Are the cadaver alerts evidence

[Mr Gray]

Post 67 doesn't really cover it. You said why the dogs were brought in.

the phrase
well you are wrong covers it
but try 65

[Mr Gray]

A cite for all to see would be handy.

no one seems to bother providing cites anymore

[Robittybob1]

So maddie may have died in the apartment or she may not......I said that about 2 yeras ago here........we know taht without the alerts

Now add in the alert but remove names for alerts don't have name tags on them.

[Robittybob1]

well you are wrong

as i said some time ago the dogs were brought in because it was possible maddie died in the apartment

why do you think a cadaver dog was brought in

Remember the rule the cadaver must be dead for 1.5 hours on average to even develop odour, and it is being detected months later, therefore time has to be longer.

[Robittybob1]

The point I am making is   if the dogs had not been brought in, you would be denying the possibility of Madeleine dying in the apartment.

The PJ were thinking that she had died even before the dogs were brought in.

[stephen25000]

How many cites have you provided this week?

Personal opinions don't count.

[Robittybob1]

no one seems to bother providing cites anymore

We should know the dog alert stuff like the back of your hands.

[slartibartfast]

Can we get back to proper discussion please.

[Robittybob1]

we can Google studies on the development of cadaver odour etc.  We've done that in the past, and they were science papers so they will still be there. 

[stephen25000]

The PJ were thinking that she had died even before the dogs were brought in.

She had disappeared without trace, as remains the situation.

No sign of a break in to the apartment, apart from unverified claim window was open. Only fingrprints identified, Kate McCann's.

How many cases of children disappearing without trace involve a child being killed or never found again ?

Any ideas Rob ?

Any ideas as to the variables which need to be considered in terms of detection of a dead body ?

Do you realize how sensitive the olfactory senses of dogs actually are ?

By the way, have you found the link to the New Zealand farmer you mentioned earlier ?

[Eleanor]

This is all too awful  Should there be no hope?

[Robittybob1]

This is all too awful  Should there be no hope?

I think we should have hope.  I look forward to the day of meeting Madeleine.

[Eleanor]

I think we should have hope.  I look forward to the day of meeting Madeleine.

Then you are even more daft than I thought you were.

[Robittybob1]

Then you are even more daft than I thought you were.

Don't you  look forward to the day of meeting Madeleine or even seeing her on TV?
What do you hope for?

[Eleanor]

Don't you  look forward to the day of meeting Madeleine or even seeing her on TV?
What do you hope for?

If and when Madeleine is found then she will never be seen on Television.  This will never be a media circus.

What do I hope for?  Nothing to do with anything that you appear to hope for.