My gut on this case has always been that it wasn't the parents...but for a number of reasons, I have always believed there were at least 2 perpetrators. Hence, to me less likely an opportunistic pedophile and more likely a childless couple or a trafficking ring.
I don’t have enough information to theorise about potential childless couples hanging around the resort….but if it was trafficking then geographically Seville seems interesting to me, because of the relatively short distance by boat in order to arrive into a completely different country. (I think it is a 3-5 hour trip depending on what kind of boat you are using).
Bearing that in mind, it stands out to me that Clarence Mitchell seemed particularly rattled about repeated, mysterious, anonymous very early morning calls made very early in the case about Madeleine being held on a farm in Seville - apparently the property described checked out but Madeleine wasn’t there.
Looking at the files, I noticed that a “Spanish” boat called Ko Phi Phi arrived from Seville on 28th April… pretty odd name for a Spanish boat…... and I believe 1 passenger/skipper who “returned” on 1st May and “departed” on 2nd May…
As you can imagine, the logs are all a bit confusing/difficult to interpret. I guess one could potentially read that the boat arrived 28th April - left 1st May - then somehow arrived back and finally departed 2nd May. Whilst it may be a red herring, I wonder if the boat’s departures and returns could fit in with the crying incidence/abduction and if anyone on this forum knew more about this particular vessel? Also, if this is a suspicious vessel I wondered who might have supplied the intelligence of the actual arrival date of the Tapas group?
Lastly, another point that springs to mind is that we know that entering a property to take a child is a risky and rare phenomenon. Someone prepared to enter a home to abduct a child would not normally do so, just because they believed there were potentially unattended children inside, but rather more likely because they were fixated enough on a particular child to feel he or she warranted such a risk. (In which case, whoever went in would likely have been observing Madeleine over the course of the preceding days, in the hours before 18.30 - after which time Madeleine would have been ‘out of sight")
Perhaps if the “days” had been given the same scrutiny/importance as the “evenings”... the PJ may well have have gathered better intelligence rather than focussing so heavily on the “checking” patterns of the evenings, especially at a time when a possible abductor was likely well hidden in the shadows.
Anyhow, like all of you I can’t be sure of anything relating to this case, but above are some of my main thoughts/questions about it.