CMTV Gonçalo Amaral - O Enigma - with English subtitles

[Erngath]

Indeed.

The whole point being of course that it is  'in your opinion'.

So what next.

You know full well, there is very little I will agree with you in this case.

So you can call that an impasse.

Of course.

Just as I disagree with your opinions on this case.

[Erngath]

The case is over, and what ever you think will not make a blind bit of difference.

It may be over but I do have the right to express my opinion.

[G-Unit]

Yes I know they had many days in court, quite sad that such a disgraceful book (imo) was judged to me more important than their right not to be unjustly accused.

Why do you continually bring every debate/discussion back to the same question which has been discussed time after time..............deflection I assume.

We are discussing Amaral's video and my particular interest in this discussion is whether it is morally correct for him to make his accustions and bizarre (imo )theories

Morally correct? What on earth does that mean?

[stephen25000]

It may be over but I do have the right to express my opinion.

Of course you can, but it won't make a difference, will it.

[Erngath]

Morally correct? What on earth does that mean?

Well in my moral compass it is wrong to make accusations of wrong doing without proof.

[Brietta]

Morally correct? What on earth does that mean?

Ethical?

[G-Unit]

Well in my moral compass it is wrong to make accusations of wrong doing without proof.

So you have decided that proof (not evidence) is required before accusations can be made? I thought policemen gathered evidence, prosecutors decided whether to charge (accuse) someone and then the courts decided if the evidence was enough to prove wrongdoing.

What the video contains is evidence which Amaral thinks points to something other than abduction.

How does your moral compass deal with the behaviour of the McCann's PI's and the UK media, I wonder?

[stephen25000]

So you have decided that proof (not evidence) is required before accusations can be made? I thought policemen gathered evidence, prosecutors decided whether to charge (accuse) someone and then the courts decided if the evidence was enough to prove wrongdoing.

What the video contains is evidence which Amaral thinks points to something other than abduction.

How does your moral compass deal with the behaviour of the McCann's PI's and the UK media, I wonder?

Ah, this was the person they said they investigated, but didn't.

I note that image along with a few other ones, appears on the official missing Madeleine site.

Even the one with the blank face.

[Erngath]

So you have decided that proof (not evidence) is required before accusations can be made? I thought policemen gathered evidence, prosecutors decided whether to charge (accuse) someone and then the courts decided if the evidence was enough to prove wrongdoing.

What the video contains is evidence which Amaral thinks points to something other than abduction.

How does your moral compass deal with the behaviour of the McCann's PI's and the UK media, I wonder?

Yes policemen gather evidence, prosecutors decide whether to charge someone but before that happens do the policemen write a book with their theories. I think not.

[ferryman]

Yes policemen gather evidence, prosecutors decide whether to charge someone but before that happens do the policemen write a book with their theories. I think not.

They do in Portugal, Erngath, do pay attention ....

[stephen25000]

I'm fairly sure some agree.

Obviously not all.

Those who disagree are wrong.

Somewhat predictable.

[Erngath]

They do in Portugal, Erngath, do pay attention ....

Noted.

[misty]

The information portrayed in Amaral's latest offering is not consistent with the PJ files in many respects.

[Mr Gray]

We are discussing the video and Amaral states things that are not true
Amaral does not have access to all the facts of the case
He is no longer  involved

[Mr Gray]

The information portrayed in Amaral's latest offering is not consistent with the PJ files in many respects.

Absolutely true