The Portuguese Police thought the dogs were 100% accurate.

[Mr Gray]

I thought it was because Kate took her work clothes on Holiday with her.... 8-)(--)

grime said their were several possibilities that would result in cross contamination...perhaps this is one of them

[Mr Gray]

Or perhaps not.

What's curious to me is that a young child disappeared 3rd May 2007 from that apartment, never to have been seen since that day and yet you place the possibility of the scent relating to her death, clearly at the back of the queue.

This is why I previously referred to you blindly following a particular viewpoint.

Blindly...as I said before is quite an insult and also inaccurate. Having assessed the available evidence I put maddies death in the apt at the back of the queue..

[stephen25000]

Blindly...as I said before is quite an insult and also inaccurate. Having assessed the available evidence I put maddies death in the apt at the back of the queue..

Meanwhile in the real world, no trace of Madeleine.

No trace of abduction or any abductor(s).

I wonder which next mystery person will be in the papers accused of being an abductor ?

[Mr Gray]

Meanwhile in the real world, no trace of Madeleine.

No trace of abduction or any abductor(s).

I wonder which next mystery person will be in the papers accused of being an abductor ?

yes disappeared of the face of the earth...just like Ben Needham

[stephen25000]

yes disappeared of the face of the earth...just like Ben Needham

Were Ben's guardians at the time he disappeared, boozing the night's away in the 'back garden' ?

[Mr Gray]

Were Ben's guardians at the time he disappeared, boozing the night's away in the 'back garden' ?

where were they...are there any independent witnesses...anyway...off topic now

[stephen25000]

where were they...are there any independent witnesses...anyway...off topic now

Off topic ?


It was you, yet again bringing up the Needhams.

[Mr Gray]

Off topic ?


It was you, yet again bringing up the Needhams.

I did mention Ben once but I think I got away with it

[Redblossom]

yes disappeared of the face of the earth...just like Ben Needham

No cadaver dog alerted in the family home, slight difference there, plus I don't recall any of them changing statements and giving different versions every so often, or being made suspects,  so not quite "just like"

[Mr Gray]

No cadaver dog alerted in the family home, slight difference there, plus I don't recall any of them changing statements and giving different versions every so often, or being made suspects,  so not quite "just like"

Cadaver dogs weren't taken to the home..they were suspects..as it was I was referring to Ben disappearing into thin air...didn't mention the family

[Redblossom]

Cadaver dogs weren't taken to the home..they were suspects..as it was I was referring to Ben disappearing into thin air...didn't mention the family

And as it was I was just referring to the fact you cant compare the two disppearances as identical even if both did vanish (but not into thin air, thats impossible)

[Mr Gray]

And as it was I was just referring to the fact you cant compare the two disppearances as identical even if both did vanish (but not into thin air, thats impossible)

who said they were identical

[Lyall]

who said they were identical

davel, it's actually not respectful to keep invoking Ben to justify your views on Madeleine's disappearance.

[icabodcrane]

Did a cadaver dog alert in Ben Needham's holiday home  ?

[Mr Gray]

davel, it's actually not respectful to keep invoking Ben to justify your views on Madeleine's disappearance.

In whose opinion...
there is no evidence of abduction for Ben...and none for Maddie
perhaps if Stephen didn't have to try to derail every thread by saying there is no evidence of abduction...
this thread is about the police and the dogs