Was Mark Rowley wrong to claim that Madeleine McCann was abducted?

[Erngath]

Now, here's a thought.

What would Mccann's supporters say if Rowley stated he believed in the accidental death scenario ?

Now would they say it is a fact ?   

Now, here's a thought.

What would McCann sceptics say if Rowley stated that Madeleine was abducted.

Ooops he has.

[Eleanor]

Now, here's a thought.

What would Mccann's supporters say if Rowley stated he believed in the accidental death scenario ?

Now would they say it is a fact ?   

He didn't  So more speculation.  Stop this now.

[barrier]

Now, here's a thought.

What would McCann sceptics say if Rowley stated that Madeleine was abducted.

Ooops he has.

So back to the thread title,was he right if so why?

[Eleanor]

So back to the thread title,was he right if so why?

I don't think we can rightly debate this.  And certainly not for why.

[barrier]

I don't think we can rightly debate this. 

With admin's statement and they themselves starting the thread they must think it can.

[stephen25000]

Now, here's a thought.

What would McCann sceptics say if Rowley stated that Madeleine was abducted.

Ooops he has.

Ooops.

He hasn't solved the crime.

[carlymichelle]

With admin's statement and they themselves starting the thread they must think it can.

i think as long as posters     dont state it as  fact ie maddie  WAS   abducted   and  say instead  they  THINK  maddie  was  abducted etc its fine its all in context

[Erngath]

i think as long as posters     dont state it as  fact ie maddie  WAS   abducted   and  say instead  they  THINK  maddie  was  abducted etc its fine its all in context

But it's Rowley who is saying  Madeleine was abducted.

[Eleanor]

With admin's statement and they themselves starting the thread they must think it can.

This is a mine field.  Tread very warily.

[Erngath]

Ooops.

He hasn't solved the crime.

But he does say/state/opine that Madeleine was abducted.

[stephen25000]

But he does say/state/opine that Madeleine was abducted.

Meaningless.

[Erngath]

Meaningless.

I will take note of that response.
Could be useful.

[carlymichelle]

i also  think  refrences to amaral not understanding  evidence etc should be  banned  from this forum he was an police officer he understands more then  anyone on this forum  what was  going on in portugal at that time   just  imo

[stephen25000]

I will take note of that response.
Could be useful.

In what way ?

Madeleine hasn't been found.

Madeleine's disappearance hasn't been solved.

What do you fail to understand about that ?

[barrier]

But he does say/state/opine that Madeleine was abducted.

But not just that,he also says there is no definitive evidence as to what happened and that's why they keep an open mind, adding even if we have to be pessimistic about the prospects, we are open minded because we don’t have definitive evidence about what happened to Madeleine.Links have been provided verifying it.