Author Topic: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...  (Read 44765 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #135 on: May 29, 2014, 11:29:52 AM »
I believe that arguido status allows rights in an investigation. 
For example, access to information on the case and the right to have legal representation when being interviewed. 

If he did make the request IMO it was very sensible of him to do so and I would suggest he took legal advice about it. 

If the Drs McCann had been made arguidos as a matter of course from the beginning of the investigation, they would have enjoyed similar rights without prejudice. 

This would have negated the shock horror of them being made ‘suspects’ at a later date by those of us who did not understand the nuances of Portuguese law.

I see what you mean, but I don't think that it would have helped.

Arguido status seems to have a negative connotation even in Portugal: it wasn't just the UK press that had a field day when Murat was made one /or requested it. I don't recall whether he did request it or not, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if he suspected that he was going to be stitched up. At that point, the McCanns didn't.

The McCanns didn't need a lawyer present for the initial interviews (although that might have been an advantage in terms of someone else who could have pointed out any translation issues).

If they had requested it, it would have been a red flag to the media via the original PJ team. They would never have had the public support to help find Madeleine that they have had, IMO, if they had done.

If they had requested it (or were constituted arguidos), it would have meant that the investigation would have been wound up in just 6 months, barring exceptional reasons to prolong it, i.e, either charged or the case shelved.

All in all, I don't think that it would have prevented the media effect that it did, it might well have made it occur earlier. In the meantime, the attention wouldn't have been on trying to help find a missing little girl.


Offline John

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #136 on: May 31, 2014, 01:46:45 AM »
Yet again, posters are interpreting the question over the identification or otherwise of Robert Murat the wrong way round.

The question isn't, did Jane Tanner identify Robert Murat?  The question should be, did Jane Tanner rule Robert Murat out?

Apparently the answer to the latter is a resounding NO.   In her own words in her Rogatory Interview she stated that she just thought he was the man she had seen.  Undoubtedly, her three companions assisted in that determination.
« Last Edit: May 31, 2014, 01:49:00 AM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #137 on: May 31, 2014, 06:44:07 AM »
Yet again, posters are interpreting the question over the identification or otherwise of Robert Murat the wrong way round.

The question isn't, did Jane Tanner identify Robert Murat?  The question should be, did Jane Tanner rule Robert Murat out?

Apparently the answer to the latter is a resounding NO.   In her own words in her Rogatory Interview she stated that she just thought he was the man she had seen.  Undoubtedly, her three companions assisted in that determination.

She didn't say the underlined words, John. She said "I just thought it was" and the officer interrupts her. The context was that she was explaining why she felt she ought to call Bob Small about the fact that the other three were convinced they'd seen him that night.

Offline John

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #138 on: May 31, 2014, 03:13:35 PM »
She didn't say the underlined words, John. She said "I just thought it was" and the officer interrupts her. The context was that she was explaining why she felt she ought to call Bob Small about the fact that the other three were convinced they'd seen him that night.

Exact extract from rogatory statement...

Jane Tanner.  I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.
4078    “No”.
Reply    “But I just thought it was”.


www.mccannfiles.com/id222.html


I suppose you also have an excuse for her offering the comment," I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door"?

Nobody would make such a comment unless they were indeed suggesting such a thing!  When a witness knows something for a fact they state it.  Regardless of how you attempt to blur the issue she wasn't 100% sure.

Back to my original comment, had Jane Tanner told Amaral that the man she saw carrying a child was NOT DEFINITELY 100% Robert Murat then he would not have been hauled in the next morning by the police.

Fact is, Jane's hesitancy and lack of clarity gave the PJ enough scope to label Murat a suspect.

« Last Edit: May 31, 2014, 03:39:16 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #139 on: May 31, 2014, 03:32:00 PM »
They met Robert Murat en route to the van.  If Jane was going to identify him, it would have been then, and in any event the whole exercise was null-and-void from that point.

Another myth that Jane had anything to do with Murat's arguido status.

If you read the separate section detailing how suspicion against Murat arose, there is no mention of Jane Tanner's sighting.

That can only be because she had nothing to do with it.

Offline John

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #140 on: May 31, 2014, 03:47:49 PM »
They met Robert Murat en route to the van.  If Jane was going to identify him, it would have been then, and in any event the whole exercise was null-and-void from that point.

Another myth that Jane had anything to do with Murat's arguido status.

If you read the separate section detailing how suspicion against Murat arose, there is no mention of Jane Tanner's sighting.

That can only be because she had nothing to do with it.

Meeting Murat had no relevance to the surveillance.  Tanner had no inkling what was expected of her when she met Murat, she thought she was being taken away by the [Spanish police] sic.  She was in fact asked to identify the man she had seen 10 days earlier carrying a child, an identification from the rear and based on her observation that he had a particular way of walking. Regardless of what she thought she did NOT rule Murat out as being that man.

« Last Edit: May 31, 2014, 03:50:58 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #141 on: May 31, 2014, 06:31:02 PM »

Fact is, Jane's hesitancy and lack of clarity gave the PJ enough scope to label Murat a suspect.
On its own?  I very much doubt it.  Any police force making someone a suspect on the basis of a witness's hesitancy and lack of clarity is very much grasping at straws imo.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #142 on: May 31, 2014, 06:34:26 PM »
Meeting Murat had no relevance to the surveillance.

Meeting Murat outright invalidated the surveillance ...

Offline Eleanor

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #143 on: May 31, 2014, 07:04:21 PM »
On its own?  I very much doubt it.  Any police force making someone a suspect on the basis of a witness's hesitancy and lack of clarity is very much grasping at straws imo.

All the more reason not to, I would have thought.  That sort of thing wouldn't have gone down very well in Court.

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #144 on: May 31, 2014, 07:37:14 PM »
Exact extract from rogatory statement...

Jane Tanner.  I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.
4078    “No”.
Reply    “But I just thought it was”.


www.mccannfiles.com/id222.html


I suppose you also have an excuse for her offering the comment," I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door"?

Nobody would make such a comment unless they were indeed suggesting such a thing!  When a witness knows something for a fact they state it.  Regardless of how you attempt to blur the issue she wasn't 100% sure.

Back to my original comment, had Jane Tanner told Amaral that the man she saw carrying a child was NOT DEFINITELY 100% Robert Murat then he would not have been hauled in the next morning by the police.

Fact is, Jane's hesitancy and lack of clarity gave the PJ enough scope to label Murat a suspect.

As I already pointed out, a page or two back, there are numerous times when either Jane or the officer interrupted each other without finishing their sentences.

« Last Edit: June 01, 2014, 06:48:50 AM by John »

Offline misty

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #145 on: June 01, 2014, 01:45:57 AM »
We don't actually know WHICH man Jane may or may not have identified outside the villa that day as there is no statement available showing how many men were at the location at the time. All Jane did say was that she met Murat on the way to the rendezvous.
Has it ever  crossed your mind that the PJ officers themselves may have put the wrong name to the wrong person?

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #146 on: June 05, 2014, 02:16:40 PM »
Whether or not Jane Tanner identified Murat as the man she saw carrying a child that night might be questionable, but,  according to the  'The McCanns and the Conman'  programme last night, what is  not in question is that Jane identified Gail Coopers  'creeyman'   as the child carrier   (   you know,  the one with straggly hair, buck teeth, and a Yosemite Sam moustache  ) 

Henri Exton's team had tracked a fellow who looked similar and taken a photo of him  ( without the moustache )

They presented the photo to Jane and she said ;

""That is the guy I saw carrying a child"

The fellow was eventually ruled out

Exton's  team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #147 on: June 05, 2014, 02:22:52 PM »
Whether or not Jane Tanner identified Murat as the man she saw carrying a child that night might be questionable, but,  according to the  'The McCanns and the Conman'  programme last night, what is  not in question is that Jane identified Gail Coopers  'creeyman'   as the child carrier   (   you know,  the one with straggly hair, buck teeth, and a Yosemite Sam moustache  ) 

Henri Exton's team had tracked a fellow who looked similar and taken a photo of him  ( without the moustache )

They presented the photo to Jane and she said ;

""That is the guy I saw carrying a child"

The fellow was eventually ruled out

Exton's  team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness

Voice analyst Dr Richard Parton on Jane Tanner identifying George the market trader, as the abductor.


'Everyone wanted to find this guy, dont get me wrong, everyone wanted to find him but, the more she had to describe him, the more inaccurate she became.'

'From the witness statements that I had processed before, there was nothing indicating that he was involved, nothing at all. I think the most exciting thing about finding him was that we could finally rule him out.'



Voice Over: Despite the serious doubts, the files reveal that surveillance was continued on the market trader for the next 3 months, but he was eventually iliminated from all enquiries.

Retired Major Tim Whatsisface: 'My understanding of it is, it was felt that she wasn't as credible a witness as we had hoped'. Witnesses will give evidence thinking that, that is what they saw or understood at the time, which is quite often inaccurate, and so Jane Tanner having said 'this is the guy that I saw', it may just have been that she so wanted to help, that she fooled herself'.
« Last Edit: June 05, 2014, 02:38:29 PM by Wonderfulspam »
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline jassi

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #148 on: June 05, 2014, 02:41:08 PM »
Voice analyst Dr Richard Parton on Jane Tanner identifying George the market trader, as the abductor.


'Everyone wanted to find this guy, dont get me wrong, everyone wanted to find him but, the more she had to describe him, the more inaccurate she became.'

'From the witness statements that I had processed before, there was nothing indicating that he was involved, nothing at all. I think the most exciting thing about finding him was that we could finally rule him out.'



Voice Over: Despite the serious doubts, the files reveal that surveillance was continued on the market trader for the next 3 months, but he was eventually iliminated from all enquiries.

Retired Major Tim Whatsisface: 'My understanding of it is, it was felt that she wasn't as credible a witness as we had hoped'. Witnesses will give evidence thinking that, that is what they saw or understood at the time, which is quite often inaccurate, and so Jane Tanner having said 'this is the guy that I saw', it may just have been that she so wanted to help, that she fooled herself'.

Oh, I'm sure she did.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Brietta

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #149 on: June 05, 2014, 02:48:58 PM »
Oh, I'm sure she did.

 ... and I am sure the voice analyst knows what he is talking about.  It was from the same recording that he could tell that Halligen was not all that he claimed to be.
In fact closer inquiry revealed he wasn't anything he claimed to be.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....