DCI Redwood now admits Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

[Eleanor]

Correct, but what would lead him to consider the possibilty of death before leaving whilst failing to mention the possibility of death after leaving? After all this is not the MO of the sexual abuser they claim to seek. There is however a cadaver dog that alerted in the apt which could lead Redwood to consider the prospect.

Therefore if it's down to the dog that the alert is being considered then it rules out abduction.

WHICH IS WHY NONE OF YOU DARE "CONSIDER" THE OPTION!

Okay.  Let's consider it.  Now what?

Still no proof of what Eddie alerted to.  Still no Forensics.  Still no body.  Still no new evidence, other than that pointing to possible perpetrators residing in Portugal long after The McCanns had left.
Have you got anything else?

[jassi]

Okay.  Let's consider it.  Now what?

Still no proof of what Eddie alerted to.  Still no Forensics.  Still no body.  Still no new evidence, other than that pointing to possible perpetrators residing in Portugal long after The McCanns had left.
Have you got anything else?

Yet SY think it might have happened.
Are they wrong in their thinking ?

[jassi]

Are you casting doubt on their deductive capability - Britain's finest ?

[jassi]

I'm sure you would

But first have you ever heard the term 'fabricated evidence'?

Do you know how easy it is to fabricate evidence?

Very enigmatic. Who are you suggesting is fabricating evidence?

[icabodcrane]

Not until the McCann's timeline is revisited. If Redwood is considering the possibility then he must in turn be considering the McCanns have lied about the checks.

I agree

Scotland Yard think there is a possibility that Madeleine died in the apartment

They have cadaver dog intelligence that suggests the possibility 

Those two  facts are,  inextricably connected

So,  if Scotland Yard are considering the intelligence provided by the dogs  (  which they must  )  they will have concluded that if  the dog had detected the scent of the missing child's dead body   (  and there is nothing to say he did not  )  then  the child would have to have been dead in the apartment for at least an hour and a half

As you say,  that brings the McCanns' checking claims into question

[Albertini]

Everything's a possibility but it ain 't evidence.

Why is it that many posts from supporter's of the family read like Kate McCann's book - a pre-emptive defence for a trial that hasn't happened.

[jassi]

Why is it that many posts from supporter's of the family read like Kate McCann's book - a pre-emotive defence for a trial that hasn't happened.

It essential reading for the true believers  - you don't qualify until you can recite it word for word.

[stephen25000]

Why is it that many posts from supporter's of the family read like Kate McCann's book - a pre-emotive defence for a trial that hasn't happened.

Indeed, it does beggar the question.

[jassi]

What I have noticed is that some internet posters are prepared to believe fully and accept certain premises without firm evidence, such as the whole abduction scenario, but not accept and refute totally others like the dogs findings.

I wonder why that is?

Cos that what Kate & Gerry believe and as a true believer, you have to repeat that daily.

[Mr Gray]

What I have noticed is that some internet posters are prepared to believe fully and accept certain premises without firm evidence, such as the whole abduction scenario, but not accept and refute totally others like the dogs findings.

I wonder why that is?

I accept the dogs findings as described by grime...the expert...I don't accept that "the dogs told us maddie died in the apartment".....which has been posted here

what YOU don't understand is that some posters ...myself....have seen all the available evidence and come to the same conclusion as SY...how wacky does that make me

[Wonderfulspam]

I accept the dogs findings as described by grime...the expert...I don't accept that "the dogs told us maddie died in the apartment".....which has been posted here

what YOU don't understand is that some posters ...myself....have seen all the available evidence and come to the same conclusion as SY...how wacky does that make me

How long did it take you to realise bundleman was bs?

[Cariad]

I accept the dogs findings as described by grime...the expert...I don't accept that "the dogs told us maddie died in the apartment".....which has been posted here

what YOU don't understand is that some posters ...myself....have seen all the available evidence and come to the same conclusion as SY...how wacky does that make me

I don't think SY have reached a conclusion, davel. The investigation is on going...

[Mr Gray]

I don't think SY have reached a conclusion, davel. The investigation is on going...

they have reached certain conclusions...the parents are not suspects...maddie may be alive...or sadly dead...they are investigating an abduction

[Albertini]

I accept the dogs findings as described by grime...the expert...I don't accept that "the dogs told us maddie died in the apartment".....which has been posted here

what YOU don't understand is that some posters ...myself....have seen all the available evidence and come to the same conclusion as SY...how wacky does that make me

Really wacky, given that SY have not come to any conclusion, they have not charged anyone nor brought a case to court to put before a Judge and jury.

Clearly you are not privy to al SY's thinking, are you?

[Wonderfulspam]

they have reached certain conclusions...the parents are not suspects...maddie may be alive...or sadly dead...they are investigating an abduction

or a murder & body snatching.