Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[John]

Hilary Clinton used the term "miss speaking" when caught out.
Such an elegant lady like term for barefaced lying.

     ...but don't you know Alice, little white lies don't count.

As an aside, has anyone ever trained as a lawyer because there must be a seminar dedicated to lying since lawyers are expert at it.

[xtina]

So Charlotte Pennington was making it all up when she said she read stories to Madeleine on May 3rd?

Or that Emma Wilding was lying when she claimed to have said Hello! to Gerry as he dropped Madeleine off at the creche that morning?

Charlotte Pennington...............is that the one who said ...maddie ...introduced herself as maddy ....when the mccs declared ...maddie insisted on being called madeleine...she hated maddy...so who was right there

[Brietta]

The abduction......... %£5&%....is that it ...the mccs said so

How do you know what SY are doing ....and don't give they are not suspects ....PJ said the same ....and look what happened there

Can the mccs prove ....maddie was there after the sunday did anyone see her ....or was she mistook for Elle .....

why does k mcc prefer to be called Healy [all her personal stuff in that name]...apparently ..because that is who she is ....yet signed the creche records k mcc apart from the last one

why was maddie in the creche ....when they were all on the beach...

the mccs seemed to avoid group meetings .apart from the first day ...

the nannie kat baker ....was known to them.......the only one who suggests she saw maddie after the sunday

abduction 0%...proof .

Ah ha ... is that what is in the video??

The great ... who saw Madeleine after Sunday conspiracy???  Well they do say that 'truth is stranger than fiction'.

C'mon ... c'mon ... don't keep it to yourself.  How does he think ... they ... dunnit?

All very convenient for those actually responsible for stealing a little girl from her bed ... more PR than money could buy ... who says crime doesn't pay?
However I hope they have been feeling a bit more insecure of late ... PR will only go so far ... particularly with two law enforcement agencies looking closely at the available evidence.

[ferryman]

Charlotte Pennington...............is that the one who said ...maddie ...introduced herself as maddy ....when the mccs declared ...maddie insisted on being called madeleine...she hated maddy...so who was right there

Cecilia Paula Dias Firmino do Carmo

Date/Time: 2007/05/06 22H00


Occupation: Public Relations

Place of Work: Millenium restaurant, OC.

She confirms that she is an employee of the OC, having signed a seven month contract in April this year. She worked in the resort last year, with the same functions and for the same period of time.

She says that her job is to receive guests at the entrance to the Millenium restaurant and check whether they have to pay for breakfast or whether this is included in their package. She works from 07.00 to 12.00 from Tuesdays to Saturdays. She says that she only attends to guests at breakfast time except on Wednesdays when there is Barbecue Night at the restaurant and when she welcomes guests for dinner, working from 18.00 to 22.00.

When asked, she says that due to her work she knows most of the guests given that most of them visit the Millenium as it is the only restaurant that serves breakfast.

When asked, she says that she knows the parents, the siblings and Madeleine. She received them for breakfast on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, she does not know whether they went for breakfast on Sunday or Monday, as these were her days off.

She says that breakfast was served between 08.00 and 10.00 and that the McCanns would arrive between 08.00 and 09.00.

She says that the McCanns appeared to be a normal family and that the relation between the members of the family was very good. Madeleine appeared to be very attached to her father and was always clinging on to him. Given her public relations function she was always very nice to the guests and would get involved with the children, saying that Madeleine was very shy and did not respond to her. She says that the only contact she had with guests was at the entrance to the Millenium restaurant, she did not have a view of the tables or the Buffet area.

She heard about the disappearance on Friday morning 4th May from a colleague called Alice.

The resort is very calm, the witness only knows of a few minor thefts and is very surprised at the news. She has no information that could help locate Madeleine.

[stephen25000]

Ah ha ... is that what is in the video??

The great ... who saw Madeleine after Sunday conspiracy???  Well they do say that 'truth is stranger than fiction'.

C'mon ... c'mon ... don't keep it to yourself.  How does he think ... they ... dunnit?

All very convenient for those actually responsible for stealing a little girl from her bed ... more PR than money could buy ... who says crime doesn't pay?
However I hope they have been feeling a bit more insecure of late ... PR will only go so far ... particularly with two law enforcement agencies looking closely at the available evidence.

.............and 2 law enforcement agencies with nothing to show for all the 'effort' and money spent.

[ferryman]

.............and 2 law enforcement agencies with nothing to show for all the 'effort' and money spent.

Grime no longer works for the police, while Harrison does, but Australian police ....

Neither have anything to show for their efforts on Madeleine's disappearance.

And Grime was free lance in PdL.

[Brietta]

That comment again reinforces the notion that you don't read other peoples comments. Try reading what I have typed about the videos.

As to SY and the Portuguese, can you tell me what they have achieved in their 'investigations' ?

Since sooner or later you will have to dig your head out of the sand on this.

Oh I read them ... some of yours I know off by heart you repeat yourself so often. 

However things may have changed and your curiosity may have got the better of you since way back then.  Mine still isn't at that stage of must knowing what was said ...as far as I can tell, it wasn't a lot and most of it flying in the face of common sense and if the title is anything to go by, decency.

[Alice Purjorick]

    ...but don't you know Alice, little white lies don't count.

As an aside, has anyone ever trained as a lawyer because there must be a seminar dedicated to lying since lawyers are expert at it.

We called it "learning how to pass the red face test".

[stephen25000]

Grime no longer works for the police, while Harrison does, but Australian police ....

Neither have anything to show for their efforts on Madeleine's disappearance.

And Grime was free lance in PdL.

I wasn't talking about them. %&5%£

[stephen25000]

Oh I read them ... some of yours I know off by heart you repeat yourself so often. 

However things may have changed and your curiosity may have got the better of you since way back then.  Mine still isn't at that stage of must knowing what was said ...as far as I can tell, it wasn't a lot and most of it flying in the face of common sense and if the title is anything to go by, decency.

Well, as to repetition, you may change your words and use a thesaurus, but the content remains the same.

As to decency, well when it comes to ignoring and excusing the behaviour of a certain two parents, some have yet to learn  and express that quality.

[Alfred R Jones]

    ...but don't you know Alice, little white lies don't count.

As an aside, has anyone ever trained as a lawyer because there must be a seminar dedicated to lying since lawyers are expert at it.

you seem to be supporting the view that the McCanns are liars, is that correct?

[Carana]

Cecilia appears to have been one of the mistaken ones, FM, as the McCanns only ever went there for breakfast on the first day.

However, there are numerous others.

[blonk]

My question is still the same. How many people would have had to have been complicit?

Answering instead of xtina once again.

Suppose, hypothetically, something very serious happened to a 3-year-old girl, let's call her 'Mary', late on the second day of a holiday. Suppose that in some way it was the fault, or responsibility, of her parents.

Suppose also that her parents came on holiday with three other couples and their infant children.

Suppose once more that no-one else on that holiday knew Mary before the holiday, with the exception of Mary's crèche nanny, who just happened to be Facebook Friends with the daughter of Mary's godfather.

All it would then need, to cover up her disappearance for say three or four days, would be the co-operation of the three other couples - and for the creche nanny to allow the parents to add Mary to the crèche records, and then, finally, to provide some confirmation by way of a statement verifying that Mary had really been there on those later days, when she actually wasn't.

No-one else would be needed.             

[Brietta]

Answering instead of xtina once again.

Suppose, hypothetically, something very serious happened to a 3-year-old girl, let's call her 'Mary', late on the second day of a holiday. Suppose that in some way it was the fault, or responsibility, of her parents.

Suppose also that her parents came on holiday with three other couples and their infant children.

Suppose once more that no-one else on that holiday knew Mary before the holiday, with the exception of Mary's crèche nanny, who just happened to be Facebook Friends with the daughter of Mary's godfather.

All it would then need, to cover up her disappearance for say three or four days, would be the co-operation of the three other couples - and for the creche nanny to allow the parents to add Mary to the crèche records, and then, finally, to provide some confirmation by way of a statement verifying that Mary had really been there on those later days, when she actually wasn't.

No-one else would be needed.             

                                     Did Richard Hall suggest that hypothesis in his video?

[lordpookles]

Apart from all the parents etc at the creche who may have seen this Maddie imposter as well or a whole host of other possible witnesses and would have pointed that out when the pics were released a few weeks later. Sorry, but that is blonkers.