Author Topic: Empathy and Support  (Read 52652 times)

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #120 on: June 24, 2014, 02:37:36 PM »
I don't know, but I hope Scotland Yard find her soon.  Then I can cheer her parents and weep tears of joy for her safe return.

Support The McCanns.  You know it makes sense.

Not only does it make sense. It is a demonstration of human decency unlike the vitriol and abuse which is so often flung at the parents repeatedly and which does absolutely nothing whatsoever to bring justice for a little child.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #121 on: June 24, 2014, 02:38:40 PM »
His mum ?

Wasn't Ben with his grandparents at the time ?

Yep, and they have taken some stick as well.  His mother was working in a bar at the time.  OMG.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #122 on: June 24, 2014, 02:40:56 PM »
I am proud to be on this forum supporting the McCanns, ALL the McCanns.

Madeleine McCann who deserves a decent investigation into her disappearance, such an investigation not having taken place back in 2007 under the PJ.

Kate McCann, the mother of Madeleine who knows she made a mistake in leaving the children in the apartment, who will suffer for the rest of her life with the guilt of that mistake and who since her child went missing has done everything in her power to find her child.

Gerry McCann, the father of Madeleine who knows he made a mistake in leaving the children in that apartment, who will suffer for the rest of his life with the guilt of that mistake and who since his child went missing has done everything in his power to find his child.

The siblings of Madeleine McCann who have lost a sister and who want her found.

The wider family of Healys and McCanns who have supported Gerry and Kate in the search for Madeleine.


It shocks me that there are hateful people who do not support the parents of a missing child in their attempts to find her.

It shocks me that there are people who believe that supporting the parents in their search for their child is in some mystifying way a denial of support to the missing child. That is simply illogical.

People who cannot see that supporting the McCanns in their search and endeavours to find Madeleine (including their attempt to stop a criminal, disgraced ex-cop profiting from harming that search with his book predicated on an unproven death) fail to empathise, fail to show understanding, and fail to act decently.

People who choose not to support the McCanns in their endeavours (including the SY investigation which they fought tooth and nail for) to make up for the appallingly botched PJ attempts to find their child are the ones who are denying Madeleine the chance to be found and the chance for justice.

Instead of supporting Madeleine, her parents and the Police there are people who choose simply to stick their heads in the papers of 2007 (papers which could not defend their false accusations and paid out for the libel they contained) and repeat hateful comments over and over again.

Those people who cannot look forward to SY bringing a conclusion to the case, who are closed to the idea of hope, who prefer to regurgitate the same old mantras who do not express any revulsion for the unmitigated abuse that is thrown by perverts, trolls and hounders from across the internet at the McCanns (and inevitably at the siblings of Madeleine as part of the family) are in my opinion self-evidently the ones who are not furthering the cause of justice.

I know which group I am in and I am proud to be in that group. I support the entire McCann family including Madeleine who is at the heart of this case.

If others are proud to be among those who enjoy repeating old facts, are proud to be among those who do not decry the filth thrown at the parents of Madeleine, her siblings, and her supporters and are proud to be among those who support a criminal ex-cop whose fantasies get ever more bizarre as his day of reckoning in court approaches then that is their decision.

No justice will be found for Madeleine in repeating the admitted lies of 2007, the completely unevidenced "theories" of Amaral, the new and still completely unevidenced "fantasies" of Amaral, the regurgitation of a mantra of blame when the McCanns have already recognised their guilt in the matter and are doing everything they can to make up for their mistake.

No justice will be found in amateur internet detection work which is always based on incomplete evidence, which can never be based on proper detection work such as observation of interviews, re-interviewing when appropriate, accurate measurements, full records of all those involved, local police knowledge etc. etc.

Justice might be found in the SY investigation which is doing work which clearly should have been done many years ago, which leaves open hope that Madeleine may be alive or at least that there may be a resolution to the case with the guilty being found.

And just in case anyone missed it. I am proud to support the McCanns in their attempts to find out what happened to their daughter. I am proud to defend the rights of people to be presumed entirely innocent when no evidence, no charges and no convictions exist against them. And underpinning my support is the fact that I can both empathise and sympathise with those at the heart of the case.

As I said and stand by it, at this stage, it is not known who caused the disappearance of Madeleine.

You do not know they told the truth.

It is your belief and no more.

Until the case is taken to court and a perpetrator convicted nothing will be resolved.

The mcccanns were responsible for the care of their children, and it was the abject failure in this, that led to Madeleine's disappearance.

Your support of the mccanns is your business, everyone else is entitled to their opinion, and whether they support them or not, and you have no right to dictate to others what they shopuld think , or pour scorn on those who you say lack 'EMPATHY'.

kate mccann was willing, I recall, to 'forgive' an unproven abductor.

What she thought of Amaral and others, is plainly visible in her 'book' and the comment shew made about Amaral, at bottom of 'my signature', and her comment says everything about her.

Offline pegasus

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #123 on: June 24, 2014, 02:46:12 PM »
...repeating old facts ...
Fortunately facts, like a good brandy, age very well.
« Last Edit: June 24, 2014, 02:49:02 PM by pegasus »

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #124 on: June 24, 2014, 02:47:49 PM »
It's blatantly obvious.

You are on this forum to support the mccanns.

It ill behoves you to make comments such as that when around fifty percent of all your posts show that you are on this forum simply to decry the McCanns.

Your complete inability to realise that your constant repetitive spamming of that mantra that Gerry and Kate were, in your view, entirely to blame for the disappearance of their child actually achieves precisely nothing in the search for an explanation as to what happened. 

Your complete inability to recognise that the blame for the disappearance also lies with any potential abductor is both illogical and indicative of your motive for being here.

Your apparent lack of understanding that you are perceived to be simply enjoying the posting of this mantra because you, like everybody else here, knows that Gerry and Kate have owned up to this mistake and admitted that the guilt they feel over it is beyond normal pain also highlights your motives for posting here.

It is obvious you are here just to throw accusations at the parents. There is nothing at all in this mantra which supports the missing little girl, Madeleine.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #125 on: June 24, 2014, 02:59:06 PM »
It ill behoves you to make comments such as that when around fifty percent of all your posts show that you are on this forum simply to decry the McCanns.

Your complete inability to realise that your constant repetitive spamming of that mantra that Gerry and Kate were, in your view, entirely to blame for the disappearance of their child actually achieves precisely nothing in the search for an explanation as to what happened. 

Your complete inability to recognise that the blame for the disappearance also lies with any potential abductor is both illogical and indicative of your motive for being here.

Your apparent lack of understanding that you are perceived to be simply enjoying the posting of this mantra because you, like everybody else here, knows that Gerry and Kate have owned up to this mistake and admitted that the guilt they feel over it is beyond normal pain also highlights your motives for posting here.

It is obvious you are here just to throw accusations at the parents. There is nothing at all in this mantra which supports the missing little girl, Madeleine.

What a poor response, and indicative of your mind set and mccann 'mantra' support.


In fact your love of the word 'mantra' is in itself obsessive.


The mccanns claimed they exhibited 'responsible parenting skills'

No they didn't. They left their children UNPROTECTED AND VULNERABLE.

That is why she disappeared.

and it wasn't just a one off, it was repeated behaviour.

The spamming visible on this forum is yours, in your attempts to impose your views on others.

IT WON'T WORK.

One day you might relaize that, no matter how many insults you throw at others.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #126 on: June 24, 2014, 03:05:19 PM »
"SY" have primacy in Portuguese judicial cases do they?.
I think not.

They may not have primacy but the pictures told the story.

It was dammed obvious that the ones calling the shots were SY and the ones doing the bidding were the PJ and GNR.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #127 on: June 24, 2014, 03:16:52 PM »
The 'search' has not been harmed.

It has courted worldwide publicity throughout.

People have come to various conclusions over the years, independent/regardless of Amaral.

Meanwhile, the Cipriano's remain convicted murderer's.

The search has clearly been harmed. I have demonstrated that you are a potential source of proof of that fact.

There are also countless examples of posters who rely on Amaral for the way in which they decry the possibility of Madeleine being found alive. They refer, for example to his blatant lie in his book where he claims that Madeleine's DNA was found and his idiocy of frozen body fluids.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #128 on: June 24, 2014, 03:25:09 PM »
The search has clearly been harmed. I have demonstrated that you are a potential source of proof of that fact.

There are also countless examples of posters who rely on Amaral for the way in which they decry the possibility of Madeleine being found alive. They refer, for example to his blatant lie in his book where he claims that Madeleine's DNA was found and his idiocy of frozen body fluids.

The search has not been harmed.

The case has been in the public eye for over 7 years.

The case remains...

'type of crime unknown'.

P.S. My views were not garnished by Amaral.

He was a coordinator on the case.

I came to my own conclusions, as have many  others.
« Last Edit: June 24, 2014, 03:27:00 PM by stephen25000 »

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #129 on: June 24, 2014, 03:48:20 PM »
The search has not been harmed.

The case has been in the public eye for over 7 years.

The case remains...

'type of crime unknown'.

P.S. My views were not garnished by Amaral.

He was a coordinator on the case.

I came to my own conclusions, as have many  others.

Why should I be concerned over Amaral?

He co-ordinated a botched investigation.

He blabbed to the press and got himself thrown off that botched investigation.

He became a criminal when he chose to cover up alleged torture in another missing child case.

He didn't have the decency to stand down from the McCann case at the beginning when on the first day of the case he was made arguido for his later proven offence in another missing child case. In this country he would have been suspended from duty.

He chose of his own free will to give up his job as a police officer (with a fair salary which many others live on without problems).

He wrote a book declaring a child dead and making allegations about that child's parents whilst still working as a serving police officer.

He publicised the book whilst a serving police officer.

He published the book of his unevidenced claims just days after the Madeleine Case was archived, a deliberate ploy to make as much profit and get as much fame from the very investigation which he botched and from which he was given the heave-ho.

He has spent the last six years promoting this book (for which there is no evidence) knowing (as he states in his own book) that it could damage the case. He has personally attempted to profit from the disappearance of a little girl.

He now has the gall to blame the McCanns for his sickness and poverty. The man is pathetic. Diabetes is brought on by over eating, over drinking, an indulgent lifestyle, lack of exercise. Stress can exacerbate it when it has been diagnosed but is not the prime cause of diabetes by any means.

But who chose the stressful route? That was Amaral himself. All the McCanns have done is defend themselves and their daughter against what they know are his lies.

If Amaral wants to reduce his stress and get back to earning an honest wage to bring himself out of poverty, then perhaps he should stop appearing on TV shows to try to salvage his honour and make a fast buck, should stop coming up with fantasies about the McCanns for which he doesn't have any evidence and should get a job. After all he has degrees, experience and lots of mates to help him doesn't he?

« Last Edit: June 24, 2014, 03:55:07 PM by gilet »

Offline faithlilly

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #130 on: June 24, 2014, 03:51:17 PM »
So this man who we are told is desperate for cash could have sued the McCanns? So why the hell has he not bothered?

And just what would he sue them for pray tell?

Defending the right of their child to have a proper investigation?

Maybe he would sue them for not agreeing that he should be able to tell his lies about them being involved in disposing of the body of their child?

Maybe he could sue them for not owning up to a crime they claim they didn't commit and which his botched investigation could not find any evidence they did commit?

Maybe he could sue them for his own stupidity in breaking secrecy laws when he told the journalist things he should not have done the day before he was thrown off the case?

Maybe he could sue them for his illness which any doctor will tell you is only aggravated by stress but is actually caused by over eating, over drinking and a sedentary lifestyle?

What do YOU think he might sue them for? 

I am waiting for your suggestions.


So now it has been decided he is the cause of his own illness.

Is there nothing you won't accuse Amaral of ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #131 on: June 24, 2014, 03:57:28 PM »

So now it has been decided he is the cause of his own illness.

Is there nothing you won't accuse Amaral of ?

I am simply stating the facts about the disease he claims to have.

I haven't decided anything about his disease.

But the real question here is not the one you have posed but the following.

So now Amaral has chosen to blame the McCanns for his illness?

Is there nothing that this disgraced, criminal ex-cop won't try to blame the McCanns for?

Offline Eleanor

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #132 on: June 24, 2014, 03:58:20 PM »

So now it has been decided he is the cause of his own illness.

Is there nothing you won't accuse Amaral of ?

Of course he is responsible for his own illness.  Pathetic.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #133 on: June 24, 2014, 03:58:53 PM »
Why should I be concerned over Amaral?

He co-ordinated a botched investigation.

He blabbed to the press and got himself thrown off that botched investigation.

He became a criminal when he chose to cover up alleged torture in another missing child case.

He didn't have the decency to stand down from the McCann case at the beginning when on the first day of the case he was made arguido for his later proven offence in another missing child case. In this country he would have been suspended from duty.

He chose of his own free will to give up his job as a police officer (with a fair salary which many others live on without problems).

He wrote a book declaring a child dead and making allegations about that child's parents whilst still working as a serving police officer.

He publicised the book whilst a serving police officer.

He published the book of his unevidenced claims just days after the Madeleine Case was archived, a deliberate ploy to make as much profit and get as much fame from the very investigation which he botched and from which he was given the heave-ho.

He has spent the last six years promoting this book (for which there is no evidence) knowing (as he states in his own book) that it could damage the case. He has personally attempted to profit from the disappearance of a little girl.

He now has the gall to blame the McCanns for his sickness and poverty. The man is pathetic. Diabetes is brought on by over eating, over drinking, an indulgent lifestyle, lack of exercise. Stress can exacerbate it when it has been diagnosed but does not cause diabetes.

If Amaral wants to reduce his stress and get back to earning an honest wage to bring himself out of poverty, then perhaps he should stop appearing on TV shows to try to salvage his honour and make a fast buck, should stop coming up with fantasies about the McCanns for which he doesn't have any evidence and should get a job. After all he has degrees, experience and lots of mates to help him doesn't he?

The case remains 'type of crime unknown'

It is your opinion it was a botched investigation.

It is not everyone's.

The case has had unparalleled publicity.

To claim the search was harmed, is not only inept , it is false.

Your loathing and detestation of Amaral is observable in nearly every post you make.

There is no evidence of abduction.

it is merely hearsay, with nothing concrete behind it.

To use the words of Mitchell, 'it is a spurious claim'.

Mitchell himself admitted there was no evidence of a break-in , in the apartment.

You can carry on believing in Madeleine's 'return', you are free to do that, but other people don't have to.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #134 on: June 24, 2014, 04:14:19 PM »
The case remains 'type of crime unknown'

It is your opinion it was a botched investigation.

It is not everyone's.

The case has had unparalleled publicity.

To claim the search was harmed, is not only inept , it is false.

Your loathing and detestation of Amaral is observable in nearly every post you make.

There is no evidence of abduction.

it is merely hearsay, with nothing concrete behind it.

To use the words of Mitchell, 'it is a spurious claim'.

Mitchell himself admitted there was no evidence of a break-in , in the apartment.

You can carry on believing in Madeleine's 'return', you are free to do that, but other people don't have to.

It is the opinion of anyone with a smattering of knowledge of the case, with an open mind and eyes in their heads that it was a botched investigation.

How else do you explain that it has taken SY to get involved before a search of waste land just a few yards from the site of the disappearance of the child took place?

How else to you explain Amaral himself chastising his own officers in their ineptitude in getting access to potentially useful CCTV video?

You really will have to do better than just say its opinion when the facts of the matter are staring you in the face.

And why you are so fixated on abduction I have no idea. Why you are so fixated that you have to introduce that question almost every time you post when I for one am not claiming anything about abduction is a mystery.

Amaral does not deserve sympathy or empathy UNTIL he changes his ways and admits that he botched the investigation, admits he cannot provide evidence for his claims etc.

The McCanns do deserve sympathy and empathy because they have fully admitted their mistake. They have since then done everything in their power to atone for that mistake.

It is not a matter of me hating Amaral as you pretend, simply that I object strongly to his being made a "saint" when in fact he has lied, he is a criminal liar, he botched an investigation and never apologised for that, he tried to profit from that botched investigation and he continues to play games with the legal system in Portugal.

I am simply telling the truth about the man, his criminal record, his botching of the investigation, his admitted failure to keep his mouth shut and his attempting to profit from a missing little girl without any evidence of his claims in a book which he admits might damage the case.