Author Topic: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013  (Read 181214 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #225 on: September 01, 2013, 10:36:28 AM »
A pity Luz doesn't look at the context in which a remark is made.  My post above:  Nothing weird at all about a justice of the high court upholding the presumption of innocence! was made in response to a post from Anne Guedes claiming it was "weird" that Mrs Justice Hogg was "in no doubt about the innocence of the McCanns."

The preumption of innocence is a basic principle of law in democracies, so nothing strange at all that Mrs Justice Hogg should have upheld this by reminding those in her court of this fact.
A pity, Chinagirl, that you interpreted so absurdly my post :
Mrs Justice Hogg, who ignored totally what was in the files and who lost her claim for access to the LC files, had curiously no doubt about the innocence of the McCanns and consequently called the wrath of God on those who know and keep silent.
Like in the Middle Age !  Weird times or rather weird places !

The presumption of innocence doesn't exclude uncertainties, just like the LC expressed it when Mrs Justice Hogg asked access to their files. I would have been shocked if Mrs Justice Hogg had declared the McCanns weren't innocent. What shocked me was the call of the wrath of God on the people who knew who had abducted Madeleine and kept silent, as if abduction was a fact.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #226 on: September 01, 2013, 10:38:27 AM »
If that was true then no libel case would be taking place now.       Whether or not Amarals book was libellous had not been established at that time as no libel trial had taken place, and so the question of libel could not be taken into account by the Supreme Court.

It is my understanding that the Court upheld Amaral's right to have the freedom to express his own theory based on the evidence known to him at that time.   However IMO he misinterpreted evidence or did not fully understand it at times and in some cases actually changed the details of the recorded evidence at his disposal to fit in with his theory.   This resulted in the libellous claims he  made against the McCanns in his book  which IMO effectivelly became little more than the  'character assassination' of the grieving parents of a missing child.   

     

Is exactly right, Benice.  The ex-parte judgment overturning the injunction did not (at all) consider the question of libel ...

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #227 on: September 01, 2013, 10:57:13 AM »
It seems that the Mccanns won't be attending the trial on the advice of UK police, now there's a surprise.

However, family members will be going.

Well they are irrelevant and biased.

So let's see what happens .


Offline Carana

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #228 on: September 01, 2013, 02:57:49 PM »
UK and PT law on libel seem to very different.

In my, admittedly limited, understanding of Portuguese law, the McCanns could lose the case in Portugal, if - as some assume - the outcome will be on the extent of proven damage caused by "misunderstandings".

However, I don't see how anyone could legitimately then assume that any outcome in Portugal would mean that all these assertions were therefore true as opposed to how actually damaging they were.
« Last Edit: September 01, 2013, 02:59:22 PM by Carana »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #229 on: September 01, 2013, 03:14:00 PM »
UK and PT law on libel seem to very different.

In my, admittedly limited, understanding of Portuguese law, the McCanns could lose the case in Portugal, if - as some assume - the outcome will be on the extent of proven damage caused by "misunderstandings".

However, I don't see how anyone could legitimately then assume that any outcome in Portugal would mean that all these assertions were therefore true as opposed to how actually damaging they were.

I would defer to Jean-Pierre on this one.

But my understanding is that the McCanns (or Isabel on their behalf) simply to have to establish that statements demonstrably untrue also lower reputation.

If they can do that, they will win (I think!)

Offline Carana

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #230 on: September 01, 2013, 03:32:47 PM »
I would defer to Jean-Pierre on this one.

But my understanding is that the McCanns (or Isabel on their behalf) simply to have to establish that statements demonstrably untrue also lower reputation.

If they can do that, they will win (I think!)

Also possible. Hard to tell.

My main point being that any ruling in one country's legal system should not be automatically reinterpreted as being the results one would assume in a different country's system.

The ruling will no doubt clarify all of this.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #231 on: September 01, 2013, 03:39:11 PM »
My main point being that any ruling in one country's legal system should not be automatically reinterpreted as being the results one would assume in a different country's system.

I certainly agree with you on that.

The bar of libel in Portugal is much higher than, certainly England, I think all of Britain.

But still (I believe) sufficiently low for the McCanns to get in.

Offline Carana

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #232 on: September 02, 2013, 06:37:27 PM »
I have no idea who is likely to win this trial.

The assumption that many are likely to make is that if the McCanns lose, then it would mean that everything that Amaral has stated is correct.

As far as I'm aware, that may not be a correct assumption to make in the case in Portuguese civil law.

Proving that some of his claims are, at best, erroneous is one thing, but proving the extent of damage of those statements may not be straightforward.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #233 on: September 02, 2013, 06:46:17 PM »
The fact that Murat recently won his libel case against a Portuguese newspaper makes me feel the McCanns have a good chance of success.

Offline faithlilly

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #234 on: September 02, 2013, 06:51:44 PM »
The fact that Murat recently won his libel case against a Portuguese newspaper makes me feel the McCanns have a good chance of success.

Did Murat win the case or did the newspaper settle ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #235 on: September 02, 2013, 07:01:05 PM »
Did Murat win the case or did the newspaper settle ?

A Lisbon court has ruled national daily Correio da Manhã pay a total of 15,000 euros to Robert Murat who was dragged into the case of missing British toddler Madeleine McCann after volunteering to act as a translator between Portuguese authorities and the McCanns.

In its judgment, the court found that publishing false allegations such as “Robert Murat is a predator who visits sites containing sexual violence” was not in the public interests and infringed upon his rights.


looks like he won the case to me

Rachel Granada

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #236 on: September 02, 2013, 07:13:08 PM »
The fact that Murat recently won his libel case against a Portuguese newspaper makes me feel the McCanns have a good chance of success.

Me too, davel.  I believe Amaral also made some disgusting smears against Robert Murat in his book. 

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #237 on: September 02, 2013, 07:16:17 PM »
Me too, davel.  I believe Amaral also made some disgusting smears against Robert Murat in his book.

What smears ?

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #238 on: September 02, 2013, 07:20:03 PM »
A Lisbon court has ruled national daily Correio da Manhã pay a total of 15,000 euros to Robert Murat who was dragged into the case of missing British toddler Madeleine McCann after volunteering to act as a translator between Portuguese authorities and the McCanns.

In its judgment, the court found that publishing false allegations such as “Robert Murat is a predator who visits sites containing sexual violence” was not in the public interests and infringed upon his rights.


looks like he won the case to me

Just found this on an old thread.

http://www.dgsi.pt/jtrl.nsf/33182fc732316039802565fa00497eec/8ae65886ef70827180257b63003d7a75?OpenDocument
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: The McCann v Gonçalo Amaral Libel Trial trial now set for September 2013
« Reply #239 on: September 02, 2013, 07:28:05 PM »
Just found this on an old thread.

http://www.dgsi.pt/jtrl.nsf/33182fc732316039802565fa00497eec/8ae65886ef70827180257b63003d7a75?OpenDocument

It started with that so called journalist Lori Campbell.

To say this woman is incompetent is putting it mildly.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BI0ud541smo
« Last Edit: September 02, 2013, 07:30:00 PM by stephen25000 »