Author Topic: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?  (Read 20531 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline south of the river

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #30 on: April 26, 2013, 03:52:42 PM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #31 on: April 26, 2013, 04:04:30 PM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

Not sure who you're quoting, there South of the river (and welcome to the board, by the way), but in an interview Amaral does, at least appear, to have said he met the McCanns once, in an "interview" where the so-called sofa theory (that Madeleine fell off it and died) is supposed to have been put to Kate.

I have my doubts.

Kate says she and Gerry saw Amaral in the flesh for the first time at the first hearing into the injunction on his book ...

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #32 on: April 26, 2013, 04:05:55 PM »
THE ENGLISH SPECIALIST DOG TEAM

The heat is scorching on this thirtieth day of July 2007 when two Springer Spaniels, Eddie and Keela, get off the British Airways plane, accompanied by their trainer, Martin Grime. An air-conditioned vehicle is waiting to take them to their accommodation. A vet, who will be on hand during their stay, has been brought in to intervene in case of illness or if the dogs get bitten by a snake. Their mission: to find Madeleine's body and expose those responsible.

Eddie has been involved in a great number of cases, helping the police to resolve a good many riddles, thanks to his sense of smell. Even if the body has been moved, objects the body has touched have been contaminated by its odour, especially porous materials, fabrics, the upholstery in cars, etc. And that odour, Eddie knows how to recognise out of a thousand.

Keela, a scenes of crime specialist, is capable of locating particles of blood even after a place has been cleaned with chemical products or bleach. Sometimes, the residues are so microscopic they are missed by the instruments of the forensic police, as sophicticated as they are, and it's impossible to harvest them without taking all of what they are on.

Eddie is always the first to be brought onto a site. Once he has discerned the odour that he knows so well, it's Keela's turn to go into action, on the lookout for the slightest whiff of blood. The simultaneous presence of the two elements in a given place - blood and cavaver odours - is taken to indicate that a body has been there and that it's probably there that the death occurred.

The dogs' CV is impressive. Besides collaborating in hundreds of investigations, they passed the practical tests brilliantly at the FBI's "Body Farm," the only place in the world where human cadavers are used to simulate homicide scenarios and concealment of bodies.

I actually thought Amaral had not fallen into the trap of stating that Eddie had been involved in hundreds of cases

But I was wrong.

Grime stated over 200 for Eddie alone:

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME_IXprocesso_2265.jpg

SYP say just 37 for Eddie.

They didn't state a number for Keela but she was half Eddie's age ...



Mr Grime chooses his words carefully to avoid lying ...


He  tells the truth, in other words

Erm, no ...

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #33 on: April 26, 2013, 04:32:09 PM »
THE ENGLISH SPECIALIST DOG TEAM

The heat is scorching on this thirtieth day of July 2007 when two Springer Spaniels, Eddie and Keela, get off the British Airways plane, accompanied by their trainer, Martin Grime. An air-conditioned vehicle is waiting to take them to their accommodation. A vet, who will be on hand during their stay, has been brought in to intervene in case of illness or if the dogs get bitten by a snake. Their mission: to find Madeleine's body and expose those responsible.

Eddie has been involved in a great number of cases, helping the police to resolve a good many riddles, thanks to his sense of smell. Even if the body has been moved, objects the body has touched have been contaminated by its odour, especially porous materials, fabrics, the upholstery in cars, etc. And that odour, Eddie knows how to recognise out of a thousand.

Keela, a scenes of crime specialist, is capable of locating particles of blood even after a place has been cleaned with chemical products or bleach. Sometimes, the residues are so microscopic they are missed by the instruments of the forensic police, as sophicticated as they are, and it's impossible to harvest them without taking all of what they are on.

Eddie is always the first to be brought onto a site. Once he has discerned the odour that he knows so well, it's Keela's turn to go into action, on the lookout for the slightest whiff of blood. The simultaneous presence of the two elements in a given place - blood and cavaver odours - is taken to indicate that a body has been there and that it's probably there that the death occurred.

The dogs' CV is impressive. Besides collaborating in hundreds of investigations, they passed the practical tests brilliantly at the FBI's "Body Farm," the only place in the world where human cadavers are used to simulate homicide scenarios and concealment of bodies.

I actually thought Amaral had not fallen into the trap of stating that Eddie had been involved in hundreds of cases

But I was wrong.

Grime stated over 200 for Eddie alone:

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME_IXprocesso_2265.jpg

SYP say just 37 for Eddie.

They didn't state a number for Keela but she was half Eddie's age ...



Mr Grime chooses his words carefully to avoid lying ...


He  tells the truth, in other words

Erm, no ...

You think Martin Grime is a liar then ? 

Rachel Granada

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #34 on: April 26, 2013, 04:41:28 PM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

Hello and welcome, south of the river.  Yes, that floored me too when I found out.  I had been under the impression that Amaral had been there at the arguido interviews etc.  I was gobsmacked when I found out that he had never even met them.  For me, based on this alone, his book has no more credibility than if it had been penned by a toilet cleaner at the Portimao cop-shop.

Offline faithlilly

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #35 on: April 27, 2013, 11:13:23 PM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

Hello and welcome, south of the river.  Yes, that floored me too when I found out.  I had been under the impression that Amaral had been there at the arguido interviews etc.  I was gobsmacked when I found out that he had never even met them.  For me, based on this alone, his book has no more credibility than if it had been penned by a toilet cleaner at the Portimao cop-shop.

I think it is your  lack of knowledge regarding the hierarchy within the PJ that is the problem. As co-ordinator Amaral would not have had any need to meet the McCanns. I believe he didn't meet Cipriano either.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #36 on: April 27, 2013, 11:29:10 PM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

Hello and welcome, south of the river.  Yes, that floored me too when I found out.  I had been under the impression that Amaral had been there at the arguido interviews etc.  I was gobsmacked when I found out that he had never even met them.  For me, based on this alone, his book has no more credibility than if it had been penned by a toilet cleaner at the Portimao cop-shop.

I think it is your  lack of knowledge regarding the hierarchy within the PJ that is the problem. As co-ordinator Amaral would not have had any need to meet the McCanns. I believe he didn't meet Cipriano either.

Even by your standards, that's pretty non-sensical, Faith

Why would the person in charge of an investigation not want to meet whoever he is investigating?

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #37 on: April 27, 2013, 11:41:17 PM »
It might not normally be unusual for the head of an investigation to not interview or meet the protagonists in an investigation  (  and leave it to subordinates to do the leg work, reporting  back to him as required )

This case was so high profile though  (  the whole world was watching, afterall )  you would think Amaral would want to be as 'hands on' and personally involved as possible

It is strange that he never set eyes on the McCanns until he was already removed from the case

Offline Benice

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #38 on: April 28, 2013, 02:00:45 AM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

Hello and welcome, south of the river.  Yes, that floored me too when I found out.  I had been under the impression that Amaral had been there at the arguido interviews etc.  I was gobsmacked when I found out that he had never even met them.  For me, based on this alone, his book has no more credibility than if it had been penned by a toilet cleaner at the Portimao cop-shop.

I think it is your  lack of knowledge regarding the hierarchy within the PJ that is the problem. As co-ordinator Amaral would not have had any need to meet the McCanns. I believe he didn't meet Cipriano either.

So why did he not make that clear in his book?   Why go out of his way to hide the fact that he had never actually met them himself?   The sheer dishonesty associated with that fact is appalling.   


The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #39 on: April 28, 2013, 02:16:25 AM »
you learn things about the case all the time ! so Amaral who was convinced that the mccans were guilty of disposing of the body - covering up a crime and being at the heart of a massive misscarriage of justice - to such an extent that he has gone on recird to say so - he never met them ? never intervied them ? Have I got that right or am I missing something

Hello and welcome, south of the river.  Yes, that floored me too when I found out.  I had been under the impression that Amaral had been there at the arguido interviews etc.  I was gobsmacked when I found out that he had never even met them.  For me, based on this alone, his book has no more credibility than if it had been penned by a toilet cleaner at the Portimao cop-shop.

I think it is your  lack of knowledge regarding the hierarchy within the PJ that is the problem. As co-ordinator Amaral would not have had any need to meet the McCanns. I believe he didn't meet Cipriano either.

So why did he not make that clear in his book?   Why go out of his way to hide the fact that he had never actually met them himself?   The sheer dishonesty associated with that fact is appalling.   

I have not read Amaral's book  ...  in what way is he dishonest about never having seen the McCanns face to face ?   ...  does he imply, in some way,  that he  did meet them ?

Offline Chinagirl

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #40 on: April 28, 2013, 04:50:12 AM »
I have not read Amaral's book  ...  in what way is he dishonest about never having seen the McCanns face to face ?   ...  does he imply, in some way,  that he  did meet them ?

Yes.  Throughout the book he gives that impression.
A

Offline Carana

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #41 on: April 28, 2013, 08:58:28 AM »
His book is one thing, his interviews are something else...


Gonçalo Amaral, police chief of the Madeleine case : "Justice is working in silence" Granada Digital
 
Lisardo García
Friday, 12/09/2008 08:39 


GD .- What were the most important facts and evidence which led to the parents of Maddie being declared arguidos (suspects)?
Fundamentally the reports from the DNA laboratory in England confirmed the work of the British police dogs who found a cadaver odour and biological traces of the girl in several rooms of the apartment, on the clothes of the mother and in the car that the McCanns rented twenty days after the disappearance of Maddie; another important test is the statement by the Irish family, Smith, who stated that they recognised the father Gerry McCann carrying a girl in his arms, who seemed to be asleep, at 23h00 that night.

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id165.html


I'm struggling to find a single detail in that that isn't either inaccurate or misleading...

Offline gilet

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #42 on: April 28, 2013, 10:08:36 PM »
Yes I have read his book.

It appalled me.  And why?

Because he described over and over how bad the PJ really were. If you want to know what went wrong in this investigation you need only read Amaral's own book.

He tells us there were no procedures for this kind of case. He tells us that the photographer who first went to the scene failed to get the necessary photos. He tells us that the fingerprint technicians were not very competent. He describes in other words a catalogue of errors which badly let Madeleine McCann down.

No opinions from me about that. Just the actual words of Amaral describing how bad his own team actually were.

But I will offer an opinion based on something else I read in the book. What kind of man is he that could on the night a child went missing just down the road (whether its his job or not to attend) simply make a couple of phone calls to check others were doing things, then go back to his meal and after that just go home to sit with his own daughter and ponder the ways of the world? He sounds sozzled in that passage to be honest.

I can't understand how he didn't simply excuse himself and head to PDL to check what was going on, not as a police officer but as a human being, a father and a concerned citizen.  But it never crossed his mind.


Offline Luz

Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #43 on: April 28, 2013, 10:43:16 PM »
a valid question in view of posts today.

Yes I read Amaral's books (there are 2 related to this case), and no I shan't discuss them with anyone that hasn't read them in portuguese.

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: Have posters on here actually read Amaral's book?
« Reply #44 on: April 28, 2013, 10:44:43 PM »
luz
Quote
Yes I read Amaral's books (there are 2 related to this case), and no I shan't discuss them with anyone that hasn't read them in portuguese.


thankyou for your contribution to the topic luz.
« Last Edit: April 28, 2013, 10:46:46 PM by amaraltheofficeboy »