Madeleine McCann case to be re-opened in Portugal as an abduction scenario.

[Kazcutt]

Martin Smith said he was 60-80% certain it was Gerry.

Nope wrong again do keep up .

We have already been told he didnt say that .and we have heard him say on the phone to the police would hypnosis help .the policeman said would you do that
If it helps then i would  he replied .

[Cariad]

All this talk of a foreign paedophile  gang. Foreign to whom?

[gilet]

Dont be so silly.........

Nothing silly about pointing out the fact that Mr Smith did not in fact say the Man was Gerry, nor for that matter about stating the fact that there is no other statement even suggesting that possibility.

Of all the Smith statements only the second one given by Mr Smith mentions it as even a possibility.

And that possibility is based entirely on him thinking Gerry carrying a child in a position hundreds of thousands of people use daily made him consider the idea because that is how the man sighted by the family also carried the child.

[Redblossom]

It will remain an unproven theory. Pretty much like it is now, only more so! 

Oh but they have a few blonde men acting suspiciously  and charity collectors still to get through.....and if that fails burglars that no one saw......

[Apostate]

What difference would it make to the abduction theory?

not much - from the start it never had any credibility

[Victoria]

not much - from the start it never had any credibility

What makes you say that?

[gilet]

Lol ! THE error intended to suggest all others aren't !

Not at all. What other errors?

[Apostate]

Nope wrong again do keep up .

We have already been told he didnt say that

told by you maybe the official record tells a different story

[AnneGuedes]

can someone provide the source for the PJ saying this is being treated as an abduction with the McCanns ruled out - otherwise we have to assume  it's Clarence making things up again

Even if it were true, they wouldn't tell it. Top Secret !
That's why Rogerio Alves wants them assistants in the process..

[Haskins]

What difference would it make to the abduction theory?

Victoria I think the difference it makes is that Smithman at least provides some evidence for the fact that Maddie was abducted (unless Smithman was  actually Gerry McCann, but that's another argument). If the Smiths were wrong then that evidence is gone, and so all the speculation becomes even hotter air.  But of course, even if the the Smith's didn't see someone carrying Maddie, this still doesn't prove she wasn't abducted.

[Apostate]

What makes you say that?

probably the complete lack of any evidence of an abduction

[AnneGuedes]

Oh but they have a few blonde men acting suspiciously  and charity collectors still to get through.....and if that fails burglars that no one saw......

I had forgotten those promising ones !

[Victoria]

probably the complete lack of any evidence of an abduction

What do you mean by lack of evidence? What evidence would you expect if an abduction had taken place?

[AnneGuedes]

probably the complete lack of any evidence of an abduction

And stats concerning "from bed one".

[Kazcutt]

What do you mean by lack of evidence? What evidence would you expect if an abduction had taken place?

A full letter probably