CMTV Gonçalo Amaral - O Enigma - with English subtitles

[pathfinder73]

So do you believe they are investigating the parents and are just playing "games" when they say that the parents are not suspects and you obviously do not go along with the theory that the parents are "off limits"
it's all so confusing when posting to sceptics.

I'm saying if they are investigating them, they are not going to necessarily tell us. Look at what happened in August 2007. The PJ are the lead force not SY.

[John]

without knowing exactly how he reached that decision you are not in  position to decide if he is right or wrong

I don't need to know how he reached a decision, I reached mine and Madeleine's fate is as yet undetermined.  As such ALL OPTIONS ARE WIDE OPEN!

Amaral has more knowledge of the case than Rowley ever will, nuff said.

[Mr Gray]

I'm saying if they are investigating them, they are not going to necessarily tell us. Look at what happened in August 2007. The PJ are the lead force not SY.

i think we can state with certainty the mccanns are not considered suspects by SY or the PJ

[stephen25000]

But we mustn't be critical of Martin Grime, of course, because he's a professional .....

He had no axe to grind.

He was invited to a job, and has received  a lot of flack from people like you.

OG were given a remit, in 1-direction.

£12,000,000 plus and zip to show for it, but the cliched 'one final lead'.

[Mr Gray]

I don't need to know how he reached a decision, I reached mine and Madeleine's fate is as yet undetermined.  As such ALL OPTIONS ARE WIDE OPEN!

but not equally open...and that is a fact

[Mr Gray]

He had no axe to grind.

He was invited to a job, and has received  a lot of flack from people like you.

OG were given a remit, in 1-direction.

£12,000,000 plus and zip to show for it, but the cliched 'one final lead'.

Martin Grime has zip to show for his efforts in PDL and Jersey....thats an observation not a criticism

[stephen25000]

but not equally open...and that is a fact

Really, then quantify that statement.

[Mr Gray]

Really, then quantify that statement.

it really is quite simple and im surprised you have to ask....do you beleive all 3 option s have the same degree of probability...they obviously dont

[pathfinder73]

i think we can state with certainty the mccanns are not considered suspects by SY or the PJ

They weren't in August 2007 to us either.

[Mr Gray]

They weren't in August 2007 to us either.

they werent until new evidence was discovered which amaral thought immplicated them....he was wrong...the evidence was flawed...the mccanns are not suspects ...if new evidence arises taht could change...i would say that is very very unlikely

[Alice Purjorick]

I have been asking the same question on here for getting on for four years with no credible answer as yet so let's wheel it out again.
For there to have been an abduction the paths of the little girl and the abductor had to cross.
How did their paths cross ? What evidence is there to support it ?

Any sceptical persons view today will be colored by the fact that had the same question been couched four years ago it would have been greeted with "Jane saw the abductor carting Madeleine off". Well Andy fragged Tannerman so scrub that off the list.

[Erngath]

I'm saying if they are investigating them, they are not going to necessarily tell us. Look at what happened in August 2007. The PJ are the lead force not SY.

This is 2017.
Ten years have passed.
OG have said the parents are not involved in her disappearance.
Do you believe they are playing a canny tick tock game.
Do you believe the PJ are playing a different tune?

[pathfinder73]

they werent until new evidence was discovered which amaral thought immplicated them....he was wrong...the evidence was flawed...the mccanns are not suspects ...if new evidence arises taht could change...i would say that is very very unlikely

They asked them questions which one didn't answer and they went home. That's about sums it up.

[stephen25000]

answer the question i asked you first before asking me one

t really is quite simple and im surprised you have to ask....do you beleive all 3 option s have the same degree of probability.

Without any evidence, which is basically the situation, they can be given equal weighting.

[Erngath]

I don't need to know how he reached a decision, I reached mine and Madeleine's fate is as yet undetermined.  As such ALL OPTIONS ARE WIDE OPEN!

Amaral has more knowledge of the case than Rowley ever will, nuff said.

Can I ask how how you can be certain  that amaral has more knowledge than rowley,