Author Topic: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...  (Read 44717 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Mr Moderator

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #90 on: May 22, 2014, 01:15:07 PM »
Jane Tanner was one of the first witnesses interviewed at police HQ on the day after Madeleine disappeared.  She claims that..."she would be able to identify the man she would recognise him from the back by his particular way of walking"  quote Amaral.

Amaral became aware of Murat a week after Madeleine disappeared. On 10 May he arrived in Luz and was walking routes near the apartment block when he noticed a man with glasses arrive in a green vehicle and go into a private villa.  He watched as he emerged with an elderly lady and followed them towards the area of the swimming pools and the tapas bar. He later saw them return and when the man passed the time of day with a GNR officer Amaral enquired of that officer who the man was.  This was Amaral's introduction to Robert Murat.

This chance meeting and the information which had already been furnished by journalist Lori Campbell about Murat set wheels turning. Thus began the investigation of Robert Murat which culminated in the covert id by Jane Tanner three days later and his intervew the following day.

Jane Tanner thought Robert Murat was the man she had seen that night by his particular way of walking.

Whether this can be classed as an identification is open to debate.
« Last Edit: May 26, 2014, 06:57:02 PM by John »

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #91 on: May 22, 2014, 02:16:20 PM »
Jane Tanner was one of the first witnesses interviewed at police HQ on the day after Madeleine disappeared.  She claims that..."she would be able to identify the man she would recognise him from the back by his particular way of walking"  quote Amaral.

Amaral became aware of Murat a week after Madeleine disappeared. On 10 May he arrived in Luz and was walking routes near the apartment block when he noticed a man with glasses arrive in a green vehicle and go into a private villa.  He watched as he emerged with an elderly lady and followed them towards the area of the swimming pools and the tapas bar. He later saw them return and when the man passed the time of day with a GNR officer Amaral enquired of that officer who the man was.  This was Amaral's introduction to Robert Murat.

This chance meeting and the information which had already been furnished by journalist Lori Campbell about Murat set wheels turning. Thus began the investigation of Robert Murat which culminated in the covert id by Jane Tanner three days later and his arrest the following day.

Jane Tanner thought Robert Murat was the man she had seen that night by his particular way of walking.

Whether this can be classed as an identification is open to debate.

Which private villa? Was this his home?
« Last Edit: May 25, 2014, 01:31:27 PM by John »

Offline Benice

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #92 on: May 22, 2014, 04:00:48 PM »
Jane Tanner was one of the first witnesses interviewed at police HQ on the day after Madeleine disappeared.  She claims that..."she would be able to identify the man she would recognise him from the back by his particular way of walking"  quote Amaral.

Amaral became aware of Murat a week after Madeleine disappeared. On 10 May he arrived in Luz and was walking routes near the apartment block when he noticed a man with glasses arrive in a green vehicle and go into a private villa.  He watched as he emerged with an elderly lady and followed them towards the area of the swimming pools and the tapas bar. He later saw them return and when the man passed the time of day with a GNR officer Amaral enquired of that officer who the man was.  This was Amaral's introduction to Robert Murat.

This chance meeting and the information which had already been furnished by journalist Lori Campbell about Murat set wheels turning. Thus began the investigation of Robert Murat which culminated in the covert id by Jane Tanner three days later and his arrest the following day.

Jane Tanner thought Robert Murat was the man she had seen that night by his particular way of walking.Whether this can be classed as an identification is open to debate.

Jane Tanner didn't even get a good enough look at Robert Murat to recognise him as the man she'd seen just an hour before!   If she had identified him in any way shape or form as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May she would have been taken to the police station - where Amaral was waiting for the phone call to hear the results of the ID parade - so that she could give a statement.     Why is that so hard for some people to understand?    She wasn't taken to the police station she was sent home instead.  There can only be one reason for that.       There is no statement by JT identifying Robert Murat - otherwise the AG would have referred to it in his Final Report as probably the prime reason why RM was made an arguido. 

She may have said at an earlier interview that she thought she would be able to recognise the man she saw by his walk - and if so then IMO Amaral has used that true statement and mixed it in with a load of untruths to try to give them authenticity.    As he does so many other times in his book and during his many TV interviews.   Once JT's sighting became an 'inconvenience' to his attempts to pin the crime on the parents his answer to that problem was to discredit her as a witness. 

It seems to me that ruining the characters of witnesses in the publics eye - by conducting smear campaigns against them via the media was a normal part of 'getting a result' for some members of the PJ.   The same treatment was meted out to Leonor Cipriano. who was tried and found guilty by an enraged public as a result of the media, - before the case even got to court. imo.   So much for Judicial Secrecy.   It's a joke imo.
« Last Edit: May 25, 2014, 01:33:07 PM by John »
The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Mr Moderator

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #93 on: May 22, 2014, 04:02:24 PM »
Which private villa? Was this his home?

His mothers residence.

Offline Mr Moderator

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #94 on: May 22, 2014, 04:12:11 PM »
Jane Tanner didn't even get a good enough look at Robert Murat to recognise him as the man she'd seen just an hour before!   If she had identified him in any way shape or form as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May she would have been taken to the police station - where Amaral was waiting for the phone call to hear the results of the ID parade - so that she could give a statement.     Why is that so hard for some people to understand?    She wasn't taken to the police station she was sent home instead.  There can only be one reason for that.       There is no statement by JT identifying Robert Murat - otherwise the AG would have referred to it in his Final Report as probably the prime reason why RM was made an arguido. 

She may have said at an earlier interview that she thought she would be able to recognise the man she saw by his walk - and if so then IMO Amaral has used that true statement and mixed it in with a load of untruths to try to give them authenticity.    As he does so many other times in his book and during his many TV interviews.   Once JT's sighting became an 'inconvenience' to his attempts to pin the crime on the parents his answer to that problem was to discredit her as a witness. 

It seems to me that ruining the characters of witnesses in the publics eye - by conducting smear campaigns against them via the media was a normal part of 'getting a result' for some members of the PJ.   The same treatment was meted out to Leonor Cipriano. who was tried and found guilty by an enraged public as a result of the media, - before the case even got to court. imo.   So much for Judicial Secrecy.   It's a joke imo.

Tanner never saw the face of the carrier, she only ever saw the side of his head and then the back of it.

She was adamant that she could identify the man by the particular manner of his walk. Nobody coerced her to say this, she offered this suggestion in an attempt to find a live Madeleine in what was those first vital 24 hours. Had she not been able and willing to do so she would not have offered to go on the identification.  She had days to think about it, if she was unsure she could have bailed at any time.

There was no need for her to make any statement about the identification, if the suspect was ever brought to trial she would have had an opportunity to testify.

It is oh so convenient to state several years after the event that she did not identify Robert Murat as the man she saw that night adding that she only thought so at the time.  Self preservation personified!
« Last Edit: May 22, 2014, 04:16:11 PM by Mr Moderator »

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #95 on: May 22, 2014, 04:15:09 PM »
His mothers residence.

Do you have a link to the source for that, or is it your own understanding of events?

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #96 on: May 22, 2014, 04:21:55 PM »
Which private villa? Was this his home?

According to whom?
« Last Edit: May 25, 2014, 01:30:34 PM by John »

Offline Benice

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #97 on: May 22, 2014, 04:34:00 PM »
Tanner never saw the face of the carrier, she only ever saw the side of his head and then the back of it.

She was adamant that she could identify the man by the particular manner of his walk. Nobody coerced her to say this, she offered this suggestion in an attempt to find a live Madeleine in what was those first vital 24 hours. Had she not been able and willing to do so she would not have offered to go on the identification.  She had days to think about it, if she was unsure she could have bailed at any time.

There was no need for her to make any statement about the identification, if the suspect was ever brought to trial she would have had an opportunity to testify.

Are you actually being serious?   If so I'm gobsmacked.   I mean, why bother to take statements from any witnesses - when you can simply call on them to testify in court if and when required.

 What Jane Tanner said in the days before the ID is irrelevant.   The fact is that on the day of the ID she was not able to identify Robert Murat as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May.     The reasons why Amaral told his officers to send her home when he got that disappointing news - rather than take a witness statement confirming that she was not able to identify RM as the' abductor' are also debatable imo.

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Mr Moderator

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #98 on: May 23, 2014, 02:37:04 PM »
Are you actually being serious?   If so I'm gobsmacked.   I mean, why bother to take statements from any witnesses - when you can simply call on them to testify in court if and when required.

 What Jane Tanner said in the days before the ID is irrelevant.   The fact is that on the day of the ID she was not able to identify Robert Murat as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May.     The reasons why Amaral told his officers to send her home when he got that disappointing news - rather than take a witness statement confirming that she was not able to identify RM as the' abductor' are also debatable imo.

What exactly would be the point of taking a statement from an eye witness who claimed to have identified a suspect by his 'walk'?

Why did Tanner go on the surveillance if she couldn't identify the carrier? 

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #99 on: May 23, 2014, 04:43:25 PM »
What exactly would be the point of taking a statement from an eye witness who claimed to have identified a suspect by his 'walk'?

Why did Tanner go on the surveillance if she couldn't identify the carrier?

Lori Campbell had reported Murat as suspicious and Tannerman was heading in an easterly direction.

Jane had said that she might be able to identify the man she saw if what she had seen was  reconstructed (my paraphrasing).

I don't see anything odd about that covert operation.

The issue is that operation screwed up and from the little that she could see, she didn't feel confident to make a positive identification.

Poor Jane. From what I've read, she was just trying to be as careful as possible concerning her recollection and seems to have avoided the transference issue. Yet, she was vilified in the press for supposedly never-ending versions.


Offline faithlilly

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #100 on: May 23, 2014, 05:00:55 PM »
Lori Campbell had reported Murat as suspicious and Tannerman was heading in an easterly direction.

Jane had said that she might be able to identify the man she saw if what she had seen was  reconstructed (my paraphrasing).

I don't see anything odd about that covert operation.

The issue is that operation screwed up and from the little that she could see, she didn't feel confident to make a positive identification.

Poor Jane. From what I've read, she was just trying to be as careful as possible concerning her recollection and seems to have avoided the transference issue. Yet, she was vilified in the press for supposedly never-ending versions.

I absolutely agree with you, Tanner was wrongly vilified for changing her story, she didn't.

What she should have been vilified for is sticking to her story even when it had been proven to be all but impossible.

Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #101 on: May 23, 2014, 06:32:53 PM »
I absolutely agree with you, Tanner was wrongly vilified for changing her story, she didn't.

What she should have been vilified for is sticking to her story even when it had been proven to be all but impossible.
JT's sighting has been confirmed by Scotland Yard - it happened just as she said it did.   Why don't you vilify them for a change?

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #102 on: May 23, 2014, 07:25:28 PM »
I absolutely agree with you, Tanner was wrongly vilified for changing her story, she didn't.

What she should have been vilified for is sticking to her story even when it had been proven to be all but impossible.

I guess it may be tempting to modify what you thought you'd seen if various other people thought they had seen a specific individual and that you knew that this was the individual that you were asked to try to identify.

It can't be that difficult to question your own memory and think that others may have been right. Even worse when the press is accusing you of lying over a long period of time and making your life hell. 

Imagine all that pressure to cave in? She didn't though, did she? She stuck to what she believes is her recollection. And she didn't positively identify Murat. 

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #103 on: May 23, 2014, 07:44:03 PM »
JT's sighting has been confirmed by Scotland Yard - it happened just as she said it did.   Why don't you vilify them for a change?

It is simply not true to say that Scotland Yard have confirmed Jane Tanner's version of events 

They  ( Scotland Yard )  have said that Jane Tanner almost certainly saw an innocent father that night   ...  that is  all  they have said

Scotland Yard have said nothing about the  circumstances   in which they believe Jane Tanner saw the innocent father  ...  and certainly made no reference to Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins having been present at the time 

There has been no  'confirmation'  that  "it happened just as she said it did"


Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #104 on: May 23, 2014, 08:43:47 PM »
It is simply not true to say that Scotland Yard have confirmed Jane Tanner's version of events 

They  ( Scotland Yard )  have said that Jane Tanner almost certainly saw an innocent father that night   ...  that is  all  they have said

Scotland Yard have said nothing about the  circumstances   in which they believe Jane Tanner saw the innocent father  ...  and certainly made no reference to Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins having been present at the time 

There has been no  'confirmation'  that  "it happened just as she said it did"
"Almost certainly" and "a revelation moment" which has changed the focus of the investigation.  And SY made a big thing about it on TV - they wouldn't do that if they weren't as sure as they could be.  And they wouldn't have been almost certain if the account of the innocent holidaymaker who they identified differed substantially in time or location or other detail from JT's statement.