Thank you.
Perhaps I am being a bit slow but I fail to see how the appeal court could be unaware of such a requirement, given it is enshrined in the Portuguese constitution and the original verdict boiled down to the McCanns right to a good name v Amaral's right to free speech. The appeal court could hardly have not taken this into account, could it?
I'm not aware how the SC works, but again it seems they can hardly ignore the good name v free speech battle. If the appeal court judgement gets overturned, I would anticipate the SC concluding that good name triumphs. If not, then either free speech triumphs or the SC does not consider the McCanns application has merit, so does not hear the case.
And if the SC does not overturn the judgement, I fail to see why there would be any significant chance of seeing McCanns v Portugal at the ECHR.
Key point about free-speech, though, is that it must be exercised
responsibly.
Amaral's exercise of
'speech' (obviously written, rather than spoken), adjudged, in the first-instance,
not to have been exercised responsibly; in the
second instance, to have
been so, denigrated, traduced and defamed. There was scarcely a word of truth in any of it.
Careful comparison of the files with Amaral's book confirms that so.
Why should Amaral be allowed to trounce reputation, and particularly harm the search for a missing little girl in that way, and especially why in the name of
free speech?
That is simply not the way a
democratic state (that upholds
democratic principles) should function.
Of course, the balance is that a democratic state
should uphold free speech; but that is freedom
exercised with responsibility, and with intent to inform, rather than to mislead, particularly in a way that results in harm rather than good.I'm afraid Amaral's book does just what the (last) part of my previous sentence says.