UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 10:37:17 AM

Title: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 10:37:17 AM
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 10:44:30 AM
Nor have Murat, the Tapas 7, Malinka, the waiters, the nursery staff or anyone else in PdL on the night of 3rd May 2007 for that matter.  All innocent until proven guilty but "not cleared" of committing a heinous act.   >@@(*&)

Totally agree.

So we should not claim that the McCanns have been cleared, just that theyare due the presumption of innocence.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Jean-Pierre on April 30, 2013, 11:18:34 AM
I really do not understand the question.  It is not possible to "cleared" of something which does not exist. 

As an aside, Lord Soper (if you remember him) used to be a regular at Speakers Corner.  One day a heckler called out "You are mad".  He ignored the interruption.  The man kept repeating "You are mad".  In the end, Soper took the bait.  "I am NOT mad.". 

"Prove it!" came the challenge.

Soper pondered for a moment.  "I can't".  "But can you prove that YOU are not mad?"

The man proudly produced a certificate of discharge from a well known mental hospital. 

There is a moral to this somewhere........   
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 11:22:28 AM
I really do not understand the question.  It is not possible to "cleared" of something which does not exist. 

As an aside, Lord Soper (if you remember him) used to be a regular at Speakers Corner.  One day a heckler called out "You are mad".  He ignored the interruption.  The man kept repeating "You are mad".  In the end, Soper took the bait.  "I am NOT mad.". 

"Prove it!" came the challenge.

Soper pondered for a moment.  "I can't".  "But can you prove that YOU are not mad?"

The man proudly produced a certificate of discharge from a well known mental hospital. 

There is a moral to this somewhere........

Totally agree- there is no procedure to 'clear' suspects, theyare merely presumed innocent.

As a retired mental health nurse I have told that story many times.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: muratfan on April 30, 2013, 11:43:42 AM
The McCanns, it was said, in the final report, were not implicit in any wrong doing concerning the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine McCann. Sounds like cleared to me.

Now remember we have different laws in different countries. Cleared of charges means different things.

UK means going to court and found NOT GUILTY

Portugal means being cleared by those prosecuting
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 11:57:13 AM
The McCanns, it was said, in the final report, were not implicit in any wrong doing concerning the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine McCann. Sounds like cleared to me.

Now remember we have different laws in different countries. Cleared of charges means different things.

UK means going to court and found NOT GUILTY

Portugal means being cleared by those prosecuting

I don't believe so. Perhaps you could produce evidence that a prosecutor failing to find sufficient evidence (no indication- note NOT 'no evidence') of a crime having been committed by an individual.

Cite please.

The prosecutor would look a right wally if he cleared someone, only later having to charge them when sufficient evidence is later found.

I am afraid all we can say is that they are still due the presumption of innocence!

Unless you can provide a reference to Portuguese Law which contradicts this......
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 03:41:45 PM
Debunker, do you agree that when someone on the "sceptic" side of the argument says "The McCanns have NOT been cleared" that this implies they are still suspects, albeit unofficially so?  What is the McCanns' status then if not cleared of suspicion and yet not official suspects?

They may mean that but they are wrong. The McCanns are due the presumption of innocence but they have not 'been cleared'.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: ferryman on April 30, 2013, 05:03:37 PM
If you were once an official suspect but are now no longer an official suspect then that means you are no longer officially suspected doesn't it?

Yes.  Unless something (at present unknown) should come to light to suggest otherwise.

A crime remains unsolved and a child remains missing.


Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 05:27:48 PM
Debunker, do you agree that when someone on the "sceptic" side of the argument says "The McCanns have NOT been cleared" that this implies they are still suspects, albeit unofficially so?  What is the McCanns' status then if not cleared of suspicion and yet not official suspects?

They may mean that but they are wrong. The McCanns are due the presumption of innocence but they have not 'been cleared'.

Surely the McCanns' and Murat's status is somewhat different to that of the Tapas 7, waiters etc who have also "not been cleared" - by virtue of the fact that they (the McCanns & Murat) WERE at one time official suspects and are now no longer. 

If you were once an official suspect but are now no longer an official suspect then that means you are no longer officially suspected doesn't it? >@@(*&)

Arguido status confers rights on people. It does not change their legal status apart from that.

There is an interesting conundrum here.

Most Pros would say that being an Arguido says nothing about culpability
Most [ censored word] would say that being an Arguido at least arouses suspicion- no smoke without fire.

Now if Arguido status is withdrawn (as in this case) then I would argue that it would be illogical for an anti to suggest that such a release did not lessen their potential culpability and most importantly a pro can not really claim that being released from Arguido status removes suspicion if they previously maintained that being made arguido did not increase their potential culpability.

Logic is a bit of a b....r!
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on April 30, 2013, 05:36:51 PM
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 05:44:04 PM
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

Correct.

You will find that Pro forums like to claim that the McCanns have been cleared of criminal charges by the processes of the judicial system. This is a false statement as there is no such process available to suspects.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on April 30, 2013, 05:52:31 PM
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

Correct.

You will find that Pro forums like to claim that the McCanns have been cleared of criminal charges by the processes of the judicial system. This is a false statement as there is no such process available to suspects.

I think you will find that pro forums say that the Mccanns have been released from arguido status and no criminal charges have been made.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on April 30, 2013, 05:54:13 PM
Quote
Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges

no criminal charges have been made.

Correct.

You will find that Pro forums like to claim that the McCanns have been cleared of criminal charges by the processes of the judicial system. This is a false statement as there is no such process available to suspects.

I think you will find that pro forums say that the Mccanns have been released from arguido status and no criminal charges have been made.

Some say that. Many say that they have been cleared.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: AnneGuedes on April 30, 2013, 10:12:22 PM
Debunker, do you agree that when someone on the "sceptic" side of the argument says "The McCanns have NOT been cleared" that this implies they are still suspects, albeit unofficially so?  What is the McCanns' status then if not cleared of suspicion and yet not official suspects?
The McCanns have no statute at all, they're free, if persons suspect them it's these persons' problem, not the McCann's.
They couldn't be relieved from their arguido (not exactly "suspect" but person of interest) statute  before the end of the investigation. Now if they had a strong element to ask for the reopening of the case, I don't know what their statute would be. It would likely be related to the nature of the element. If, desperate to see the case reopened, they'd ask for a reconstitution, would they be made arguidos just to protect them ? I've no idea !
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Chinagirl on May 01, 2013, 12:34:05 AM
Quote:
Most Pros would say that being an Arguido says nothing about culpability
Most [ censored word] would say that being an Arguido at least arouses suspicion- no smoke without fire.

Unquote

I agree with Martha's comment above that "most pros" would agree with [ censored word] that being made arguido arouses suspicion of wrongdoing on the part of the arguido.  However, the removal of the arguido status because no evidence of criminality was found against that arguido removes all vestige of suspicion, and the arguido is then CLEARED.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 12:43:56 AM
Quote:
Most Pros would say that being an Arguido says nothing about culpability
Most [ censored word] would say that being an Arguido at least arouses suspicion- no smoke without fire.

Unquote

I agree with Martha's comment above that "most pros" would agree with [ censored word] that being made arguido arouses suspicion of wrongdoing on the part of the arguido.  However, the removal of the arguido status because no evidence of criminality was found against that arguido removes all vestige of suspicion, and the arguido is then CLEARED.

That's my reading too. I recall an in depth item on the BBC's 'Today' programme when two Portuguese solicitors
explained the concept of the arguido(a) - that was roughly in June 2007 - what stuck in my mind was that the solicitors explained that at that time - roughly 10% of the entire adult population of PT had been or were arguidos.

The arguido does not need to incriminate him/herself during the investigation - and the police/judiciary have put the person of interest on official notice - that they are part of the case - until the arguido status is lifted off them. 

That's how I understood it anyway - I'm glad for someone versed in the byzantine judicial system of Portugal - to blow my reading out of the water - all good for debate  ?{)(**
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: icabodcrane on May 01, 2013, 12:51:53 AM
The McCann's Arguido status was lifted by the Portuguese prosecutor as a pre-requisite of him shelving the case

In so doing,  he did not  'clear'  the McCanns  ...  he could not  'clear'  the McCanns because it was,  quite simply,  not within his remit to do so

He determined there was no evidence of a crime having been committed by them and there was, therefore, no prospect of a successful prosection if charges were brought

That was his only  job ... deciding if a prosecution was likely to result in a guilty verdict 

The Prosecutor is not a Judge,  and he is unable to 'clear' anyone
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Chinagirl on May 01, 2013, 12:57:24 AM
Quote:
He determined there was no evidence of a crime having been committed by them and there was, therefore, no prospect of a successful prosection if charges were brought
Unquote

That'll do me for being cleared1
 8)--))
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 01:00:51 AM
in response to icabodcrane's post:

Which contrasts sharply with ermmm Amaral - who was an arguido - and was then sentenced to be a bona-fide perjurer and criminal by his peers.

Unlike Robert/Kate/Gerry - who are unencumbered by any legal sentence to tarnish their good names and reputations.

Thanks for clearing this up
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: icabodcrane on May 01, 2013, 01:10:24 AM
Quote:
He determined there was no evidence of a crime having been committed by them and there was, therefore, no prospect of a successful prosection if charges were brought
Unquote

That'll do me for being cleared1
 8)--))

It will have to do for the McCanns also

Of course, the definitive  'clearance'  ( declaration of innocence )  can only come from a court, a Judge, and  a Jury of 12 men and women, good and true

For now,  though,  the  presumption of innocence is their  only ( and  rightful )  refuge
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 01:13:52 AM
nonsense

they don't need refuge

they are not criminals like say, Amaral - their one-time, wannabe nemesis
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: icabodcrane on May 01, 2013, 01:35:06 AM
nonsense

they don't need refuge

they are not criminals like say, Amaral - their one-time, wannabe nemesis

Which begs the question  ...  why did they pull out of facing him in court on the eve of the libel trial ?
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 01:53:53 AM
nonsense

they don't need refuge

they are not criminals like say, Amaral - their one-time, wannabe nemesis

Which begs the question  ...  why did they pull out of facing him in court on the eve of the libel trial ?

Don't know and don't care

Kate & Gerry are free citizens

Amaral is a convicted liar and criminal

That's it in a (coco)nutshell

I have no personal feelings for or against Amaral, the convicted perjurer - but judging by his
appearance in the last 6 months or so (he looks very ill) - it is probably better for him to let matters rest in any case

Kate & Gerry are probably doing the convicted criminal a favour
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 02:07:29 AM
The karma police will get one everytime
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: John on May 01, 2013, 02:49:52 AM
Oh dear me...good job Luz has gone to bed.  (http://images.zaazu.com/img/ssshh-ssshh-animated-animation-smiley-emoticon-000358-medium.gif) (http://images.zaazu.com/img/sleep-anim-male-sleep-sleeping-smiley-emoticon-000368-medium.gif)
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 06:09:32 AM
Quote:
Most Pros would say that being an Arguido says nothing about culpability
Most [ censored word] would say that being an Arguido at least arouses suspicion- no smoke without fire.

Unquote

I agree with Martha's comment above that "most pros" would agree with [ censored word] that being made arguido arouses suspicion of wrongdoing on the part of the arguido.  However, the removal of the arguido status because no evidence of criminality was found against that arguido removes all vestige of suspicion, and the arguido is then CLEARED.

The word was no 'indication' of criminality. There was considerable evidence but none of it indicated a crime committed by the McCanns.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 06:10:15 AM
The McCann's Arguido status was lifted by the Portuguese prosecutor as a pre-requisite of him shelving the case

In so doing,  he did not  'clear'  the McCanns  ...  he could not  'clear'  the McCanns because it was,  quite simply,  not within his remit to do so

He determined there was no evidence of a crime having been committed by them and there was, therefore, no prospect of a successful prosection if charges were brought

That was his only  job ... deciding if a prosecution was likely to result in a guilty verdict 

The Prosecutor is not a Judge,  and he is unable to 'clear' anyone

Exactly
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 06:10:56 AM
Quote:
He determined there was no evidence of a crime having been committed by them and there was, therefore, no prospect of a successful prosection if charges were brought
Unquote

That'll do me for being cleared1
 8)--))

Cite please for those words.

The word used was 'Indication' not 'evidence'
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 06:12:03 AM
The karma police will get one everytime

Believers in karma are bound to be disappointed.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Benice on May 01, 2013, 07:24:39 AM
nonsense

they don't need refuge

they are not criminals like say, Amaral - their one-time, wannabe nemesis

Which begs the question  ...  why did they pull out of facing him in court on the eve of the libel trial ?

No-one knows who made the first move to try to achieve an out of court settlement.  I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong, but  it is my understanding  that only the Plaintiff (the McCanns) could apply to the court for a 'stay' in proceedings - the Defendant (Amaral) does not have the legal power to do that.     

Therefore if the McCanns made the first approach and Amaral agreed to 'discuss' - then the McCanns would apply for a stay.  However if it was Amaral who approached the McCanns suggesting discussing a settlement, and they agreed to do that  - then it would still be the McCanns who would have to apply to the court for the necessary 'stay'.




   
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Chinagirl on May 01, 2013, 07:33:38 AM
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 07:42:18 AM
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 07:43:50 AM
What is the status of a statement by someone who insists that the McCanns have been 'cleared'?

It is a claim backed by no evidence- merely the belief of the utterer. It has no meaning in law and is as meaningful as someone who says that they are still suspects- merely a social opinion with no standing in law.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 08:14:18 AM
Just watching the news.

Amanda Knox.

Under the Roman Law based legal system as Portugal.

Has she been cleared?
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 08:17:01 AM
I look forward today to the first post from someone insisting that the McCanns have been cleared that includes a reference to the procedure that legally 'clears' people.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Chinagirl on May 01, 2013, 08:42:58 AM
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

Has the UK attorney general (or any law enforcement authority) stated that there "are no indications of a crime" committed by them?

The McCanns and Murat have had such a statement made about them by Portugal's AG, effectively clearing them of any crime.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: stephen25000 on May 01, 2013, 09:24:25 AM
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

Has the UK attorney general (or any law enforcement authority) stated that there "are no indications of a crime" committed by them?

The McCanns and Murat have had such a statement made about them by Portugal's AG, effectively clearing them of any crime.

Nothing to do with the UK.

The events occurred on Portuguese soil.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Chinagirl on May 01, 2013, 09:30:42 AM
Agreed, Stephen - but Debunker has stated a general concept - that no one can be "cleared" of suspicion of having committed a crime unless found not guilty in a court of law - in any jurisdiction.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:45:18 AM
Just watching the news.

Amanda Knox.

Under the Roman Law based legal system as Portugal.

Has she been cleared?

Christ knows.  She WAS aquitted but now she is being re-tried.  When they find her guilty again will she have a right to appeal and be acquiited again?  It's madness.

It is noit madness, but a different judicial system where 'getting it right' is more important than 'winning a case'.

The continental inquisitorial system works under the philosophical misapprehension that it is possible to make a decision now about exactly what happened at an earlier time. The adversarial system is more pragmatic, relying on what is provable ablout the past but making no claim to accuracy about the true events.

But you do see what I mean by the difficulty of saying someone is 'cleared'.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:46:55 AM
So, if the McCanns have not been cleared, then neither has Murat.  What can these people do to clear their names of suspicion once and for all?  Insist that they are tried for abduction and cover-up?

They do not need to clear their names any more than other people with means, motive and opportunity (Tapas 7, Warner staff etc.) who are all due the same thing- presumption of innocence.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:51:12 AM
As it says.

This is a Pro myth.

There is no legal procedure (short of trial and a finding of Not Guilty) that in any way clears people of a crime.

They remain protected by the presumption of innocence, but have not been 'cleared'.

So anyone who has ever been a suspect in any crime, but the case is dropped for lack of evidence (lor whatever reason) before coming to trial, remains uncleared of that crime because there has been no verdict of not guilty. 

Come on; let's have a bit of common sense here ...

There is no procedure in law for deciding who is 'uncleared' of a crime and there is no procedure in law for 'clearing' someone.

If one is questioned, arrested, charged etc, this does not remove the presumption of innocence- that remains until a trial has been held and completed.

Consider the killers of Stephen Lawrence.

It is a factual matter that at least four known mini-gang members were present and involved in his killing For many years none of them were found to have acted criminally in the matter. They remained suspects but there was insufficient evidence to charge and convict them. Were they cleared when the case was not proceded with by the then DPP, were they cleared when the private prosecution was brought by his parents, were they cleared when the Daily Mail plastered their picture on the front page under the Headline 'Murderers'? No. They were allowed by right the presumption of innocence, but at no point were they 'cleared'. Two have now been arrested, charged, tried, found guilty and lost their appeals- are they more guilty than the other two against whome inadequate evidence was available. There is today a story that more evidence against the free pair has been offered to the police. Are they currently 'cleared' or 'not cleared'?

There is no legal procedure save a finding of Not Guilty at a trial that can be seen as 'being cleared'.

End of story.

Has the UK attorney general (or any law enforcement authority) stated that there "are no indications of a crime" committed by them?

The McCanns and Murat have had such a statement made about them by Portugal's AG, effectively clearing them of any crime.

It does not in any way change their legal status regarding potential culpability.

1/ They were once not under suspicion (before Madeleine disappeared)
2/ They came under suspicion along with all others with mean, motive or opportunity
3/ They became arguidos which gave them more rights
4/ They were released from Arguido status which removed those rights
5/ If further evidence emerges, they may become under suspicion again.

Items 1,2 and 5 apply to all others ever under suspicion.

No-one ever lost the right to presumption of innocence.

No-one entered any special category from which they needed to be legally freed (cleared.)

There is no process in law to clear someone of a suspicion.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:52:17 AM
Agreed, Stephen - but Debunker has stated a general concept - that no one can be "cleared" of suspicion of having committed a crime unless found not guilty in a court of law - in any jurisdiction.

That is correct.

Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:53:30 AM
I think we have to accept that when we say the McCanns have been cleared we are using the phrase in the idiomatic sense, ie:

Idioms:
clear the air
To dispel differences or emotional tensions.
in the clear
1. Free from burdens or dangers.
2. Not subject to suspicion or accusations of guilt: The evidence showed that the suspect was in the clear.



http://www.thefreedictionary.com/clear

As the McCanns were never charged then they can not be cleared of charges of criminal activity, only of any suspicion of guilt that being an arguido may have conferred on them. 

Is being cleared even a legal term out of interest?

Idiomatic equals opinion.

I have no problem with people having the opinion that (in their eyes) the McCanns have been cleared.

What is not true is the claim that the McCanns have been cleared.

Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:54:31 AM
So, if the McCanns have not been cleared, then neither has Murat.  What can these people do to clear their names of suspicion once and for all?  Insist that they are tried for abduction and cover-up?

They do not need to clear their names any more than other people with means, motive and opportunity (Tapas 7, Warner staff etc.) who are all due the same thing- presumption of innocence.

However, other people were not made arguidos or had their reputations ruined by the press for months.

Legally that makes no difference.

None of them have been 'cleared' because there is no such process.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 09:56:21 AM
Just watching the news.

Amanda Knox.

Under the Roman Law based legal system as Portugal.

Has she been cleared?

Christ knows.  She WAS aquitted but now she is being re-tried.  When they find her guilty again will she have a right to appeal and be acquiited again?  It's madness.

It is noit madness, but a different judicial system where 'getting it right' is more important than 'winning a case'.

The continental inquisitorial system works under the philosophical misapprehension that it is possible to make a decision now about exactly what happened at an earlier time. The adversarial system is more pragmatic, relying on what is provable ablout the past but making no claim to accuracy about the true events.

But you do see what I mean by the difficulty of saying someone is 'cleared'.

So can Amanda Knox EVER be said to be cleared, even if she is acquitted again?

Once the final court has heard the case, she will be cleared by the Italian System of Justice if they find that she did not kill anyone. The Inquisition will be finalised and she will be cleared.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 10:05:08 AM
I think we have to accept that when we say the McCanns have been cleared we are using the phrase in the idiomatic sense, ie:

Idioms:
clear the air
To dispel differences or emotional tensions.
in the clear
1. Free from burdens or dangers.
2. Not subject to suspicion or accusations of guilt: The evidence showed that the suspect was in the clear.



http://www.thefreedictionary.com/clear

As the McCanns were never charged then they can not be cleared of charges of criminal activity, only of any suspicion of guilt that being an arguido may have conferred on them. 

Is being cleared even a legal term out of interest?

Idiomatic equals opinion.

I have no problem with people having the opinion that (in their eyes) the McCanns have been cleared.

What is not true is the claim that the McCanns have been cleared.

You clearly DO have a problem with people holding the opinion that the McCanns have been cleared because you keep on and on and on about it and attempt to belittle people who hold that opinion as "rabid pros" who want to believe in myths. 

I shall continue to say that the McCanns are in the clear (having been cleared of any inference of guilt that their arguidoship conferred upon them) and no doubt you will insist on telling me that I'm wrong.  Or, you could just let it lie for once! @)(++(*

Anyone is free to hold any opinion and to state it publicly if it is not libellous or harassment.

That does not assign any truth value to the statement. It is a statement of individual belief and cannot be proven to be true as it is, factually and with normal English usage and Legal usage, in fact a false statement.

The equivalent false statement on the Anti side is "The McCanns are still suspects in the death or disappearance of their daughter."

Do you respect their right to believe, state and claim that to be true as they will be using the same fallacious reasoning that you are using to support your contention to support their contention.

Sauce for the Goose

If you do persist in what you say, you need to accept that a forker claiming that "the McCanns are still suspects" has the same status as your claim that "the McCanns have been cleared."

Both or neither I am afraid.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 10:20:18 AM
Agreed, Stephen - but Debunker has stated a general concept - that no one can be "cleared" of suspicion of having committed a crime unless found not guilty in a court of law - in any jurisdiction.

This discussion is getting more about semantics than cold hard facts.

Fact: all three ex- arguidos are at the present moment - free citizens in their respective countries - who do not have criminal records for any law-breaking.

That makes them 'cleared' of crime or any suspicion of crime  - in my book.

Unlike say Amaral, who does have a criminal record for the crime of perjury. He is not clear of a defined crime.

Simples really

Any unresolved issues will be sorted out by the karma police in due course

 

Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 10:35:07 AM
Debunker, what it boils down to is this (in my opinion) - if the McCanns are no longer suspects in their child's disappearance when once they were (which you seem to agree is the case), then they are in the clear. That's a lay person's term, and one that is perfectly acceptable and understandable to the vast majority of ordinary people.  Just because YOU don't accept it isn't going to stop me saying it.

If the "sceptics" want to say that the McCanns are still suspects as far as the police are concerned then they need to provide evidence that shows that the authorities are still viewing them with suspicion - all the evidence points to the fact that SY are not treating them as suspects, whether that's the case in Portugal is another matter.  I fully accept that the "sceptics" still think they are the key suspects, there's nothing I can say to change their opinion on the matter.

That's it in one.

We are lay people (debunker included) this constant referring to dictionaries is reminding me of the scene in Crocodile Dundee - when Dundee is threatened by a hoodlum with a knife - and Dundee produces his own weapon - looking at the kid and saying - 'you call that a knife?'

Cleared of crime is perfectly adequate to reflect that a person has not been committed of a crime or is not being actively investigated on suspicion of having committed a crime.

It really is NOT rocket science with words. 
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 11:11:21 AM
Debunker, what it boils down to is this (in my opinion) - if the McCanns are no longer suspects in their child's disappearance when once they were (which you seem to agree is the case), then they are in the clear. That's a lay person's term, and one that is perfectly acceptable and understandable to the vast majority of ordinary people.  Just because YOU don't accept it isn't going to stop me saying it.

If the "sceptics" want to say that the McCanns are still suspects as far as the police are concerned then they need to provide evidence that shows that the authorities are still viewing them with suspicion - all the evidence points to the fact that SY are not treating them as suspects, whether that's the case in Portugal is another matter.  I fully accept that the "sceptics" still think they are the key suspects, there's nothing I can say to change their opinion on the matter.

You are entitled to your beliefs.

I shall just stick with knowledge.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 11:50:54 AM
Debunker, what it boils down to is this (in my opinion) - if the McCanns are no longer suspects in their child's disappearance when once they were (which you seem to agree is the case), then they are in the clear. That's a lay person's term, and one that is perfectly acceptable and understandable to the vast majority of ordinary people.  Just because YOU don't accept it isn't going to stop me saying it.

If the "sceptics" want to say that the McCanns are still suspects as far as the police are concerned then they need to provide evidence that shows that the authorities are still viewing them with suspicion - all the evidence points to the fact that SY are not treating them as suspects, whether that's the case in Portugal is another matter.  I fully accept that the "sceptics" still think they are the key suspects, there's nothing I can say to change their opinion on the matter.

You are entitled to your beliefs.

I shall just stick with knowledge.

Could you stick to keeping your knowledge to yourself for a bit?  We know full well that you think we "rabid pros" are somewhat inferior beings with our silly (albeit harmless) beliefs and myths, no need to keep on and on about it is there? 8**8:/:

There is a choice: either posters (Pros or [ censored word]) can continue to shout their unsupported beliefs at each other, OR we can seek the truth- statements that are supported by evidence.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 11:53:11 AM
Debunker, what it boils down to is this (in my opinion) - if the McCanns are no longer suspects in their child's disappearance when once they were (which you seem to agree is the case), then they are in the clear. That's a lay person's term, and one that is perfectly acceptable and understandable to the vast majority of ordinary people.  Just because YOU don't accept it isn't going to stop me saying it.

If the "sceptics" want to say that the McCanns are still suspects as far as the police are concerned then they need to provide evidence that shows that the authorities are still viewing them with suspicion - all the evidence points to the fact that SY are not treating them as suspects, whether that's the case in Portugal is another matter.  I fully accept that the "sceptics" still think they are the key suspects, there's nothing I can say to change their opinion on the matter.

You are entitled to your beliefs.

I shall just stick with knowledge.

Could you stick to keeping your knowledge to yourself for a bit?  We know full well that you think we "rabid pros" are somewhat inferior beings with our silly (albeit harmless) beliefs and myths, no need to keep on and on about it is there? 8**8:/:

There is a choice: either posters (Pros or [ censored word]) can continue to shout their unsupported beliefs at each other, OR we can seek the truth- statements that are supported by evidence.

Debunker, as you are glued to your dictionary - please define 'tedious'
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 12:02:32 PM
1/ (verb) Registrars continued sniping on the UK Justice Forum
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: registrar on May 01, 2013, 12:05:37 PM
1/ (verb) Registrars continued sniping on the UK Justice Forum

incorrect

'tedious' is an adjective NOT a verb
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 01, 2013, 12:09:09 PM
1/ (verb) Registrars continued sniping on the UK Justice Forum

incorrect

'tedious' is an adjective NOT a verb

I knew you would say that.

Criticising grammar is tedious.

Go away (4,3)
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 01, 2013, 12:19:16 PM
Debunker, what it boils down to is this (in my opinion) - if the McCanns are no longer suspects in their child's disappearance when once they were (which you seem to agree is the case), then they are in the clear. That's a lay person's term, and one that is perfectly acceptable and understandable to the vast majority of ordinary people.  Just because YOU don't accept it isn't going to stop me saying it.

If the "sceptics" want to say that the McCanns are still suspects as far as the police are concerned then they need to provide evidence that shows that the authorities are still viewing them with suspicion - all the evidence points to the fact that SY are not treating them as suspects, whether that's the case in Portugal is another matter.  I fully accept that the "sceptics" still think they are the key suspects, there's nothing I can say to change their opinion on the matter.
Martha, the Portuguese authorities aren't viewing the McCanns with suspicion. This is over.
The public opinion is another story. Here in Portugal, most people avoid mentioning a case connoted with humiliation and ungratefulness, but in France, for example, people don't hesitate to express what will always weigh upon this poor family : doubt.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 04:56:28 PM
Quote
Mr Murat has rebuilt his life since he was cleared of all suspicion over Madeleine's disappearance and stands ready and willing to help.

Debunker, best you get onto the Express and tell them to stop peddling such outrageous myths!  8(>((

You trust the Express to use English correctly?

He has certainly been cleared in the minds of some people, maybe most, but there is still no legal procedure that clears anyone of any offence.

Do you believe the four compatriots of the murderers of Stephen Lawrence have been cleared?
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 05:49:14 PM
I trust the Express to use English correctly yes, though I don't trust them to always report accurately.  I don't think many people would quibble with the fact that Murat has been cleared of all suspicion - apart from you dear Deb. 

As for the Stephen Lawrence murderer compatriots - did they ever get formally cleared of suspicion in the way that Murat and the McCanns did, ie: in a final report which concluded that there was "a lack of evidence of any crime committed"?

They were tried and acquitted!
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 06:14:12 PM
I trust the Express to use English correctly yes, though I don't trust them to always report accurately.  I don't think many people would quibble with the fact that Murat has been cleared of all suspicion - apart from you dear Deb. 

As for the Stephen Lawrence murderer compatriots - did they ever get formally cleared of suspicion in the way that Murat and the McCanns did, ie: in a final report which concluded that there was "a lack of evidence of any crime committed"?

They were tried and acquitted!

Now that's rare on a forum ...  a literal QED moment !
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 06:22:26 PM
I trust the Express to use English correctly yes, though I don't trust them to always report accurately.  I don't think many people would quibble with the fact that Murat has been cleared of all suspicion - apart from you dear Deb. 

As for the Stephen Lawrence murderer compatriots - did they ever get formally cleared of suspicion in the way that Murat and the McCanns did, ie: in a final report which concluded that there was "a lack of evidence of any crime committed"?

They were tried and acquitted!

Now that's rare on a forum ...  a literal QED moment !

Yet they are currently under active investigation as suspects in the crime.

Presumed innocent  but still suspects. Not cleared at all.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 06:55:50 PM
I trust the Express to use English correctly yes, though I don't trust them to always report accurately.  I don't think many people would quibble with the fact that Murat has been cleared of all suspicion - apart from you dear Deb. 

As for the Stephen Lawrence murderer compatriots - did they ever get formally cleared of suspicion in the way that Murat and the McCanns did, ie: in a final report which concluded that there was "a lack of evidence of any crime committed"?

They were tried and acquitted!

OK - so if they were tried and acquitted were they not therefore cleared?  Or can you be acquitted and still not cleared?

Since the removal of the double jeopardy protection, even those found not guilty are not in any way permanently cleared.

You will find I am technically, factually and pedantically correct on the issues of "criminal clearance" and "evidence against suspects."

No-one has posted any reference which contradicts my assertions.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 07:03:28 PM
Martha,Gary Dobson and David Norris were acquitted originally  but recharged on new evidence found, after they could be when the double jeopardy law was changed in the UK, ie you can be tried again if new evidence is found even if acquitted first time.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 07:16:34 PM
I think that is what Debunker said Martha ie

Since the removal of the double jeopardy protection, even those found not guilty are not in any way permanently cleared.

Ie anyone cleared can be retried

Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 07:21:35 PM
I think that is what Debunker said Martha ie

Since the removal of the double jeopardy protection, even those found not guilty are not in any way permanently cleared.

Do you agree with him?  Sounds crazy to me.

Its the law of the UK, why not agree to it if new evidence potentially showing guilt of those acquitted comes out? Well, I suppose it should be strong evidence that shows the guilty might have got away on top of any original evidence they had
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 07:26:11 PM
This basically means that no one who has ever been acquitted in a court of law has been cleared, let alone the McCanns or Murat!  It is simply not possible to be cleared.  The phrase is obviously redundant.  Glad we've sorted that out then.

Thank you.

Now go and review the "evidence" thread.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 07:27:33 PM
This basically means that no one who has ever been acquitted in a court of law has been cleared, let alone the McCanns or Murat!  It is simply not possible to be cleared.  The phrase is obviously redundant.  Glad we've sorted that out then.

No it doesnt mean that at all

Other people may have been convicted of said crime after

As for the Mccanns or Murat his does not apply as they havent been tried

The Lawrence group were tried because evidence was found, they were charged and tried, all acquitted, shameful at the time, I hope they get the rest of them

Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 07:29:26 PM
I'll risk wikipedia:


England and Wales

In England and Wales, which share a common legal system, the Criminal Justice Act 2003 creates an exception to the double jeopardy rule, by providing that retrials may be ordered if "new and compelling evidence" comes to light after an acquittal for a serious crime. Also the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 permits a "tainted acquittal" to be set aside in circumstances where it is proved beyond reasonable doubt that an acquittal has been obtained by violence or threats of violence to a witness or juror/s.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acquittal
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 07:32:51 PM
This basically means that no one who has ever been acquitted in a court of law has been cleared, let alone the McCanns or Murat!  It is simply not possible to be cleared.  The phrase is obviously redundant.  Glad we've sorted that out then.

Thank you.

Now go and review the "evidence" thread.

 Don't thank me Deb, I think it's quite absurd.

I am non too keen on the dropping of double jeopardy.

But it fully supports my case about 'being cleared'- there is no formal procedure for this concept.

In Napoleonic Law countries (see Amanda Knox) only the superior courts can definitely clear people.
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 07:35:35 PM
Debunker is right on this one.

The murderers of Stephen Lawrence were tried twice and convicted second time around.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2012/jan/03/double-jeopardy-change-law-retrial
Title: Re: Myth: The McCanns have been cleared of any criminal charges
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 07:38:19 PM
This basically means that no one who has ever been acquitted in a court of law has been cleared, let alone the McCanns or Murat!  It is simply not possible to be cleared.  The phrase is obviously redundant.  Glad we've sorted that out then.

No it doesnt mean that at all



According to Debunker that's exactly what it means.

see my amended post earlier