I believe that arguido status allows rights in an investigation.
For example, access to information on the case and the right to have legal representation when being interviewed.
If he did make the request IMO it was very sensible of him to do so and I would suggest he took legal advice about it.
If the Drs McCann had been made arguidos as a matter of course from the beginning of the investigation, they would have enjoyed similar rights without prejudice.
This would have negated the shock horror of them being made ‘suspects’ at a later date by those of us who did not understand the nuances of Portuguese law.
I see what you mean, but I don't think that it would have helped.
Arguido status seems to have a negative connotation even in Portugal: it wasn't just the UK press that had a field day when Murat was made one /or requested it. I don't recall whether he did request it or not, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if he suspected that he was going to be stitched up. At that point, the McCanns didn't.
The McCanns didn't need a lawyer present for the initial interviews (although that might have been an advantage in terms of someone else who could have pointed out any translation issues).
If they
had requested it, it would have been a red flag to the media via the original PJ team. They would never have had the public support to help find Madeleine that they have had, IMO, if they had done.
If they had requested it (or were constituted arguidos), it would have meant that the investigation would have been wound up in just 6 months, barring exceptional reasons to prolong it, i.e, either charged or the case shelved.
All in all, I don't think that it would have prevented the media effect that it did, it might well have made it occur earlier. In the meantime, the attention wouldn't have been on trying to help find a missing little girl.