Author Topic: The Smith sighting revisited.  (Read 157723 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline sadie

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #120 on: October 01, 2014, 01:15:31 AM »

And very well done you, Sadie . What a lot of work you have done to get it right,,,As usual  8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Thank you Anna. 

It took a long time, but we got there in the end.

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #121 on: October 01, 2014, 01:21:04 AM »
Thanks re Halligen.
M.Smith and A.Smith both saw the same trousers. So combining their two descriptions, that means the trousers had the shape of a classic cut, and possibly had buttons.
Re the sighting reported by a newspaper, IIRC the childcarrier talking on his mobile phone was walking "towards the wasteland" (meaning the wasteland south of Rua 25 Abril which SY extensively searched).

I have searched every sighting and there is only one using a mobile phone and that is the one too far away.
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Brietta

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #122 on: October 01, 2014, 03:29:07 AM »
http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/dm141013a.jpg



First things that I notice:

1)  THe LH mans face is a long, rather thin heart shaped face, the RH mans face appears to be rather "square" ...    I think the second man had his face was inclined right down, and his chin tucked right into his neck fat (jowls).  This caused his chin to visually vanish in the poor light and shadow from the upper face.


2.  Because his face is inclined right down, certain parts of the face are foreshortened [fs]  as well as the chin vanishing into his "jowls" (fatty neck)

Despite having only 3 statements, it is quite likely that everyone who saw Smithman had his/her own go at the Efit.  The RH efit has loads of foreshortening and also appears very "woolley.  Is it an amalgam of several efits?  Has that caused the woolleyness ?


3.    The LH man is slightly smiling, the RH man is not.  Smiling increases the length of the mouth and thins the lips down.  It also lifts the cheeks a little as in these photos.

I dont know, but I think the LH image was Aoifes image. 
I wonder if Aoife was a pretty 12 y.o. (going on 15 with make up) and he liked the look of her?  Hence the direct look and the appreciative small smile?  She would notice that and such is the natural reaction, would see an image that might be better looking than he really was?   


4.  Both men have small ears set flat against the head


5   However, the ears on the LH man appear to be stuck on in the wrong places, overlapping and cutting off a bit on each side oif the face, so making the LH face appear even slimmer.


6.  Both men have a pronounced 10 o'clock shadow on their upper lips, but nowhere else.


7.  The eyes and eyebrows have many similarities.   Eye shapes are not dis-similar, and neither are the eyebrow shapes.  Whilst one looks very groomed, the other looks a little unkept in comparison.  They are both horizontal in alignment.    Could the unkept look be because several efit images provided by several witnesses were superimposed and the minor variances caused the unkempt look?

With both images the brows widthwise, are are just covering the eyes and little more ... and lie in a horizontal plane  There is a good gap between the brows on both and they are of similar o/all shape. 



8.  However, the vertical gap between the eyes and brows differs between the two images.
Could that be because RH man was looking down and this feature was foreshortened?


9.  Both have the unusual bulges over the eyes. However the LH man has larger and bright eyes, whilst the RH man has a duller older look and his eyes are set closer together.  Seems that as the head was tilted forward AKA the RH image, the bulge almost slightly obscured the top of the eyes.

The eyes are similar is shape , but the bulge above the eyes tends to "squash" the eyes in the RH image


10.  The noses are not disimilar but again the RH image seems to be foreshortened, giving what appears to be a shorter nose.
Is the upper lip partially hidden by the nose and also foreshortened in the RH image?


11.  The hairlines are not the same, but if the man in the second image had his head grossly tilted down then it would be difficult to assess the hairline.




I feel sure they are the same man.


Thanks for your conclusions in this and the following post; you have explained your reasoning  very concisely. 

I thought the depictions might have been of the same person but you have confirmed it … the eyes (7) have it! and I hadn’t even noticed the five o’clock shadow only on the upper lip.

Thank you for going to so much trouble, Sadie … hope you are getting on with your clear-out, you have my sympathies because I am a terrible hoarder too but like you I am getting rid bit by bit.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Eleanor

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #123 on: October 01, 2014, 08:50:53 PM »

Well done, Sadie.  And very well explained.


Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #125 on: October 02, 2014, 06:25:39 PM »


The eyes of man on left are much larger and protruding than the eyes of man on right.
The nose of man on left is larger and longer than nose of man on right.

« Last Edit: October 02, 2014, 09:27:43 PM by John »

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #126 on: October 02, 2014, 06:43:26 PM »
http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/dm141013a.jpg
The eyes of man on left are much larger and protruding than the eyes of man on right.
The nose of man on left is larger and longer than nose of man on right.

Sorry to disagree Pegasus, but I believe it is the same man, but possible done by two witnesses, seperately. I have always thought it was the same man in the e-fits
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #127 on: October 02, 2014, 08:01:35 PM »
Sorry to disagree Pegasus, but I believe it is the same man, but possible done by two witnesses, seperately. I have always thought it was the same man in the e-fits
If the two efits were from two different sightings in two different locations and at two different times, would you still think the two efits are of the same man?

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #128 on: October 02, 2014, 08:15:58 PM »
If the two efits were from two different sightings in two different locations and at two different times, would you still think the two efits are of the same man?

I probably would. but not entirely sure that it would register as fast. I do believe that Several efits from other witnesses are the same man although they look a bit different. Tasmin's efit and description and the fact that he had a pen on a string hanging from his pocket and also shaving spots, puts me in mind of at least one of the charity collectors. PJ identified him and his details were withheld. They might have the wrong man. Sorry I have gone off topic
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #129 on: October 02, 2014, 08:54:08 PM »
I probably would. but not entirely sure that it would register as fast. I do believe that Several efits from other witnesses are the same man although they look a bit different. Tasmin's efit and description and the fact that he had a pen on a string hanging from his pocket and also shaving spots, puts me in mind of at least one of the charity collectors. PJ identified him and his details were withheld. They might have the wrong man. Sorry I have gone off topic
The man seen by TS had fair hair.
Back to the pair of SY efits: If one works from the assumption that the pair of efits released by SY are by two members of the Smith group, that would automatically mean both efits must be of the same man, and so one would have to look for similarities between the 2 efits (where IMO apart from hair length there are no similarities),


« Last Edit: October 02, 2014, 08:57:59 PM by pegasus »

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #130 on: October 02, 2014, 08:57:57 PM »
The man seen by TS had fair hair.
If one works from the assumption that the pair of efits released by SY are by two members of the Smith group, that would automatically mean both efits must be of the same man, and so one would have to look for similarities between the 2 efits (where IMO apart from hair length there are no similarities),

TS was unsure of the colour, because of sunlight glare IIRC
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #131 on: October 02, 2014, 09:02:10 PM »
TS was unsure of the colour, because of sunlight glare IIRC
Unsure only to the extent of unsure whether fair or blonde.
Which (unless we add an instant hair-dying lady to the formula) would mean he can't be smithman.

Offline pegasus

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #132 on: October 02, 2014, 09:09:20 PM »
Re the pair of efits.
One efit has a big face with small features.
The other efit has a thin face with big pronounced features.
Couldn't look more different JIMO.

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #133 on: October 02, 2014, 09:23:17 PM »
Unsure only to the extent of unsure whether fair or blonde.
Which (unless we add an instant hair-dying lady to the formula) would mean he can't be smithman.


I did not say that he was like smithman.



There is a collector described similar but with grey sides to his hair (Fair?) his ID photo showed him with a Goatie beard (shaved?)


Deposition of T. M. S., aged 12, a resident in Luz, on the 9th of May 2007, 4 p.m.
Page 800-804, volume III of process 201/07.0GALGS


Concerning the individual, she describes him as being: Caucasian race, light skin, so he wasn’t Portuguese, but could be British, according to her criteria. Approximately 180 cm tall, thin complexion, 30/35 years of age. Short hair, like shaved with 1 cm of length and fair, but she isn’t sure if it was blonde because the sun was reflecting, and made perception more difficult. She didn’t see the eyes because he wore dark glasses of black colour, with a structure of mass, a thick frame. He had a large forehead. Nose of normal size, a bit pointy and sharp. Large ears, close against the head. Mouth with thin lips, she didn’t see his teeth. Chin pointing up, which stood out on a face that she describes as sharp. No beard, no moustache, a clean shave. No other special signs, apart from some small pimples on the face as a result of shaving. He looked ugly, even ‘disgusting’.

The first time that she saw him he was wearing a sports style jacket of thin black leather, with a zipper and several pockets also with similar zippers, in silver. She saw no label or inscription. The jacket was open, therefore she saw a white t-shirt, with a dark blue label near the waist, which she cannot identify very well.

Trousers, she thinks, of blue jeans, worn out. Sports shoes (trainers) in black and grey, with a wave, maybe ‘Nike’ in a colour that she can’t remember.

The second time, he wore the same jacket, this time zipped up, because the day was colder than the first one, windy. She didn’t notice the rest of the clothing. She says that on that day he had a pen with a string attached to one of his pockets.The first time, he was leaning against the wall against his hands, and the second time, he had his hands in his pockets.

She never saw him with any photo camera, or any mobile phone, although the second time, he might have a device in his pocket, which she detected by the shape.

When asked, she says that she saw no vehicle near the man, only a few vehicles, but near the ‘Baptista’.

When asked she says that she saw Madeleine once, on a day that she cannot indicate, on the balcony where the man was staring at, the first time. She even waved at her because it was a small child, in a caring gesture.

A map of the area is added, where A is the spot of the first sighting and B the spot for the second one. The ‘Baptista’ supermarket and Madeleine’s apartment.

She said that she can recognise the man both personally and photographically, and create a photofit.

Therefore I interrupt the present deposition and show the deponent photographs of individuals with similar characteristics.

I resume the deposition where it is consigned that the diligence resulted negatively, according to a report that is annexed.

“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline sadie

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #134 on: October 02, 2014, 09:52:41 PM »
http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/dm141013a.jpg
The eyes of man on left are much larger and protruding than the eyes of man on right.
The nose of man on left is larger and longer than nose of man on right.
Yep, but the man in the RH image has his head held right down with his chin in his chest.  THe whole image is foreshortened and I think the image is composed of several images overelapped, all from several members of the Smith family.  There were several adults and near adults who altho they never gave a statement, saw this man .... and it is quite probable that they all had a go at the image.  Hence its woolleyness, caused by the overlapping of these images.

I agree the nose on the left is a good deal longer than the nose on the right.   That is partially because of foreshortening but mainly, it seems an anomoly.   The images have much that makes them very similar but there undoubtedly are some anomolies.  But that would be expected, I think. 

Sit even 6 experienced artists down with a model and one gets 6 different images, but if the artists are good, each image will look  like the model ... there will be differences tho.

I know that I could be wrong Pegasus, but I do have a very good erye for portraiture and figure drawing.  Was about to have a studio built in the garden to do portraits etc to sell commercially when the Madeleine case broke.  Instead I decided to spend my time trying to work out what happened to Madeleine.    I never had my studio  8(8-)).




The eyes on the left appear more protuding.  You are quite right.  The bulge on the top of the eye gives that away, but the man on the right also has eyes that are somewhat protuding, the bulge is still there but seen more from above, so it cuts a little of the eye off and is less obvious.

But there are other things about the eyes and brows that connect them.

I agree about the image on the left having bolder, more definite ,larger features ... but you cant get away from the striking likenesses of the two images.   Did you try cutting the botton of the RH image off to match the chin shape and size of the LH image? 

If you did, you will see that once all the neck folds are gone, the images are drawn to a different scale, which will account a little for the proprtions between the two images being different.

If you read my assessment you will see why I think there is additionally such a difference.  I think a bit of fancying the other happened between Smithman and Aoife and because of this, she saw a better image of Smithman than did the others.  The light was much better where she was too,  A giant lamp overhead at the road crossing, apart from normal street lights would illuminate Smithman better


That is an assumption that might not be correct.  Maybe there was no fancying going on, but good lighting would certainly make a big difference.



Pegasus, I ask you to consider what I am saying about the RH face being foreshortened and Smithman lowering his face as much as he could.  Personally, I think this is an indicator that he was up to no good, trying to hide his face and probably carrying Madeleine.