Author Topic: The Sun claims Madeleine McCann was kidnapped during a botched burglary.  (Read 306217 times)

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Brietta

I can't give the why, other than narrowing it to two obvious alternatives.

Paedophilia v replacement/surrogate child.

I do not have any evidence to be more precise.

I don't think Madeleine's disappearance was opportunistic I think it was planned.

She may have fitted the location or she might have fitted the template.  I doubt all that trouble would have been gone to for paedophilia.  Replacement/surrogate child has always been high on my list of what may have happened to Madeleine and is one of the reasons to hope she may still be alive.

Therefore not a botched burglary but a highly successful one which achieved its objective.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

stephen25000

  • Guest
I don't think Madeleine's disappearance was opportunistic I think it was planned.

She may have fitted the location or she might have fitted the template.  I doubt all that trouble would have been gone to for paedophilia.  Replacement/surrogate child has always been high on my list of what may have happened to Madeleine and is one of the reasons to hope she may still be alive.

Therefore not a botched burglary but a highly successful one which achieved its objective.

Explain with cites why you think it was planned.

Offline Heriberto Janosch


I don't know if there is anything about it in the files but I came across this while browsing ... the link no longer exists.


Thank you Brietta.

Offline slartibartfast

I may be mixing up Thomas Cook with Thompsons, and if that is the case, mea culpa.  Just compare and contrast the two major tour operators at the time, and make up your own mind about what level of information appears on the MW arrivals list that does not appear on the other.

The reason as to why the individual might have been involved at this level of activity is documented in the files.  Note I have stressed 'might', as I definitely cannot prove 'was'.

Said individual could determine where the T9 were to be accommodated, had access to the keys and is on file as saying the T9 would probably choose Tapas over Millennium, due to the distances involved.

Said individual had no control over 1) whether the T9 all had decent baby monitors 2) whether the T9 used the crèche or had a nanny sit in 3) whether the T9 took their children to the Tapas a la Stephen Carpenter 4) whether the T9 conducted checks every 5 minutes or not.

Point 4) is predictable and provides the major window of opportunity in both a botched burglary and a pre-planned abduction.  While the T9 stated the checks were time driven (i.e. look at watch, 30mins has gone by, must go and check) nothing supports this and various statements suggest otherwise.  The visits appear to be largely event driven.  I can find no evidence whatsoever of any of the checkers looking at their watches, during either starters or mains, deciding the time had come for a check, and getting up and leaving the meal half-eaten to conduct a check.

Everything supports that when starters began to be served, the checkers stayed at the table until they had eaten, then did any check between starters and mains.  Seeing starters come out would give a perpetrator a quite limited window of opportunity to act.  I can't remember off hand if Gerry's check was before or after starters, because it is not particularly significant.  At the time of Gerry's check, it was still too light to conduct a burglary/abduction/body disposal with any degree of safety.

That moves us to around 9.30, when it WAS dark enough to carry out the deed under the cover of darkness.  Two checkers go, one stays behind re a sick child (also an event a burglar/abductor could not possibly control) and Matthew pops into 5A to do his check, which does not involve actually checking Madeleine.

Matthew returns to the table.  We are now back into event-driven checking.  Mains start to be served.  As per usual, none of the checkers gets up with a meal half-eaten.  One checker eats her meal hurriedly, then goes to take over from her partner, but no-one leaves until his/her mains have been consumed.  This switch between one partner and another is out of pattern, but I don't see that as being important either.

A burglar or an abductor who had any inkling of the T9 routine should have been into 5A as soon as the mains started to be served.  It is the longest, most predictable window of opportunity for that night.  Neither burglary nor abduction requires more than one perpetrator.

That perpetrator does not have to be the person making the T9 arrangements.  I have no evidence to support it was, or was not.  It just has to be a perpetrator willing to take a risk.  With the knowledge I have detailed that risk gets minimised, but of course it might have been lightning-strike random instead.

I have already pointed, as clearly as I am going to, to the small group of people with access to the knowledge, with access to the keys, and with ability to control.  I can only make it clearer by naming names, and I'm not prepared to do that, even if everything is covered in the files.

Right, I am going to take exception to your inferences. You appear to be suggesting that because someone has access to holiday booking information that is a good reason to assume that that person may have leaked information. I have a daughter who works in the travel industry who by default books people on holidays. So it follows that you seem to think she would hand that information over for some sort of reward.

If that isn't what you mean, perhaps  you should revise what you post.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline John

Can we get back to relevant posting please, all off topic posts have been expunged.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline slartibartfast

If you can show that your daughter was in Luz 2007, you may be right.

Can you show that your daughter was in Luz in 2007?

I would guess the answer to this one is no, so why on Earth have you introduced your daughter into the mix?

You are saying that someone connected with booking the t9 in the the OC may have passed that information on to a perpetrator. That person is someone's son or daughter. As you have no evidence of anything, I am standing up for them against that slur.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline John

You are saying that someone connected with booking the t9 in the the OC may have passed that information on to a perpetrator. That person is someone's son or daughter. As you have no evidence of anything, I am standing up for them against that slur.

SiL is corrrect, nobody is above suspicion.  Someone in the know could very well have provided information about guests staying at the Ocean Club.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline carlymichelle

You are saying that someone connected with booking the t9 in the the OC may have passed that information on to a perpetrator. That person is someone's son or daughter. As you have no evidence of anything, I am standing up for them against that slur.

imo that is a  big statement  to accuse innocent   hotel  workers  of anything involving maddie

Offline Mr Gray

You are saying that someone connected with booking the t9 in the the OC may have passed that information on to a perpetrator. That person is someone's son or daughter. As you have no evidence of anything, I am standing up for them against that slur.


you have said Maddie may have died in the apartment...with no evidence to support it...you support amarals right to accuse the mccanns without any evidence to support it

Offline slartibartfast

SiL is corrrect, nobody is above suspicion.  Someone in the know could very well have provided information about guests staying at the Ocean Club.

There are a little limited number of people who could do that. It could be seen as libel to suggest what you are suggesting.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Mr Gray

There are a little limited number of people who could do that. It could be seen as libel to suggest what you are suggesting.

It is a possibility...police have to look at all possibilities...every parent is under suspicion when a child disappears...that is not libellous

Offline slartibartfast

It is a possibility...police have to look at all possibilities...every parent is under suspicion when a child disappears...that is not libellous

A parent is usually one of the last people in contact with the child. The police do not usually go in for fairy stories without some facts pointing to it.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Alice Purjorick

I can't give the why, other than narrowing it to two obvious alternatives.

Paedophilia v replacement/surrogate child.

I do not have any evidence to be more precise.

Well it has been like pulling teeth but let's flesh that out a bit also in the light of Brietta's following post to yours.

1.Mrs and Mrs Plutocrat wanted to purchase a bootleg child to a particular spec. for whatever reason. ..... &%+((£

2.Mr Abductor wanted to abduct a child to play with or sell on......... &%+((£

You can play tunes with a and b versions of the same themes but essentially that's it.
Without one of those there is no prime mover for a planned abduction.

So from 1 and 2  Lay on Macduff.
How does it go from there and why? We will not be so ungentlemanly as to ask why the so and so Mr and Mrs Plutocrat want a bootleg child when the likes of Tom Cruise and Elton John find adoption no problem.



"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline mercury

I tend to favour the woke and wandered, met with an accident and was lifted.

That works

lifted by an opportunist paedofile doessnt, i dount they wonder the streets waiting

BUT the dog evidence suggests otherwise too

Offline Brietta

A parent is usually one of the last people in contact with the child. The police do not usually go in for fairy stories without some facts pointing to it.

You are familiar with "inside job"?  It happens when employees use information gained in the course of their employment to commit a crime ... and it happens a lot.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....