Author Topic: The Smith sighting revisited.  (Read 157705 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #180 on: October 07, 2014, 01:35:28 PM »
Why would she do that?  It is an ongoing investigation.

She would have told SY.

They would have made appeals about her sighting.

They haven't.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline Eleanor

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #181 on: October 07, 2014, 01:53:37 PM »
She would have told SY.

They would have made appeals about her sighting.

They haven't.

I doubt she knows any better than we all do.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #182 on: October 07, 2014, 02:01:34 PM »
I agree with Kate.  I am very unsure that the man Jane Tanner saw was some innocent party.

Certainly it is strange that Jane Tanner's sighting stayed up on the findMadeleine site so long.

Dunno ...

Offline Anna

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #183 on: October 07, 2014, 02:22:34 PM »
Smithman dunnit , Ellie, & it's not too difficult to work out who Smithman was.

You & the rest of em have to pretend otherwise, that's why you all cling to bundleman.

SC are also looking for Smithman, but if you know who he is, It is your duty to report it to them, not us.
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #184 on: October 07, 2014, 02:23:54 PM »
SC are also looking for Smithman, but if you know who he is, It is your duty to report it to them, not us.

You know who it was, that's why you're here.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline Brietta

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #185 on: October 10, 2014, 02:55:10 PM »
Irishman was already discarded - 24Horas
7 July 2008

When he was discharged, the former investigator of the Maddie case was preparing to hear an Irishman, who was considered to be a very relevant witness. But the present investigators don’t give him credibility

The statements from the Irish citizen who is considered to be a key witness in the Maddie case by Gonçalo Amaral, the man who lead the entire investigation, were not considered to be relevant by the investigators from the Polícia Judiciária who presently hold the process.

During the two depositions, both informal, the Irishman who is only known as “Smith” said that he saw the father of Madeleine McCann, Gerry, leaving the apartment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, Algarve, carrying a child on the day that the little girl disappeared. This, during the period of time between 6 and 10 p.m., precisely when Maddie disappeared.

“He was one of the witnesses that should be questioned within the rogatory letter that was sent to England. But, due to the fact that he is an Irish citizen, the authorities in Leicester, England, failed to contact him. The diligence was not deemed relevant, given the fact that he was informally heard at the beginning of the process and his depositions were highly contradictory”, a senior officer who is connected to the investigations revealed to 24Horas.

The same source specified: “First he said that he saw Maddie’s father leaving the apartment carrying a child. But during a second hearing he said he was not certain that it was Gerry who carried the child. He even said he could not assert whether said person was actually carrying a human being. This type of witness is not admissible in court and they do not deserve credibility”.

It is now up to prosecutor Magalhães e Meneses, who is analyzing the process, to decide whether it is necessary to carry out further diligences, namely whether the hearing of the Irish citizen is necessary or not to reach a decision about the case, which apparently is to be archived concerning the suspicions of concealment of a cadaver and possible homicide that are pending on the McCanns.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2008/07/irishman-was-already-discarded-24horas.html

My reading is that apart from Martin Smith's statement identifying Madeleine's father as the carrier the PJ had nothing which would bear the scrutiny of a court.

Nothing from the forensics;
Nothing from the dogs;
No 'confession'.

Interestingly, the PJ did not appear to find Mr Smith a credible witness.  So basically they had nothing to go on or another line of investigation to follow since all the eggs had been put in one basket and the one theory pursued.

IMO this makes the proposed reconstruction nothing more than a trawling exercise but when it did not take place, a convenient face saving excuse to close the case for which they had no evidence to prosecute.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #186 on: October 10, 2014, 03:07:55 PM »
Irishman was already discarded - 24Horas
7 July 2008

When he was discharged, the former investigator of the Maddie case was preparing to hear an Irishman, who was considered to be a very relevant witness. But the present investigators don’t give him credibility

The statements from the Irish citizen who is considered to be a key witness in the Maddie case by Gonçalo Amaral, the man who lead the entire investigation, were not considered to be relevant by the investigators from the Polícia Judiciária who presently hold the process.

During the two depositions, both informal, the Irishman who is only known as “Smith” said that he saw the father of Madeleine McCann, Gerry, leaving the apartment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, Algarve, carrying a child on the day that the little girl disappeared. This, during the period of time between 6 and 10 p.m., precisely when Maddie disappeared.

“He was one of the witnesses that should be questioned within the rogatory letter that was sent to England. But, due to the fact that he is an Irish citizen, the authorities in Leicester, England, failed to contact him. The diligence was not deemed relevant, given the fact that he was informally heard at the beginning of the process and his depositions were highly contradictory”, a senior officer who is connected to the investigations revealed to 24Horas.

The same source specified: “First he said that he saw Maddie’s father leaving the apartment carrying a child. But during a second hearing he said he was not certain that it was Gerry who carried the child. He even said he could not assert whether said person was actually carrying a human being. This type of witness is not admissible in court and they do not deserve credibility”.

It is now up to prosecutor Magalhães e Meneses, who is analyzing the process, to decide whether it is necessary to carry out further diligences, namely whether the hearing of the Irish citizen is necessary or not to reach a decision about the case, which apparently is to be archived concerning the suspicions of concealment of a cadaver and possible homicide that are pending on the McCanns.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2008/07/irishman-was-already-discarded-24horas.html

My reading is that apart from Martin Smith's statement identifying Madeleine's father as the carrier the PJ had nothing which would bear the scrutiny of a court.

Nothing from the forensics;
Nothing from the dogs;
No 'confession'.

Interestingly, the PJ did not appear to find Mr Smith a credible witness.  So basically they had nothing to go on or another line of investigation to follow since all the eggs had been put in one basket and the one theory pursued.

IMO this makes the proposed reconstruction nothing more than a trawling exercise but when it did not take place, a convenient face saving excuse to close the case for which they had no evidence to prosecute.

Fascinating.

Add this to the equation:

Martin Smith said in his statement to the Irish Gardia police at the end of January 2008 that he had been approached by Brian Kennedy representing the McCanns to produce an e-fit, but refused.

It surely makes perfect sense that while he believed the man he saw was Gerry, he would refuse.  Gerry, after all, does not need identification.

Surely the only reason Mr Smith changed his mind is because he was persuaded by release of the files in early August 2008 that he was (honestly) mistaken to suppose that the man was Gerry.

ETA:

This

It is now up to prosecutor Magalhães e Meneses, who is analyzing the process, to decide whether it is necessary to carry out further diligences,


The prosecutors actually, initially, decided that Mr Smith should be further interviewed by rogatory.

But there was an error in sending the letter of request to Westminster rather than the parliament of the Irish Republic, just never rectified.

So they didn't bother ...
« Last Edit: October 10, 2014, 03:15:48 PM by ferryman »

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #187 on: October 10, 2014, 03:23:05 PM »
Fascinating.

Add this to the equation:

Martin Smith said in his statement to the Irish Gardia police at the end of January 2008 that he had been approached by Brian Kennedy representing the McCanns to produce an e-fit, but refused.

It surely makes perfect sense that while he believed the man he saw was Gerry, he would refuse.  Gerry, after all, does not need identification.

Surely the only reason Mr Smith changed his mind is because he was persuaded by release of the files in early August 2008 that he was (honestly) mistaken to suppose that the man was Gerry.

ETA:

This

It is now up to prosecutor Magalhães e Meneses, who is analyzing the process, to decide whether it is necessary to carry out further diligences,


The prosecutors actually, initially, decided that Mr Smith should be further interviewed by rogatory.

But there was an error in sending the letter of request to Westminster rather than the parliament of the Irish Republic, just never rectified.

So they didn't bother ...

Seems that Meneses believed Gerry really was at the Tapas bar at the time of the Smiths sighting, & that he really did send Kate to check at 10:03.
« Last Edit: October 23, 2014, 12:36:27 PM by Mr Moderator »
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #188 on: October 10, 2014, 03:25:17 PM »
Seems that Meneses believed Gerry really was at the Tapas bar at the time of the Smiths sighting, & that he really did send Kate to check at 10:03.

If only de Meneses had your foresight and perspicacity ...
« Last Edit: October 23, 2014, 12:36:53 PM by Mr Moderator »

Offline faithlilly

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #189 on: October 10, 2014, 04:30:11 PM »
Seems that Meneses believed Gerry really was at the Tapas bar at the time of the Smiths sighting, & that he really did send Kate to check at 10:03.

What choice did he have ?

9 witnesses said Gerry was at the tapas bar and no idependent witness was able to to say otherwise so what was he supposed to do ?
« Last Edit: October 23, 2014, 12:37:21 PM by Mr Moderator »
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline John

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #190 on: October 10, 2014, 04:34:17 PM »
What did it matter where he was at 10pm since Madeleine was removed from the apartment by AN Other just after 9.10pm. 
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #191 on: October 10, 2014, 04:43:59 PM »
What did it matter where he was at 10pm since Madeleine was removed from the apartment by AN Other just after 9.10pm.

If all the emphasis is on the Smith sighting, then not so.

Around 2200, the time of Kate's alert.

At last, I believe, an answer to a question that has long puzzled me -- the assumption that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the same man.

My puzzlement has long been simply that, if they were the same man, either the Smiths or Jane were somewhat out in their recollection of the man's hair.  Jane's man has long, scraggily, untidy hair; Smith's man short-cut and quite tidy.

But I've just re-visted the site, which has this text, along side two e-fits (one Jane's, the other a rear-view):

These two pictures show a man carrying a child away from the family's apartment. This sighting was seen by a witness at 21:15 on the evening of Thursday, May 3rd, 2007.

Based or more recent information, the Metropolitan Police now believe this man [Jane's e-ft] may represent a guest at the Ocean Club who was carrying his daughter back to their apartment. However as it is not possible to be certain that these two men are actually the same person, if you have seen this man in the pictures or suspect who it may be, please contact the Metropolitan Police's OPERATION GRANGE on 0207 321 9251 (0044 207 321 9251 from outside the UK)
« Last Edit: October 10, 2014, 04:54:42 PM by ferryman »

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #192 on: October 10, 2014, 04:52:17 PM »
Irishman was already discarded - 24Horas
7 July 2008

When he was discharged, the former investigator of the Maddie case was preparing to hear an Irishman, who was considered to be a very relevant witness. But the present investigators don’t give him credibility

The statements from the Irish citizen who is considered to be a key witness in the Maddie case by Gonçalo Amaral, the man who lead the entire investigation, were not considered to be relevant by the investigators from the Polícia Judiciária who presently hold the process.

During the two depositions, both informal, the Irishman who is only known as “Smith” said that he saw the father of Madeleine McCann, Gerry, leaving the apartment in Praia da Luz, Lagos, Algarve, carrying a child on the day that the little girl disappeared. This, during the period of time between 6 and 10 p.m., precisely when Maddie disappeared.

“He was one of the witnesses that should be questioned within the rogatory letter that was sent to England. But, due to the fact that he is an Irish citizen, the authorities in Leicester, England, failed to contact him. The diligence was not deemed relevant, given the fact that he was informally heard at the beginning of the process and his depositions were highly contradictory”, a senior officer who is connected to the investigations revealed to 24Horas.

The same source specified: “First he said that he saw Maddie’s father leaving the apartment carrying a child. But during a second hearing he said he was not certain that it was Gerry who carried the child. He even said he could not assert whether said person was actually carrying a human being. This type of witness is not admissible in court and they do not deserve credibility”.

It is now up to prosecutor Magalhães e Meneses, who is analyzing the process, to decide whether it is necessary to carry out further diligences, namely whether the hearing of the Irish citizen is necessary or not to reach a decision about the case, which apparently is to be archived concerning the suspicions of concealment of a cadaver and possible homicide that are pending on the McCanns.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2008/07/irishman-was-already-discarded-24horas.html

My reading is that apart from Martin Smith's statement identifying Madeleine's father as the carrier the PJ had nothing which would bear the scrutiny of a court.

Nothing from the forensics;
Nothing from the dogs;
No 'confession'.

Interestingly, the PJ did not appear to find Mr Smith a credible witness.  So basically they had nothing to go on or another line of investigation to follow since all the eggs had been put in one basket and the one theory pursued.

IMO this makes the proposed reconstruction nothing more than a trawling exercise but when it did not take place, a convenient face saving excuse to close the case for which they had no evidence to prosecute.

Interesting.
What was "this" Smith doing outside the apartment?
Do we know who the source of this information is?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline misty

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #193 on: October 10, 2014, 05:20:49 PM »
Interesting.
What was "this" Smith doing outside the apartment?
Do we know who the source of this information is?

There is a picture of Amaral surrounded by reporters attached to the article. Perhaps that is a clue.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: The Smith sighting revisited.
« Reply #194 on: October 10, 2014, 06:42:09 PM »
There is a picture of Amaral surrounded by reporters attached to the article. Perhaps that is a clue.

Not really it still doesn't explain why Smith is stated as being outside the apartment when he wasn't.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey