They were just 50m away, just like dining in ones back garden?

[Robittybob1]

so what is that suppose to mean..............

It seems like you just are always stabbing at the McCanns.  Am I right you don't like them?

Yes the set a fund up as have many other parents of missing children.

No,  it was because he was accusing them and making out it was a fact that Madeleine was dead.

This is the preferred view.

[Lace]

Are you saying it's a fact that they didn't stage an abduction?

Oh sorry IMO.

[xtina]

Yes the set a fund up as have many other parents of missing children.

No,  it was because he was accusing them and making out it was a fact that Madeleine was dead.

what other parents ...............

how do you know as fact...... maddie isn't

[Robittybob1]

Oh sorry IMO.

You can't say for certain who staged the abduction scene.  Or can you?

[Robittybob1]

what other parents ...............

how do you know as fact...... maddie isn't

If Goncalo said Maddie could be dead or alive, I'd imagine the McCanns would have no problem with him.

[faithlilly]

No I don't agree - her friend reports on something she supposedly said on the 3rd of May, after days of obviously not having any concerns about the safety of the children when they left them.  Clearly she raised the issue of whether or not to lock the patio door not because she was afraid of someone (a burglar or abductor)getting in, but more concerned about Madeleine if she awoke again (as she had done the night before) and wanted to try and get out to come to them.  So - no lies from Kate as you have (libellously) claimed.

She had worried about leaving the children alone with the patio doors open, Tanner and FP  both reported that she voiced her concern on the 3rd of May. Therefore when she claimed she would never have thought twice about leaving the children alone she is most certainly lying.

[Benice]

Are you saying it's a fact that they didn't stage an abduction?

If they did -  they didn't make a very good job of it.

You devise a  plan to have an open window and shutters as your only evidence of an intruder -  and then close them before the police arrive - and don't even make sure that other independent witnesses see them wide open before you do close them.

A couple of 10 year olds could have made a better job of it.

IMO

[Robittybob1]

She had worried about leaving the children alone with the patio doors open, Tanner and FP  both reported that she voiced her concern on the 3rd of May. Therefore when she claimed she would never have thought twice about leaving the children alone she is most certainly lying.

Citations and context please.  I'm not saying you are wrong in fact but where did these reports come from?

If they did -  they didn't make a very good job of it.

You devise a  plan to have an open window and shutters as your only evidence of an intruder -  and then close them before the police arrive - and don't even make sure that other independent witnesses see them wide open before you do close them.

A couple of 10 year olds could have made a better job of it.

IMO

Who closed them before the police arrived?

[stephen25000]

If they did -  they didn't make a very good job of it.

You devise a  plan to have an open window and shutters as your only evidence of an intruder -  and then close them before the police arrive - and don't even make sure that other independent witnesses see them wide open before you do close them.

A couple of 10 year olds could have made a better job of it.

IMO

A pair of 10 year olds would also show more sense than the McCann's did in caring of younger children.

[faithlilly]

If they did -  they didn't make a very good job of it.

You devise a  plan to have an open window and shutters as your only evidence of an intruder -  and then close them before the police arrive - and don't even make sure that other independent witnesses see them wide open before you do close them.

A couple of 10 year olds could have made a better job of it.

IMO

Or a pair of terrified 30 somethings?

[Alfie]

She had worried about leaving the children alone with the patio doors open, Tanner and FP  both reported that she voiced her concern on the 3rd of May. Therefore when she claimed she would never have thought twice about leaving the children alone she is most certainly lying.

Can you please tell me what her friend reported she was worried about, specifically about leaving the door unlocked? 

[Alfie]

Or a pair of terrified 30 somethings?

In your version of events Gerry already knows M is dead and is hatching his plan prior to meeting Jes.  Jes reports that his behavious was absolutely normal and chatty.  Doesn't sound to me like a terrified person. 

[Robittybob1]

Or a pair of terrified 30 somethings?

who or what couple are you referring to?  there were 5 couples (or parts of couples) asked to attend the reconstruction.

In your version of events Gerry already knows M is dead and is hatching his plan prior to meeting Jes.  Jes reports that his behaviour was absolutely normal and chatty.  Doesn't sound to me like a terrified person. 

Wouldn't they just think Gerry is a good actor?

[Alfie]

who or what couple are you referring to?  there were 5 couples (or parts of couples) asked to attend the reconstruction.
Wouldn't they just think Gerry is a good actor?

Hmm.  So terrified that they can't even stage a remotely convincing break in but not that terrified that they can act perfectly normal and chatty before the alarm is raised.  Very likely I'm sure.

[Robittybob1]

Hmm.  So terrified that they can't even stage a remotely convincing break in but not that terrified that they can act perfectly normal and chatty before the alarm is raised.  Very likely I'm sure.

They deserve an Oscar for that.