Author Topic: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?  (Read 120781 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #210 on: April 25, 2016, 04:30:38 PM »
You may have missed some posts
The appeal to the ECHR would be on the grounds of the right to a good name
It is mentioned in art 10 but art 8 has been used in other cases
I'm sure Ms Duarte knows what she is talking about
Thank you.

Perhaps I am being a bit slow but I fail to see how the appeal court could be unaware of such a requirement, given it is enshrined in the Portuguese constitution and the original verdict boiled down to the McCanns right to a good name v Amaral's right to free speech.  The appeal court could hardly have not taken this into account, could it?

I'm not aware how the SC works, but again it seems they can hardly ignore the good name v free speech battle.  If the appeal court judgement gets overturned, I would anticipate the SC concluding that good name triumphs.  If not, then either free speech triumphs or the SC does not consider the McCanns application has merit, so does not hear the case.

And if the SC does not overturn the judgement, I fail to see why there would be any significant chance of seeing McCanns v Portugal at the ECHR.
What's up, old man?

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #211 on: April 25, 2016, 04:38:03 PM »
MOD NOTE

Folks, you have had gentle encouragement and heavy duty warnings re the need for civility.

Please note, whatever behaviour occurred after the original report re goading etc. is irrelevant.  You have had extremely clear messages that it will not be tolerated now.

Thank you.
« Last Edit: April 25, 2016, 05:26:29 PM by ShiningInLuz »
What's up, old man?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #212 on: April 25, 2016, 04:45:32 PM »
Thank you.

Perhaps I am being a bit slow but I fail to see how the appeal court could be unaware of such a requirement, given it is enshrined in the Portuguese constitution and the original verdict boiled down to the McCanns right to a good name v Amaral's right to free speech.  The appeal court could hardly have not taken this into account, could it?

I'm not aware how the SC works, but again it seems they can hardly ignore the good name v free speech battle.  If the appeal court judgement gets overturned, I would anticipate the SC concluding that good name triumphs.  If not, then either free speech triumphs or the SC does not consider the McCanns application has merit, so does not hear the case.

And if the SC does not overturn the judgement, I fail to see why there would be any significant chance of seeing McCanns v Portugal at the ECHR.

the SC may not ignore the right of the mccanns to a good name but they may make a judgement that ...in the eyes of the McCanns unfairly favours amaral. Could it be possible that the law would favour they police and the establishment...who knows. The McCanns then have the opportunity to apply for a judgement from thr ECHR on this point.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #213 on: April 25, 2016, 04:50:17 PM »
Thank you.

Perhaps I am being a bit slow but I fail to see how the appeal court could be unaware of such a requirement, given it is enshrined in the Portuguese constitution and the original verdict boiled down to the McCanns right to a good name v Amaral's right to free speech.  The appeal court could hardly have not taken this into account, could it?

I'm not aware how the SC works, but again it seems they can hardly ignore the good name v free speech battle.  If the appeal court judgement gets overturned, I would anticipate the SC concluding that good name triumphs.  If not, then either free speech triumphs or the SC does not consider the McCanns application has merit, so does not hear the case.

And if the SC does not overturn the judgement, I fail to see why there would be any significant chance of seeing McCanns v Portugal at the ECHR.

You recently posted....


And bodies that are considered pillars of the state get special protection, including the police.  You'ld have a tough time writing a bestseller about mistreatment by the police.


that seems a little unfair towards the man in the street ...is this why amaral's rights are being respected

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #214 on: April 25, 2016, 05:06:47 PM »
Thank you.

Perhaps I am being a bit slow but I fail to see how the appeal court could be unaware of such a requirement, given it is enshrined in the Portuguese constitution and the original verdict boiled down to the McCanns right to a good name v Amaral's right to free speech.  The appeal court could hardly have not taken this into account, could it?

I'm not aware how the SC works, but again it seems they can hardly ignore the good name v free speech battle.  If the appeal court judgement gets overturned, I would anticipate the SC concluding that good name triumphs.  If not, then either free speech triumphs or the SC does not consider the McCanns application has merit, so does not hear the case.

And if the SC does not overturn the judgement, I fail to see why there would be any significant chance of seeing McCanns v Portugal at the ECHR.

If the Portuguese Supreme Court restores the (commendable) sanity and common sense bestowed upon the Portuguese judiciary by the decision of the first-instance court, we (the McCanns!) need not even contemplate the European Court of Human Rights.

But if the Supreme Court  ignores both  its own reputation and that of the whole Portuguese judiciary, then I'm not sure there's any other recourse.
« Last Edit: April 25, 2016, 05:23:54 PM by ferryman »

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #215 on: April 25, 2016, 05:20:51 PM »
If the Portuguese Supreme Court restores the (commendable) sanity and common sense bestowed upon the Portuguese judiciary by the decision of the first-instance court, we (the McCanns!) need not even contemplate the European Court of Human Rights.

But if the Supreme Court ignores both ignores both its own reputation and of the whole Portuguese judiciary, then I'm not sure there's any other recourse.

The judgement last week abides by the dictates of Portuguese Law.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #216 on: April 25, 2016, 05:23:52 PM »
You recently posted....


And bodies that are considered pillars of the state get special protection, including the police.  You'ld have a tough time writing a bestseller about mistreatment by the police.


that seems a little unfair towards the man in the street ...is this why amaral's rights are being respected
I consider it to be old-fashioned, rather like the UK maybe 30 or 40 years ago.  As in - policemen never lie - you can trust Dr Shipman, cos he's a doctor - and the teacher was entitled to give you a clip round the ear, you must have been naughty.

Perhaps the (privileged) judges thought an ex-policeman deserved somewhat privileged treatment, but I very much doubt it.  Amaral's status as a doctor might or might not be an influence, but again I doubt it.  After all, the McCanns were both doctors, entitled to that respect.
What's up, old man?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #217 on: April 25, 2016, 05:39:35 PM »
Thank you.

Perhaps I am being a bit slow but I fail to see how the appeal court could be unaware of such a requirement, given it is enshrined in the Portuguese constitution and the original verdict boiled down to the McCanns right to a good name v Amaral's right to free speech.  The appeal court could hardly have not taken this into account, could it?

I'm not aware how the SC works, but again it seems they can hardly ignore the good name v free speech battle.  If the appeal court judgement gets overturned, I would anticipate the SC concluding that good name triumphs.  If not, then either free speech triumphs or the SC does not consider the McCanns application has merit, so does not hear the case.

And if the SC does not overturn the judgement, I fail to see why there would be any significant chance of seeing McCanns v Portugal at the ECHR.

Key point about free-speech, though, is that it must be exercised responsibly.

Amaral's exercise of 'speech' (obviously written, rather than spoken), adjudged, in the first-instance, not to have been exercised responsibly; in the second instance, to have been so, denigrated, traduced and defamed.  There was scarcely a word of truth in any of it.

Careful comparison of the files with Amaral's book confirms that so.

Why should Amaral be allowed to trounce reputation, and particularly harm the search for a missing little girl in that way, and especially why in the name of free speech?

That is simply not the way a democratic state (that upholds democratic principles) should function.

Of course, the balance is that a democratic state should uphold free speech; but that is freedom exercised with responsibility, and with intent to inform, rather than to mislead, particularly in a way that results in harm rather than good.

I'm afraid Amaral's book does just what the (last) part of my previous sentence says.
« Last Edit: April 25, 2016, 05:45:34 PM by ferryman »

Offline G-Unit

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #218 on: April 25, 2016, 05:39:55 PM »
If the Portuguese Supreme Court restores the (commendable) sanity and common sense bestowed upon the Portuguese judiciary by the decision of the first-instance court, we (the McCanns!) need not even contemplate the European Court of Human Rights.

But if the Supreme Court ignores both ignores both its own reputation and of the whole Portuguese judiciary, then I'm not sure there's any other recourse.

There's not many who think the Portuguese Judiciary have damaged their 'reputation' or will in future, but it's a unique idea.  @)(++(*
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #219 on: April 25, 2016, 05:47:58 PM »
There's not many who think the Portuguese Judiciary have damaged their 'reputation' or will in future, but it's a unique idea.  @)(++(*

Extending the prison sentence of a woman beaten into 'confession' (when the only sane, sensible and just decision would have been to quash the conviction) was scarcely its finest hour ...

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #220 on: April 25, 2016, 05:51:48 PM »
Extending the prison sentence of a woman beaten into 'confession' (when the only sane, sensible and just decision would have been to quash the conviction) was scarcely its finest hour ...

Off topic.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #221 on: April 25, 2016, 05:52:15 PM »
Key point about free-speech, though, is that it must be exercised responsibly.

Amaral's exercise of 'speech' (obviously written, rather than spoken), adjudged, in the first-instance, not to have been exercised responsibly; in the second instance, to have been so) denigrated, traduced and defamed.  There was scarcely a word of truth in any of it.

Careful comparison of the files with Amaral's book confirms that so.

Why should Amaral be allowed to trounce reputation, and particularly harm the search for a missing little girl in that way, and especially why in the name of free speech?

That is simply not the way a democratic state (that upholds democratic principles should function.

Of course, the balance is that a democratic state should uphold free speech; but that is freedom exercised with responsibility, and with intent to inform, rather than to mislead, particularly in a way that results in harm rather than good.

I'm afraid Amaral's book does just what the (last) part of my previous sentence says.

Unfortunately you never actually grasped what the first judgement was about. It wasn't about the truth or otherwise of the book (not relevant). It wasn't about the damage to the search (not proven)

It was about Amaral having more responsibilities than an ordinary person. The judge said he did, the (senior) appeal judges said he didn't.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #222 on: April 25, 2016, 05:52:42 PM »
Key point about free-speech, though, is that it must be exercised responsibly.

Amaral's exercise of 'speech' (obviously written, rather than spoken), adjudged, in the first-instance, not to have been exercised responsibly; in the second instance, to have been so) denigrated, traduced and defamed.  There was scarcely a word of truth in any of it.

Careful comparison of the files with Amaral's book confirms that so.

Why should Amaral be allowed to trounce reputation, and particularly harm the search for a missing little girl in that way, and especially why in the name of free speech?

That is simply not the way a democratic state (that upholds democratic principles should function.

Of course, the balance is that a democratic state should uphold free speech; but that is freedom exercised with responsibility, and with intent to inform, rather than to mislead, particularly in a way that results in harm rather than good.

I'm afraid Amaral's book does just what the (last) part of my previous sentence says.
I find this interesting.

Amaral's book 120,000.  TVI documentary 2 million.

Having read the book, it pushes the limits but stays just the right side of the dividing line, IMO.

Having seen the documentary, it goes over the diving line, IMO.

Some of the TV appearances by Amaral strike me as way over the line.  Body added to a coffin in the dead of night, then cremated, as per the last CMTV show.  I really don't understand how one can say something like that without producing supporting evidence.

I dare say the court case only considers actions up to a certain cut-off time, but if I were a moderator on the forum of life, Mr Amaral would be on naughty points by now.
What's up, old man?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #223 on: April 25, 2016, 06:04:19 PM »
Unfortunately you never actually grasped what the first judgement was about. It wasn't about the truth or otherwise of the book (not relevant). It wasn't about the damage to the search (not proven)

It was about Amaral having more responsibilities than an ordinary person. The judge said he did, the (senior) appeal judges said he didn't.

Emphatically relevant, but I think you have been misled by Anne Guides.

It was not her job to judge the truth or otherwise of the files themselves.

Her job was to judge how true Amaral's book was to the files. 

Where Amaral's book deviated from the files, that was a black mark against Amaral, be the purported 'fact' true or not.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Does the European Court of Human Rights, Indeed, Beckon?
« Reply #224 on: April 25, 2016, 06:12:34 PM »
I find this interesting.

Amaral's book 120,000.  TVI documentary 2 million.

Having read the book, it pushes the limits but stays just the right side of the dividing line, IMO.

Having seen the documentary, it goes over the diving line, IMO.

Some of the TV appearances by Amaral strike me as way over the line.  Body added to a coffin in the dead of night, then cremated, as per the last CMTV show.  I really don't understand how one can say something like that without producing supporting evidence.

I dare say the court case only considers actions up to a certain cut-off time, but if I were a moderator on the forum of life, Mr Amaral would be on naughty points by now.

I'm surprised what you say in the first part I underline; agree with the second part.