Is there more circumstantial evidence against the mccanns than there is CB

[Mr Gray]

That is, in my opinion, a ludicrous statement.

I agree...I think the evidence from CBs friends is far more reliable

[Mr Gray]

Afaiaa Smith and his wife have been supportive of the McCanns so he cannot still believe he saw Gerry carrying Maddie

[Vertigo Swirl]

That is, in my opinion, a ludicrous statement.

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street weeks earlier, should be any more reliable than the anecdotal evidence of people who were close to CB?  I look forward to your rationale.

[kizzy]

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street weeks earlier, should be any more reliable than the anecdotal evidence of people who were close to CB?  I look forward to your rationale.

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street

Seems the e-fit was a very good likeness IMO

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article2371953.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/E-fit.jpg

[Vertigo Swirl]

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street

Seems the e-fit was a very good likeness IMO

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article2371953.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/E-fit.jpg

You do realise that the e-fits were created well after Gerry McCann had become world famous don't you?  And that if Mr Smith was absolutely certain he'd seen Gerry he could have just told the e-fit artist to copy a picture of Gerry's face?

[Myster]

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street

Seems the e-fit was a very good likeness IMO

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article2371953.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/E-fit.jpg

Looks more like Desperate Sceptic Dan to me...

[Anthro]

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street

Seems the e-fit was a very good likeness IMO

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article2371953.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/E-fit.jpg

I thought Mr Smith didn’t have his glasses on (?)

[kizzy]

You do realise that the e-fits were created well after Gerry McCann had become world famous don't you?  And that if Mr Smith was absolutely certain he'd seen Gerry he could have just told the e-fit artist to copy a picture of Gerry's face?

Don't you think the police would have been aware of that when they showed it on crime watch years later?

Yet still showed it as a possible suspect.

Seems it definitely wasn't CB that he saw...at least you admit it does look like gmcc to compare it to a picture of gmcs face..

[kizzy]

I thought Mr Smith didn’t have his glasses on (?)

Oh right why do you think that

Could be the reason he was only 60/80% sure rather than 100% imo

He obviously could see to describe the colour of clothing.

[barrier]

Carrying a child with a description "very close to that of Madeleine McCann" Redwood 2013,very fleeting in deed.

[Eleanor]

Perhaps you could explain why Martin Smith's recall of a fleeting glimpse of a stranger passing him in the street

Seems the e-fit was a very good likeness IMO

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article2371953.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/E-fit.jpg

Of Paulo Cristovao.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Don't you think the police would have been aware of that when they showed it on crime watch years later?

Yet still showed it as a possible suspect.

Seems it definitely wasn't CB that he saw...at least you admit it does look like gmcc to compare it to a picture of gmcs face..

No I didn't, that's in your imagination.

[kizzy]

No I didn't, that's in your imagination.

You do realise that the e-fits were created well after Gerry McCann had become world famous don't you?  And that if Mr Smith was absolutely certain he'd seen Gerry he could have just told the e-fit artist to copy a picture of Gerry's face?

Your post, not my imagination.

[Wonderfulspam]

Not once have SY said

a) That there's no evidence against the McCanns

& b) That they didn't do it.

[Vertigo Swirl]

You do realise that the e-fits were created well after Gerry McCann had become world famous don't you?  And that if Mr Smith was absolutely certain he'd seen Gerry he could have just told the e-fit artist to copy a picture of Gerry's face?

Your post, not my imagination.

I know what I wrote.  Where do I admit anything at all?