Where was Gerry immediately after Kate found Madeleine gone at 10pm?

[Wonderfulspam]

I'm not wrong. You are speculating as you don't know what has been said on the missing statements. Ask Birch how he got the 10.15 time?

Imo and entirely speculating, the missing statements by Michael Sperrey & Stephen Carpenter are not missing by accident.

Mr Sperrey stayed in FP05 & Mr Carpenter in FP02, the view from both apartments is straight into Mr Murats back garden.  >@@(*&)

[pegasus]

I'm not wrong. You are speculating as you don't know what has been said on the missing statements. Ask Birch how he got the 10.15 time?

Who fabricated ("under 20 metres") a distance in an obsession to attack an innocent man?
ETA Who  obsessively accused an innocent man and scanned his driveway?

[pathfinder73]

Who fabricated ("under 20 metres") a distance in an obsession to attack an innocent man?

Birch may have lied but then again he may have got hold of the missing statements. Be interesting to know who is source is for 10.15.

[pathfinder73]

Imo and entirely speculating, the missing statements by Michael Sperrey & Stephen Carpenter are not missing by accident.

Mr Sperrey stayed in FP05 & Mr Carpenter in FP02, the view from both apartments is straight into Mr Murats back garden.  >@@(*&)

True they are probably held back because they contain important info on a suspect.

[Wonderfulspam]

Who fabricated ("under 20 metres") a distance in an obsession to attack an innocent man?
ETA Who  obsessively accused an innocent man and scanned his driveway?

Mr Birch has never & does not accuse Mr Murat of any involvement in Madeleine's disappearance.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQhe05pkcYg

PS,
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/361930/Jenny-Murat-Kate-McCann-printed-such-awful-things-about-my-Robert-in-her-Madeleine-book

[Wonderfulspam]

True they are probably held back because they contain important info on a suspect.

CRUCIAL files relating to Madeleine McCann’s disappearance are being kept secret by the Government to avoid a diplomatic war with Portugal.

They contain discussions between Home Office ­officials and the Met over ­vital information on the case.
 
But Home Secretary Theresa May and her staff have spent the past nine months preventing the Daily Star Sunday from obtaining the papers.

They said there would be “specific detriment to the UK’s relationship with Portugal” if the four files were released.
 
Ms May also claimed disclosure of three of the documents would “stifle discussion” ­between ­officials.

But we understand the papers may show a difference of opinion between the Home Office and Met officers, who are reviewing the files on Madeleine’s 2007 disappearance in Praia da Luz.

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/259644/Madeleine-McCann-Key-files-into-probe-kept-top-secret-to-avoid-Portugal-row

[pegasus]

The FIRSTsearcher the people on that balcony noticed was GM.
It seems impossible that during the time a person supposedly did this route, not a single other searcher looked in the carpark opposite tapas reception. It is so close to 5A.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=3629.0;attach=3713

[Wonderfulspam]

The FIRSTsearcher the people on that balcony noticed was GM.
It seems impossible that during the time a person supposedly did this route, not a single other searcher looked in the carpark opposite tapas reception. It is so close to 5A.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=3629.0;attach=3713

It seems impossible that during the time a person supposedly did this route.

Unless the person that took that particular route was the first searcher himself.

[pathfinder73]

The FIRSTsearcher the people on that balcony noticed was GM.
It seems impossible that during the time a person supposedly did this route, not a single other searcher looked in the carpark opposite tapas reception. It is so close to 5A.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=3629.0;attach=3713

Never seen that route pic. Yes that's the circle but Madeleine didn't end up at Casa ......... He may have departed West from the path instead of North. Why do that route for that destination?

[Wonderfulspam]

Never seen that route pic. Yes that's the circle but Madeleine didn't end up at Casa ........ Why do that route for that destination?

Madeleine didn't end up at Casa ........

Now we don't know that for sure.

Why do that route for that destination?

I believe he had his reasons, weren't people searching in the area of the more direct route?

[pathfinder73]

Not to the north they were searching south - tapas area, tennis courts, supermarket. You would hide her to the north IMO not to the west if Murat's was the destination. You could take her to Murat's and back in minutes on one of the checks. He was only 150 metres away wasn't he?

[pegasus]

IMO the initial search of the immediate surroundings would within 2 minutes of the alarm include the carpark opposite tapas reception.
(It is a path the child had walked ten or more times, was familiar with, all the group knew that, so it would be one of the first places checked in the very early search).
Therefore the people on the open balcony looking over that carpark heard and saw their first searcher within 2 minutes of the alarm.
The Brit analyst in the files (who saw the early statements) states clearly the first searcher the balcony people heard and saw was GM.
Therefore the balcony people heard and saw GM within 2 minutes of the alarm.
Thats called logic IMO  >@@(*&)

[pathfinder73]

No there's only one way how Madeleine disappeared in this case and Smithman is the one who did it.

[pegasus]

Oh, do let's have a Stephen Birch Thread...

none of the group ever had access to that garden.

[Wonderfulspam]

IMO the initial search of the immediate surroundings would within 2 minutes of the alarm include the carpark opposite tapas reception.
(It is a path the child had walked ten or more times, was familiar with, all the group knew that, so it would be one of the first places checked in the very early search).
Therefore the people on the open balcony looking over that carpark heard and saw their first searcher within 2 minutes of the alarm.
The Brit analyst in the files (who saw the early statements) states clearly the first searcher the balcony people heard and saw was GM.
Therefore the balcony people heard and saw GM within 2 minutes of the alarm.
Thats called logic IMO  >@@(*&)

The Brit analyst in the files (who saw the early statements) states clearly the first searcher the balcony people heard and saw was GM.

Just another case of mistaken identity imo.