CMTV Gonçalo Amaral - O Enigma - with English subtitles

[misty]

I have never wondered what (if anything) Amaral is hoping to achieve. He wrote his book to explain his part in the investigation and he achieved his objective. He speaks on the subject when asked. like a lot of others do. The fact that the McCanns (and you) don't like him doing so is no concern of his; why should it be? If it's just nonsense I'm surprised people waste their time getting upset about it. It's a bit like when the media demonise people, it makes people wonder why.

Money is the root of all evil, personified by the words & actions of those you have mentioned.

[ferryman]

So are you disputing what Brunty claimed because what he was reading was NOT the official FSS Report?

ie what he was reading were 'preliminary results'.

John Lowe sent Stuart Prior an email explaining one result from the solitary report.

[ferryman]

So are you disputing what Brunty claimed because what he was reading was NOT from the official FSS Report?

ie what he was reading were 'preliminary results'.

He was not.

He was reading an email explaining one result.

Sent Amaral foaming at the mouth because John Lowe did not (again) mention the (irrelevant) result from the boot of the car in his one -- and only -- report.

[G-Unit]

Money is the root of all evil, personified by the words & actions of those you have mentioned.

The actual quote is 'For the love of money is the root of all evil:' you can only guess what motivation people have.

[Mr Gray]

So are you disputing what Brunty claimed because what he was reading was NOT from the official FSS Report?

ie what he was reading were 'preliminary results'.

Brunt was repeating a leak he had heard from the Portuguese investigation
The only reference to a preliminary report is Levy
There is no real evidence of any preliminary report
To suggest the FSS deliberately lied about their results is highly defamatory

[stephen25000]

Brunt was repeating a leak he had heard from the Portuguese investigation
The only reference to a preliminary report is Levy
There is no real evidence of any preliminary report
To suggest the FSS deliberately lied about their results is highly defamatory

Perhaps you can provide cites.

[stephen25000]

Suggestive is not the same as indicate
I think Grime also used the term
May suggest
What he didn't say was how suggestive they were
Harrison stated clearly no inference could be drawn from the alerts yet Amaral does
I'm stating facts not opinion

Then provide cites to prove your points.


Otherwise, they are merely opinions.

[stephen25000]

He was not.

He was reading an email explaining one result.

Sent Amaral foaming at the mouth because John Lowe did not (again) mention the (irrelevant) result from the boot of the car in his one -- and only -- report.

Well, prove it.

[Mr Gray]

Then provide cites.

Cites for what exactly
Everything I have said is in the files
Just tell me exactly what you would like cites for

[Robittybob1]

So are you disputing what Brunty claimed because what he was reading was NOT from the official FSS Report?

ie what he was reading were 'preliminary results'.

He is just repeating what he has been told isn't he? 
The first few words " I've learnt some important detail of the forensic test results ...."   It does says he has them or he has seen them but rather learnt them.

[Mr Gray]

There have been a multitude of false statements made by Amaral and the Portuguese media which have convinced the Portuguese of the Mccanns guilt

[stephen25000]

There have been a multitude of false statements made by Amaral and the Portuguese media which have convinced the Portuguese of the Mccanns guilt

You are giving your opinion that the Portuguese media and Amaral has that kind of influence.

It doesn't appear to have occurred to you, that people in Portugal have made their own decisions for themselves.

[Mr Gray]

You are giving your opinion that the Portuguese media and Amaral has that kind of influence.

It doesn't appear to have occurred to you, that people in Portugal have made their own decisions for themselves.

On what information have they come to their conclusions
From the media... From amaral

Where else
Think about it

[stephen25000]

On what information have they come to their conclusions
From the media... From amaral

Where else
Think about it

Reading the cases files that are available.

The McCann's actions in leaving their children by themselves.

An anathema to many people.

The McCann's blaming other people for their own failings.

Expecting tax payers to pay for their blunders.

etc.

[stephen25000]

Are you really suggesting all the Portuguese public who believe Amarals ideas have read the files on line
Surely not

Perhaps you can't comprehend why people don't believe the McCann's story of 'abduction'.