Author Topic: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.  (Read 91825 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #30 on: June 11, 2014, 06:03:53 AM »
Albertini - the minute you hit the post button on '48 questions' what little cred. you may have had flew out the window.
I stated "are you suggesting the PJ weren't looking to find out what happened to the child".

Your reply was "possibly".

So you are stating that an official police force in your opinion may not have been trying to find the child.

That's why your credibility has just gone up in a puff of smoke.

You're no better than the nutters on Havern's forum who think  the SY investigation is a whitewash.

In relation to the 48 questions I quoted a question whereby Kate McCann gave an answer which if she genuinely believed her daughter had been abducted, she sat there in the interview room and gave an answer which effectively signed the poor child's death warrant.

The questions put to Kate are irrelevant, what's important is it demonstrates the lack of cooperation and ultimately sabotage of the investigation by the McCann's into determining what happened to their child.

If you are prepared to choose self preservation, sabotage and non cooperation with the official investigation looking for your child and you genuinely don't know what's happened to her, you are, in my book, and my most right minded peoples minds, a monster.

However if you do know the fate of the child then the tactics employed make perfect sense.

It's really that simple.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #31 on: June 11, 2014, 07:12:01 AM »

It seems a trifle strange to me that Kate's original answers to the questions weren't recorded.  So they make her an Arguida, after which she isn't obliged to answer, and then recorded the fact that she refused on this second occasion.  This sounds fearfully like a publicity stunt to me.

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #32 on: June 11, 2014, 07:15:37 AM »
It seems a trifle strange to me that Kate's original answers to the questions weren't recorded.  So they make her an Arguida, after which she isn't obliged to answer, and then recorded the fact that she refused on this second occasion.  This sounds fearfully like a publicity stunt to me.

Well I'm sure it does to you, given your well established persuasion.

it still does not escape the bald facts that Kate's (and Gerry's) actions signed her own child's death warrant, which is utterly despicable.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #33 on: June 11, 2014, 07:20:54 AM »
Well I'm sure it does to you, given your well established persuasion.

it still does not escape the bald facts that Kate's (and Gerry's) actions signed her own child's death warrant, which is utterly despicable.

So answering the questions the first time around wasn't enough?  How did that sign Madeleine's death warrant?  The PJ already had their answers.

Gerry, however, did answer the questions, against legal advice.  How did that sign Madeleine's death warrant?

This reply to my post is codswallop.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #34 on: June 11, 2014, 07:22:25 AM »
Albertini...you are posting the same rubbish you posted last year and was fully discussed for a week. let me tell you why what you are posting is absurd...

first no one has to or should have to prove their innocence.....have you ever heard of this before in any legal case.
it impossible to prove innocence,,did OJ prove his innocence when he was tried for the murder of his wife...no

The Pj according to amaral had decided the parents were guilty and were not looking elsewhere if Kate had answered the 48 questions they would have found 48 more...then 48 more...this is how the police work.the only way to stop this is to refuse to answer any more questions and force the police to act on the evidence they have...in this case nothing...and stop the harassment. The Pj investigation had no where to go..kates not answering questions did not stall the investigation..it was already stalled. Your statement that she signed maddies death warrant is plainly ridiculous.

 As far as I am concerned kate did the right thing.

The archiving report states that there was no evidence against the mccanns,,,the pj acted disgracefully towards the parents as far as I am concerned.....because amaral misunderstood the dog and the forensic evidence..now hes going on about links to MI5..the man is a complete fool as far as I am concerned

Perhaps you could tell me what evidence there is to link the mccanns to a crme....SY certainly don't think there is any


Offline Mr Gray

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #35 on: June 11, 2014, 07:23:58 AM »
Well I'm sure it does to you, given your well established persuasion.

it still does not escape the bald facts that Kate's (and Gerry's) actions signed her own child's death warrant, which is utterly despicable.

only in your rather strange world...I doubt if many would agree with you

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #36 on: June 11, 2014, 07:37:50 AM »
Well I'm sure it does to you, given your well established persuasion.

it still does not escape the bald facts that Kate's (and Gerry's) actions signed her own child's death warrant, which is utterly despicable.

you seem to confuse opinion and facts,,,this is your opinion..not a fact...no wonder all your conclusions are so perverse

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #37 on: June 11, 2014, 07:44:47 AM »
Albertini...you are posting the same rubbish you posted last year and was fully discussed for a week. let me tell you why what you are posting is absurd...

first no one has to or should have to prove their innocence.....have you ever heard of this before in any legal case.
it impossible to prove innocence,,did OJ prove his innocence when he was tried for the murder of his wife...no

The Pj according to amaral had decided the parents were guilty and were not looking elsewhere if Kate had answered the 48 questions they would have found 48 more...then 48 more...this is how the police work.the only way to stop this is to refuse to answer any more questions and force the police to act on the evidence they have...in this case nothing...and stop the harassment. The Pj investigation had no where to go..kates not answering questions did not stall the investigation..it was already stalled. Your statement that she signed maddies death warrant is plainly ridiculous.

 As far as I am concerned kate did the right thing.

The archiving report states that there was no evidence against the mccanns,,,the pj acted disgracefully towards the parents as far as I am concerned.....because amaral misunderstood the dog and the forensic evidence..now hes going on about links to MI5..the man is a complete fool as far as I am concerned

Perhaps you could tell me what evidence there is to link the mccanns to a crme....SY certainly don't think there is any

Like I said you don't understand what the archiving report means. You didn't understand then and you still don't. The term demonstrating their innocence was written by a lawyer in a legal archiving summary.

Do you think if it was "rubbish" it would have gone in there?

You are calling it rubbish because you are not a lawyer and you don't understand it.

As last year you fail spectacularly to differentiate between a police investigation which the archiving report was based on and a legal case with judicial finding.

As you were told last year police forces around the world seek to rule people out of their enquiries by establishing innocence to the crime .

The investigation was following the evidence uncovered. Had it been allowed to run its course then then PJ would have been more likely to have been able to find out what had happened to their child.

By refusing to cooperate they ended it abandoning their daughter to her fate.

The investigation stalled when they refused to cooperate with the diligence required by the investigation.

If you think that  a conscious decision to  sabotage an investigation which was the only one looking for your child  is right you are one sick puppy.

The point again that you miss is that the investigation was stopped by the McCann's actions preventing any further evidence being discovered against them or anyone else for that matter.

It is not the same as investigation fully running its course and discovering no evidence.

But I don't expect you to understand it now when you struggled so badly with it last year.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #38 on: June 11, 2014, 07:47:37 AM »
Like I said you don't understand what the archiving report means. You didn't understand then and you still don't. The term demonstrating their innocence was written by a lawyer in a legal archiving summary.

Do you think if it was "rubbish" it would have gone in there?

You are calling it rubbish because you are not a lawyer and you don't understand it.

As last year you fail spectacularly to differentiate between a police investigation which the archiving report was based on and a legal case with judicial finding.

As you were told last year police forces around the world seek to rule people out of their enquiries by establishing innocence to the crime .

The investigation was following the evidence uncovered. Had it been allowed to run its course then then PJ would have been more likely to have been able to find out what had happened to their child.

By refusing to cooperate they ended it abandoning their daughter to her fate.

The investigation stalled when they refused to cooperate with the diligence required by the investigation.

If you think that  a conscious decision to  sabotage an investigation which was the only one looking for your child  is right you are one sick puppy.

The point again that you miss is that the investigation was stopped by the McCann's actions preventing any further evidence being discovered against them or anyone else for that matter.

It is not the same as investigation fully running its course and discovering no evidence.

But I don't expect you to understand it now when you struggled so badly with it last year.

Excellent post Albertini. 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #39 on: June 11, 2014, 07:54:14 AM »
Like I said you don't understand what the archiving report means. You didn't understand then and you still don't. The term demonstrating their innocence was written by a lawyer in a legal archiving summary.

Do you think if it was "rubbish" it would have gone in there?

You are calling it rubbish because you are not a lawyer and you don't understand it.

As last year you fail spectacularly to differentiate between a police investigation which the archiving report was based on and a legal case with judicial finding.

As you were told last year police forces around the world seek to rule people out of their enquiries by establishing innocence to the crime .

The investigation was following the evidence uncovered. Had it been allowed to run its course then then PJ would have been more likely to have been able to find out what had happened to their child.

By refusing to cooperate they ended it abandoning their daughter to her fate.

The investigation stalled when they refused to cooperate with the diligence required by the investigation.

If you think that  a conscious decision to  sabotage an investigation which was the only one looking for your child  is right you are one sick puppy.

The point again that you miss is that the investigation was stopped by the McCann's actions preventing any further evidence being discovered against them or anyone else for that matter.

It is not the same as investigation fully running its course and discovering no evidence.

But I don't expect you to understand it now when you struggled so badly with it last year.

How did Kate's refusal to answer the questions on the second occasion they were put to her, prevent The PJ from discovering or pursuing evidence against other persons?

And how did Gerry's answers sign Madeleine's death warrant?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #40 on: June 11, 2014, 07:59:31 AM »
Like I said you don't understand what the archiving report means. You didn't understand then and you still don't. The term demonstrating their innocence was written by a lawyer in a legal archiving summary.

Do you think if it was "rubbish" it would have gone in there?

You are calling it rubbish because you are not a lawyer and you don't understand it.

As last year you fail spectacularly to differentiate between a police investigation which the archiving report was based on and a legal case with judicial finding.

As you were told last year police forces around the world seek to rule people out of their enquiries by establishing innocence to the crime .

The investigation was following the evidence uncovered. Had it been allowed to run its course then then PJ would have been more likely to have been able to find out what had happened to their child.

By refusing to cooperate they ended it abandoning their daughter to her fate.

The investigation stalled when they refused to cooperate with the diligence required by the investigation.

If you think that  a conscious decision to  sabotage an investigation which was the only one looking for your child  is right you are one sick puppy.

The point again that you miss is that the investigation was stopped by the McCann's actions preventing any further evidence being discovered against them or anyone else for that matter.

It is not the same as investigation fully running its course and discovering no evidence.

But I don't expect you to understand it now when you struggled so badly with it last year.

First you cant separate opinion from fact...secondly you want to overturn the whole legal system...in fact practically the whole worlds legal system and move the burden of proof onto the defendant..a totally ridiculous stance....


So once again...what evidence did amaral have against the mccanns to make them arguido...

Remember mccannns not suspects..get over it

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #41 on: June 11, 2014, 08:08:13 AM »
So to get back on track...the evidence used by amaral to suspect the mccanns and make them arguidos was discounted by the archiving report

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #42 on: June 11, 2014, 08:10:23 AM »
So to get back on track...the evidence used by amaral to suspect the mccanns and make them arguidos was discounted by the archiving report

No dave. There was insufficient evidence to charge anyone.

Offline Carana

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #43 on: June 11, 2014, 08:11:24 AM »
Irrelevant. Your daughter is missing. You want to find her if she's been abducted. The only way to do that is to ensure the investigation remains open.

Answer them again, and then again if necessary. Do anything and everything to keep that investigation alive, because that's the only way you are going to have your daughter found.

It beggars belief that they were so nonchalant about ensuring the investigation stopped looking for their child.

Why would it have kept the investigation alive? Once there are arguidos, the clock is ticking to either bring charges or to shelve the case. See Article 276 of the CPP.
 

Artigo 276.º
(Prazos de duração máxima do inquérito)
1 - O Ministério Público encerra o inquérito, arquivando­o ou deduzindo acusação, nos prazos máximos de seis meses, se houver arguidos presos ou sob obrigação de permanência na habitação, ou de oito meses, se os não houver.
2 - O prazo de seis meses referido no número anterior é elevado:
a) Para oito meses, quando o inquérito tiver por objecto um dos crimes referidos no artigo 215.º, n.º 2;
b) Para dez meses, quando, independentemente do tipo de crime, o procedimento se revelar de excepcional complexidade, nos termos do artigo 215.º, n.º 3, parte final;
c) Para doze meses, nos casos referidos no artigo 215.º, n.º 3.
3 - Para efeito do disposto nos números anteriores, o prazo conta­se a partir do momento em que o inquérito tiver passado a correr contra pessoa determinada ou em que se tiver verificado a constituição de arguido.
4 - Sempre que tiver conhecimento de que os prazos referidos no número anterior foram excedidos, o Procurador-Geral da República pode mandar avocar o inquérito e procede de acordo com o disposto no artigo 109.º.
http://paulosantos-adv.planetaclix.pt/CPP.htm

Article 276. º
(Maximum limit for the survey)
1 - The Public Ministry terminating the investigation, arquivandoo or deducting charges, the maximum term of six months, if arrested or under obligation to remain in the dwelling, or eight months defendants, if there is not.
2 - The period of six months referred to in the preceding paragraph is high:
a) For eight months, when the investigation any matter relating to the offenses referred to in Article 215, paragraph 2..;
b) For ten months when, regardless of the type of crime, the procedure proved exceptionally complex, under Article 215, paragraph 3, the final part..;
c) For twelve months, in the cases referred to in Article 215., no. 3.
3 - For the purposes of the preceding paragraphs, the term contase from the time the survey has passed to run against a person or that he has checked the constitution of the accused.
4 - Where is aware that the deadlines referred to above have been exceeded, the Attorney General's Office may have to call the inquiry and proceeds in accordance with the provisions of Article 109..
« Last Edit: June 12, 2014, 02:23:43 AM by John »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #44 on: June 11, 2014, 08:16:12 AM »
No dave. There was insufficient evidence to charge anyone.

there usually is when you are innocent