Author Topic: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?  (Read 47983 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #135 on: August 19, 2019, 03:00:46 PM »
I see this as bragging about your cleverness;

snip/

an extremely well thought out and detailed theory where all the pieces fit together puuuuurfectly supporting stranger abduction
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10983.msg553235#msg553235

snip/

I've been able to solve the case based on the material we do have.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10983.msg553088#msg553088

I don't see it as clever as I don't consider the case is difficult to solve.  If I said I was able to solve global warming  or find a cure for cancer that would make me clever if I was able to deliver on my claims.
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #136 on: August 19, 2019, 03:01:38 PM »
Not to mention "Its easy for someone like me to solve the case".

'Someone like me' in terms of not having any official role as an investigator.
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #137 on: August 19, 2019, 03:12:56 PM »
'Someone like me' in terms of not having any official role as an investigator.
Holly, I don't want to appear to keep on attacking you as I think you're probably quite a sound person but you have successfully infuriated both sceptics and supporters alike with your wholly unsubstantiated claim - perhaps it was a secret ploy on your part to unite us?  LOL.  There is nothing more annoying on forums than people dangling some personal insight or knowledge and then not backing it up.  You'd have done better to keep schtum entirely.  How would you like it if I claimed to know exactly where Madeleine was right now, but discretion prevents me from saying anymore?  You'd view it as a wind-up, and quite rightly so.  But if I kept on insisting I did it would start to get people's backs up, see?
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #138 on: August 19, 2019, 03:24:04 PM »
Holly, I don't want to appear to keep on attacking you as I think you're probably quite a sound person but you have successfully infuriated both sceptics and supporters alike with your wholly unsubstantiated claim - perhaps it was a secret ploy on your part to unite us?  LOL.  There is nothing more annoying on forums than people dangling some personal insight or knowledge and then not backing it up.  You'd have done better to keep schtum entirely.  How would you like it if I claimed to know exactly where Madeleine was right now, but discretion prevents me from saying anymore?  You'd view it as a wind-up, and quite rightly so.  But if I kept on insisting I did it would start to get people's backs up, see?

Yes I understand what you're saying.  When I was on the Bamber board a poster claimed to have made a 'forensic evidence breakthrough'.  He agreed to share with me in a face-to-face meeting.  We met and it was a crock of shite  8)><(  The venue ended up being a micro brewery and as I quite like beer it wasn't a totally wasted trip  8)-)))

I'm going on hols soon and thereafter I'll refrain from mentioning until such time I feel able to either post it in the private section or send a copy of the email to the boss and he can then let you know what he thinks if applicable. 
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline G-Unit

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #139 on: August 19, 2019, 05:46:40 PM »
I don't see it as clever as I don't consider the case is difficult to solve.  If I said I was able to solve global warming  or find a cure for cancer that would make me clever if I was able to deliver on my claims.

It's a matter of perception, not intention.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline kmc

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #140 on: August 19, 2019, 08:44:20 PM »

My gut on this case has always been that it wasn't the parents...but for a number of reasons, I have always believed there were at least 2 perpetrators. Hence, to me less likely an opportunistic pedophile and more likely a childless couple or a trafficking ring.

I don’t have enough information to theorise about potential childless couples hanging around the resort….but if it was trafficking then geographically Seville seems interesting to me, because of the relatively short distance by boat in order to arrive into a completely different country.  (I think it is a 3-5 hour trip depending on what kind of boat you are using).

Bearing that in mind, it stands out to me that Clarence Mitchell seemed particularly rattled about repeated, mysterious, anonymous very early morning calls made very early in the case about Madeleine being held on a farm in Seville - apparently the property described checked out but Madeleine wasn’t there.   

Looking at the files, I noticed that a “Spanish” boat called Ko Phi Phi arrived from Seville on 28th April… pretty odd name for a Spanish boat…... and I believe 1 passenger/skipper who “returned” on 1st May and “departed” on 2nd May…

As you can imagine, the logs are all a bit confusing/difficult to interpret.  I guess one could potentially read that the boat arrived 28th April - left 1st May  - then somehow arrived back and finally departed 2nd May.   Whilst it may be a red herring, I wonder if the boat’s departures and returns could fit in with the crying incidence/abduction and if anyone on this forum knew more about this particular vessel?  Also, if this is a suspicious vessel I wondered who might have supplied the intelligence of the actual arrival date of the Tapas group?

Lastly, another point that springs to mind is that we know that entering a property to take a child is a risky and rare phenomenon.   Someone prepared to enter a home to abduct a child would not normally do so, just because they believed there were potentially unattended children inside, but rather more likely because they were fixated enough on a particular child to feel he or she warranted such a risk.  (In which case, whoever went in would likely have been observing Madeleine over the course of the preceding days, in the hours before 18.30 - after which time Madeleine would have been ‘out of sight")

Perhaps if the “days” had been given the same scrutiny/importance as the “evenings”... the PJ may well have have gathered better intelligence rather than focussing so heavily on the “checking” patterns of the evenings, especially at a time when a possible abductor was likely well hidden in the shadows. 

Anyhow, like all of you I can’t be sure of anything relating to this case, but above are some of my main thoughts/questions about it.

Offline sadie

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #141 on: August 19, 2019, 11:58:18 PM »
The images were taken Feb 2015 so OC would have been pretty quiet.
Balu had a hire car that week but I'd guess it was parked at the front of Block 6. I've not cross-referenced all the other guests in the vicinity of Block 6/villas opposite to see who else had a hire car that week. There was one known long-term occupier in no.35 (one of the villas) who had a Landrover which was probably parked in the lot in question in 2007.
A vehicle is much easier to trace than a random person in a fluid population.

No 35 was in the next road down to the little car park oposite the Tapas reception. 
It is the end villa and had a view of 5A and anyone walking from the Tapas up Rua Dr FGM.  This info has been taken from viewing GE and there may be obstructions to that view that I am not aware of

The person staying there long term had a Landrover with, according to images shown yonks ago, great big search lights on the top.


He has been mentioned before re the case, because IIRC he was a friend of RM and also of SM.  I forget his name, but I think it began with Matt.  I think he had some connection with one of them to a boat named 'Ocean Expeditions' or something like that.




Please note:  Rua Dr FGM has several cul-de-sacs branching off it, and it seems that all the cul-de-sacs are also called Rua Dr FGM. 

Offline misty

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #142 on: August 20, 2019, 12:36:12 AM »
No 35 was in the next road down to the little car park oposite the Tapas reception. 
It is the end villa and had a view of 5A and anyone walking from the Tapas up Rua Dr FGM.  This info has been taken from viewing GE and there may be obstructions to that view that I am not aware of

The person staying there long term had a Landrover with, according to images shown yonks ago, great big search lights on the top.


He has been mentioned before re the case, because IIRC he was a friend of RM and also of SM.  I forget his name, but I think it began with Matt.  I think he had some connection with one of them to a boat named 'Ocean Expeditions' or something like that.




Please note:  Rua Dr FGM has several cul-de-sacs branching off it, and it seems that all the cul-de-sacs are also called Rua Dr FGM.

You are correct according to this map of OC layout, Sadie. No. 35 is almost opposite the Baptista. I misread the house number in the cul-de-sac opposite Tapas reception.

http://luzoceanclub.com/content/uploads/LUZ-OCEAN-CLUB-MAP.pdf
« Last Edit: August 20, 2019, 12:38:39 AM by misty »

Offline sadie

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #143 on: August 20, 2019, 01:20:41 AM »
You are correct according to this map of OC layout, Sadie. No. 35 is almost opposite the Baptista. I misread the house number in the cul-de-sac opposite Tapas reception.

http://luzoceanclub.com/content/uploads/LUZ-OCEAN-CLUB-MAP.pdf

Yep, misty, you are correct.
The best way to look at it is on GE where it is the first villa in the cul-de-sac.   If you change to street scene, the number 35 is shown clearly above the door.   The cul-de-sac is the one immediately below (south of) the little car park cul-de-sac opposite the Tapas reception.

There are two ways thru to that car park from number 35.  One is via the main Rua FGM and then there is an almost hidden way thru .  If you want to see the hidden way thru, you will have to zoom in closely.

Offline G-Unit

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #144 on: August 20, 2019, 07:12:49 AM »
No 35 was in the next road down to the little car park oposite the Tapas reception. 
It is the end villa and had a view of 5A and anyone walking from the Tapas up Rua Dr FGM.  This info has been taken from viewing GE and there may be obstructions to that view that I am not aware of

The person staying there long term had a Landrover with, according to images shown yonks ago, great big search lights on the top.


He has been mentioned before re the case, because IIRC he was a friend of RM and also of SM.  I forget his name, but I think it began with Matt.  I think he had some connection with one of them to a boat named 'Ocean Expeditions' or something like that.




Please note:  Rua Dr FGM has several cul-de-sacs branching off it, and it seems that all the cul-de-sacs are also called Rua Dr FGM.

An English couple with a child lived there, although at the time he was living in England and his wife didn't know when he might return. He used to be partners with Malinka running a computer store in Lagos. The Land Rover was hers. No mention of a boat?
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KELSIE_HARRIS.htm
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Lace

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #145 on: August 20, 2019, 10:04:25 AM »
My gut on this case has always been that it wasn't the parents...but for a number of reasons, I have always believed there were at least 2 perpetrators. Hence, to me less likely an opportunistic pedophile and more likely a childless couple or a trafficking ring.

I don’t have enough information to theorise about potential childless couples hanging around the resort….but if it was trafficking then geographically Seville seems interesting to me, because of the relatively short distance by boat in order to arrive into a completely different country.  (I think it is a 3-5 hour trip depending on what kind of boat you are using).

Bearing that in mind, it stands out to me that Clarence Mitchell seemed particularly rattled about repeated, mysterious, anonymous very early morning calls made very early in the case about Madeleine being held on a farm in Seville - apparently the property described checked out but Madeleine wasn’t there.   

Looking at the files, I noticed that a “Spanish” boat called Ko Phi Phi arrived from Seville on 28th April… pretty odd name for a Spanish boat…... and I believe 1 passenger/skipper who “returned” on 1st May and “departed” on 2nd May…

As you can imagine, the logs are all a bit confusing/difficult to interpret.  I guess one could potentially read that the boat arrived 28th April - left 1st May  - then somehow arrived back and finally departed 2nd May.   Whilst it may be a red herring, I wonder if the boat’s departures and returns could fit in with the crying incidence/abduction and if anyone on this forum knew more about this particular vessel?  Also, if this is a suspicious vessel I wondered who might have supplied the intelligence of the actual arrival date of the Tapas group?

Lastly, another point that springs to mind is that we know that entering a property to take a child is a risky and rare phenomenon.   Someone prepared to enter a home to abduct a child would not normally do so, just because they believed there were potentially unattended children inside, but rather more likely because they were fixated enough on a particular child to feel he or she warranted such a risk.  (In which case, whoever went in would likely have been observing Madeleine over the course of the preceding days, in the hours before 18.30 - after which time Madeleine would have been ‘out of sight")

Perhaps if the “days” had been given the same scrutiny/importance as the “evenings”... the PJ may well have have gathered better intelligence rather than focussing so heavily on the “checking” patterns of the evenings, especially at a time when a possible abductor was likely well hidden in the shadows. 

Anyhow, like all of you I can’t be sure of anything relating to this case, but above are some of my main thoughts/questions about it.

There's an island called Phi Phi [pee pee]  in Thailand.

Offline sadie

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #146 on: August 20, 2019, 10:22:52 AM »
[
An English couple with a child lived there, although at the time he was living in England and his wife didn't know when he might return. He used to be partners with Malinka running a computer store in Lagos. The Land Rover was hers. No mention of a boat?
https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KELSIE_HARRIS.htm


His name is Matthew Fazackerley.  His wifes name is Kelsie Harris and his shop, jointly owned with Sergie Malinka, was next door to Robert Murats Estate agency in nearby Lagos.  So all three of them knew each other, despite denials by one of them.

Can anyone remember which one originally claimed not to know Sergie?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #147 on: August 20, 2019, 11:10:36 AM »
Yes I understand what you're saying.  When I was on the Bamber board a poster claimed to have made a 'forensic evidence breakthrough'.  He agreed to share with me in a face-to-face meeting.  We met and it was a crock of shite  8)><(  The venue ended up being a micro brewery and as I quite like beer it wasn't a totally wasted trip  8)-)))

I'm going on hols soon and thereafter I'll refrain from mentioning until such time I feel able to either post it in the private section or send a copy of the email to the boss and he can then let you know what he thinks if applicable.

I think that crock of shite remark could come back to haunt you

Offline G-Unit

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #148 on: August 20, 2019, 11:16:05 AM »
My gut on this case has always been that it wasn't the parents...but for a number of reasons, I have always believed there were at least 2 perpetrators. Hence, to me less likely an opportunistic pedophile and more likely a childless couple or a trafficking ring.

I don’t have enough information to theorise about potential childless couples hanging around the resort….but if it was trafficking then geographically Seville seems interesting to me, because of the relatively short distance by boat in order to arrive into a completely different country.  (I think it is a 3-5 hour trip depending on what kind of boat you are using).

Bearing that in mind, it stands out to me that Clarence Mitchell seemed particularly rattled about repeated, mysterious, anonymous very early morning calls made very early in the case about Madeleine being held on a farm in Seville - apparently the property described checked out but Madeleine wasn’t there.   

Looking at the files, I noticed that a “Spanish” boat called Ko Phi Phi arrived from Seville on 28th April… pretty odd name for a Spanish boat…... and I believe 1 passenger/skipper who “returned” on 1st May and “departed” on 2nd May…

As you can imagine, the logs are all a bit confusing/difficult to interpret.  I guess one could potentially read that the boat arrived 28th April - left 1st May  - then somehow arrived back and finally departed 2nd May.   Whilst it may be a red herring, I wonder if the boat’s departures and returns could fit in with the crying incidence/abduction and if anyone on this forum knew more about this particular vessel?  Also, if this is a suspicious vessel I wondered who might have supplied the intelligence of the actual arrival date of the Tapas group?

Lastly, another point that springs to mind is that we know that entering a property to take a child is a risky and rare phenomenon.   Someone prepared to enter a home to abduct a child would not normally do so, just because they believed there were potentially unattended children inside, but rather more likely because they were fixated enough on a particular child to feel he or she warranted such a risk.  (In which case, whoever went in would likely have been observing Madeleine over the course of the preceding days, in the hours before 18.30 - after which time Madeleine would have been ‘out of sight")

Perhaps if the “days” had been given the same scrutiny/importance as the “evenings”... the PJ may well have have gathered better intelligence rather than focussing so heavily on the “checking” patterns of the evenings, especially at a time when a possible abductor was likely well hidden in the shadows. 

Anyhow, like all of you I can’t be sure of anything relating to this case, but above are some of my main thoughts/questions about it.

Just a couple of points. Why would someone sail to Seville when it can be reached in 3 hours by car? The sea route via Gibralter seems quite complicated.

Secondly, boat's names don't necessarily match with the country they're registered in. There's a GB registered boat named 'Koala'!
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Angelo222

Re: What Are The Current Theories Held By Contributors At UKJF?
« Reply #149 on: August 20, 2019, 11:53:11 AM »
So those who believe the McCanns are responsible believe MM came to some harm in the apartment and her body disposed of? 

What are the general theories from those who believe the McCanns are not responsible? 

Abduction from 5A or woke and wandered and abducted elsewhere? 

Motives?  Childless couple or paedophile?

Perp? Local, OC employee, MW guest/visitor, organised crime gang?

Current status?  Alive or dead?

For me the only theory which stands up to scrutiny is that Maddie woke up and being the determined child she was made her way outside to find her parents. Very possibly she heard her father chatting to Jez Wilkins outside 5a and decided that this was her chance.  The tracker dogs followed her fresh scent out the front door of the family holiday apartment, around block 5 and back out to the main road where it suddenly ended.  It is not beyond the realms of possibly that she was knocked down by a motorist who panicked and carried her off in his vehicle.  Maybe he intended to seek medical help at the town's medical centre, thus the Smith sighting immediately outside it.

No other theory is backed up by any evidence. There is no evidence that Maddie was abducted from her bedroom but plenty to suggest she was taken from the street outside imo.
« Last Edit: August 20, 2019, 11:56:52 AM by Angelo222 »
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!