Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[John]

How many of the McCann supporters have watched the current set of material from Mr. Hall ?

I managed to view Part I only so far but I think the title is a bit unfortunate.  Mr Hall should not be promoting his opinion as fact simply to created some sensationalism.  Only those involved in her disappearance, if such people exist, know if she is alive or dead?

[Eleanor]

Can we please cut the word, "Lies?"

Richard Hall could well be mistaken.

[stephen25000]

For my sins, I have.

Well I managed about 5 minutes

[John]

Can we please cut the word, "Lies?"

Richard Hall could well be mistaken.

Absolutely, far too many people are claiming to know the truth in this case but the only real truth is that nobody except the perp(s) know.

[Brietta]

Well I managed about 5 minutes

A much better effort than mine ... but I have cheated and watched two of three fifteen minutes edits of what someone who has sat through it thinks are the salient points of the videos ... and imo if that is it, we haven't missed a great deal at all and we've had four extra hours of life (three and a half in my case, and I will watch the other fifteen minutes later) with which to do something more productive.

[Alice Purjorick]

How many of the McCann supporters have watched the current set of material from Mr. Hall ?

Like Mr Wright in court about "that book" . They don't have to watch/read to know it is all wrong!
I watched two "reels" imho he cocked it up in the first reel by making a gross assumption, then skating very carefully round the evidence or lack of it to sustain his theory. I doubt the supporters read it otherwise they would have been all over it like a cheap suit and we would not be on page 69 or whatever............
all imho of course.

[xtina]

I managed to view Part I only so far but I think the title is a bit unfortunate.  Mr Hall should not be promoting his opinion as fact simply to created some sensationalism.  Only those involved in her disappearance, if such people exist, know if she is alive or dead?

i don't think he putting his opinion ...as fact ...R H uses the word suggest ...what could have happened ...ot that all we know about ...is not as credable ..as it seems..


It was about the reported disappearance of Madeleine McCann. It was a response to a documentary film by Richard D. Hall titled: “When Madeleine Died?” In that film, Hall - who earlier, in August 2014, nailed his colours to the mast by suggesting that Madeleine’s abduction was a hoax,

[G-Unit]

Your statements are not factual...hall has told a bare faced untruth...a phrase he likes to use re the mccanns ...when he says the dogs detected cadaver and you are trying to justify the telling of untruths.

Not factual? I can provide cites for all of them and I can provide cites to show they were all untrue.

No-one knows whether the dog (Eddie, Keela detected only blood) detected cadaver, so no-one can prove RH is wrong.

[Jean-Pierre]

Not factual? I can provide cites for all of them and I can provide cites to show they were all untrue.

No-one knows whether the dog (Eddie, Keela detected only blood) detected cadaver, so no-one can prove RH is wrong.

That is what all "conspiracy theorists" rely on.

Hall has form - 9/11, 7/7, UFOs, etc etc. 

I actually thought you were a bit more savvy than that, G-Unit.   

[ferryman]

Absolutely, far too many people are claiming to know the truth in this case but the only real truth is that nobody except the perp(s) know.

Some truths are plain without need of proof.

The innocence of the McCanns is one.

[jassi]

Some truths are plain without need of proof.

The innocence of the McCanns is one.

HaHa.  Say it a million times and people still won't believe you.

[stephen25000]

Some truths are plain without need of proof.

The innocence of the McCanns is one.

Crime if any,  unknown.

[ferryman]

HaHa.  Say it a million times and people still won't believe you.

There is a question of belief and there is a question of fact.

Some people refuse to believe facts.

Nothing to be done about that ....

[Eleanor]

Some truths are plain without need of proof.

The innocence of the McCanns is one.

I agree.  Especially after nine years.

[ferryman]

Crime if any,  unknown.

The shelved enquiry discounted woke and wandered and in all events no trace of Madeleine has been found.

So emphatically a crime.

And the shelved enquiry established the innocence of the McCanns ....