Wandering Off Topic

[Robittybob1]

Was Pegasus saying that the apartment 5A may not have been searched sufficiently enough?  I can only imagine what that means.

[misty]

Was Pegasus saying that the apartment 5A may not have been searched sufficiently enough?  I can only imagine what that means.

Yes. There have been many discussions about this. Only one GNR officer searched the premises on the night of 3rd. There was no evidence in the statements showing exactly where various people searched within the apartment & its immediate boundary.
Given that there have been more than a couple of UK cases in recent years relating to children who have been reported missing & subsequently found to have been in the home all along, this latest case shows that UK police still don't seem to have learned lessons & ensured the home is properly searched before additional resources are mobilised.

[Robittybob1]

Yes. There have been many discussions about this. Only one GNR officer searched the premises on the night of 3rd. There was no evidence in the statements showing exactly where various people searched within the apartment & its immediate boundary.
Given that there have been more than a couple of UK cases in recent years relating to children who have been reported missing & subsequently found to have been in the home all along, this latest case shows that UK police still don't seem to have learned lessons & ensured the home is properly searched before additional resources are mobilised.

That doesn't make much sense either does it if you combine Pegasus and and Amaral's theory together. 
The McCann's find MM deceased, and hide her within the apartment, raise the alarm and let everyone else check to see if they can find her.  That would be one of the weirdest crime scenarios I've ever heard.

[misty]

That doesn't make much sense either does it if you combine Pegasus and and Amaral's theory together. 
The McCann's find MM deceased, and hide her within the apartment, raise the alarm and let everyone else check to see if they can find her.  That would be one of the weirdest crime scenarios I've ever heard.

The McCanns don't have to find Madeleine deceased. She may have hidden after being frightened by someone opening her bedroom shutters & window. An incomplete search may have failed to find her before everyone vacated the apartment. That doesn't explain what happened next, though.

In the case of Josh yesterday, it flies in the face of logic that a 9 year old should remain hidden if people are shouting his name & searching, yet it happened. I don't yet know if he was just asleep or deliberately hiding.

[Robittybob1]

The McCanns don't have to find Madeleine deceased. She may have hidden after being frightened by someone opening her bedroom shutters & window. An incomplete search may have failed to find her before everyone vacated the apartment. That doesn't explain what happened next, though.

In the case of Josh yesterday, it flies in the face of logic that a 9 year old should remain hidden if people are shouting his name & searching, yet it happened. I don't yet know if he was just asleep or deliberately hiding.

Seems unlikely considering the number of people checking for Madeleine within the apartment.

[pathfinder73]

Danny Collins LOL.



Ten years on, Spanish-based investigative journalist Danny Collins has returned to Praia da Luz to re-examine the case. This is the story of what happened on that terrible night and what has followed since, piecing together the clues and false leads from the original investigation with the Metropolitan Police's efforts in recent years to find Madeleine and solve one of the most talked-about cases of the century.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/d/Books/Vanished-Disappearance-Madeline-McCann-Danny-Collins/1786062720

[G-Unit]

Danny Collins LOL.



Ten years on, Spanish-based investigative journalist Danny Collins has returned to Praia da Luz to re-examine the case. This is the story of what happened on that terrible night and what has followed since, piecing together the clues and false leads from the original investigation with the Metropolitan Police's efforts in recent years to find Madeleine and solve one of the most talked-about cases of the century.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/d/Books/Vanished-Disappearance-Madeline-McCann-Danny-Collins/1786062720

Merrily making up the story as he goes along, I see. Unlikely to contain anything of interest therefore.

[jassi]

Another work of fiction. Perhaps McCanns will attempt to sue him for telling lies about them.

[Erngath]

Merrily making up the story as he goes along, I see. Unlikely to contain anything of interest therefore.

" Merrily making up the story as he goes along", much the same as Amaral then.

[G-Unit]

" Merrily making up the story as he goes along", much the same as Amaral then.

Amaral's facts are in the files, Collins' facts are wrong.

[Robittybob1]

Amaral's facts are in the files, Collins' facts are wrong.

What I worry about is that Amaral made sure his "facts" were in the file before he resigned.  He set up "facts" without any factual basis in other words.

[Mr Gray]

Amaral's facts are in the files, Collins' facts are wrong.

many of amarals facts are wrong too

[barrier]

many of amarals facts are wrong too

To this day,SY nor the counterparts in the PJ have come with anything different.

[Mr Gray]

To this day,SY nor the counterparts in the PJ have come with anything different.

some of amarals facts are wrong....such as there are no confirmed alerts to cadaver odour and no dna match to maddie...there is no evidence of cadaver in the apartment...

[G-Unit]

many of amarals facts are wrong too

Amaral repeats what the investigation found and thought. Collins hasn't even checked the very simple easy to verify whereabouts of the McCanns on 3rd May. We know for sure they were not at the Paraiso that evening. There's no excuse for such a lack of research.