The evidence places Gerry McCann in the tapas bar at 10pm

[Rachel Granada]

Do people seriously imagine that the Smith sighting was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse away from the apartment? Come on!

Do people seriously believe that the Tanner "sighting" was an abductor carrying a sleeping Madeleine from the apartment? Come on!

I'm not talking about Tanner, I'm talking about the logistics of Gerry McCann carrying a corpse through the streets of Praia da Luz.  What say you, C Edwards?

[C.Edwards]

Do people seriously imagine that the Smith sighting was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse away from the apartment? Come on!

Do people seriously believe that the Tanner "sighting" was an abductor carrying a sleeping Madeleine from the apartment? Come on!

I'm not talking about Tanner, I'm talking about the logistics of Gerry McCann carrying a corpse through the streets of Praia da Luz.  What say you, C Edwards?

Pointless asking me. As Debunker says, it's not impossible so it's possible.

[Rachel Granada]

Do people seriously imagine that the Smith sighting was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse away from the apartment? Come on!

Do people seriously believe that the Tanner "sighting" was an abductor carrying a sleeping Madeleine from the apartment? Come on!

I'm not talking about Tanner, I'm talking about the logistics of Gerry McCann carrying a corpse through the streets of Praia da Luz.  What say you, C Edwards?

Pointless asking me. As Debunker says, it's not impossible so it's possible.

Forum readers... draw your own conclusions from C Edwards' failure to address my question.

[AnneGuedes]

Whoever the carrier, to what perfect spot was he walking with Madeleine ?

[AnneGuedes]

Do people seriously imagine that the Smith sighting was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse away from the apartment? Come on!

Do people seriously believe that the Tanner "sighting" was an abductor carrying a sleeping Madeleine from the apartment? Come on!

I'm not talking about Tanner, I'm talking about the logistics of Gerry McCann carrying a corpse through the streets of Praia da Luz.  What say you, C Edwards?

Pointless asking me. As Debunker says, it's not impossible so it's possible.

Forum readers... draw your own conclusions from C Edwards' failure to address my question.

Thanks to your "seriously" the reaction seems appropriate to me.

[Rachel Granada]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

[AnneGuedes]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

Yes I can. I'm not sure about the carrier, but I've no doubt the little girl he carried was Madeleine.  Was she in a coma or was she dead ? Likely the second. Did he kill her ? I don't think so. Predators use, kill and leave behind, they don't carry corpses.
Just my opinion !

[Rachel Granada]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

Yes I can. I'm not sure about the carrier, but I've no doubt the little girl he carried was Madeleine.  Was she in a coma or was she dead ? Likely the second. Did he kill her ? I don't think so. Predators use, kill and leave behind, they don't carry corpses.
Just my opinion !

Are you saying that it was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse, Anne?

[AnneGuedes]

You must be a seriously sick person to post what you have.
Shame on you.

I'm not sick, seriously or not, don't worry ! And remember opinions never killed little girls.

[AnneGuedes]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

Yes I can. I'm not sure about the carrier, but I've no doubt the little girl he carried was Madeleine.  Was she in a coma or was she dead ? Likely the second. Did he kill her ? I don't think so. Predators use, kill and leave behind, they don't carry corpses.
Just my opinion !

Are you saying that it was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse, Anne?

No, Rachel, I'm certainly not saying that.

[Admin]

Do people seriously believe that the Tanner "sighting" was an abductor carrying a sleeping Madeleine from the apartment? Come on!

If I may intercede.

Why ever not? Isn't that the only scenario which fits with all the known evidence?

The apartment was one of the easiest to get to, the abductor most probably had a key to it and possibly others.  There is evidence from at least two witnesses that the apartments were being watched from across the street, there had been incidents in the past when intruders had entered the apartments.  Security seems to have been lax at the complex especially after dark.

[Admin]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

Yes I can. I'm not sure about the carrier, but I've no doubt the little girl he carried was Madeleine.  Was she in a coma or was she dead ? Likely the second. Did he kill her ? I don't think so. Predators use, kill and leave behind, they don't carry corpses.
Just my opinion !

Carry her for over 400 metres in an area swarming with tourists on a night out? In any event that is not where the tracker dogs ended up.

[John]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

Yes I can. I'm not sure about the carrier, but I've no doubt the little girl he carried was Madeleine.  Was she in a coma or was she dead ? Likely the second. Did he kill her ? I don't think so. Predators use, kill and leave behind, they don't carry corpses.
Just my opinion !

Carry her for over 400 metres in an area swarming with tourists on a night out? In any event that is not where the tracker dogs ended up.

I will be introducing this subject tomorrow with maps showing where the police dogs tracked Madeleine to.

[Rachel Granada]

So, Anne Guedes... can you give us your opinion about the Smith sighting?

Yes I can. I'm not sure about the carrier, but I've no doubt the little girl he carried was Madeleine.  Was she in a coma or was she dead ? Likely the second. Did he kill her ? I don't think so. Predators use, kill and leave behind, they don't carry corpses.
Just my opinion !

Are you saying that it was Gerry McCann carrying Madeleine's corpse, Anne?

No, Rachel, I'm certainly not saying that.

What are you saying then, Anne?

[AnneGuedes]

Do people seriously believe that the Tanner "sighting" was an abductor carrying a sleeping Madeleine from the apartment? Come on!

If I may intercede.

Why ever not? Isn't that the only scenario which fits with all the known evidence?

The apartment was one of the easiest to get to, the abductor most probably had a key to it and possibly others.  There is evidence from at least two witnesses that the apartments were being watched from across the street, there had been incidents in the past when intruders had entered the apartments.  Security seems to have been lax at the complex especially after dark.

Do you suggest Mrs Fenn could have been abducted by "her" intruder ?
I don't doubt Jane T saw a man carrying a child, but I suggest the child was in a coma or dead, according to the position of the child (for me the best proof she saw someone, she couldn't have invented that curious way of carrying).