Is there any hard evidence whatsoever in the Madeleine McCann case?

[mercury]

This thread is Re: Is there any hard evidence whatsoever in the Madeleine McCann case?


Well it seems not, unless one can take into account an open window and a missing child, which only gives evidence of her disappearance, but not how she came to disappear or where she is now. Not a trace of her anywhere. alive or otherwise

Exactly , period, there is no evidence of an abduction, soft, let alone hard

[G-Unit]

This thread is Re: Is there any hard evidence whatsoever in the Madeleine McCann case?


Well it seems not, unless one can take into account an open window and a missing child, which only gives evidence of her disappearance, but not how she came to disappear or where she is now. Not a trace of her anywhere. alive or otherwise

There is no evidence of an open window.

[Mr Gray]

There is no evidence of an open window.

there is evidence of an open window...Kate's statement is evidence...again...you do not understand the meaning of the word evidence......

You have talked about facts...kate's statement is evidence ...that is a fact

[slartibartfast]

there is evidence of an open window...Kate's statement is evidence...again...you do not understand the meaning of the word evidence......

You have talked about facts...kate's statement is evidence ...that is a fact

As is Grimes statement.

[Wonderfulspam]

there is evidence of an open window...Kate's statement is evidence...again...you do not understand the meaning of the word evidence......

You have talked about facts...kate's statement is evidence ...that is a fact

It wasn't actually open though.

Fabricated evidence.

[Mr Gray]

As is Grimes statement.

No where does Grime state that the dog's alerted to a cadaver...I have no problem with anything Grime has said...nothing he says provides any sort of hard evidence that a cadaver had been in 5a

[G-Unit]

there is evidence of an open window...Kate's statement is evidence...again...you do not understand the meaning of the word evidence......

You have talked about facts...kate's statement is evidence ...that is a fact

Is it 'hard' evidence though? I have been castigated on this thread for referring to statements.

[G-Unit]

Indeed, and they can even add their signature to a statement which doesn't make it true.  Simples.

I agree with Brietta!

[stephen25000]

No where does Grime state that the dog's alerted to a cadaver...I have no problem with anything Grime has said...nothing he says provides any sort of hard evidence that a cadaver had been in 5a

and where did he say the dogs could not have alerted to a body in the apartment.

The dogs made alerts, the forensic results were inconclusive, but did not remove the possibility of a body being alerted to.

.................and in the cold light of reality, there is nothing else in this case.

[Mr Gray]

Is it 'hard' evidence though? I have been castigated on this thread for referring to statements.

You said it wasn't evidence...it is

[Mr Gray]

and where did he say the dogs could not have alerted to a body in the apartment.

The dogs made alerts, the forensic results were inconclusive, but did not remove the possibility of a body being alerted to.

.................and in the cold light of reality, there is nothing else in this case.

so the dog's may have alerted to a cadaver...or they may not have....doesn't tell us anything does it

[stephen25000]

It wasn't actually open though.

Fabricated evidence.

Indeed.

Absolutely no independent verification the shutters were moved or the window opened.

The only fingerprints identified were mccanns.

[G-Unit]

You said it wasn't evidence...it is

Why was I told to stay on topic when I used statements as evidence then?

[stephen25000]

so the dog's may have alerted to a cadaver...or they may not have....doesn't tell us anything does it

There is nothing else in this case.

Now how do you explain after virtually 8 years bar a few days, NOT ONE TRACE of Madeleine has been found ?

[Wonderfulspam]

No where does Grime state that the dog's alerted to a cadaver...I have no problem with anything Grime has said...nothing he says provides any sort of hard evidence that a cadaver had been in 5a

There definitely had been though.