The suggestion that the kids may have been sedated issue.

[Chinagirl]

Neither of the two posts above from Luz are factually correct.  The role of the British ambassador and consul was to ASSIST the McCanns with the police enquiries, not to prevent them.  This happens with all consular assistance anywhere in the world where a British citizen finds themselves involved in a police investigation.

The issue of possible sedation was raised long before the twins had their haircut.

[Luz]

Neither of the two posts above from Luz are factually correct.  The role of the British ambassador and consul was to ASSIST the McCanns with the police enquiries, not to prevent them.  This happens with all consular assistance anywhere in the world where a British citizen finds themselves involved in a police investigation.

The issue of possible sedation was raised long before the twins had their haircut.

The issue of sedation was raised 4 MONTHS after the event - prove me wrong with documents.

You are a mind reader so you can go deeper than the Ambassador and Council actions and words. Fantastic.

[Luz]

For today I've had it.

This case makes me sick.

[Mr Gray]

So to put the record straight, according to her book, both Kate and Gerry went out to search that night. the cold and dark claim is just another forum myth.

[Carana]

The issue of sedation was raised 4 MONTHS after the event - prove me wrong with documents.

You are a mind reader so you can go deeper than the Ambassador and Council actions and words. Fantastic.

Luz, links to the statements of the family liaison officers have already been posted here. They raised the issue with them as soon as they arrived.

[stephen25000]

So to put the record straight, according to her book, both Kate and Gerry went out to search that night. the cold and dark claim is just another forum myth.

A book is just words.

Not proof.

Jane Hill interview,no myth.

[Mr Gray]

A book is just words.

Not proof.

Jane Hill interview,no myth.

red blossom used the words cold and dark,  not true.
Nowhere in the Jane Hill interview does kate say she did not search that night. If you relied on the truth you would have very little to attack the McCanns with.

[Chinagirl]

A book is just words.

Not proof.

Jane Hill interview,no myth.

So the same can be said about Amaral's book, then?  Just words - not proof.

Of course, neither book is proof, but both are original sources, as are the files.

[stephen25000]

red blossom used the words cold and dark,  not true.
Nowhere in the Jane Hill interview does kate say she did not search that night. If you relied on the truth you would have very little to attack the McCanns with.

'....did not physically search for Madeleine...'

[Carana]

'....did not physically search for Madeleine...'

To place it in context:
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39077768/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2018

[stephen25000]

To place it in context:
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39077768/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2018

Just listen to the interview.

In it's entirety.

[Benice]

'....did not physically search for Madeleine...'

How typical to take a few words out of context and hold them up as proof.   Kate was not asked if she never searched for Madeleine, she was asked if she didn't feel she had wanted to join the locals and others who had given up their time in the days/week following the abduction, not on the night it happened - which is when Kate and Gerry  searched.

The following day they were at the police station.  Do you think they should have refused to attend - on the grounds that they were looking for their daughter?   When they returned hundreds of press had arrived - with one aim in mind and that was to photograph and question the McCanns.   We've all seen what happens when the 'target' of the press comes into sight.   They are mobbed, jostled, have microphones stuck in the faces and questions fired at them.   The idea that they would have been allowed by the Press to walk around PdL  searching for their daughter unhindered  is preposterous.


 


     

[stephen25000]

How typical to take a few words out of context and hold them up as proof.   Kate was not asked if she never searched for Madeleine, she was asked if she didn't feel she had wanted to join the locals and others who had given up their time in the days/week following the abduction, not on the night it happened - which is when Kate and Gerry  searched.

The following day they were at the police station.  Do you think they should have refused to attend - on the grounds that they were looking for their daughter?   When they returned hundreds of press had arrived - with one aim in mind and that was to photograph and question the McCanns.   We've all seen what happens when the 'target' of the press comes into sight.   They are mobbed, jostled, have microphones stuck in the faces and questions fired at them.   The idea that they would have been allowed by the Press to walk around PdL  searching for their daughter unhindered  is preposterous.


I said listen to the whole interview.


 


   

[Benice]

I said listen to the whole interview.

I suggest you do the same but do take your blinkers off first and then tell us where Kate is asked if it was true that she never searched for Madeleine.     

I see you've ignored my comments about the press attention which would have made searching impossible for them? 

If the police did their job properly they will have advised the McCanns to stay at home.

IIRC April Jones parents did not search after the police were called.   Apart from the fact they may well have been in no fit state to search - they followed the advice of the police.   

[stephen25000]

I suggest you do the same but do take your blinkers off first and then tell us where Kate is asked if it was true that she never searched for Madeleine.     

I see you've ignored my comments about the press attention which would have made searching impossible for them? 

If the police did their job properly they will have advised the McCanns to stay at home.

IIRC April Jones parents did not search after the police were called.   Apart from the fact they may well have been in no fit state to search - they followed the advice of the police.

I have no blinkers.

I've watched the video.

Now why in the book did she say no one was searching for Madeleine ?