Author Topic: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.  (Read 104247 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #105 on: November 11, 2014, 12:31:24 PM »
Part1 Nov 11th
Please Read from bottom up
or
you can follow live updates here-
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/shrien-dewani-trial-live-updates-4606708

 



10:39 am


Judge Traverso to cop: 'You knew who the glove was warn by'




PA Mziwamadoda Qwabe

Mziwamadoda Qwabe: One of the men convicted of murdering Anni
 

Defence barrister Francois Van Zyl is continuing to cross-examine police officer Paul Hendrickse

Van Zyl asks Hendrickse whether he entries in his diary "as to how the investigation proceeded?"

Hendrickse replies that no other entries were made in the diary.

Van Zyl refers to a glove that was sent for tests for primer residue.

Van Zyl asks Hendrickse: "You say you only became aware of the findings when the defence requested it."

Hendrickse replied that this was "an oversight."

Judge Jeanette Traverso said "A rather important oversight.

"You knew there was no dispute that the glove was worn by [convicted killer Mziwamadoda Qwabe]."

Hendrickse says yes.



10:28 am


Policeman: 'Is the state implying something underhanded was done?'




Barcroft Dewani trial

Trial: Shrien Dewani at the Western Cape High Court
 

Shrien Dewani's defence lawyer Francois Van Zyl is cross-examining police officer Paul Hendrickse.

Van Zyl says there was an "investigation diary, that stops in March 2011."

He asks Hendrickse why it stopped in March, because investigations are ongoing [at that time].

Hendrickse replied the decision was made because "things were being leaked to the press from that docket."

The cop asks Van Zyl what he is trying to imply.

"I don't know if the state is implying that something underhanded has been done.

"If so, tell me what you're trying to imply."



10:17 am


Policeman says his Facebook account was hacked



 
Tragedy: Shrien Dewani (right and top left with Anni) and the taxi she was killed in (bottom left)
 

Shrien Dewani's defence lawyer Francois Van Zyl is cross-examining police officer Paul Hendrickse.

He asks Hendrickse whether he made the following entry on his personal Facebook account after Shrien Dewani's extradition to South Africa was halted on mental health grounds.

"Mental Health Act? Human Rights? Fair trial? Are these just escape routes?"

Hendrickse replies that he does not recall making those entries.

He said it was the first time he had seen the entries, and that his Facebook page had been hacked.

He said he had now disabled it.



10:11 am


Hendrickse: 'This version of events is fabricated'




Getty Dewani trial

Case: The trial is taking place at Western Cape High Court
 

Police officer Paul Hendrickse is still giving evidence.

"As far as I can see, as far as the investigation goes, this version of [Shrien] Dewani is newly fabricated.

He said the evidence "would've been vital to supply to the investigating Officer, that [Zola] Tongo knew there was money and that he was arranging a helicopter trip.

Hendrickse said that in the version of events given by Mziwamadoda Qwabe "it was first alleged that Mr Dewani was involved."



9:58 am


Prosecutor: 'Dewani did not tell Anni's family that he had a meeting with taxi driver Zola Tongo'



Shrien Dewani meeting Zola Tongo
Accused: Shrien Dewani meeting Zola Tongo the morning after Anni was murdered
 

Prosecutor Adrian Mopp is speaking.

He said Shrien Dewani has entered a plea explanation.

"In it, he says he asked Tongo to arrange a helicopter trip as a surprise for his wife."

"Tongo took [Shrien and Anni Dewani], he took R10k in cash and placed it in her handbag, etc."

Mopp said Dewani had told Anni's family "that he had no contact with Tongo subsequent to the incident and the first contact he had with Tongo, was the Saturday."

Mopp said Dewani did not tell the family that he had a meeting with Tongo, exchanged texts and contact by phone - or the trip to exchange money.

Police officer Paul Hendrickse said: "That's correct."

Hendrickse said that if he had that information right from the beginning then taxi driver Zola Tongo would have become a "suspect right from the beginning and it would've provided a motive."

Judge Jeanette Traverso asks why would this have meant Tongo becoming a suspect?

Hendrickse replies that it would have provided a motive for Tongo to extort money."

Judge Traverso asks Hendrickse whether this is because he knew Shrien Dewani had money?

Hendrickse said that is correct.



9:46 am


Hendrickse: 'Dewani became uneasy and paced up and down'



Shrien and Anna Dewani CCTV footage from hotel released in 2012
Honeymoon: CCTV footage showing Shrien and Anna in their hotel before the shooting
 

Paul Hendrickse said Shrien Dewani changed his version of events saying that he did not see two firearms and cannot testify as to how taxi driver Zola Tongo got out of the car.

Hendrickse said he was "a bit confused because Dewani told me specifically where to find the ring, after he said (in his statement) that he gave the rings to the attackers."

Hendrickse said he put this to Dewani and that he "became uneasy with the question and paced up and down."



9:40 am


Hendrickse: 'I could see Dewani was stressed'



 
CCTV captures the moment Shrien Dewani 'was told his wife had been killed' Court sees hotel CCTV
 

Police captain Paul Henrickse said officers "obtained footage and audio from the Protea hotel.

Hendrickse said he wanted to give Shrien Dewani to look through his statement "because I understood that he was stressed."

PH said "the teo of us were alone. We chit-chatted in the vehicle. He [Dewani] was very calm, cooperative."

"He proceeded to rectify certain things in the statement."



9:26 am


Anni Dewani: "Just because we had a Bollywood wedding... we should not pretend"




Enterprise news and pictures Anni Dewani

Tragedy: Anni Dewani (pictured) sent emails to Shrien before she died
 

Captain Hendrickse explained that he took a second statement from taxi driver Zola Tongo.

He said that after taking that statement the police applied for a warrant of arrest Shrien Dewani.

That same day - in January 2011 - Anni Dewani's phone was sent to Britain so that its contents could be obtained.

Through that the police were able to obtain communication between the Anni and Shrien.

Prosecutor Mopp hands in email from Anni to the accused dated 5/11/2010.

It said: "I don't want an insecure man or whose feelings aren't real. I am ready to pack and leave. This is not a joke. I can't sleep

"Because we had a Bollywood wedding doesn't mean we are Bollywood actors and should just pretend."



9:15 am


Hendrickse: 'Dewani asked why we had arrested the taxi driver?'



 
Trial: Dewani and Anni had only been married a few weeks when she was killed
 

Judge Jeanette Traverso is getting frustrated with the questioning of Prosecutor Adrian Mopp.

Traverso told Mopp "you are pushing me to the point where I will do something - this crime happened four years ago."

Paul Hendrickse said that he received a call from Shrien Dewani.

"I explained that there have been certain developments and arrests have been made," he said.

Hendrickse said he told Dewani that taxi driver Zola Tongo was arrested. He said Dewani asked "why the taxi driver?"



8:55 am


Hendrickse: 'I had concerns after taking Zola Tongo's statement'



Zola Tongo (pic: Pixel)
Trial: Murderer Zola Tongo was fetched from prison to give evidence in court earlier in the trial
 

Police captain Paul Hendrickse is giving evidence.

He said that on the 17th November he interviewed taxi driver Zola Tongo - who was later convicted of Anni Dewani's murder.

PH said that when he took Tongo's statement, he was concerned that 1) "he was a black taxi driver who knew the locations" and secondly "that he would drive into an area at that time of night" and thirdly that "he should've known at that time of night Mzoli's [meat cafe] is closed."

He said he was also concerned that "Tongo had been pushed out the vehicle and later the accused was pushed out the vehicle and drove off with the deceased.

"I shared my concerns with Tongo," he said.



8:37 am


Hendrickse: 'I told Dewani I had found some items'



 
Case: Dewani (left) and Anni with her cousin Sneha Mashru (right)
 

Hendrickse said that during the morning of 15th November he received a phone call from Shrien Dewani to look between the stitching of the seat of the car for a wedding ring.

He said that he was later told that Xolile Mngeni - who was later convicted of Anni's murder - was identified from a palm print on the bonnet.

Hendrickse says he got in touch with Dewani that afternoon afternoon and told him he wanted to interview him.

He also told Dewani that he had recovered items from the scene.



8:29 am


State calls investigating police officer Paul Hendrickse



 
CCTV: Image captures the moment Shrien Dewani 'was told his wife had been killed'
 

The state has called its next witness, investigating police officer, Captain Paul Hendrickse.

Hendrickse arrived at the scene of the murder just after 9am.

He met Shrien Dewani for the first time at the Cape Grace hotel where he and Anni had been staying.

Hendrickse (PH): tells the court: "I proceeded to the Cape Grace hotel and interviewed the accused in this matter. I verified property stolen, cell numbers."

"The accused identified the wedding band as that of the deceased. It was an informal interview. I explained the procedure of identifying the deceased at the state mortuary."



7:51 am


Mbolombo: 'Dewani knew everything from start to finish'



 
Holiday: Shrien and Anni Dewani at their hotel
 

Court is due to recommence in half an hour.

A new witness is reportedly expected to appear and give evidence today.

Yesterday in court Judge Jeanette Traverso asked witness Monde Mbolombo whether he was only going to get money after the killing happened?

Mbolombo said what he knew was that "it was a matter of MUST - that it had to happen that Saturday."

Traverso said: "I'm going to ask you the last time. Who said it was a matter of must?"

"[Zola] Tongo," Mbolombo replied.

Referring to a phone call between Mbolombo and and convicted killer Mziwamadoda Qwabe, Dewani's defence lawyer Francois Van Zyl said: "It's that thing we talked about, it must happen today."

Van Zyl: "What were you referring to?"

Mbolombo: "What I was saying is this lady had to be killed on that day, Saturday."

Van Zyl asked Molombo why he said that to Qwabe at that time.

Mbolombo: "Maybe he had doubts, that's why."

Van Zyl said Shrien Dewani "will say he was not involved in a conspiracy to kill his wife."

Mbolombo replied that he wanted to also tell the court that Dewani is lying.

"[Shrien Dewani] knows everything from start to finish."



7:38 am


Shrien Dewani's murder trial restarts

Welcome to our live coverage of the murder trial of British businessman Shrien Dewani.

Yesterday in court in Cape Town former hotel receptionist Monde Mbolombo was cross-examined by Dewani's defence lawyer.

Dewani is accused of plotting the killing of his wife Anni during their honeymoon in South Africa in 2010. She was shot dead when their car was ambushed in Cape Town.

Three men, taxi driver Zola Tongo, Mziwamadoda Qwabe and Xolile Mngeni, 23, were jailed for Anni's murder.

Mbolombo struck a deal with prosecutors in the cases of others involved in the plot.

Under cross-examination by Dewani's defence barrister Francois Van Zyl, Mbolombo detailed his part in the plot to kill Anni.

Mbolombo said "I was making sure the job was done. Since there was money to be received, I wanted to make sure it happened.

Mbolombo: "What I was saying is this lady had to be killed on that day, Saturday
 
   

 

« Last Edit: November 11, 2014, 12:35:21 PM by Anna »
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #106 on: November 11, 2014, 02:13:22 PM »
Part 2 Nov 11th

10.11
Police officer Paul Hendrickse is still giving evidence.


"As far as I can see, as far as the investigation goes, this version of [Shrien] Dewani is newly fabricated.
He said the evidence "would've been vital to supply to the investigating Officer, that [Zola] Tongo knew there was money and that he was arranging a helicopter trip.

Hendrickse said that in the version of events given by Mziwamadoda Qwabe "it was first alleged that Mr Dewani was involved."

10.17
Shrien Dewani's defence lawyer Francois Van Zyl is cross-examining police officer Paul Hendrickse.

He asks Hendrickse whether he made the following entry on his personal Facebook account after Shrien Dewani's extradition to South Africa was halted on mental health grounds.

"Mental Health Act? Human Rights? Fair trial? Are these just escape routes?"

Hendrickse replies that he does not recall making those entries.

He said it was the first time he had seen the entries, and that his Facebook page had been hacked.

He said he had now disabled it.

10.39
Van Zyl asks Hendrickse whether he entries in his diary "as to how the investigation proceeded?"
Hendrickse replies that no other entries were made in the diary.

Van Zyl refers to a glove that was sent for tests for primer residue.

Van Zyl asks Hendrickse: "You say you only became aware of the findings when the defence requested it."

Hendrickse replied that this was "an oversight."


Judge Jeanette Traverso said "A rather important oversight.

"You knew there was no dispute that the glove was worn by [convicted killer Mziwamadoda Qwabe]."

Hendrickse says yes.

10.56
Defence barrister Francois Van Zyl is quizzing cop Paul Hendrickse about the shooting itself.

He asked Hendrickse whether he would agree that Anni Dewani had not been killed in an execution-type murder.


Hendrickse says no.

"In my view, this is not a professional person. Execution-style killings are usually well organised."

"It appears from the facts and evidence I got, they were robbed."

Hendrickse said the shooting was 'not unique for the violent society we live in in South Africa.'


He said it does not appear to have been a professional hit, but that it does not mean that it wasn't.

Van Zyl asks Hendrickse why he won't concede that the placing of the shot to Anni's neck "is not normally what one would see in execution cases."

Hendrickse says this is because the case has a "different set of merits."

Hendrickse said Shrien Dewani and Zola Tongo were let out of the taxi and then "they took the lady and killed her."

"It was not a typical execution-style shooting to the head," he said.



Defence barrister Van Zyl said Qwabe testified that Xolile Mngeni had pulled the trigger.

Van Zyl refers to the marks Anni Dewani's leg.

"Did that play a role?"

Hendrickse said he believed the marks were "purely because of the manhandling while she was being robbed."

The court has adjourned for lunch.

12.55

The trial has resumed after lunch and Shrien Dewani's defence lawyer Francois Van Zyl is questioning police officer Paul Hendrickes about the evidence he gathered.

Hendrickes said Dewani had become 'uncomfortable.'

Van Zyl asked the cop whether he thought this proved Dewani's guilt?

Hendrickes said: "I'm not saying that, I just noticed a change in his demeanour."

Van Zyl is now making reference to a BBC Panorama programme which focused on CCTV footage from the Protea Hotel.

Addressing Paul Hendrickes, Van Zyl refers to attorney Tanya Lochner, who he said he had spoken to during the lunch hour.

"She told me that you said they (hitmen) did not mean to shoot her (Anni).

"They only shot because she wouldn't stop screaming."


1.05

Shrien Dewani's defence barrister Francois Van Zyl has also quizzed police officer Paul Hendrickes about Anni's ring.

He said: "The accused will further say, back in the UK, Sneha Hindocha [Anni's cousin and friend] looked in Anni's jewellery box, that the ring with the black stone was missing.

Hendrickes said "no, I don't."

Van Zyl said Shrien Dewani will will say that, that is when you [Hendrickes] wanted to take his fingerprints.

Hendrickes said this is "incorrect."

"That didn't happen,' he said.


Van Zyl said: "I'm telling you it did."


1.44

Shrien Dewani's defence barrister Francois Van Zyl questions policeman Paul Hendrickes about the apparent differences in the evidence given by Monde Mbolombo and taxi driver Zola Tongo over the shooting.

Van Zyl said: "You knew that Monde Mbolombo's statement that the wife had to be killed flies in the face of Tongo's version?

Responds That he does

Van Zyl said there is "a rumour that Mr Tongo decided to change his story. And that you, his attorney and legal officer went to see him to find out."

Hendrickes said that is correct, but that Tongo had been upset with his attorney, saying he hadn't seen him in a long while.

"He didn't want to see me or [prosecutor Shareen] Riley - [he[ said that's it, he's not testifying.

"He didn't want to see me or Miss Riley, said that's it, he's not testifying."


Trial has adjourned for the day
« Last Edit: November 13, 2014, 11:42:24 AM by John »
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #107 on: November 12, 2014, 12:04:33 PM »
12th nov 2014
Read from the bottom up.   

http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/LIVE-Dewani-trial-day-20-20141112
 
   

   

AS IT HAPPENED: Dewani judge angry with State
2014-11-12 09:52



Get all the highlights from the 20th day of Shrien Dewani's trial in the Western Cape High Court for the murder of his wife, Anni Hindocha.


 

LIVE NEWS FEED



Jump to
 bottom

Last Updated at 11:54




10:44 






Share Icon

 So we're closing updates now after a very brief session today. It'll be back on Friday when the trial resumes. Cheers.
 

 

 
 






10:31 






Share Icon

 Proceedings have been adjourned until Friday.
 

 

 
 






10:29 






Share Icon

 Judge Traverso scathingly asks the State: Why are you still scurrying around for witnesses?
 

 

 
 






10:28 






Share Icon

 Traverso:I am not going to argue with you any further. I must just express my great displeasure with the way this case is going... 

 

 
 






10:27 






Share Icon


Traverso: Surely you knew this before coming to trial. Why is there no report? The police have gone on TV, on Panorama about the state's case. I'm going to grant you the indulgence but I want to know, why only now.

Mopp: We've been trying to get an expert from the police, who is competent, to talk about primer residue & what happens when a shot is fired.

 
 

 
 






10:24 






Share Icon

 VZ says the defence does not have a report for this new witness. Mopp says there is a report in the docket but there is a new aspect the witness will be questioned on. Mopp says she has been asked to draw up a report and hand it to the State and defence.
 

 

 
 






10:23 






Share Icon

 The state has arranged for 2 witnesses. Requests a postponement until Friday, to lead an expert witness coming from Pretoria. 

 

 
 






10:21 






Share Icon


VZ: Would you agree this is banter between two people who have affection for one another, to avoid the word love? PH: yes

Traverso: Did you know about those BBMs? PH: Yes.
 
 

 
 






10:19 






Share Icon

 Further messages reveal Anni found out the honeymoon was going to be in South Africa (it was supposed to be a surprise). SD smiles as his lawyer reads the messages.
 

 

 
 






10:18 






Share Icon

 SD responds to Anni's Nandos message by saying he's hungry. Anni says he should call her if he wants to be picked up.
 

 

 
 






10:17 






Share Icon

 Anni messaged SD about lunch - "mmm Nandos"
 

 

 
 






10:16 






Share Icon

 VZ: We;ve extracted BBM messages from that phone (Anni's) for the 4 and 5 November. (records handed to the court). 

 

 
 






10:13 






Share Icon

 VZ: Did he deny it? PH: That's correct. In the transcripts, even his brother Preyen asks him when his last contact was. 

 

 
 






10:13 






Share Icon

 PH: the accused, when asked when he had communication with Tongo, he says the Saturday. Even then, he didn't say that he spoke to Tongo on that Friday. These intentions here may seem nice to us, but the investigation proves there was a phone call between M. Dewani and Mr Tongo that night. He never told us about the call, nor in the interview with (journalist) Nick Parker.
 

 

 
 






10:12 






Share Icon

 Judge to PH: Do you concede that they were kissing and cuddling? PH: yes. 

 

 
 






10:12 






Share Icon

 SD is trying to compose himself in the dock, he is taking deep breaths, wipes away tears, sips water. 

 

 
 






10:11 






Share Icon

 The photos are taken in a bar area. Anni takes pictures of SD, then a waiter takes pictures of them both. Anni leans into SD, hand on his shoulder, as she speaks to him. SD then holds her and gives her a kiss.
 

 

 
 






10:09 






Share Icon

 Another clip shows the couple posing for a photo, they are affectionate, look like typical honeymooners. 

 

 
 






10:07 






Share Icon

 VZ: Both clips are on their way back. The point is, that was some hours after, according to the state's case, he plotted to murder his wife...
 

 

 
 






10:07 






Share Icon

 VZ: You are aware that the accused and the deceased went to Sevruga on the Friday night. PH: That's correct 

 

 
 






10:06 






Share Icon

 SD is said to be fighting back the tears in the courtroom.
 

 

 
 






10:05 






Share Icon

 The 1st clip shows SD and Anni walking over the bridge outside the Cape Grace.They're hand in hand.
 

 

 
 






10:04 






Share Icon

 Defence shows Hendrickse (PH) three clips. The first two were taken by CCTV cameras at the Cape Grace.
 

 

 
 






10:03 






Share Icon

 

 

 
 
 




09:56 






Share Icon

 Hendrikse, will be recalled to the stand this morning, at the defence's request, tweets eNCA's Leigh-Anne Jansen. He is expected to be questioned about two or three video clips.
 

 

 
 






09:53 






Share Icon


Hendrickse, who led the investigation into Hindocha's murder, denied bias against her husband in the Western Cape High Court on Tuesday, Sapa reports.

Francois van Zyl, for Shrien Dewani, asked Captain Paul Hendrikse whether his attitude towards his client and the investigation was fairly impartial. Hendrikse, the 15th State witness, replied yes.

The defence also criticised Hendrikse for not keeping an investigation diary and for failing to timeously follow up on the primer residue results for Qwabe's yellow kitchen glove.

The officer explained that he put all his notes and observations into statements that were available to the defence.

He said it was an "oversight" that they only obtained the primer residue results after the defence requested it from the State.
 
 

 
 






09:53 






Share Icon


On Tuesday, the court heard about emails sent from Anni Hindocha to Dewani, just days before her murder in Cape Town.

Captain Paul Hendrikse, the State's 15th witness, said they recovered her BlackBerry phone and sent it to the United Kingdom in January 2011 to obtain its contents. Two e-mails from the deceased to her murder-accused husband were found.

"I left my home, family and everything to be with you and three days later you say that if you knew marriages were like this, you wouldn't [have] got married. Seriously, do you want me to leave you?" she said in the first e-mail.

"It's very mean of you to tell me things you told me just after marriage.

"Then you should have told me this before. I don't want an insecure man or a man whose feelings doesn't come naturally that you have to force yourself."
 
 


“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #108 on: November 12, 2014, 12:51:01 PM »
Todays hearing was short and lacking . It was stated that time is required to bring two new witnesses to the stand, so court is adjourned until Friday. (It is in connection with ballistics)

There seems to be more evidence of  the trivial than the important ,being presented and I am inclined to believe that the defence is skirting around the important facts to find fault in the investigative procedures, to achieve acquittal on Technicalities ? Just my opinion of course!

The CCTV footage shown in court,(some damning) gives a better understanding of what was happening at the time. The evidence by witnesses who say that SD lied about several things and the murder plot.

  I will do a list of pointers of evidence which are positive/negative when I have more time.

  A slow moving trial with many irrelevant factors and I think Dewani will walk free, unless some very strong evidence is forthcoming.

I find the following emails from Anni, tell us what was going on  prior to her death.  I believe that, that poor young woman, was used in the most selfish manner.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The court heard that police investigating the case had obtained emails sent from Anni to Shrien.

One of the emails, dated November 5th, 2010 - just eight days before Anni was shot - read:

"I don't want an insecure man or whose feelings aren't real. I am ready to pack and leave. This is not a joke. I can't sleep."

Another read:

"Because we had a Bollywood wedding doesn't mean we are Bollywood actors and should just pretend."
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #109 on: November 13, 2014, 05:13:11 PM »
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #110 on: November 14, 2014, 01:16:56 PM »
 

  Nov 14, 2014 10:12 
By Sam Adams
 

The British millionaire is on trial accused of plotting the murder of his wife Anni during their honeymoon in South Africa in 2010
 Court has adjourned until Monday.

Today's proceedings from Shrien Dewani's murder trial were short but eventful.

The prosecution called a new witness, forensics expert Colonel Thandiwe Mlabateki.

He explained how primer residue can be distributed, and where it is most likely to be found.

He was cross examined by defence lawyer Pieter Botha.

Today's questions revolved around residue found on the glove of convicted killer Mziwamadoda Qwabe.

To recap on all of today's updates scroll down:




8:25 am


Murder trial restarts




Rex Accused: Shrien Dewani is on trial accused of murdering his wife

Shrien Dewani leaves the Western Cape High Court on 10th Nov
 

The trial of Shrien Dewani has recommenced in Cape Town, South Africa.

Proceedings were cut short on Wednesday when the prosecution asked for the trial to be adjourned so they could call two news witnesses.

Despite this, there was still time for some dramatic evidence to be revealed.

Shrien Dewani's defence showed three CCTV clips of the married couple seemingly enjoying each other's company before the shooting.

Two of the clips were taken at the Cape Grace Hotel, on the Friday evening before Anni was killed.

The first - which is just a few seconds long - shows Shrien Dewani and Anni Dewani walking outside the hotel.

The second shows an aerial view of newly married pair together, with Shrien holding Anni at one point.

the third CCTV clip shows Shrien and Anni taking photographs of each other at 'Sevruga's bar' area.

Anni can be seen taking a photo of Shrien and then the waiter takes a pic of the pair of them.

At one point Shrien holds Anni and kisses her.

Reporter Leigh-Anne Jansen says Shrien is wiping away tears in court.



8:33 am


Forensics expert takes the stand



 
Case:
 

Colonel Thandiwe Mlabateki has taken the stand, and is the state's 16th witness.

He is an officer attached to the police Forensics Science Laboratory.

Mlabateki, who is a primer residue expert and has 19 years experience in forensics, has prepared a report.



8:42 am


Mlabateki: 'Gun residue particles have 2m radius'



 
Holiday: Shrien and Anni Dewani captured on CCTV at their hotel
 

Prosecutor Adrian Mopp is questioning Thandiwe Mlabateki.

Mopp produces a photograph of a glove warn by convicted killer Mziwamadoda Qwabe.

Mlabateki said that when a firearm is discharged primer residue particles are deposited on the hands of the individual who fired the weapon.

He said these residue particles have a radius of about 2 metres.



8:51 am


'Someone close to gun being fired could be covered in primer residue'




Getty Dewani trial

Case: The trial is taking place at Western Cape High Court
 

Forensics expert Thandiwe Mlabateki is being questioned by prosecutor Adrian Mopp.

He said it is possible that a person in 'close proximity' to someone firing a gun can test positive for primer residue.

He said wind and rain can influence the results of residue tests and that if there is significant movement, the particles could move.

Mlabateki said it is easy for residue particles to move on leather seats as their surface is so smooth.



9:01 am


'Can't deduce where shot came from'




Getty 

Trial: Shrien Dewani (left) and inset with wife Anni on honeymoon


Colonel Mlabateki said you cannot deduce where the shot came from.

The residue is made up of lead, barium and antimony.

He described the three reasons why a person might test positive for primer residue:

1. They fired the weapon

2. They were within 2m of the person who fired the gun.

3. 'Secondary transfer' - If someone comes into contact with something that is covered in primer residue.



9:12 am


Defence lawyer cross-examines Col Mlabateki about the residue



 
 

Prosecutor Adrian Mopp is questioning forensics expert Thandiwe Mlabateki.

Mopp is referring to photograph of the Qwabe's glove.

Mlabateki said the glove was not disturbed as he sees it in the photo.

"It was reserved and therefore it was possible to get a positive result," he said.

Defence lawyer Pieter Botha is cross-examining Mlabateki.

Botha asks what Mlabateki knows thus far?

Mlabateki said the weapon fire in the taxi and that there was wind as well.

Both asks him "where was the wind?"

Mlabateki said he is not sure if it was on that specific day.

He agreed with Botha's suggestion that wind does not play a role when the windows are rolled up.



9:26 am


Mziwamadoda Qwabe 'said he never touched the gun'



The scene where Anni Dewani was murdered in Cape Town, South Africa (Pic: Getty)
Shooting: The scene where Anni Dewani was murdered in Cape Town, South Africa
 

Botha asks Colonel Thandiwe Mlabateki's if a person can test positive for primer residue if it is found anywhere on their body?

He replies that it is.

Botha says Qwabe's evidence was that he never touched the firearm before or after it was fired.

He asks Mlabateki whether he was informed about this?

Mlabateki said he did not know that.

Botha: "That secondary transfer is then excluded from this instance, would you agree with me?"

Mlabateki said: "If he was in the vehicle, wearing the glove, primer residue will settle on all exposed areas. If he was wearing the glove chances are high."

Qwabe's evidence was that he had picked up the shell casing.

Mlabateki said the place where you are most likely to find primer residue is in the web between the thumb and the index finger, because this is the closest part of the hand to the weapon.



9:34 am


Botha: 'Presence of primer residue on body doesn't prove person fired gun'




PA Mziwamadoda Qwabe

Mziwamadoda Qwabe: One of the men convicted of murdering Anni
 

Defence lawyer Pieter Botha is continuing to cross examine forensics expert Colonel Thandiwe Mlabateki.

Botha says the presence of primer residue on a person's body does not conclusively prove they fired the gun.

Mlabateki said this is correct.

He asks Mlabateki whether it would surprise him that the police report on the residue was only made available at the request of the defence in August this year?

Mlabateki said it does.



9:51 am


The trial has been adjourned - Recap on today's events in court



 
Gunman: Qwabe (left), Dewani (top right) and Anni
 

The trial has been adjourned until Monday.

To recap on today's events:

Prosecutor Adrian Mopp introduced a new witness - forensics expert Thandiwe Mlabateki.

Mopp produces a photograph of a glove warn by Mziwamadoda Qwabe - one of three men convicted of murdering Anni Dewani.

Mlabateki said that when a firearm is discharged primer residue particles are deposited on the hands of the individual who fired the weapon.

He said these residue particles have a radius of about 2 metres.

He said it is possible that a person in 'close proximity' to someone firing a gun can test positive for primer residue.

He said wind and rain can influence the results of residue tests and that if there is significant movement, the particles could move.



 
Tragedy: CCTV captures the moment Shrien Dewani 'was told his wife had been killed'
 

Mlabateki said it is easy for residue particles to move on leather seats as their surface is so smooth.

The residue is made up of lead, barium and antimony.

He described the three reasons why a person might test positive for primer residue:

1. They fired the weapon

2. They were within 2m of the person who fired the gun.

3. 'Secondary transfer' - If someone comes into contact with something that is covered in primer residue.

Mlabateki says primer residue is most likely to be found in the web of the hand of the person who fired a gun - because that is the closest area to the weapon.

Defence lawyer Pieter Botha asks Mlabateki whether he agrees that the presence of primer residue in the web area of the hand does not conclusively mean that that person fire the weapon.

Mlabateki said that is correct.

Botha asked Mlabateki whether he was surprised that a copy of the report on the primer residue was only made available at the request of the defence in August this year?

Mlabatekin said that it does.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/shrien-dewani-trial-recap-court-4626354
 
   

 




   
« Last Edit: November 14, 2014, 01:19:04 PM by Anna »
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Miss Taken Identity

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #111 on: November 15, 2014, 01:54:24 PM »
Like a fox in a corner, clever fox, he cried mental health issues and the idiots in the UK accepted it, we have to protect murderers in this country dont you know.

I know Africa i lived there. IF you dont give a gunman what they want they shoot you they dont ask you, they shoot you or hack you to death. A real attack would have raped her, and maybe even him, and killed them both and even taken her beautiful shoes.

They dont leave witnesses. When we were there in Nairobi a journalist was killed because he wouldnt give over his car. He managed to explain to police before he died. I think then they were coming in from Uganda like bloody pirates.

That poor sad girl, what a horrible way to die. God rest her soul.

I dont even care if this guy is gay or straight, but he has an evil heart either way.

I agree Colombs.  Sordid was always associated with him! Mental illness indeed he thought money could save him..... sometimes it does!
'Never underestimate the power of stupid people'... George Carlin

Offline Holly Goodhead

Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #113 on: November 17, 2014, 03:23:27 PM »
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2837723/Shrien-Dewani-s-lawyers-officially-case-against-thrown-following-succession-prosecution-lines-collapsing.html

Thanks Holly,
You beat me too it. The case is adjourned for a week while a request for a dismissal of the case is submitted, due to lack of evidence........................
Evidence? .......If only Anni could speak!
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline Holly Goodhead

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #114 on: November 17, 2014, 03:30:14 PM »
Thanks Holly,
You beat me too it. The case is adjourned for a week while a request for a dismissal of the case is submitted, due to lack of evidence........................
Evidence? .......If only Anni could speak!

You're welcome Anna.  You've done most of the work keeping us up-dated  8((()*/ 

I've always thought the case against SD seemed weak but it's not over yet!

 
Just my opinion of course but Jeremy Bamber is innocent and a couple from UK, unknown to T9, abducted Madeleine McCann - motive unknown.  Was J J murdered as a result of identifying as a goth?

Offline John

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #115 on: November 17, 2014, 04:34:20 PM »
Good God, the defence asks that the case against Dewani be dismissed because of lack of evidence yet it has been clearly proven that Dewani had contact with these killers both before and after the dirty deed.

The defence is obviously attempting to take advantage of a dishevelled police force struggling to cope in South Africa. 
« Last Edit: November 18, 2014, 01:50:46 AM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #116 on: November 17, 2014, 08:56:28 PM »
Good God, the defence asks that the case against Dewani be dismissed because of lack of evidence yet it has been clearly proven that Dewani had contact with these killers both before and after the dirty deed.

The defence is obviously attempting to take advantage of a dishevelled police force struggling to cope in South Africa.

It's too like the Pistorius well paid defence lawyer.......Money pays off!
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Offline John

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #117 on: November 18, 2014, 01:49:09 AM »
Dewani trial - The State rests

After calling 16 witnesses to testify in the Honeymoon Murder Trial, the prosecution has closed its case.

www.ewn.co.za/Media/2014/11/17/Dewani-Trial-The-State-Rests
« Last Edit: November 19, 2014, 04:24:19 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #118 on: November 18, 2014, 06:57:10 PM »

I have been sort of watching this.  And what a farce it seems to me.  The minute one of the perpetrators get's a reduced sentence for dobbing in the husband, you have to wonder if in fact the husband was guilty.

Offline Anna

Re: Shrien Dewani trial commences in Capetown.
« Reply #119 on: November 19, 2014, 01:06:28 PM »
I have been sort of watching this.  And what a farce it seems to me.  The minute one of the perpetrators get's a reduced sentence for dobbing in the husband, you have to wonder if in fact the husband was guilty.

Another mysterious case, but it is forensic evidence, that may sway in His favour IMO. If it isn't thrown out, as has been applied for. We will know more on Friday or Monday.
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato