If I have got the gist correct, you either think my use of 'manipulation' has a connotation that is negative e.g. wrongdoing, or that what happened in the media afterwards implied manipulation associated with a negative sentiment.
As to the latter, I have made clear that I did not follow case, and I do so again. Therefore, I am in no position to comment.
As to the former, you should know me well enough by now to know that I do not do either pro-McCann or anti-McCann. That is simply not my starting point. If you feel the word 'manipulation' has a negative connotation, I am happy to change it to one of several others. Would you accept leveraging? I cannot see a potential negative connotation in that.
The McCann 'team', loosely defined as relatives and contacts, seem to have gotten round to putting a lot of material into the public domain in a very short time. I cannot see how this can be contested. The media scrum in Luz would not have happened if this had not been the case.
Help me out here, as I did NOT follow the case.
Were the press briefings in the UK conducted by the McCann team (sorry, but I need to use a shorter tag than McCann relatives and contacts every time I refer to this, no connotation implied), or were they conducted by UK police with representatives from the McCann team?
Is it normal for people involved in a UK crime to hold media briefings that do not involve the UK police?
If this had happened the other way round would we applaud it? The other way round is where a Portuguese family on holiday in the UK had a child go missing. And then decided before the British detectives turned up, that they should contact relatives in Portugal. And those relatives would in turn contact the Portuguese Foreign Office, the Portuguese Embassy (presumably in London) and, should it exist, whatever Portuguese Consulate is nearest to the incident scene?
If this Portuguese family had, directly or through contacts, got the Portuguese media onto the case by early next day, would we applaud such an intervention into a British case?
If such actions had meant hordes of media descending on the incident scene, would we applaud it?
If such actions had meant the British investigation had to divert significant resources to deal with the media scrum, would we applaud it?
If I have got the gist correct, you either think my use of 'manipulation' has a connotation that is negative e.g. wrongdoing, or that what happened in the media afterwards implied manipulation associated with a negative sentiment.
As to the latter, I have made clear that I did not follow case, and I do so again. Therefore, I am in no position to comment.
As to the former, you should know me well enough by now to know that I do not do either pro-McCann or anti-McCann. That is simply not my starting point. If you feel the word 'manipulation' has a negative connotation, I am happy to change it to one of several others. Would you accept leveraging? I cannot see a potential negative connotation in that.
Madeleine McCann's case was re-opened in 2013 ... since then I have discovered that one of the standard accusations of sceptics is the manipulation of the media by 'team McCann'.The McCann 'team', loosely defined as relatives and contacts, seem to have gotten round to putting a lot of material into the public domain in a very short time. I cannot see how this can be contested. The media scrum in Luz would not have happened if this had not been the case.
The 'McCann team' was not on standby for the event, for the simple reason 'team McCann' did not exist as a cohesive entity straining to heave its manipulative tentacles into influencing the world's media mainly to cast the Portuguese police and in particular the case coordinator in the worst possible light.
An hysterical phone call from Gerry to his sister informing her that the police were telling him Madeleine had probably just wandered and would turn up in the morning, engendered reaction from her.
She contacted her local police who could not help; her husband searched the internet to find contact for assistance; she contacted relations; she broke the news to Madeleine's grandmother and she spoke to the BBC.http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PATRICIA_CAMERON.htm Help me out here, as I did NOT follow the case.
Neither did I. I arrived on the scene when the case was reopened and I innocently posted a 'good luck' message on a Yahoo comment page ... and unleashed the whirlwind of Dogs Don't Lie / Gaspar statement / cats files and all the usual accusations and calumnies which although discounted seem to be treasured. Were the press briefings in the UK conducted by the McCann team (sorry, but I need to use a shorter tag than McCann relatives and contacts every time I refer to this, no connotation implied), or were they conducted by UK police with representatives from the McCann team?
Is it normal for people involved in a UK crime to hold media briefings that do not involve the UK police?
I have absolutely no idea if there were official statements or press briefings in which Leicestershire Police were involved; however I detect a tone that you think the friends and relations of the Drs McCann should have been 'gagged' from giving interviews (if they did).
Freedom of speech for Portugal but none for the UK ?? If this had happened the other way round would we applaud it? The other way round is where a Portuguese family on holiday in the UK had a child go missing. And then decided before the British detectives turned up, that they should contact relatives in Portugal. And those relatives would in turn contact the Portuguese Foreign Office, the Portuguese Embassy (presumably in London) and, should it exist, whatever Portuguese Consulate is nearest to the incident scene?
If this Portuguese family had, directly or through contacts, got the Portuguese media onto the case by early next day, would we applaud such an intervention into a British case?
Who has applauded the media intrusion into Portugal?
Who had the power to prevent it?
The victims of the crime had no power over the press, but much maligned Clarence Mitchell did manage to reach a compromise with them which allowed the Drs McCann some breathing space from the scrum.
The Portuguese authorities had the power; which those on the ground abused lending to the feeding frenzy.
The problem as I see it and have already said is that the media presence was not subject to appropriate management and was used in a way by the police which made it subject to abuse.If such actions had meant hordes of media descending on the incident scene, would we applaud it?
If such actions had meant the British investigation had to divert significant resources to deal with the media scrum, would we applaud it?
The key to preventing the supposed media scrum to which you refer is in my opinion to keep it informed.
Hanging around Hugo Beaty's waiting for the odd crumb of rumour or 'information' comes well within what I would have considered a recipe for disaster.
I doubt that a similar tragedy involving a Portuguese couple on British soil would ever have been allowed to sink to the depths that Madeleine McCann's investigation was allowed to dredge.
The blame directed at her parents for media intrusion is misplaced; for information ... neither they nor anyone else contacted SKY NEWS.