding I will be told I am wrong and it is quite acceptable not to do financial checks 8(>((.
-
Forget for a moment surnames which in the this case tend to cloud the issue with emotion.
I have never understood why, with respect to Metodo3 and Oakley International, a basic principle of business was not followed. That is if one is considering letting a high value contract to a company it is pretty much obligatory and a simple matter to check their finances, obtain references from previous clients and find out how many are on the payroll. Even two out of three would be better than not bothering. In my book it defies description not withstanding I will be told I am wrong and it is quite acceptable not to do financial checks 8(>((.
Well within the bounds of responsible surveillancing @)(++(*
-
Forget for a moment surnames which in the this case tend to cloud the issue with emotion.
I have never understood why, with respect to Metodo3 and Oakley International, a basic principle of business was not followed. That is if one is considering letting a high value contract to a company it is pretty much obligatory and a simple matter to check their finances, obtain references from previous clients and find out how many are on the payroll. Even two out of three would be better than not bothering. In my book it defies description not withstanding I will be told I am wrong and it is quite acceptable not to do financial checks 8(>((.
Correct Alice.
There was a lot of money involved after all, but I think that(finance check) may have been covered by any fraudster.
Didn't Halligan use several names? I believe it was he who was charged with fraud etc not the company "Oakley" or "Metado"
The original benefactor (paying for Metado) seemed to take an active part in their actions and spent time in Portugal ,Please correct me if I am wrong.
-
I'm not sure where I lie witht this situation. There are at least two scenarios for the PI's
1. despareate parents wanting to find the fate of their daughter
OR
2. Wanting to find out what could be found out, to arm themselves with a defence.
Hmm
Either way they would not want to imploy incompetents...they were duped into that in my opinion.
It doesn't seem to have been the parent's idea initially to employ PI's.
Initially, we are told a 'wealthy backer' paid for Control Risks Group to go to Portugal on 13th May 2007 to investigate. We have not been told why private investigators were considered necessary at this stage, if they made any discoveries or what they were.
According to Kate McCanns book Brian Kennedy contacted them initially through his lawyer Edward Smethurst on 12th September 2007 (page 268)
Kennedy then became heavily involved. Perhaps he was the 'wealthy backer'? Not only did Kennedy put his money in, he also got involved in interviewing witnesses.
As a successful businessman we might expect Kennedy to have good judgement, but he was instrumental in hiring the private investigators and working with them. Some say witnesses were intimidated by Kennedy.
Of course the Fund was also paying the PI's. whether any of them could be seen as capable of assessing the suitability of the PI's I'm not sure.
Peter Hubner; a retired consultant;
Brian Kennedy, a retired head teacher;
John McCann, a medical representative;
Edward Smethurst – A Commercial lawyer;
Doug Skehan, clinical director in cardiology at Glenfield Hospital;
Jon Corner – Director of a media company;
Michael Linnett, a retired accountant
-
So are you going to suggest the McCanns didn't know what was going on in the name of the Madeleine Fund?
Regardless of whether Kennedy had employed them or who was funding them surely the McCanns would have been fully au fait as to what was going on?
I think hindsight is a wonderful thing John. And it's so easy to be wise after the event. I imagine the McCanns trusted the recommendations of others at the time. Why wouldn't they?
AFAIK - none of the other clients who also employed these people in good faith (especially Haligen) have been criticised. They are all regarded as victims - except the McCanns of course. So nothing new there then.
Just another stick to beat the McCanns with IMO and comes under the heading of 'Everything they say is wrong and Everything they do is wrong'.
-
It doesn't seem to have been the parent's idea initially to employ PI's.
Initially, we are told a 'wealthy backer' paid for Control Risks Group to go to Portugal on 13th May 2007 to investigate. We have not been told why private investigators were considered necessary at this stage, if they made any discoveries or what they were.
According to Kate McCanns book Brian Kennedy contacted them initially through his lawyer Edward Smethurst on 12th September 2007 (page 268)
Kennedy then became heavily involved. Perhaps he was the 'wealthy backer'? Not only did Kennedy put his money in, he also got involved in interviewing witnesses.
As a successful businessman we might expect Kennedy to have good judgement, but he was instrumental in hiring the private investigators and working with them. Some say witnesses were intimidated by Kennedy.
Of course the Fund was also paying the PI's. whether any of them could be seen as capable of assessing the suitability of the PI's I'm not sure.
Peter Hubner; a retired consultant;
Brian Kennedy, a retired head teacher;
John McCann, a medical representative;
Edward Smethurst – A Commercial lawyer;
Doug Skehan, clinical director in cardiology at Glenfield Hospital;
Jon Corner – Director of a media company;
Michael Linnett, a retired accountant
That is correct G
He was financing Metado
Concerning the investigation of the disappearance of the British minor, Madeleine McCann, I present you Sir with the following:
On the 19th of October, we were contacted by the Commissary General, located in Madrid, by the Chief of the Kidnapping Unit, Alberto Carbas, who passed to us the information that the McCann family had contracted a Spanish company known as 'METODO 3', composed of Spanish private detectives. This business, or in other words, the costs of the activities of this business were being covered by a Scottish multi-millionaire whose name is BRIAN KENNEDY and whose objective was to locate the British minor.
With this information, we were asked if we were available and interested in meeting with a representative of this Spanish business, and also with the Commissary General and Chief of the Kidnapping Unit of the Police of our neighbouring country, whose operation is in Madrid.
The meeting had as its objective to receive on behalf of the private detectives, from that moment and for their own wishes, relevant information with the aim to ascertain the truth, and to state that they would not interfere in police work, and at most they would serve as a complement to some useful information. They firmly state that they are not working directly for the McCann family, but for Brian Kennedy and that their sole purpose is to locate the missing child, or to gather the inescapable truth of what happened.
They did not ask for any information regarding the investigation, nor was any offered to them, for obvious reasons as this is found incorporated in the Portuguese penal process.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/BRIAN-KENNEDY.htm
-
Correct Alice.
There was a lot of money involved after all, but I think that(finance check) may have been covered by any fraudster.
Didn't Halligan use several names? I believe it was he who was charged with fraud etc not the company "Oakley" or "Metado"
The original benefactor (paying for Metado) seemed to take an active part in their actions and spent time in Portugal ,Please correct me if I am wrong.
I doubt a full search was done by a company such as Dun and Bradstreet. How many names Halligen had is not relevant. A search on the company would reveal the company's turnover the number of people on the payroll and whether they were a good financial risk. If that didn't stack up with the story being peddled then watch out. My take is that the appointment of the PI's was a bit slapdash from a business perspective for whatever reason.
-
The PI's indirectly brought you the Smithman efits. Now surely that was worth its weight in gold to the sceptics.
Allegedly.
-
Allegedly.
I wonder what happenned to the information, they gave to Paiva and Ferreira, at that meeting.
-
To employ a bunch of crooks once can be put down to sheer bad luck but to repeat it immediately was incompetence. Who was advising them at the time and who brought Haligen and Metodo 3 to the trough?
A phrase from a Dickens novel springs to mind. 8(0(*
-
I wonder what happenned to the information, they gave to Paiva and Ferreira, at that meeting.
During the course of this meeting, the director of METODO 3 gave us a small book (attached), with information relative to the disappearance of the minor. This information, as we were told, was received via telephone and that they had already opened a line in Spain, specifically to receive and deal with information.
In this book, written in Spanish, we can analyse three pieces of information:
1. In the first case, we observed that there was report of facts which occurred in August/September of 2006, and which appears to us somewhat extemporaneous, as it cannot now be related to the material under investigation.
2. In the second point, we should remember that the computers of Sergey Malinka were searched and that nothing of suspicion was found there or related to paedophilia.
3. In that which concerns the third point, we are currently carrying out diligences with the intent to confirm or disprove the related information.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/BRIAN-KENNEDY.htm
-
I wonder what happenned to the information, they gave to Paiva and Ferreira, at that meeting.
All noted and dealt with - this is the investigation into the third piece of information;
The PJ traced the driver, Manuel A P Gautier, and spoke to him.
- He acknowledged speaking to M3 on 3 November.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/METODO_3.htm
-
I doubt a full search was done by a company such as Dun and Bradstreet. How many names Halligen had is not relevant. A search on the company would reveal the company's turnover the number of people on the payroll and whether they were a good financial risk. If that didn't stack up with the story being peddled then watch out. My take is that the appointment of the PI's was a bit slapdash from a business perspective for whatever reason.
Halligen was nothing more than an overpaid mercenary and totally suited to PI work which requires subtilty and finesse.
From his profile.
After leaving the AEA, Halligen set up Red Defence International Ltd as an international security and political risk company, advising clients on the risks involved in investing and doing business in unstable, war-torn and corrupt countries. He worked closely with political risk companies and was a persuasive advocate of IT security. In 2006, he struck gold when hired by Trafigura, the Dutch commodities trading company. Executives were imprisoned in the Ivory Coast after toxic waste was dumped in landfills near its biggest city Abidjan. Trafigura was blamed and hired Red Defence International at vast expense to help with the negotiations to release its executives. A Falcon business jet was rented for several months during the operation and it was Halligen's first taste of the good life. The case only ended when Trafigura paid $197 million to the government of the Ivory Coast to secure the release of the prisoners.
-
Halligen was nothing more than an overpaid mercenary and totally suited to PI work which requires subtilty and finesse.
From his profile.
After leaving the AEA, Halligen set up Red Defence International Ltd as an international security and political risk company, advising clients on the risks involved in investing and doing business in unstable, war-torn and corrupt countries. He worked closely with political risk companies and was a persuasive advocate of IT security. In 2006, he struck gold when hired by Trafigura, the Dutch commodities trading company. Executives were imprisoned in the Ivory Coast after toxic waste was dumped in landfills near its biggest city Abidjan. Trafigura was blamed and hired Red Defence International at vast expense to help with the negotiations to release its executives. A Falcon business jet was rented for several months during the operation and it was Halligen's first taste of the good life. The case only ended when Trafigura paid $197 million to the government of the Ivory Coast to secure the release of the prisoners.
He managed to con Henry Exton who was supposedly ex M15
-
So to remind of the opening post. Has all the money which has been spent on PI's been worth it or achieved anything useful in the search for Madeleine McCann?
-
So to remind of the opening post. Has all the money which has been spent on PI's been worth it or achieved anything useful in the search for Madeleine McCann?
Someone must have come up with something for Scotland Yard to follow. And the files from the PIs were taken by Scotland Yard. Who knows what they found?
-
So to remind of the opening post. Has all the money which has been spent on PI's been worth it or achieved anything useful in the search for Madeleine McCann?
Bump my post #62.
We could say the primary objectives were not achieved so in that respect it was a failure and possibly a waste of money. If however lurking in the PI files is a bit of evidence that is later used to bring the guilty party or parties to justice then it could be deemed to be successful, the job's a goodun and the money well spent .
Watch this space maybe?
The interesting part is neither Metodo3 nor Oakley International Ltd were at the crease long enough to see the shine off the ball.
-
Someone must have come up with something for Scotland Yard to follow. And the files from the PIs were taken by Scotland Yard. Who knows what they found?
I find CRG the most interesting because they were the first, three weeks after Madeleine's disappearance. Paid for by 'a wealthy benefactor';
According to Kate McCann's book, Control Risks Group
Set up meetings with "Hugh" - a former intelligence officer who was now a kidnap negotiator and counsellor
Re-took the McCanns' statements as it was feared that parts of these might have been lost in translation/retranslation (this later proved to be the case)
Arranged for forensic testing of the twins hair for the presence of drugs.
Checked the McCanns' home for bugging devices.
why would innocent people be concerned about being bugged?
According to media reports, the drug testing was done in September 2007. I wonder why it took so long, as suspicions were raised very early on about whether the twins had been sedated?
-
So to remind of the opening post. Has all the money which has been spent on PI's been worth it or achieved anything useful in the search for Madeleine McCann?
Unfortunately it seem to have been a complete waste of money...but as some of us understand...it's very easy to be a complete smart arse after the event
-
A phrase from a Dickens novel springs to mind. 8(0(*
Sorry to be picky but; Lady Bracknell; Importance of Being Earnest; O. Wilde.
-
I find CRG the most interesting because they were the first, three weeks after Madeleine's disappearance. Paid for by 'a wealthy benefactor';
According to Kate McCann's book, Control Risks Group
Set up meetings with "Hugh" - a former intelligence officer who was now a kidnap negotiator and counsellor
Re-took the McCanns' statements as it was feared that parts of these might have been lost in translation/retranslation (this later proved to be the case)
Arranged for forensic testing of the twins hair for the presence of drugs.
Checked the McCanns' home for bugging devices.
why would innocent people be concerned about being bugged?
According to media reports, the drug testing was done in September 2007. I wonder why it took so long, as suspicions were raised very early on about whether the twins had been sedated?
This part I do not understand.
What do Control Risks Group have in common with Metodo3 and Oakley International?
Nothing ! CRG are bloody good at what they do.
Were they hired by Mark Warner initially?
-
I find CRG the most interesting because they were the first, three weeks after Madeleine's disappearance. Paid for by 'a wealthy benefactor';
According to Kate McCann's book, Control Risks Group
Set up meetings with "Hugh" - a former intelligence officer who was now a kidnap negotiator and counsellor
Re-took the McCanns' statements as it was feared that parts of these might have been lost in translation/retranslation (this later proved to be the case)
Arranged for forensic testing of the twins hair for the presence of drugs.
Checked the McCanns' home for bugging devices.
why would innocent people be concerned about being bugged?
According to media reports, the drug testing was done in September 2007. I wonder why it took so long, as suspicions were raised very early on about whether the twins had been sedated?
Someone must have come up with something for Scotland Yard to follow. And the files from the PIs were taken by Scotland Yard. Who knows what they found?
Well
1) THey suspected enough to want to interview some guys, didn't they?
2) They wanted to extradite someone, didn't they?
And according to the research done by Anna and misty, Roderick Robinson did not exist any more.
So who was he?
And why was he jailed in a cushy jail/ psychiatric hospital in Malta when there were three countries looking for him ... and all wanting him?
Why did The Maltese over-ride the more serious charges of these countries?
Andy Redwood came back from his visit to Malta looking totally distraught and immediately announced his retirement.
I wonder why ?
Hugh is an interesting name. I nearly called my son Hugh ... and that was before I found out that I have Hugenoet Jewish blood
If I were in the Mccanns position, I would have wanted my home checked for bugs too.
And the files re-translating.
Oh and let's not forget that Kate wanted the twins tested for drugs in the first week, IIRC. Please correct me if I am remembering this incorrectly.
-
Well
1) THey suspected enough to want to interview some guys, didn't they?
2) They wanted to extradite someone, didn't they?
And according to the research done by Anna and misty, Roderick Robinson did not exist any more.
So who was he?
And why was he jailed in a cushy jail/ psychiatric hospital in Malta when there were three countries looking for him ... and all wanting him?
Why did The Maltese over-ride the more serious charges of these countries?
Andy Redwood came back from his visit to Malta looking totally distraught and immediately announced his retirement.
I wonder why ?
Hugh is an interesting name. I nearly called my son Hugh ... and that was before I found out that I have Hugenoet Jewish blood
If I were in the Mccanns position, I would have wanted my home checked for bugs too.
And the files re-translating.
Oh and let's not forget that Kate wanted the twins tested for drugs in the first week, IIRC. Please correct me if I am remembering this incorrectly.
I don't know what they did actually, only what Kate McCann says. Why would an innocent person want their accommodation checked for bugs then? Which accommodation? When? If Kate wanted the twins tested it could have been done in May when CRG were hired, why wait until September? It was their statements they wished to correct, but they signed them at the time so they should have corrected them then.
-
Topic: Has Employing PIs Been Worth the Money Paid ?
-
I don't know what they did actually, only what Kate McCann says. Why would an innocent person want their accommodation checked for bugs then? Which accommodation? When? If Kate wanted the twins tested it could have been done in May when CRG were hired, why wait until September? It was their statements they wished to correct, but they signed them at the time so they should have corrected them then.
Well my bet is that the PI's passed quite a lot of useful information to SY.
SY then added stuff that various members of the public gave them
They went thru the files to see anything that was strange or omitted or badly done
They threw out any red herrings .... and there were loads of those
And then equiped with a fair bit of info, including stuff from the PI's they came to PT to eliminate things and hone down to the likely scenaio.
I think they know who did it, but powerful people are preventing them making arrests.
As I have said all along, some people are untouchables. They get away with everything.
As to whether the PI's were worth what was spent on them, we will never know
But Kate and Gerry employed them in good faith ... and had they come up with the Madeleine, they would have been worth every penny spent.
-
I don't know what they did actually, only what Kate McCann says. Why would an innocent person want their accommodation checked for bugs then? Which accommodation? When?
That what stood out to me, what does that have to do with finding M?
-
That what stood out to me, what does that have to do with finding M?
It does not say, unless I am mistaken, that the suggestion was that of Kate. It was probably the chap, Hugh, who suggested it and arranged for the drugs tests.
Would you be happy that someone was listening in to your every word in any room?
Anyway can we stick to the topic, please
-
It does not say, unless I am mistaken, that the suggestion was that of Kate. It was probably the chap, Hugh, who suggested it and arranged for the drugs tests.
Would you be happy that someone was listening in to your every word in any room?
Anyway can we stick to the topic, please
I think that was on topic. The question becomes what was the purpose of the PIs?
-
It does not say, unless I am mistaken, that the suggestion was that of Kate. It was probably the chap, Hugh, who suggested it and arranged for the drugs tests.
Would you be happy that someone was listening in to your every word in any room?
Anyway can we stick to the topic, please
I was discussing the role of Control Risks Group, the first investigators to be engaged.
-
I apologize to those of you who thought I was complaining that you were off topic. It was I, who was going off topic asking about how you would feel about bugging devices in your home, which was not sticking to the topic of the thread, as message:-
"Would you be happy that someone was listening in to your every word in any room?
Anyway can we stick to the topic, please"
-
That what stood out to me, what does that have to do with finding M?
You seem to be concerned about finding Madeleine McCann. Who, other than the private investigators were looking for her?
From the point of view of keeping Madeleine McCann's archived case alive the private investigators were certainly worth the money paid, and who knows how Madeleine's case might have progressed if the information passed from the private investigators to the police had been actioned at the time by the people with the legal power to do so.
-
You seem to be concerned about finding Madeleine McCann. Who, other than the private investigators were looking for her?
From the point of view of keeping Madeleine McCann's archived case alive the private investigators were certainly worth the money paid, and who knows how Madeleine's case might have progressed if the information passed from the private investigators to the police had been actioned at the time by the people with the legal power to do so.
You have evidence to suggest that all the info provided by Metodo3, Oakley International and Alpha Investigations was useful to The Met and was worthy of action?
-
You have evidence to suggest that all the info provided by Metodo3, Oakley International and Alpha Investigations was useful to The Met and was worthy of action?
Do you have evidence to suggest it was not?
-
You seem to be concerned about finding Madeleine McCann. Who, other than the private investigators were looking for her?
From the point of view of keeping Madeleine McCann's archived case alive the private investigators were certainly worth the money paid, and who knows how Madeleine's case might have progressed if the information passed from the private investigators to the police had been actioned at the time by the people with the legal power to do so.
Which information did they pass on which was ignored?
-
Do you have evidence to suggest it was not?
I don't have to have.
You are the one trying to pass off. I am just asking you to justify your dissertation.
Clearly you can't
-
Which information did they pass on which was ignored?
Alfred R Jones
There is correspondence in the files between Paiva and Amaral which proves that sightings were not followed up - specifically the one I remember is the sighting at Lagos Marina of a couple seen with a young child early morning 4th May 2007 - a sighting that was only very half-heartedly followed up, and then dismissed as "not relevant to the investigation". Dismissed on what grounds exactly? Was the couple traced? Who was this child? Where is the information in the files?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4962.msg176384#msg176384
-
Alfred R Jones
There is correspondence in the files between Paiva and Amaral which proves that sightings were not followed up - specifically the one I remember is the sighting at Lagos Marina of a couple seen with a young child early morning 4th May 2007 - a sighting that was only very half-heartedly followed up, and then dismissed as "not relevant to the investigation". Dismissed on what grounds exactly? Was the couple traced? Who was this child? Where is the information in the files?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4962.msg176384#msg176384
That would be George Brooks' sighting
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id399.html
-
You seem to be concerned about finding Madeleine McCann. Who, other than the private investigators were looking for her?
From the point of view of keeping Madeleine McCann's archived case alive the private investigators were certainly worth the money paid, and who knows how Madeleine's case might have progressed if the information passed from the private investigators to the police had been actioned at the time by the people with the legal power to do so.
When Control Risks Group were hired in May 2007 the case was very much a live investigation.
-
You have evidence to suggest that all the info provided by Metodo3, Oakley International and Alpha Investigations was useful to The Met and was worthy of action?
Where does Brietta say ALL the info was useful to the Met?
Dont put words in her mouth Alice. There's a good fella.
The very fact that they ignored a good number is enough
And why were they ignored?
- Laziness?
- Because Amaral had jumped to conclusions and virtually from day one had fixed in his mind that The Mccanns had dunit, so he ignored anything that pointed in another direction?
or
- was there some other reason?
-
Where does Brietta say ALL the info was useful to the Met?
Dont put words in her mouth Alice. There's a good fella.
The very fact that they ignored a good number is enough
And why were they ignored?
- Laziness?
- Because Amaral had jumped to conclusions and virtually from day had fixed in his mind that The Mccanns had dunit, so he ignored anything that pointed in another direction?
or
- was there some other reason?
Once again, it must be pointed out that Gonçalo Amaral did not determine the direction of the investigation, that was the evidence. Furthermore, he regrets giving the McCanns too much leeway and benefit of the doubt from the beginning. He did not set his sights on them from the start, as so many of you want us to believe.
-
Once again, it must be pointed out that Gonçalo Amaral did not determine the direction of the investigation, that was the evidence. Furthermore, he regrets giving the McCanns too much leeway and benefit of the doubt from the beginning. He did not set his sights on them from the start, as so many of you want us to believe.
Montclair, IIRC Amaral is on record as saying himself that from the following morning, he "knew" The Mccanns were responsible
Maybe someone who can find the relevant words would be so kind as to post them? Thanks.
-
Alfred R Jones
There is correspondence in the files between Paiva and Amaral which proves that sightings were not followed up - specifically the one I remember is the sighting at Lagos Marina of a couple seen with a young child early morning 4th May 2007 - a sighting that was only very half-heartedly followed up, and then dismissed as "not relevant to the investigation". Dismissed on what grounds exactly? Was the couple traced? Who was this child? Where is the information in the files?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4962.msg176384#msg176384
Although newspaper reports say George Burke reported his sighting to the PJ there is no record of this among the numerous 'sightings' recorded in the PJ files.
-
Although newspaper reports say George Burke reported his sighting to the PJ there is no record of this among the numerous 'sightings' recorded in the PJ files.
Just another thing that they [Amarals crew] arbitrarily decided was not of interest ? No need to record it, the Mccanns dunit, sort of thing? Decided from day 1 ?
-
Just another thing that they [Amarals crew] arbitrarily decided was not of interest ? No need to record it, the Mccanns dunit, sort of thing? Decided from day 1 ?
There is no evidence that George Burke contacted the PJ in May 2007. Therefore there is no evidence that they ignored his story. Do you have evidence that the PJ decided on Day 1 that the McCanns dunit? Do you have details of what the PJ classed as 'of no interest'? Please share if so.
-
Just another thing that they [Amarals crew] arbitrarily decided was not of interest ? No need to record it, the Mccanns dunit, sort of thing? Decided from day 1 ?
That can be applied to the mccanns and company, who said an abductor dunnit, without a shred of evidence to back it up.
Meanwhile the PJ were directed to look at the mccanns, as any police force would have donew in the circumstances.
-
That can be applied to the mccanns and company, who said an abductor dunnit, without a shred of evidence to back it up.
Meanwhile the PJ were directed to look at the mccanns, as any police force would have donew in the circumstances.
Stephen
I am all in favour thta the PJ looked at The Mccanns and thoroughly, BUT without anything against them, except "gut feelings" ....
Why did Amaral turn sightings and potential evidence away?
-
That can be applied to the mccanns and company, who said an abductor dunnit, without a shred of evidence to back it up.
Meanwhile the PJ were directed to look at the mccanns, as any police force would have donew in the circumstances.
[/b]
As a result of which the following conclusion was reached and their Arguido status removed.
Quote
The non-involvement of Madeleine's parents in any criminally significant action is apparent from the fact that they were not in the apartment at the time of her disappearance, their normal behaviour up to that moment and afterwards, as witnessed by the statements of the witnesses, the analysis of the telephone communications and the conclusions of the experts reports.
None of the indications which led to their being made suspects was substantiated later; there was no proof of them having notified the media before the police, the laboratory did not confirm the traces found by the dogs, and the initial e-mail indications transcribed above later turned out to be harmless.
Unquote
-
[/b]
As a result of which the following conclusion was reached and their Arguido status removed.
Quote
The non-involvement of Madeleine's parents in any criminally significant action is apparent from the fact that they were not in the apartment at the time of her disappearance, their normal behaviour up to that moment and afterwards, as witnessed by the statements of the witnesses, the analysis of the telephone communications and the conclusions of the experts reports.
None of the indications which led to their being made suspects was substantiated later; there was no proof of them having notified the media before the police, the laboratory did not confirm the traces found by the dogs, and the initial e-mail indications transcribed above later turned out to be harmless.
Unquote
Can you tell me how it is known whether the mccanns were in the apartment, or not, when the crime has not yet been determined ?
and why haven't you quoted the full findings ?
P.S. The forensic analysis of the apartment was inconclusive.
It neither confirmed or dismissed the dogs indications.
I do recommend you keep to the facts.
-
Where does Brietta say ALL the info was useful to the Met?
Dont put words in her mouth Alice. There's a good fella.
The very fact that they ignored a good number is enough
And why were they ignored?
- Laziness?
- Because Amaral had jumped to conclusions and virtually from day one had fixed in his mind that The Mccanns had dunit, so he ignored anything that pointed in another direction?
or
- was there some other reason?
OK delete the word all and substitute the word any in the same question.
-
Stephen
I am all in favour thta the PJ looked at The Mccanns and thoroughly, BUT without anything against them, except "gut feelings" ....
Why did Amaral turn sightings and potential evidence away?
Sorry, but which sightings and evidence?
-
Sorry, but which sightings and evidence?
Remember G-Unit, there are pointers, always pointers.
-
Remember G-Unit, there are pointers, always pointers.
Looks like that's all I'm getting. @)(++(*
-
Topic. If you please. And that is not a request.
-
Seeing as all the PIs employed found nothing to bring back Madleine Mccann then I would say it was money lost
Whether it was worth it is a bit of a pointless question as one isnt to know beforehand
With hindsight it was worthless as neither thr Mccanns nor the police have found any value in the PIs work
-
Seeing as all the PIs employed found nothing to bring back Madleine Mccann then I would say it was money lost
Whether it was worth it is a bit of a pointless question as one isnt to know beforehand
With hindsight it was worthless as neither thr Mccanns nor the police have found any value in the PIs work
I don't think you can know this as a fact.
-
I never said I did, its IMO, which is a default on most forums
-
I never said I did, its IMO, which is a default on most forums
So glad that it is just in your opinion.
-
So glad that it is just in your opinion.
Some folks are easily pleased, and hate discussion, disappointing, oh well have to go work now