Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[stephen25000]

The title of the thread (and of Hall's video), in its own right, libels Kate and Gerry.

There is no evidence (at least in the public domain) that Madeleine is dead.

Far from all comment (on this thread) will be libel.

But much of it will be.

And the film itself (displayed on this board for all to watch) certainly is.

Wrong on that.

BHH said it is a murder investigation.

[faithlilly]

The title of the thread (and of Hall's video), in its own right, libels Kate and Gerry.

There is no evidence (at least in the public domain) that Madeleine is dead.

Far from all comment (on this thread) will be libel.

But much of it will be.

And the film itself (displayed on this board for all to watch) certainly is.

Do you think anyone really cares ferryman ?

[Eleanor]

The title of the thread (and of Hall's video), in its own right, libels Kate and Gerry.

There is no evidence (at least in the public domain) that Madeleine is dead.

Far from all comment (on this thread) will be libel.

But much of it will be.

And the film itself (displayed on this board for all to watch) certainly is.

I think you've all done a sterling job at demolishing it.  Supporters and Sceptics alike.

[ferryman]

Wrong on that.

BHH said it is a murder investigation.

And?

[G-Unit]

Like it or not opinion is divided on this case. Rather than censoring different theories it's better to examine them critically and point out any mistakes imo. Every theory proposed in this case should be critically examined, it all serves to educate people as to what can and cannot be stated as fact.

[ferryman]

Do you think anyone really cares ferryman ?

Some do.

(More's the pity) others don't ....

[sadie]

The title of the thread (and of Hall's video), in its own right, libels Kate and Gerry.

There is no evidence (at least in the public domain) that Madeleine is dead.

Far from all comment (on this thread) will be libel.

But much of it will be.

And the film itself (displayed on this board for all to watch) certainly is.

Further more, it was probably entered onto thuis forum as subject to discuss, not for the discussion itself, but to advertise and promote it to people that would not normally have bothered with it

It is a PROMOTION SCAM folks !

And we by discussing it ...  are further promoting what imo and in the opinion of others is Libel ... because people like reading a good argument.


If there is any chance this is libel, and it is thought that there is, it should NOT be screened on this forum
.
 The thread should be wiped in its entirity... immediately.



Of course the forum is pretty safe from libel because it is run from another country ... were you all aware of that?

[slartibartfast]

I think you've all done a sterling job at demolishing it.  Supporters and Sceptics alike.

Not really many supporters at all.

"When you tear out a man's tongue, you are not proving him a liar, you're only telling the world that you fear what he might say."

[ferryman]

The opening post (of this thread) repeats libel in the video and makes the poster herself guilty of libel.

[stephen25000]

And?

Read the post I replied to.

[ferryman]

Not really many supporters at all.

"When you tear out a man's tongue, you are not proving him a liar, you're only telling the world that you fear what he might say."

At least metaphorically, that's what you do to me when you sweep my posts about Martin Grime off the board.

[slartibartfast]

At least metaphorically, that's what you do to me when you sweep my posts about Martin Grime off the board.

Don't libel and they will stay.

[ferryman]

Read the post I replied to.

They are considering the possibility that Madeleine might be dead (unsurprisingly).

And there is also a (slimmer) possibility that Madeleine might be alive.

Your point is?

[ferryman]

Don't libel and they will stay.

I have never libelled and my posts have frequently not stayed.

[stephen25000]

They are considering the possibility that Madeleine might be dead (unsurprisingly).

And there is also a (slimmer) possibility that Madeleine might be alive.

Your point is?

It is a murder inquiry.

There has been no trace of Madeleine since she disappeared.

So your point is ?