Author Topic: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.  (Read 91873 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #60 on: June 11, 2014, 08:42:50 AM »
The questions you or the McCann's believe should or should not have been asked are now and were then irrelevant.

It's not up to you or them to determine whether a question posed by the investigation is a valid one.

You answer the bloody things and keep answering them until the police are confidently able to rule you of their enquiries.

If they ask you to perform a diligence which they believe will help the investigation move forward, you do it. then you do it again if needs be, for the sake of your missing daughter.

You don't wilfully go out and sabotage the very investigation which is trying to find your child.
Once again I ask you, how would answering those 48 questions, or even 480 or 4800 questions rule out the McCanns?  And, you have studiously avoided addressing Bernice's post regarding the pointlessness of a reconstruction - perhaps you could also explain how that would have been conducted, whose timelines they would have adopted, and how THAT would have proven the McCanns' innocence?  And why do you keep on insisting the McCanns refused to take part in the reconstruction when you KNOW this is untrue?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #61 on: June 11, 2014, 08:44:43 AM »
Answered already.

The questions themselves are irrelevant. It's about doing everything in your power to ensure the police investigation continues to find out what happened to your child.

When the thrust of the questioning is to implicate you and you know you are innocent, for the sake of the child as much as anything else, you exercise your right to silence.

The Ciprianos exercised their right to silence.

They were convicted.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #62 on: June 11, 2014, 08:45:25 AM »
Because by refusing to co-operate with the investigation, and after being told that it would harm the investigation by them not doing they still sought to bring it to a close.

If they genuinely believed the child had been abducted and being told how important their cooperation was to keep the investigation alive and open, by refusing to assist the PJ, they were abandoning Madeleine to her fate with the abductor.

Does an Arguido have the right to silence? 

If so, why were The McCanns given this status if The PJ wanted them to repeat the answers that they had already given?

The case wasn't shelved for a further seven or eight months, so how did The McCanns force this conclusion?

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #63 on: June 11, 2014, 08:48:32 AM »
No I think saying the bald FACT is that not answering questions...etc...which is your opinion...not fact ...I think the fact you want to change the whole worlds justice system and move the burden of proof to the defendant...that's perverse...the fact that that you continue to state that not answering the questions sabotaged the investigation...well that's plain barmy

Drivel as per usual.

The bald facts are this:

Kate McCann refused to answer 48 questions the investigation put to her apart form one question where she answered in the affirmative when she was asked if she knew that by not answering she was hindering the investigation.

The Mccann's and friends refused to participate in the reconstruction. Whilst the McCann's wrote they would attend their spokesman had already stated their lawyers would block them from returning.

These are facts.

Then it comes down to a sense of human decency as to whether you regard the price of your refusal to co-operate and self preserve is more important to you then the police investigation continuing to run and look for your missing child.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #64 on: June 11, 2014, 08:50:02 AM »
Does an Arguido have the right to silence? 

If so, why were The McCanns given this status if The PJ wanted them to repeat the answers that they had already given?

The case wasn't shelved for a further seven or eight months, so how did The McCanns force this conclusion?

There is a distinction that by Portuguese law, informal witnesses don't have a right to silence but neither can be asked leading or incriminating questions.

To ask leading questions, a person must, first, be made arguido.  That also carries the right not to answer questions.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #65 on: June 11, 2014, 08:51:43 AM »
Drivel as per usual.

The bald facts are this:

Kate McCann refused to answer 48 questions the investigation put to her apart form one question where she answered in the affirmative when she was asked if she knew that by not answering she was hindering the investigation.

The Mccann's and friends refused to participate in the reconstruction. Whilst the McCann's wrote they would attend their spokesman had already stated their lawyers would block them from returning.

These are facts.

Then it comes down to a sense of human decency as to whether you regard the price of your refusal to co-operate and self preserve is more important to you then the police investigation continuing to run and look for your missing child.

The PJ were not looking for a missing child at that stage.  The questions made that quite obvious.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #66 on: June 11, 2014, 08:52:55 AM »
There is a distinction that by Portuguese law, informal witnesses don't have a right to silence but neither can be asked leading or incriminating questions.

To ask leading questions, a person must, first, be made arguido.  That also carries the right not to answer questions.

"Leading Questions."  Precisely.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #67 on: June 11, 2014, 08:53:46 AM »
Drivel as per usual.

The bald facts are this:

Kate McCann refused to answer 48 questions the investigation put to her apart form one question where she answered in the affirmative when she was asked if she knew that by not answering she was hindering the investigation.

The Mccann's and friends refused to participate in the reconstruction. Whilst the McCann's wrote they would attend their spokesman had already stated their lawyers would block them from returning.

These are facts.

Then it comes down to a sense of human decency as to whether you regard the price of your refusal to co-operate and self preserve is more important to you then the police investigation continuing to run and look for your missing child.

Why are you still banging on about the irrelevant reconstitution?

But shifting the time line, Scotland Yard have demonstrated that the crime of abduction was perfectly feasible.

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #68 on: June 11, 2014, 08:54:20 AM »
Once again I ask you, how would answering those 48 questions, or even 480 or 4800 questions rule out the McCanns?  And, you have studiously avoided addressing Bernice's post regarding the pointlessness of a reconstruction - perhaps you could also explain how that would have been conducted, whose timelines they would have adopted, and how THAT would have proven the McCanns' innocence?  And why do you keep on insisting the McCanns refused to take part in the reconstruction when you KNOW this is untrue?

You just don't get it do you? it's not about the detail of the questions nor the detail of what diligences the investigation wanted them to perform.

Those are irrelevant.

It's the fact by not co-operating and being told your non co-operation is harming the search for your missing child you wilfully continue down that path jeopardising  the search for your missing child.

Your posting style is one of answering questions with questions. My opinions on the questions or the diligences, like yours and like the McCann's at the time mean nothing.

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #69 on: June 11, 2014, 08:55:05 AM »
The PJ were not looking for a missing child at that stage.  The questions made that quite obvious.

And your evidence for this statement is........

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #70 on: June 11, 2014, 08:56:09 AM »
And your evidence for this statement is........

Self-evident in the questions, and in the arguido/a status of Kate and Gerry.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #71 on: June 11, 2014, 08:57:12 AM »
And your evidence for this statement is........

I can read, you know.  And I suspect that I understand more about The Law than you do.  Including Portuguese Law.

Offline Albertini

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #72 on: June 11, 2014, 08:57:22 AM »
Why are you still banging on about the irrelevant reconstitution?

But shifting the time line, Scotland Yard have demonstrated that the crime of abduction was perfectly feasible.

Great, so had the McCann's performed it as requested the PJ presumably they could have come to the same conclusion as SY and the hunt for Maddie would have continued, and the PJ would have been forced to look for an abductor.

The parents refusal to take part prevented this from happening.

Says everything you need to know.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #73 on: June 11, 2014, 08:59:03 AM »
Great, so had the McCann's performed it as requested the PJ presumably they could have come to the same conclusion as SY and the hunt for Maddie would have continued, and the PJ would have been forced to look for an abductor.

The parents refusal to take part prevented this from happening.

Says everything you need to know.

The McCanns did not refuse to take part.  They accepted one of the dates suggested.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Kate's refusal on legal advice to answer those 48 questions.
« Reply #74 on: June 11, 2014, 08:59:37 AM »
You just don't get it do you? it's not about the detail of the questions nor the detail of what diligences the investigation wanted them to perform.

Those are irrelevant.

It's the fact by not co-operating and being told your non co-operation is harming the search for your missing child you wilfully continue down that path jeopardising  the search for your missing child.

Your posting style is one of answering questions with questions. My opinions on the questions or the diligences, like yours and like the McCann's at the time mean nothing.

So, are you saying if Kate McCann had, like her husband, answered every single one of the questions put to her (questions that were clearly designed to establish her guilt) then the police would have been closer to finding her child?  Please explain how.