Dog Alerts- Evidence or not?

[Mr Gray]

Del

[Mr Gray]

SY have confirmed in a FOI request that they still have the DNA data for analysis. So they can share it with Dr Perlin as part of their investigation.

if they have breukners DNA they may already have eliminated him from the dna sample...sorry to burst your bubble

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

if they have breukners DNA they may already have eliminated him from the dna sample...sorry to burst your bubble

I haven't seen one shred of evidence that he set foot in 5A. So you're not bursting anything!

[Mr Gray]

I haven't seen one shred of evidence that he set foot in 5A. So you're not bursting anything!

they have his dna...so perlin wont be any help to show he has...just ponting out the obvious

[Carana]

I doubt it too but you never know... it would confirm an abduction anyway! Dr Perlin reckons he can reach a conclusive analysis of the DNA data in two weeks. There's nothing to lose in taking him up on this offer.

A conclusive analysis of what? His system is a probabilistic black box.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

they have his dna...so perlin wont be any help to show he has...just ponting out the obvious

He could see if it matched the blood human cellular material on swab 3A.

[pathfinder73]

He could see if it matched the blood human cellular material on swab 3A.

No supporter wants that as they are running scared. None of them believe the Germans DNA will be inside apartment 5A or they would be supporting new tests.

[Carana]

He could see if it matched the blood human cellular material on swab 3A.

Why was there nothing on swab 3b?

[Carana]

No supporter wants that as they are running scared. None of them believe the Germans DNA will be inside apartment 5A or they would be supporting new tests.

New tests? From 5a, when it was rented out 4 times after she disappeared and however many people have occupied it since?

[Mr Gray]

No supporter wants that as they are running scared. None of them believe the Germans DNA will be inside apartment 5A or they would be supporting new tests.

They dont need any new tests. They can simply look at how many markers of CB are in the mixed sample and they may well have already done that. As I recall the data file was removed around  ayear ago.

[Carana]

I haven't followed forensic hair analysis for a while. The PT lab (INML) couldn't find enough nDNA for analysis, but noted numerous mtDNA results which didn't correspond to any of the reference samples that they could compare them with.

It's therefore possible that one of the unknown profiles could correspond to Christian B or eventually to an accomplice.

However, as forensic science seems to have advanced, it may now be possible to narrow down mtDNA results of samples.

It might be helpful if they could locate the missing hairs from her bed....

[Carana]

if they have breukners DNA they may already have eliminated him from the dna sample...sorry to burst your bubble

I still don't know which DNA sample is being referred to.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Why was there nothing on swab 3b?

There was DNA on swab 3b

"In my opinion there is no evidence to support the view that Madeleine McCann contributed DNA to this result" (FSS Report)

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

A conclusive analysis of what? His system is a probabilistic black box.

When your critique of his methods are published in peer reviewed forensic science journals I will take your questions seriously.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

New tests? From 5a, when it was rented out 4 times after she disappeared and however many people have occupied it since?

No... new analysis on the DNA data!