Former McCann PI "Who is protecting Maddie's kidnapper?"

[Miss Taken Identity]

You have stated the man has no pride, that his conduct is shameful and unprofessional, that he has acted with the approval of the McCanns - are these facts or is this your opinion?

Another quote from you in which you slag him off - fact or your opinion?:

"He doesn't care enough to put his dignity on hold, he's just to (sic) dense to realise when it's happening".

Well let us look at his 'work' on this case. He was given a remit from the parents, along with selected files, and based on this investigation he stated that Maddie was alive and being cared for by loving childless couple- the investigations ends.  HE BELIEVES. His theory ties in with a nice feel good story and her parents claim that she came to no harm she = Maddie their daughter. So no panic and nothing to worrry about.

THEN... OMG she is in a dungeon being tortured and god know what else...
Sorry but Faith is correct anyone who is being paid money should come up with something more concrete than  'we believe'.  AND to pass off different theories is just disgusting! he is playing the guessing game and I believe being a mouth piece for the MacCanns. He can offer NOTHING to the investigaion going on,  so time to sit down and shut up.

[stephen25000]

Well let us look at his 'work' on this case. He was given a remit from the parents, along with selected files, and based on this investigation he stated that Maddie was alive and being cared for by loving childless couple- the investigations ends.  HE BELIEVES. His theory ties in with a nice feel good story and her parents claim that she came to no harm she = Maddie their daughter. So no panic and nothing to worrry about.

THEN... OMG she is in a dungeon being tortured and god know what else...
Sorry but Faith is correct anyone who is being paid money should come up with something more concrete than  'we believe'.  AND to pass off different theories is just disgusting! he is playing the guessing game and I believe being a mouth piece for the MacCanns. He can offer NOTHING to the investigaion going on,  so time to sit down and shut up.

IMO, that sums up the situation with Edgar precisely.

[Alfie]

That is my opinion based on the facts.

And it is a fact that the following post of  yours is completely untrue:

"I have not tried to convince anyone of anything. I have merely taken Edgar's own words and actions and repeated them, that is all and if readers now think that he really is a bit dim that is entirely his own doing".

[G-Unit]

Well let us look at his 'work' on this case. He was given a remit from the parents, along with selected files, and based on this investigation he stated that Maddie was alive and being cared for by loving childless couple- the investigations ends.  HE BELIEVES. His theory ties in with a nice feel good story and her parents claim that she came to no harm she = Maddie their daughter. So no panic and nothing to worrry about.

THEN... OMG she is in a dungeon being tortured and god know what else...
Sorry but Faith is correct anyone who is being paid money should come up with something more concrete than  'we believe'.  AND to pass off different theories is just disgusting! he is playing the guessing game and I believe being a mouth piece for the MacCanns. He can offer NOTHING to the investigaion going on,  so time to sit down and shut up.

I assume the police are trained to follow evidence. Wild guesses seem to be Edgar's forte.

[Alfie]

Well let us look at his 'work' on this case. He was given a remit from the parents, along with selected files, and based on this investigation he stated that Maddie was alive and being cared for by loving childless couple- the investigations ends.  HE BELIEVES. His theory ties in with a nice feel good story and her parents claim that she came to no harm she = Maddie their daughter. So no panic and nothing to worrry about.

THEN... OMG she is in a dungeon being tortured and god know what else...
Sorry but Faith is correct anyone who is being paid money should come up with something more concrete than  'we believe'.  AND to pass off different theories is just disgusting! he is playing the guessing game and I believe being a mouth piece for the MacCanns. He can offer NOTHING to the investigaion going on,  so time to sit down and shut up.

This is such a cheap and childish rant it's not worthy of further comment.

[Alfie]

I assume the police are trained to follow evidence. Wild guesses seem to be Edgar's forte.

Police look for evidence but they also have to formulate theories, even when there is zero evidence to support them.  Ask Amaral about coffins, sports bags, calpol, frozen bodies, for example.

[Alfie]

Contrary to the nonsense written above by MTI, this is what Dave Edgar said 8 years ago on the subject:

 “This rural, sprawling terrain makes it extremely difficult to search. You could quite easily keep a child there for years and no-one else would know.

“The person who has Maddie is most likely a paedophile or a person so desperate for a family they were willing to kidnap for it.

“I wouldn’t like to speculate on what is happening to her.”

His position really hasn't changed that much in the intervening years. 

[Robittybob1]

I assume the police are trained to follow evidence. Wild guesses seem to be Edgar's forte.

And Goncalo Amaral's.

[G-Unit]

Contrary to the nonsense written above by MTI, this is what Dave Edgar said 8 years ago on the subject:

 “This rural, sprawling terrain makes it extremely difficult to search. You could quite easily keep a child there for years and no-one else would know.

“The person who has Maddie is most likely a paedophile or a person so desperate for a family they were willing to kidnap for it.

“I wouldn’t like to speculate on what is happening to her.”

His position really hasn't changed that much in the intervening years.

Did that person buy her from the child sex gang then?

Revealing findings, that a child-sex gang most likely took the three-year-old,
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/someone-protecting-madeleine-mccann-kidnapper-10104793

[Eleanor]

Did that person buy her from the child sex gang then?

Revealing findings, that a child-sex gang most likely took the three-year-old,
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/someone-protecting-madeleine-mccann-kidnapper-10104793

Okay. No more of this, because I simply will not have it to be discussed.  I will not allow any of you to go down this road.

That's it. End of.

[Alfie]

Did that person buy her from the child sex gang then?

Revealing findings, that a child-sex gang most likely took the three-year-old,
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/someone-protecting-madeleine-mccann-kidnapper-10104793

What a cheap, distasteful comment.  What is your point?

[Alfie]

There's quite a lot we are not able to discuss
Such as amaral being a liar and a crook
Even though it's true

Alice is quite wrong (as usual).  I am always being reprimanded for initiating discussion about the McCanns possible involvement in Madeleine's disappearance which is considered too libellous for this forum, quite the opposite of what he is accusing me of.

[slartibartfast]

Did that person buy her from the child sex gang then?

Revealing findings, that a child-sex gang most likely took the three-year-old,
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/someone-protecting-madeleine-mccann-kidnapper-10104793

Based on the statistics, it is a unfortunate fact that if it was an abduction, the taken by a loving family is a low probability option. We do not need to go into detail but must accept the likely outcome of an abduction.

[Mr Gray]

Based on the statistics, it is a unfortunate fact that if it was an abduction, the taken by a loving family is a low probability option. We do not need to go into detail but must accept the likely outcome of an abduction.

But it seems gunit want to go into detail

[faithlilly]

Edgar April 2017

'Mr Edgar believes the three-year-old was snatched by a child-sex gang and insists her parents had nothing to do with her disappearance'

Edgar May 2009

'He ( Edgar) said: “Everybody hopes she has been taken by someone who wanted a child to take care of. That’s also my theory because it is supported by obvious facts.'

But by September 2009

'Maddie is imprisoned in a hellish lair – just like kidnapped sex slave Jaycee Lee Dugard.'