What Happened To Madeleine McCann? - by Ian Horrocks.

[Mr Gray]

You twisted what I said about Smithman and threw in a cheap gibe.

Rather than childish insults explain exactly what is wrong with my post
Smithman had no desire to avoid anyone
His mo was to act like a tourist
That rather blows your theory out of the water
Sorry if the truth hurts

[jassi]

A child was missing.

A man was seen carrying a child coming from the direction of her apartment.

Surely the police were remiss in not being able to trace that person for elimination purposes.  They were informed timeously enough.

As I recall, the information was held in a UK police file and never saw the light of day until discovered by OG.

[ShiningInLuz]

Rather than childish insults explain exactly what is wrong with my post
Smithman had no desire to avoid anyone
His mo was to act like a tourist
That rather blows your theory out of the water
Sorry if the truth hurts

Why do you keep bringing Smithman to the Horrocks thread when there is a perfectly good, active Smithman thread?

Could it be you are hoping no one reads the Smithman thread, where it is perfectly clear you are deploying nonsensical tactics, and have added not a jot to the debate?

[pathfinder73]

A British tourist who was taking a decidedly odd route with his child from the creche to his accommodation has almost certainly been traced.
The question is ... was that the man seen by Jane Tanner outside Block A?  Until there is a definitive answer to that one Jane Tanner's sighting is evidence now as it was when she reported it on the night of the little girl's disappearance ten years ago.

The lighting in the room would not have been described by the witness in the manner it was unless the shutter had been raised.

Have you seen crecheman's clothes and kids pyjamas? Blue and orange = brown.



That was SY's revelation moment.

The room was lighter than I expected but I definitely didn't see the shutters up, the curtains were definitely not disturbed and the shutters would have had to have been completely up, I presume, not to get that sort of, because they were shutters that went solid but when you lifted them they had gaps of light, and I wasn't aware of that and it may well be that the light was just the source from behind'

I was there to check, erm, no, no funny sort of smells, no sort of funny draughts, no sort of funny sort of noises, no, erm, nothing that I can think of for that. I mean, it was a complete just a shock out of the blue when, you know, I'd been in and then suddenly somebody's saying Madeleine's missing, there was nothing that made me think, oh'.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm

[Robittybob1]

I have read the description given by the witness.

Jane Tanner saw a man carrying a child whether she saw him in the twilight and under street lighting she saw what she saw and made sworn statements about her sighting with as much detail as she could remember.

Her sighting is evidence.

But it can't be linked to the McCann's apartment.  Jane Tanner only saw the person crossing the top of the road.

[Robittybob1]

Yes, evidence of a man taking his child home.

How many times have we been told by Mccann supporters on here, you sometimes see what you wish to see ?

What Jane saw was a person (either a man or a woman) carrying a child from the left to the right across the top of the road.  Nothing about on his way home.

[jassi]

What Jane was a person (either a man or a woman) carrying a child from the left to the right across the top of the road.  Nothing about on his way home.

It's OG that says he was on his way home, I think

[Robittybob1]

Of a man carrying a small child - nothing more.

Well a bit more than that a limp child, in pyjamas with no shoes on. No blanket.

[stephen25000]

What Jane was a person (either a man or a woman) carrying a child from the left to the right across the top of the road.  Nothing about on his way home.

Were you there Rob ?

How do you they weren't on the way home.


Have you never seen a parent carrying a tired child  ?

Remember Gerry McCann coming off a plane ?

[pathfinder73]

Well a bit more than that a limp child, in pyjamas with no shoes on. No blanket.

There was a blanket covering the child. Pink in Tanner's drawing.

[stephen25000]

There was a blanket covering the child. Pink in Tanner's drawing.

Ah yes, the incredible Ms. Tanner with the incredible eyesight in poor lighting conditions.

[Robittybob1]

Were you there Rob ?

How do you they weren't on the way home.


Have you never seen a parent carrying a tired child  ?

Remember Gerry McCann coming off a plane ?

Yes I carried a "dead" child too.  You can't carry a limp child as you can a sleeping child. Jane could not tell from what she saw what the person had intentions of doing.

[Robittybob1]

There was a blanket covering the child. Pink in Tanner's drawing.

I would not call that covered by a blanket in Tanner's sketch.

[pathfinder73]

She thought it was a top from her sketch but it was that pink blanket covering the child.

[jassi]

All irrelevant anyway as OG are not interested in this man or child.