Stephen Birch Body Finder Extraordinaire Revisit

[Benita]

Have you read the statement of Carlos ............Costa

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post5986.html#p5986

yes anna read that a few years ago .. if true looks like murat has mental and aggressive issues ..always thought there was something iffy about the guy ..and knows more than letting on  >@@(*&)

He also states that it is his opinion that Robert could have committed a crime of this nature—abduction of a child. That he does not have the capacity of getting involved in a paedophile ring. If he did abduct this child, then the witness believes she may be dead. He concludes this from Robert’s violent and deviant personality. He adds still that he also was violent with his mother when he was reprimanded and would react by kicking her.
• He asserts that Robert did receive psychiatric treatment whilst in the U.K.

[Anna]

If there was a body under that area, it would have been moved a long time ago, so no point in digging now !

[Carana]

It's way too late for that though.

I should stress I have no doubt Birch is a fraud and a Charlatan. 

But if they dig up the Murats' drive and find nothing, that will nail nothing and instead give rise to fresh speculation and fresh innuendo: when was "the body" (spit!) exumed and moved, and where to?

Best to leave Birch to stew, I reckon.

His "revelations" concern an area of a property close to a swimming pool, which needs pipes to drain and add  water as necessary. It wouldn't be difficult for the Murats to provide plans of the system. Was Birch able to exclude any logical explanation of any plans or work undertaken concerning the swimming pool?

If an excavation led to no body, the out clause is that it had been moved since his "revelations". He could go on for years...

[Benita]

If there was a body under that area, it would have been moved a long time ago, so no point in digging now !

 

[Carana]

yes anna read that a few years ago .. if true looks like murat has mental and aggressive issues ..always thought there was something iffy about the guy ..and knows more than letting on  >@@(*&)

He also states that it is his opinion that Robert could have committed a crime of this nature—abduction of a child. That he does not have the capacity of getting involved in a paedophile ring. If he did abduct this child, then the witness believes she may be dead. He concludes this from Robert’s violent and deviant personality. He adds still that he also was violent with his mother when he was reprimanded and would react by kicking her.
• He asserts that Robert did receive psychiatric treatment whilst in the U.K.

Who was this Carlos guy? Was anything substantiated?

[Angelo222]

Who was this Carlos guy? Was anything substantiated?

Substantiated?? 

[Anna]

Who was this Carlos guy? Was anything substantiated?

Don't think anyone else gave a character statement ...................Here you go Carana . Statement

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post5986.html#p5986

[Carana]

I've cared for many felines... and I find this "testimony" somewhat unlikely. Even Amaral didn't seem to give it much credence.

[Anna]

I've cared for many felines... and I find this "testimony" somewhat unlikely. Even Amaral didn't seem to give it much credence.

Sorry Carana, Yes I found more statements as to his character ,Who say otherwise to that of Carlos statement, so probably didn't like him, who knows.

[John]

4 Oct 2013

Birch apparently took scans of the ground in the property. He states that the scans show an object like a child or animal on a secluded portion of the property. Photo’s in Birch’s possession show that police never did excavations in that section at the time.

Birch has continued with an online campaign since making the allegations. It is aimed at the British and Portuguese government, and Maddie’s parents, in the hope that his findings will be investigated.

Kate McCann, Maddie’s mother then on a British TV program asked sarcastically: ”Who is Stephen Birch actually?”

“He is not a reliable source” she said.

In reaction to her statement Birch said,” If it was your child and there was a chance that she was buried there, would you not do everything possible to ensure that the findings are not true. Unless of course you have something to hide and you want nobody near the place.

More...

[Sherlock Holmes]

I love the parts where he accuses British and Portuguese systems of cover-up (and mentions the EU as a whole as well at times) and suggests that South African lawyers will put everyone right about fair play and good arbitration.

What planet is he on?

[Carana]

Has anyone followed his ramblings?

Just a few...

https://twitter.com/BirchStephen

SilverLining ‏@Ev3ryCloud 14h14 hours ago

@BirchStephen That's a false start as you know there's no body,  show some respect for family & friends of Brenda Leyland...#mccann
0 retweets 0 favorites

Stephen D.Birch
‏@BirchStephen

@Ev3ryCloud There ain't no body the bitch is alive #McCann
0 retweets 0 favorites



Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen 2h2 hours ago

#McCann £100 for the first person who pushes Kate off her bicycle, gives her spade and tells her to dig up the Murat driveway-make it happen

Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 12

I'll pay 50 000 pounds to anyone who can show me Brenda Leyland's body #McCann

Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 1

Knock knock Jenny Murat
1 retweet 0 favorites


Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 21

2 Schools in Leicester close their facebook pages to stop kids finding out about Madeleine McCann under the Murat driveway #McCann
0 retweets 1 favorite

[Carana]

Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen 2h2 hours ago

#McCann £100 for the first person who pushes Kate off her bicycle, gives her spade and tells her to dig up the Murat driveway-make it happen
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 12

50 000 pounds reward to the person who can show me Brenda Leyland's decomposing body #McCann Goodluck
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 12

I'll pay 50 000 pounds to anyone who can show me Brenda Leyland's body #McCann
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 11

#McCann Brenda Leyland is alive- check her grave !
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 5

People who find reasons not to look/ and re-look for MADELEINE MCCANN in certain places, do not want to find her #McCann @SoniaPoulton
1 retweet 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 5

Any person who finds reasons not to look/ and re-look for MADELEINE MCCANN in certain places does not want to find her #McCann
1 retweet 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 5

remove Tony Bennett off Jillhavern until he provides his court settlement agreement with McCann's & UK state #McCann
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 5

Lady leFaye is a MI6 agent. She says "lets stay focussed. Birch is a distraction." Really, digging up Maddie/Murat driveway is ???? #McCann
1 retweet 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

5 International ground penetrating radar experts want the Murat driveway dug up -Tony Bennett does not want the dig to occur ! Why #McCann
0 retweets 1 favorite
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

Goncarlo Amaral lost his home, Tony Bennett kept his home ! Why ? #McCann
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

Goncarlo Amaral lost his home and everything.Tony Bennett did not !! Why? #McCann Bennett work for the UK government now !
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

Tony Bennett has deceived all those good people really wanting to find Madeleine McCann #McCann Don't trust Tony Bennett !!!!
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

#McCann @SoniaPoulton Tony Bennett cannot be trusted. He does not want to find Madeleine McCann !!!! The UK government gave him no option
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

Tony Bennett & McCanns/UK are one.Bennett has been against the excavation of the Murat driveway ! ! #McCann @SoniaPoulton Maddie
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 4

Tony Bennett was forced through a court settlement to work for McCanns/UK to prevent Madeleine McCann being found ! #McCann @SoniaPoulton
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Jun 1

Knock knock Jenny Murat
1 retweet 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch followed leanne byrne, CLARE SAMBROOK and Missing People

leanne byrne
@lealeabyrne

    CLARE SAMBROOK
    @CLARESAMBROOK

    investigative journo, edits Shine A Light @openDemocracy, novelist Hide&Seek, cofounded EndChildDetentionNow, has won prizes: Paul Foot & Bevins

Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 21

Round Hill Community college & Gartree High try to prevent students from knowing #McCann Facebook pages now locked
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 21

2 Schools in Leicester close their facebook pages to stop kids finding out about Madeleine McCann under the Murat driveway #McCann
0 retweets 1 favorite
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 21

#McCann tonight sees us inform 200 000 Leicester people
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 21

Last night saw over 100 000 Leicester people being informed that Maddie is under the Murat driveway in Portugal.#McCann
0 retweets 2 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

17 000 people attached to this post #McCann
https://www.facebook.com/diggingformadeleinmccann?fref=nf … Gerry buried MADDIE in Murat yard
0 retweets 1 favorite
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

People joining the facebook page "Digging for Madeleine McCann" #McCann
Confirmed Gerry McCann buried MADDIE in #Murat property
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

#mccann DLA Piper 2 write 2 Carter Ruck on behalf Stephen D Birch accussing Dr Gerald Patrick McCann of burying his daughter Maddie #Murat
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

Stephen D. Birch says Dr Gerald Patrick McCann left his daughter Maddie rotting in the Murat garden ! #McCann
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

I GERRY MCCANN BURIED MADDIE IN THE MURAT PROPERTY & THEN I PUT BUILDING RUBBLE ONTOP OF HER ! #McCann
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

I GERRY MCCANN BURIED MADDIE IN THE MURAT PROPERTY ! #McCann
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 1 favorite
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

I GERRY MCCANN BURIED MADDIE IN THE MURAT PROPERTY !
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 16

I BURIED MADDIE IN THE MURAT PROPERTY ! #McCann
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 15

#McCann If Amaral calls for the excavation of Murats driveway & Maddies there, I,ll pay 1/2 his legal costs. #MadeleineMcCann
0 retweets 2 favorites

    Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 15

#McCann Let's excavate Madeleine McCann

Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 7

#McCann a 2 000 000 UK people data base will see the launch of campaign "Kate Slap" & excavation of the Murat driveway #Madeleine
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 7

Carter Ruck to be informed by DLA Piper South Africa of the campaign "Kate Slap" a campaign to slap Kate McCann  #McCann #Muratdriveway
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 7

"Kate Slap" to become the biggest campaign in the UK #McCann letter on it's way to Carter Ruck informing them of campaign via SA lawyers
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 4

Casa Lilianna up for sale, Stephen D Birch to gain access to dig up Murat driveway #McCann #MadeleineMcCann
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen May 2

#McCann Facebook Digging for Madeleine McCann- £100 pounds for person who provides a photo slapping Kate McCann !
Embedded image permalink
View photo
0 retweets 0 favorites

Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Apr 30

Amaral is an idiot, he will loose the appeal, unless he digs up Murats rear gravel driveway #Sardinemuncher #McCann
0 retweets 0 favorites
Stephen D.Birch ‏@BirchStephen Apr 28

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/apr/28/madeleine-mccann-parents-win-libel-damages-goncalo-amaral-trial …
I told this idiot and his lawyer where to find MADDIE. They ignored me ! Its just cost them £500 000 #mccann
View summary
0 retweets 0 favorites

[Carana]

Do you agree with his statements? If so, why? If not, why not?

[Eleanor]

Goodness Me.