Author Topic: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?  (Read 132844 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #90 on: November 11, 2015, 10:51:36 PM »
Yeah I read that. Sky News' interpretation of the video of DCI Redwood you posted earlier?. Lets look again and highlight different words.

When asked whether he believed the family was being watched, he said: "The physical evidence demonstrates to us that there are people, unexplained people, possibly doing just that.

"By the way the witnesses have described them ... lurking around in the very close proximity from where Madeleine was taken."

He said that one reading of the evidence indicated the abduction had "all the hallmarks of a pre-planned abduction that would undoubtedly have involved reconnaissance".
So?
What else were they possibly doing?
Which witnesses?
What other readings are there? the implication being there are others.
Do you think this Sky News report is a definitive MPS statement?
Andy Redwood would be very foolish to state definitively that Madeleine was definitely abducted and these individuals were definitely involved, however what we can glean from his words, even through the Sky spin machine, is that the Met were taking very seriously indeed the theory that Madeleine was taken in a pre-planned abduction, and they announced that they were pursuing this theory at the same time as the "greased" (to use your favoured terminology) Tannerman.  This takes me back to the point I made earlier.  See above. 

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #91 on: November 11, 2015, 11:11:47 PM »
Andy Redwood would be very foolish to state definitively that Madeleine was definitely abducted and these individuals were definitely involved, however what we can glean from his words, even through the Sky spin machine, is that the Met were taking very seriously indeed the theory that Madeleine was taken in a pre-planned abduction, and they announced that they were pursuing this theory at the same time as the "greased" *(to use your favoured terminology) Tannerman. This takes me back to the point I made earlier.  See above.

It was an option among others. To ignore it would have been slapdash. Even the PJ covered more than one possibility.
We can now look at it with two years hindsight. Has that option delivered suspects or arrests? So what next?

 * "Fragged" is my favoured term but I will be accused of being "Stuckey II" if I don't ring the changes with "greased"  "creamed" and "spread".
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #92 on: November 12, 2015, 07:35:55 AM »
Sorry, I was under the impression that police officers investigating a serious crime make it their business to find out everything and anything that may be relevant to solving that crime, not wait for people to tell them about it.  Why wouldn't police operating in and around holiday destinations have some inkling about holidaymakers using creche facilities?  It's hardly a new fangled concept is it?  Why did it not occur to them to ask the question of themselves and those around them: "why would a man be carrying a sleeping child through the streets at night in this area" and discover that, actually it was a fairly common occurence in and around the OC because of that creche?  Why do you keep making excuses for the police in Portugal?
I don't keep making excuses for anyone, I simply prefer reality.

Why did Redwood dig up central Luz?  The bit he dug up is an integral part of the one-way system.  Both Rua 25 de Abril and the seemingly meaningless road across the mound are essential to traffic flow.  Presumably Redwood looked at Streetview and thought they were minor.

Why did Redwood not twig that 3 nannies in the search put Godfrey Barrington Norton and his Escort van on top of the mound that night.  Well, that would be because he wouldn't understand that there are 2 places in Luz that people camp. One is on the flat and can be ruled out as the nanny said the van was on a hill.  The hill people camp on (motorhomes, not tents) is the mound that SY dug up.

So Redwood did not understand the Luz traffic system or where folks camp.  Did this make him look a tw..?  To people who understand both, the answer is a definite yes.  So here is the unapologetic but realistic answer.  Redwood did not understand Luz therefore he could not reach this conclusion.

So, is Redwood a tw.. for not getting boots on ground to actually understand Luz?  I have my own opinion on that.  Please feel free to make up your own mind.

Is Nicola Wall a tw.. for not getting boots on ground?  I have my own opinion on that.  Please feel free to make up your own mind.

Here's another thought.  The nanny in question could not identify where the hill was. So ... why not?  After all, Luz is a very compact place.  From memory she had been out here for about a month.  Surely by then she should have known where the hill was in Luz?  That would have tied up everything nicely.  But she didn't, according to her statement.  Why not?  1) She would have been on foot (no car).  She would have had little familiarity with the 1-way system and no need to drive on either 25 de Abril or the road through the mound.  2) The one and only reason I can think of why she might have gone near there is to go to a small take-away.  It is the one that says Kebab/Pizza in Streetview, though it has been through at least 2 changes since 2007.  She would not have seen the mound even if she did go there.

So the nanny had no reason to know where the hill was, and unsurprisingly, she did not know where the hill was.

Nor did the PJ.

Nor did Redwood.

So, let's turn to Amaral.  He makes Luz 'closed' early in the evening of 3 May 2007.  This is important, as if Luz was closed, then obviously Smithman could wander at will.  My own take is that around 70 commercial establishments were open in Luz AT SMITHMAN TIME i.e. 10pm.  With this info, Smithman is totally innocent, or EXTREMELY lucky, or he has a very good knowledge of Luz.

If you really believe the PJ should have mapped Luz to an extent that they knew there was a crèche before those 8 families went home to wherever, try answering the following.

1) I believe that there was at least one other organisation offering sports holidays in Luz at the time.  I have not followed up on this as I can't see the relevance.  But is the OC crèche the only one that was operating that night, or should we be considering more?

2) Smithman hardly fits with the OC crèche, so we have more to explain than the OC crèche.

3) How about a test of Luz in another factor that is important?  How many commercial establishments in Luz ran large screen TVs on 3 May?  I am sifting through this because I believe it is relevant to cracking the telephone traffic that evening.  And that info has to go to OG before it shuts down because once it does, there is no way to access the data. Should the PJ have established this, when they got the phone data?

It is 8.5 years on and there is still a lot that needs to be mapped, so lets have a splash of reality rather that simplistic PJ-bashing.  No one has covered themselves in glory on this one.

My question is still how SY got its hands on a crèche register after 6 years, when said register is not in the PJ files.  I am having trouble believing this actually happened.
What's up, old man?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #93 on: November 12, 2015, 08:03:32 AM »
I don't keep making excuses for anyone, I simply prefer reality.

Why did Redwood dig up central Luz?  The bit he dug up is an integral part of the one-way system.  Both Rua 25 de Abril and the seemingly meaningless road across the mound are essential to traffic flow.  Presumably Redwood looked at Streetview and thought they were minor.

Why did Redwood not twig that 3 nannies in the search put Godfrey Barrington Norton and his Escort van on top of the mound that night.  Well, that would be because he wouldn't understand that there are 2 places in Luz that people camp. One is on the flat and can be ruled out as the nanny said the van was on a hill.  The hill people camp on (motorhomes, not tents) is the mound that SY dug up.

So Redwood did not understand the Luz traffic system or where folks camp.  Did this make him look a tw..?  To people who understand both, the answer is a definite yes.  So here is the unapologetic but realistic answer.  Redwood did not understand Luz therefore he could not reach this conclusion.

So, is Redwood a tw.. for not getting boots on ground to actually understand Luz?  I have my own opinion on that.  Please feel free to make up your own mind.

Is Nicola Wall a tw.. for not getting boots on ground?  I have my own opinion on that.  Please feel free to make up your own mind.

Here's another thought.  The nanny in question could not identify where the hill was. So ... why not?  After all, Luz is a very compact place.  From memory she had been out here for about a month.  Surely by then she should have known where the hill was in Luz?  That would have tied up everything nicely.  But she didn't, according to her statement.  Why not?  1) She would have been on foot (no car).  She would have had little familiarity with the 1-way system and no need to drive on either 25 de Abril or the road through the mound.  2) The one and only reason I can think of why she might have gone near there is to go to a small take-away.  It is the one that says Kebab/Pizza in Streetview, though it has been through at least 2 changes since 2007.  She would not have seen the mound even if she did go there.

So the nanny had no reason to know where the hill was, and unsurprisingly, she did not know where the hill was.

Nor did the PJ.

Nor did Redwood.

So, let's turn to Amaral.  He makes Luz 'closed' early in the evening of 3 May 2007.  This is important, as if Luz was closed, then obviously Smithman could wander at will.  My own take is that around 70 commercial establishments were open in Luz AT SMITHMAN TIME i.e. 10pm.  With this info, Smithman is totally innocent, or EXTREMELY lucky, or he has a very good knowledge of Luz.

If you really believe the PJ should have mapped Luz to an extent that they knew there was a crèche before those 8 families went home to wherever, try answering the following.

1) I believe that there was at least one other organisation offering sports holidays in Luz at the time.  I have not followed up on this as I can't see the relevance.  But is the OC crèche the only one that was operating that night, or should we be considering more?

2) Smithman hardly fits with the OC crèche, so we have more to explain than the OC crèche.

3) How about a test of Luz in another factor that is important?  How many commercial establishments in Luz ran large screen TVs on 3 May?  I am sifting through this because I believe it is relevant to cracking the telephone traffic that evening.  And that info has to go to OG before it shuts down because once it does, there is no way to access the data. Should the PJ have established this, when they got the phone data?

It is 8.5 years on and there is still a lot that needs to be mapped, so lets have a splash of reality rather that simplistic PJ-bashing.  No one has covered themselves in glory on this one.

My question is still how SY got its hands on a crèche register after 6 years, when said register is not in the PJ files.  I am having trouble believing this actually happened.
Where did I suggest that the PJ should have established who was using the night creche BEFORE the users went home?  Anytime during their botched investigation would have been good, that's - what? - 18 months?  As for your questions, don't you think the PJ should have found out the answers to them too?  And as for your repeated use of the T word in you questions concerning Redwood and Wall - well, I'm surprised at you, frankly.  I thought you were better than that!

Offline G-Unit

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #94 on: November 12, 2015, 09:33:43 AM »
Where did I suggest that the PJ should have established who was using the night creche BEFORE the users went home?  Anytime during their botched investigation would have been good, that's - what? - 18 months?  As for your questions, don't you think the PJ should have found out the answers to them too?  And as for your repeated use of the T word in you questions concerning Redwood and Wall - well, I'm surprised at you, frankly.  I thought you were better than that!

Leicestershire Police were busy in the Uk on the PJ's behalf. Their investigation included correspondence from Crimestoppers and house to house questionnaires. Either one of those could have included details of who used the night creche. What we don't know is how that information was dealt with. Did LP look at this evidence and highlight the ones they considered important or did they simply pass all of it to the PJ unread? Either way someone saying he collected his child from the creche wouldn't have been identified as being the same person  who was seen walking towards the creche.
https://leics.police.uk/media/uploads/library/file/op-task-publication-strategy.pdf
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #95 on: November 12, 2015, 10:27:09 AM »
Where did I suggest that the PJ should have established who was using the night creche BEFORE the users went home?  Anytime during their botched investigation would have been good, that's - what? - 18 months?  As for your questions, don't you think the PJ should have found out the answers to them too?  And as for your repeated use of the T word in you questions concerning Redwood and Wall - well, I'm surprised at you, frankly.  I thought you were better than that!
If OG hasn't, why bash the PJ?

By the way, where I come from, if you change the a in the T word to an i or an o it means exactly the same. It means 'not particularly intelligent' and nothing more.

'botched investigation'  Is OG's investigation botched because it did something 'dumber' than the PJ managed?
What's up, old man?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #96 on: November 12, 2015, 11:18:26 AM »
If OG hasn't, why bash the PJ?

By the way, where I come from, if you change the a in the T word to an i or an o it means exactly the same. It means 'not particularly intelligent' and nothing more.

'botched investigation'  Is OG's investigation botched because it did something 'dumber' than the PJ managed?
What do you mean "If OG hasn't"?  OG found and eliminated the key suspect!  Basically what you seem to be saying is: The PJ shouldn't have been expected to ask themselves or anyone else in PdL during the course of the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance what reasons a man could legitimately have for walking through PdL that night carrying a child, in order to eliminate him from the enquiry.  I disagree. 

PS: If you'd written 'twit' your word would have passed the word censor.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #97 on: November 12, 2015, 11:47:12 AM »
What do you mean "If OG hasn't"?  OG found and eliminated the key suspect!  Basically what you seem to be saying is: The PJ shouldn't have been expected to ask themselves or anyone else in PdL during the course of the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance what reasons a man could legitimately have for walking through PdL that night carrying a child, in order to eliminate him from the enquiry.  I disagree. 

PS: If you'd written 'twit' your word would have passed the word censor.
OG hasn't.  That is why the title of the thread is ...

Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?

So where was Smithman going?

Thank you for the PS.  It reminds me of the true story that the RSPBS had an auto censor that allowed the word 'hen' for a female bird, but it cut out the word for a male bird.

Ah, the good old days!
What's up, old man?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #98 on: November 12, 2015, 11:49:01 AM »
OG hasn't.  That is why the title of the thread is ...

Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?

So where was Smithman going?

Thank you for the PS.  It reminds me of the true story that the RSPBS had an auto censor that allowed the word 'hen' for a female bird, but it cut out the word for a male bird.

Ah, the good old days!
So, is it your opinion that OG have failed to identify Tannerman?  This thread has nothing to do with Smithman, so let's keep on topic.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #99 on: November 12, 2015, 12:03:14 PM »
What do you mean "If OG hasn't"?  OG found and eliminated the key suspect!  Basically what you seem to be saying is: The PJ shouldn't have been expected to ask themselves or anyone else in PdL during the course of the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance what reasons a man could legitimately have for walking through PdL that night carrying a child, in order to eliminate him from the enquiry.  I disagree. 

PS: If you'd written 'twit' your word would have passed the word censor.

Really?
Given the ruling document in the case is the archiving process, where a crime could not be identified, it is a bit of a nonsense to suggest there could have been a key suspect for an unidentified crime.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #100 on: November 12, 2015, 12:10:20 PM »
Really?
Given the ruling document in the case is the archiving process, where a crime could not be identified, it is a bit of a nonsense to suggest there could have been a key suspect for an unidentified crime.

it isn't nonsense...its a key suspect for a suspected crime

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #101 on: November 12, 2015, 12:13:03 PM »
Really?
Given the ruling document in the case is the archiving process, where a crime could not be identified, it is a bit of a nonsense to suggest there could have been a key suspect for an unidentified crime.
So Tannerman was not a key suspect. OK my mistake.  What was he then?  Smithman not a key suspect either then I guess.

Offline John

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #102 on: November 12, 2015, 12:30:38 PM »
Another way of looking at this whole mystery is to ask the question, what are the chances of two men fitting the same description clad in similar clothing carrying a barefoot young child also similarly clad, in the exact same way at exactly 9.15pm on 3rd May 2007? 

There was a similar situation in the Luke Mitchell murder of Jodi Jones case where two identically dressed youths were claimed to have occupied the same space at exactly the same time on an almost deserted road. Not likely imo.

DCI Redwood was of the opinion that Tanner did not see an abductor which if true means that Jane Tanner was mistaken about the frilly bottoms.

« Last Edit: November 12, 2015, 12:37:41 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline John

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #103 on: November 12, 2015, 12:43:01 PM »
I would like to hear more about this notion that Andy Redwood should somehow be answerable to  his critics on the internet - John?  Would you care to shed more light on your earlier comments on this matter please?

It's very simple, Mr Redwood should have explained why his crècheman was walking in the wrong direction had he been returning from the night crèche.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Anna

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #104 on: November 12, 2015, 12:51:16 PM »
Another way of looking at this whole mystery is to ask the question, what are the chances of two men fitting the same description clad in similar clothing carrying a barefoot young child also similarly clad, in the exact same way at exactly 9.15pm on 3rd May 2007? 

There was a similar situation in the Luke Mitchell murder of Jodi Jones case where two identically dressed youths were claimed to have occupied the same space at exactly the same time on an almost deserted road. Not likely imo.

DCI Redwood was of the opinion that Tanner did not see an abductor which if true means that Jane Tanner was mistaken about the frilly bottoms.

Who said that he wore exactly the same clothes (as many tourists, I must add) or that it was at exactly 9.15?

I am not sure what times the creche operated at night, but it seems a bit early to be collecting a child, unless he was taking her there of course.

We have no statement from Crecheman .but apparently as parents of one of the 11 children in the creche that night, those parents thought that it was possibly them. That is according to the crime watch video already posted on here.

How could he remember exactly what he and the child was wearing that night?

Please correct me if I remembered anything  incorrectly.
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato