Author Topic: The Smith sighting revisited.  (Read 157581 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #105 on: September 28, 2014, 11:26:43 PM »
Thanks re Halligen.
M.Smith and A.Smith both saw the same trousers. So combining their two descriptions, that means the trousers had the shape of a classic cut, and possibly had buttons.
Re the sighting reported by a newspaper, IIRC the childcarrier talking on his mobile phone was walking "towards the wasteland" (meaning the wasteland south of Rua 25 Abril which SY extensively searched).

I will have a look and see if I can find where that sighting came from.
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #106 on: September 29, 2014, 12:00:23 AM »
"... there is a British witness that saw one of the men carrying a child in his arms to the empty lot ... The woman saw him speaking English on the phone as he walked by with the child in his arms."
CdM (paper edition) 6 June 2014

Maybe one of the SY e-fits is by this british woman, and the other is by one of the Smith group.


Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #107 on: September 29, 2014, 12:10:03 AM »
"... there is a British witness that saw one of the men carrying a child in his arms to the empty lot ... The woman saw him speaking English on the phone as he walked by with the child in his arms."
CdM (paper edition) 6 June 2014

Maybe one of the SY e-fits is by this british woman, and the other is by one of the Smith group.

May be Pegasus, but I think the 2 efits look alike, but at a different angle.
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #108 on: September 29, 2014, 12:22:23 AM »
Re Pereira statement, I think that was possibly up north between Lisboa and Sintra.
Re the 2 efits, I think they look like 2 different men.
Is it possible that one e-fit is by one of the Smith group (possibly by one of them other than the 3 who gave statements, for example maybe TS) and is of a non-english speaker (reportedly he made no reply to greeting).
And that the other e-fit is by the british woman, of a completely different man, an english speaker.
« Last Edit: September 29, 2014, 12:28:53 AM by pegasus »

Offline John

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #109 on: September 29, 2014, 12:29:02 AM »
It has always concerned me that these e-fits were withheld from the public for all these years.  Had it been my child who had disappeared I would have wanted them out there displayed on every lamppost at the first opportunity regardless of any police force.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Brietta

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #110 on: September 29, 2014, 10:35:50 AM »
May be Pegasus, but I think the 2 efits look alike, but at a different angle.

I think they look like the same person but constructed from the description provided by two different individuals; maybe Sadie would have a more educated opinion as this is very much her field.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline faithlilly

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #111 on: September 29, 2014, 10:39:38 AM »
It has always concerned me that these e-fits were withheld from the public for all these years.  Had it been my child who had disappeared I would have wanted them out there displayed on every lamppost at the first opportunity regardless of any police force.

Which is exactly what they did with the other efits they had commissioned John. I wonder why not these ones ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #112 on: September 29, 2014, 03:33:54 PM »
The two efits are meant to be of the same man, therefore they both came from the Smith family.  Probably the source for the darker skinned man is Peter Smith, as he saw a tanned man.  The source for the lighter skinned one is probably Martin Smith, who came to think he might have seen Gerry.

Both men stated that the lighting was poor.
What's up, old man?

Offline pathfinder73

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #113 on: September 29, 2014, 07:05:52 PM »
At the time she saw his face but now cannot remember it.  He was walking in her direction at a distance of, give or take, two metres. (AS)
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #114 on: September 30, 2014, 12:09:36 AM »
The two efits are meant to be of the same man, therefore they both came from the Smith family.  Probably the source for the darker skinned man is Peter Smith, as he saw a tanned man.  The source for the lighter skinned one is probably Martin Smith, who came to think he might have seen Gerry.

Both men stated that the lighting was poor.
Yes, good point, witness PS says "slightly brown skin as a result of sun exposure".
« Last Edit: September 30, 2014, 12:18:25 AM by pegasus »

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #115 on: September 30, 2014, 12:20:16 AM »
Witness MS says "He had a normal complexion, a bit on the thin side".
This indicates that if MS did one of the efits, it is likely to be the efit with the thinner face.

Offline Brietta

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #116 on: September 30, 2014, 11:26:17 AM »
Witness MS says "He had a normal complexion, a bit on the thin side".
This indicates that if MS did one of the efits, it is likely to be the efit with the thinner face.

On the basis of what Martin Smith has said in his first statement ... he would have been unable to provide a description to enable such a detailed ... and perhaps identifiable portrait to be constructed.

It should be remembered that in their earliest statements when it could be supposed memory might be clearest ... all three Smiths signed statements to the effect they could not describe the man's features ... nor would they be able to recognise him from photographs.

From that it seems apparent that the Smiths are not the source of detailed efits of a person they are on record as stating they would be unable to identify.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline sadie

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #117 on: October 01, 2014, 12:15:22 AM »
http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/dm141013a.jpg



First things that I notice:

1)  THe LH mans face is a long, rather thin heart shaped face, the RH mans face appears to be rather "square" ...    I think the second man had his face was inclined right down, and his chin tucked right into his neck fat (jowls).  This caused his chin to visually vanish in the poor light and shadow from the upper face.


2.  Because his face is inclined right down, certain parts of the face are foreshortened [fs]  as well as the chin vanishing into his "jowls" (fatty neck)

Despite having only 3 statements, it is quite likely that everyone who saw Smithman had his/her own go at the Efit.  The RH efit has loads of foreshortening and also appears very "woolley.  Is it an amalgam of several efits?  Has that caused the woolleyness ?


3.    The LH man is slightly smiling, the RH man is not.  Smiling increases the length of the mouth and thins the lips down.  It also lifts the cheeks a little as in these photos.

I dont know, but I think the LH image was Aoifes image. 
I wonder if Aoife was a pretty 12 y.o. (going on 15 with make up) and he liked the look of her?  Hence the direct look and the appreciative small smile?  She would notice that and such is the natural reaction, would see an image that might be better looking than he really was?   


4.  Both men have small ears set flat against the head


5   However, the ears on the LH man appear to be stuck on in the wrong places, overlapping and cutting off a bit on each side oif the face, so making the LH face appear even slimmer.


6.  Both men have a pronounced 10 o'clock shadow on their upper lips, but nowhere else.


7.  The eyes and eyebrows have many similarities.   Eye shapes are not dis-similar, and neither are the eyebrow shapes.  Whilst one looks very groomed, the other looks a little unkept in comparison.  They are both horizontal in alignment.    Could the unkept look be because several efit images provided by several witnesses were superimposed and the minor variances caused the unkempt look?

With both images the brows widthwise, are are just covering the eyes and little more ... and lie in a horizontal plane  There is a good gap between the brows on both and they are of similar o/all shape. 



8.  However, the vertical gap between the eyes and brows differs between the two images.
Could that be because RH man was looking down and this feature was foreshortened?


9.  Both have the unusual bulges over the eyes. However the LH man has larger and bright eyes, whilst the RH man has a duller older look and his eyes are set closer together.  Seems that as the head was tilted forward AKA the RH image, the bulge almost slightly obscured the top of the eyes.

The eyes are similar is shape , but the bulge above the eyes tends to "squash" the eyes in the RH image


10.  The noses are not disimilar but again the RH image seems to be foreshortened, giving what appears to be a shorter nose.
Is the upper lip partially hidden by the nose and also foreshortened in the RH image?


11.  The hairlines are not the same, but if the man in the second image had his head grossly tilted down then it would be difficult to assess the hairline.




I feel sure they are the same man.










Offline sadie

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #118 on: October 01, 2014, 12:17:53 AM »
http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/dm141013a.jpg



First things that I notice:

1)  THe LH mans face is a long, rather thin heart shaped face, the RH mans face appears to be rather "square" ...    I think the second man had his face was inclined right down, and his chin tucked right into his neck fat (jowls).  This caused his chin to visually vanish in the poor light and shadow from the upper face.


2.  Because his face is inclined right down, certain parts of the face are foreshortened [fs]  as well as the chin vanishing into his "jowls" (fatty neck)

Despite having only 3 statements, it is quite likely that everyone who saw Smithman had his/her own go at the Efit.  The RH efit has loads of foreshortening and also appears very "woolley.  Is it an amalgam of several efits?  Has that caused the woolleyness ?


3.    The LH man is slightly smiling, the RH man is not.  Smiling increases the length of the mouth and thins the lips down.  It also lifts the cheeks a little as in these photos.

I dont know, but I think the LH image was Aoifes image. 
I wonder if Aoife was a pretty 12 y.o. (going on 15 with make up) and he liked the look of her?  Hence the direct look and the appreciative small smile?  She would notice that and such is the natural reaction, would see an image that might be better looking than he really was?   


4.  Both men have small ears set flat against the head


5   However, the ears on the LH man appear to be stuck on in the wrong places, overlapping and cutting off a bit on each side oif the face, so making the LH face appear even slimmer.


6.  Both men have a pronounced 10 o'clock shadow on their upper lips, but nowhere else.


7.  The eyes and eyebrows have many similarities.   Eye shapes are not dis-similar, and neither are the eyebrow shapes.  Whilst one looks very groomed, the other looks a little unkept in comparison.  They are both horizontal in alignment.    Could the unkept look be because several efit images provided by several witnesses were superimposed and the minor variances caused the unkempt look?

With both images the brows widthwise, are are just covering the eyes and little more ... and lie in a horizontal plane  There is a good gap between the brows on both and they are of similar o/all shape. 



8.  However, the vertical gap between the eyes and brows differs between the two images.
Could that be because RH man was looking down and this feature was foreshortened?


9.  Both have the unusual bulges over the eyes. However the LH man has larger and bright eyes, whilst the RH man has a duller older look and his eyes are set closer together.  Seems that as the head was tilted forward AKA the RH image, the bulge almost slightly obscured the top of the eyes.

The eyes are similar is shape , but the bulge above the eyes tends to "squash" the eyes in the RH image


10.  The noses are not disimilar but again the RH image seems to be foreshortened, giving what appears to be a shorter nose.
Is the upper lip partially hidden by the nose and also foreshortened in the RH image?


11.  The hairlines are not the same, but if the man in the second image had his head grossly tilted down then it would be difficult to assess the hairline.




I feel sure they are the same man.


Because of the face tilt and the chin not being properly visible in the folds of neck fats, I decided to print the images off as large as I could and then in pencil, on the RH image, put marks guaging where the chin would have been .  I then pencilled in a jaw outline to match the outline of the jaw in the LH image and cut along the line.  It took about 5% off the length of the image doing this and meant that they were no longer to the same scale, so really I should have altered the sizing of each against the other, but I didn't have the technical nous.



The cheeks suddenly became alike, as well. when the new chin was given to the RH image



What truly amazed me was the way that the RH male image, forgetting the ten oclock shadow and with a smaller chin, lost its masculinity and became quite woman like !  But it still had so many features that tied it to the LH image.





There were differences, but with so many likenesses, I would be gobsmacked if these two images were of different people, unless they were brothers.



I find it incredible that such matching images could have been produced by at least two, and probably several people.  Well done The Smiths and well done who ever produced them!

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #119 on: October 01, 2014, 12:34:22 AM »
Because of the face tilt and the chin not being properly visible in the folds of neck fats, I decided to print the images off as large as I could and then in pencil, on the RH image, put marks guaging where the chin would have been .  I then pencilled in a jaw outline to match the outline of the jaw in the LH image.  It took about 5% off the length of the image doing this and meant that they were no longer to the same scale, so really I should have altered the sizing of each against tyhe otherr, but I didn't have the technical nous.



The cheeks suddenly became alike, as well. when the new chin was given to the RH image



What truly amazed me was the way that the RH male image, forgetting the ten oclock shadow and with a smaller chin, lost its masculinity and became quite woman like !  But it still had so many features that tied it to the LH image.





There were differences , but with so many likenesses, I would be gobsmacked if these two images were of different people, unless they were brothers.



I find it incredible that such matching images could have been produced by at least two, and probably several people.  Well done The Smiths and well done who ever produced them!


And very well done you, Sadie . What a lot of work you have done to get it right,,,As usual  8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato