Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[xtina]

This thread is about the contents of Richard Hall's video - which is being heralded  and promoted  by some as a really well researched piece of work by the author.   That obviously isn't the case as made apparent from the start by his lack of understanding of the dog alerts.

How many times do we see posts all over the place claiming that 'someone died in 5A'

His claim that the dogs detected the past presence of a human corpse is false and perpetuates that myth.

Your excuse that other people have made 'misleading' statements is not relevant to this thread IMO.

His claim that the dogs detected the past presence of a human corpse is false and perpetuates that myth.


well people can decide for themselves ....can't they ...the links are there for all to see.....on page one of this thread...

[G-Unit]

This thread is about the contents of Richard Hall's video - which is being heralded  and promoted  by some as a really well researched piece of work by the author.   That obviously isn't the case as made apparent from the start by his lack of understanding of the dog alerts.

How many times do we see posts all over the place claiming that 'someone died in 5A'

His claim that the dogs detected the past presence of a human corpse is false and perpetuates that myth.

Your excuse that other people have made 'misleading' statements is not relevant to this thread IMO.

It's not an excuse, it's a factual list of misleading statements in answer to your accusation that RH is misleading the British public. Misleading the British public is an enduring feature of this case. Everyone's opinions are based on belief rather than facts. At least RH's belief about the dog alerts hasn't yet been shown to be wrong, unlike the misleading examples I quoted.

[ferryman]

Curious that a thread running to 64 pages was killed stone dead (as a debate) by posts 2 and 4 (on page one).

But still it rumbles on ....

[xtina]

Curious that a thread running to 64 pages was killed stone dead (as a debate) by posts 2 and 4 (on page one).

But still it rumbles on ....

yes cos lets face it .....the crime of what happened to maddie is unknown



soooooo........either some one took maddie .or they didn't ....

i cant believe ....the fact ...a lot on here does not seem interested in what did happen to maddie... if she has not been taken...of which there is no proof she was ....is there.....and no thread she was is rumbling on is there ....because its just the mccs say so ....that is wearing very thin

thank god for R H ...and others ...who i don't have to mention as it is RH thread...who are concerned of what happened to that little girl maddie ...who was not given a chance to live her life ...because of the actions of her parents....and not afraid to speak out......



seems ...very quiet also ...on the mcc front ....C M ...C R .....wonder if the mccs are now left to fend for themselves ....it would have been a different story if they had been in the beginning ...

[jassi]

yes cos lets face it .....the crime of what happened to maddie is unknown



soooooo........either some one took maddie .or they didn't ....

i cant believe ....the fact ...a lot on here does not seem interested in what did happen to maddie... if she has not been taken...of which there is no proof she was ....is there.....and no thread she was is rumbling on is there ....because its just the mccs say so ....that is wearing very thin

thank god for R H ...and others ...who i don't have to mention as it is RH thread...who are concerned of what happened to that little girl maddie ...who was not given a chance to live her life ...because of the actions of her parents....and not afraid to speak out......



seems ...very quiet also ...on the mcc front ....C M ...C R .....wonder if the mccs are now left to fend for themselves ....it would have been a different story if they had been in the beginning ...

So true. Many seem more interested in pushing the view that it had nothing to do with the McCanns than anuthing else.

[xtina]

So true. Many seem more interested in pushing the view that it had nothing to do with the McCanns than anuthing else.

Ill agree with that jassi

[ferryman]

64 pages of manufactured insinuation against Kate, Gerry and their friends is, I'm afraid, just about the mark of this board ....

Correction .... 67 pages ....

[xtina]

64 pages of manufactured insinuation against Kate, Gerry and their friends is, I'm afraid, just about the mark of this board ....

Correction .... 67 pages ....

aw don't worry yourself.fman ......I'm sure the mccs and c/o wont be reading it

if they are ....they can feel free to take it up with R H

[Mr Gray]

It's not an excuse, it's a factual list of misleading statements in answer to your accusation that RH is misleading the British public. Misleading the British public is an enduring feature of this case. Everyone's opinions are based on belief rather than facts. At least RH's belief about the dog alerts hasn't yet been shown to be wrong, unlike the misleading examples I quoted.

Your statements are not factual...hall has told a bare faced untruth...a phrase he likes to use re the mccanns ...when he says the dogs detected cadaver and you are trying to justify the telling of untruths.

[xtina]

what like when he denied having last photo....then decided to produce it three weeks later .....

the photo probably taken on the Sunday..........there wasn't any more after that was there ....apart from them taking a pic of maddies pyjamas

[stephen25000]

How many of the McCann supporters have watched the current set of material from Mr. Hall ?

[Mr Gray]

How many of the McCann supporters have watched the current set of material from Mr. Hall ?

Why should I want to read it when his first sentence in promoting it is a "bare faced untruth"..I've seen enough of his backround to understand he is not a reliable source...Have you read the Koran


I haven't read any of Ickes's books either

[misty]

How many of the McCann supporters have watched the current set of material from Mr. Hall ?

I watched all 1, 2 , 4 & part of number 3.
Mindnumbing.
Do I qualify for a medal or something?

[Jean-Pierre]

How many of the McCann supporters have watched the current set of material from Mr. Hall ?

For my sins, I have. 

[jassi]

I watched all 1, 2 , 4 & part of number 3.
Mindnumbing.
Do I qualify for a medal or something?

No medal, but maybe a free high quality wristband or two.