Author Topic: The Sun claims Madeleine McCann was kidnapped during a botched burglary.  (Read 306343 times)

0 Members and 9 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Brietta

Yes B da Silva did communicate his sighting to police. See his statement "in informal conversation with the inspectors of this police force (DIC Portimao), he reported a situation, which at the time seemed abnormal". The details of his sighting are in a different part of the files. And BTW he saw stairwellman at about 6pm on Thu 3rd.

Thanks Pegasus, I missed that entirely and have done him an injustice as a result.

A weird way of doing things though don't you think ... I would have been interested in what he found suspicious.  It looks as if someone else reported the same thing if it had already been checked out.


**snip
"He states that at no moment, did he notice the presence of anyone with an abnormal behaviour, as regards children, or anything else which appeared to be of suspicious nature.
 
The witness states that, in informal conversation with the inspectors of this police force (DIC Portimao), he reported a situation, which at the time seemed abnormal, but that these facts have already been investigated, and it was determined that they had no relevance to the current investigation."
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline misty

Yes B da Silva did communicate his sighting to police. See his statement "in informal conversation with the inspectors of this police force (DIC Portimao), he reported a situation, which at the time seemed abnormal". The details of his sighting are in a different part of the files. And BTW he saw stairwellman at about 6pm on Thu 3rd.

I was under the impression it was Mario Marreiros who saw stairwellman on the 3rd.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/madeleine-mccann-witness-saw-weird-1918572

ETA Sorry, report says 24hours before Madeleine went missing. Wonder why he hadn't collected the laundry on the Thursday?
« Last Edit: May 15, 2016, 01:03:02 AM by misty »

Offline mercury

Is it a crime to be in a stairwell?

Offline pegasus

http://youtu.be/qdMoUFnnYfc?t=43m38s
Opening 5A door with plastic card is prevented by design of doorframe (43m41).
Even if it was possible to get card in, it would be prevented by protruding screw (44m25).
« Last Edit: May 15, 2016, 01:51:13 AM by pegasus »

Offline ShiningInLuz

Do you expect people to read the entire files to check that what you're saying is correct? Please provide a cite confirming your assertion.
Unless I am mistaken, this story is in the media, but not in the files.

One of the 11 people interviewed in Dec 2014 is alleged to have lost a key chain containing every OC key to block 5.

The allegation was made by a fellow worker who says the alleged person was a prankster whom he did not like.

Tiago da Silva comes to mind, but there are so many da Silvas in this case it is hard to keep track of them.
What's up, old man?

Offline ShiningInLuz

My old grannies recipe for jugged hare started with "first catch your hare".
How is the key removed and taken for copying ?
Your thrust seems to be "inside job". In that case tell how an easily programmable electronic keycard is more secure?

I have some nice magic mushrooms in the woods near me shall I send you some?
I will pass on your nice magic mushrooms.  I have never indulged and I don't intend to start now.

I am curious, however, as to their impact on brain function, for the following reason.

Mechanical key.  Access by multiple staff.  Key cutter within 100m.  €6.50 per copy.  Weak control over key retention.

Q1 What in this issue do you not understand?

Q2 Is this, or is this not, weak security re keys?

Q3 Are you going to tell us what your 3 out of 10 theory is?

Q4 How does one tell if a mushroom is magic?

Q5 How does one tell if a magic mushroom is 'nice'?

Q6 Do magic mushrooms and jugged hare go together?  I am trying to get some distinctive recipes together.  I think I can manage the hare.  Not sure what the Portuguese is for magic mushroom, though.
What's up, old man?

Offline sadie

Is it a crime to be in a stairwell?
Of course it is not

But not the most comfortable of places to spend an evening , is it ?

Nowhere to sit and cold tiles everywhere .... not to mention the dirty washing piled up.


Just the place to spend an TWO evening(s), don't yer think?

Offline G-Unit

Eleanor is right.  It is common knowledge to anyone who has followed the case.

So Eleanor was mistaken to say it's in the files. It was a newspaper rumour. It's so difficult to separate the propaganda and myths from the facts, isn't it Sadie? That's why I request cites.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Carana

http://youtu.be/qdMoUFnnYfc?t=43m38s
Opening 5A door with plastic card is prevented by design of doorframe (43m41).
Even if it was possible to get card in, it would be prevented by protruding screw (44m25).

I've never understood what "screw" this may have been. I eventually found the model in question and there doesn't appear to be anything protruding.

The only thing I can think of is that he tried it deadlocked -  ignoring the fact that Gerry didn't remember whether he'd deadlocked it or simply shut it.


http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1207.0

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1207.msg32882;topicseen#msg32882

Offline Alice Purjorick

I will pass on your nice magic mushrooms.  I have never indulged and I don't intend to start now.

I am curious, however, as to their impact on brain function, for the following reason.

Mechanical key.  Access by multiple staff.  Key cutter within 100m.  €6.50 per copy.  Weak control over key retention.

Q1 What in this issue do you not understand? Reply: I don't understand why you have failed to work out that most security is to deter the average Joe. If someone wants to get in ie the "professional" they will.

Q2 Is this, or is this not, weak security re keys? Reply: security of key depends on who has access. Once it is handed over to a third party security gorn as you might say. If one is running a business letting out rooms it is very hard not to hand the key, whatever sort of, to a third party. Particularly if one has designs on staying in that particular business.

Q3 Are you going to tell us what your 3 out of 10 theory is?Reply:I do not understand the question. What is the the two out of ten theory and by whom was it identified/specified as such

4 How does one tell if a mushroom is magic? Reply:Fairies become pregnant when sitting on them in areas where they cannot find toadstools

Q5 How does one tell if a magic mushroom is 'nice'? Reply: Their manners give it away

Q6 Do magic mushrooms and jugged hare go together?  I am trying to get some distinctive recipes together.  I think I can manage the hare.  Not sure what the Portuguese is for magic mushroom, though. Reply: Oh yes rather. The hare is fleet of foot and the mushrooms hallucinogenic ; amazing flights of fancy can stem from a jugged hare served in a soup of magic mushrooms.
« Last Edit: May 15, 2016, 12:27:02 PM by Alice Purjorick »
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline pegasus

I've never understood what "screw" this may have been. I eventually found the model in question and there doesn't appear to be anything protruding. (snip)
Photo 1: The doorframe prevents inserting a plastic card far enough to open the latch.
Photo 2: Even if a plastic card could be inserted, the plastic card would hit one of the screws which fixes the lock to the door. This screw is not intended to stick out, but it does because it has become loose.
source: http://youtu.be/qdMoUFnnYfc?t=43m38s

Offline Carana

So why didn't he try moving the card up a bit to avoid the screw?

Offline pegasus

There is absolutely no evidence that the wooden door was opened by a stranger.

On the other hand there is very clear evidence that the window and shutter were opened by a stranger.
The evidence is: The witness who discovered the scene states clearly that the window and shutter were open.

The case should be completely solve-able starting with the evidence: that a stranger opened the window and shutter from outside but then immediately got disturbed and did not enter.


Offline Carana

There is absolutely no evidence that the wooden door was opened by a stranger.

On the other hand there is very clear evidence that the window and shutter were opened by a stranger.
The evidence is: The witness who discovered the scene states clearly that the window and shutter were open.

The case should be completely solve-able starting with the evidence: that a stranger opened the window and shutter from outside but then immediately got disturbed and did not enter.

We don't know whether it was opened from the outside or the inside, though. It possibly was, but there is no firm evidence.

Offline pegasus

So why didn't he try moving the card up a bit to avoid the screw?
Yes you are right, moving the card up a bit would get past the screw. However the screw is an absolutely hypothetical issue with no relevance, because Simas's main point is that the doorframe does not permit a plastic card to be inserted as far as the screw or latch. Before he knocks, you can see him trying to insert the plastic card, and it won't even go around the bend, therefore it's impossible to open that door with a plastic card.

You've correctly identified a minor error in the examination of the door. Can you identify the two huge and extremely relevant errors in the examination of the window (which follows straight after the examination of the door in that video)? Starts at at 44m37.
« Last Edit: May 15, 2016, 12:33:29 PM by pegasus »