UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on May 04, 2013, 11:27:28 PM

Title: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: John on May 04, 2013, 11:27:28 PM
Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment.

Former Maddie suspect Robert Murat says key 48 hours must be re-enacted and that police probe is a mess!

  (http://i.imgur.com/LsW0OE6.jpg)
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 04, 2013, 11:29:31 PM
Is this a new story ?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: sammy on May 04, 2013, 11:35:07 PM
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 04, 2013, 11:36:20 PM
Which  '48 hours'  is he refering to, I wonder
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: John on May 04, 2013, 11:36:59 PM
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.

He must be really pissed at being named as a suspect by members of the tapas 9.  It must have damaged his business interests no end and after he went out of his way to assist them?  There's gratitude for you?

Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 04, 2013, 11:38:20 PM
he got a very big payout years ago
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 04, 2013, 11:42:16 PM
My eye sight  not that good  (  any 20/20's here, who can read that small print ? )
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 04, 2013, 11:56:49 PM
Is he saying that Scotland should bring them back for a reconstruction  ?

Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 12:01:02 AM
Is he saying that Scotland should bring them back for a reconstruction  ?

where did you get that from?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 12:03:24 AM
Is he saying that Scotland should bring them back for a reconstruction  ?

where did you get that from?

The only words I can make are 'Scotland Yard'  ...  that's why I was asking
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: puglove on May 05, 2013, 12:16:12 AM
Is he saying that Scotland should bring them back for a reconstruction  ?

where did you get that from?

Why, six years down the line, have none of you got anything? The dogs, the attacks on the Mccanns, the rubbish about blood and scents, the finding of death in a car that they rented after she was taken? Can't you all see how crazy this all is? Can anyone of you look at Kate and consider, for a single moment, that she was involved in the loss of her child?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 12:18:16 AM
Is he saying that Scotland should bring them back for a reconstruction  ?

where did you get that from?

Why, six years down the line, have none of you got anything? The dogs, the attacks on the Mccanns, the rubbish about blood and scents, the finding of death in a car that they rented after she was taken? Can't you all see how crazy this all is? Can anyone of you look at Kate and consider, for a single moment, that she was involved in the loss of her child?

No
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 12:51:35 AM
My eye sight  not that good  (  any 20/20's here, who can read that small print ? )

The small print on the front page of the paper.

Quote
Robert Murat today appeals for Scotland Yard to stage a filmed reconstruction of all the events surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann. 

Marking the sixth anniversary of her abduction, the Algarve-based businessman says a 48-hour timeline would help police conducting a £4.5 million review of the case.

Mr Murat, who was cleared as a suspect, said "They need to start..."
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 12:53:18 AM
My eye sight  not that good  (  any 20/20's here, who can read that small print ? )

The small print on the front page of the paper.

Quote
Robert Murat today appeals for Scotland Yard to stage a filmed reconstruction of all the events surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann. 

Marking the sixth anniversary of her abduction, the Algarve-based businessman says a 48-hour timeline would help police conducting a £4.5 million review of the case.

Mr Murat, who was cleared as a suspect, said "They need to start..."

Thanks gilet
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 12:53:36 AM
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.

He must be really pissed at being named as a suspect by members of the tapas 9.  It must have damaged his business interests no end and after he went out of his way to assist them?  There's gratitude for you?

That could be a motive. Alternatively he may have got wind that they are once again interested in him as a suspect. We can but guess at this stage.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: muratfan on May 05, 2013, 12:54:09 AM
Think it would be better to wait for the whole story to appear
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 12:59:03 AM
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.

He must be really pissed at being named as a suspect by members of the tapas 9.  It must have damaged his business interests no end and after he went out of his way to assist them?  There's gratitude for you?

That could be a motive. Alternatively he may have got wind that they are once again interested in him as a suspect. We can but guess at this stage.

Or maybe the papers have got wind of something  ...  is there a possibility, do you think,  that Scotland Yard are already considering doing a reconstruction ?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: muratfan on May 05, 2013, 01:01:11 AM
Oh dear some ......... arwe getting in a tizz over this. Wonder how they will react when they read the story? Wonder why he speaks out now??
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 01:36:52 AM
Oh dear some ......... arwe getting in a tizz over this. Wonder how they will react when they read the story? Wonder why he speaks out now??

And why is the Express quoting him now ? 

It's been years since there was a front page headline as  'McCann unfriendly'  as that !
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 07:08:01 AM
Looks like that was an early edition Front Page Filler. Current article is completely different emphasis:

http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle

(http://i.imgur.com/JNdquSV.jpg)


Police must keep up effort to solve Madeleine riddle

SIX years have now passed since Madeleine McCann went missing during a family holiday in Portugal.

Published: Sun, May 5, 2013


It is now six years since Madeleine McCann went missing

Despite their unimaginable suffering, parents Kate and Gerry have campaigned without rest to keep their daughter's case in the public eye and maintain pressure on the police for that vital resolution.

So we can only hope that the couple are justified in their current belief that a significant breakthrough in the case is just around the corner.

In two years, the £4.5million case review by homicide detectives at Scotland Yard has failed to shed new light on events of that evening in 2007 or to persuade the Portuguese authorities to reopen the investigation.

No one expects Operation Grange to provide a running commentary on its review but revelations that Scotland Yard has yet to interview key witness and former suspect Robert Murat must surely raise questions.

The search must continue for Madeleine McCann

No matter how terrible the case, Scotland Yard must account for the public money being spent in pursuit of the truth.

Mr Murat has rebuilt his life since he was cleared of all suspicion over Madeleine's disappearance and stands ready and willing to help.

He cannot understand why a full reconstruction of the night has not been conducted and believes other key witnesses have also not been reinterviewed.

No matter how terrible the case, Scotland Yard must account for the public money being spent in pursuit of the truth.

Questions must be asked as to whether all key witnesses will be reinterviewed and, if not, why not? The passage of time must not render the search for Madeleine any less exhaustive.


http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 08:12:19 AM
Not so.

Oddly the Express have put up three separate McCann stories within the last two hours.  Yours was just the first of the three to be posted.

The headline story begins exactly as the front page shown last night did.

(http://i1296.photobucket.com/albums/ag1/gilet2013/exp568_zps51c31c50.jpg)

http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle (http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle)

(http://i1296.photobucket.com/albums/ag1/gilet2013/exp570_zps9f907040.jpg)

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397235/McCanns-light-candles-for-April-Jones-at-emotional-service (http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397235/McCanns-light-candles-for-April-Jones-at-emotional-service)

(http://i1296.photobucket.com/albums/ag1/gilet2013/exp569_zps1139241d.jpg)

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397244/Bring-them-all-back-to-Portugal (http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397244/Bring-them-all-back-to-Portugal)
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 08:16:33 AM
He [murat] cannot understand why a full reconstruction of the night has not been conducted and believes other key witnesses have also not been reinterviewed.

Murat would not be privy to that information.

I think this is The Express fishing for a slant ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 08:19:22 AM
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397244/Bring-them-all-back-to-Portugal (http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397244/Bring-them-all-back-to-Portugal)

'Bring them all back to Portugal’

ROBERT MURAT today appeals for Scotland Yard to stage a filmed reconstruction of all the events surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

By: James Murray
Published: Sun, May 5, 2013

(http://images.dailyexpress.co.uk/img/dynamic/1/590x/robert-murat-397244.jpg)
 Robert Murat was cleared as a suspect long ago (Sunday Express photographer Mark Kehoe)

Marking the sixth anniversary of her abduction, the Algarve-based businessman says a 48-hour timeline would help police conducting a £4.5million review of the case.

Mr Murat, who was cleared as a suspect, said: “They need to start from the beginning.” So far the two-year review by more than 20 detectives in London has not led to a breakthrough.

Portugal’s authorities have not been persuaded to reopen the investigation, although Policia Judiciaria policewoman Helena Monteiro liaises regularly with officers from the Yard’s Operation Grange.

Mr Murat, 39, spoke to the Sunday Express while sipping tea in Casa ¬Liliana, his elderly mother Jenny’s villa 150 yards from apartment 5a of the Ocean Club where Madeleine vanished.

He said: “They need to speak to everybody, including myself, and they need to get the Portuguese involved in a much more constructive way.

“To get somewhere now they need to have a joint team working here together in Praia da Luz. This is where it happened. It didn’t happen in England.

“The reconstruction should cover the critical period just before and after the abduction.”

Madeleine was three when she disappeared from the apartment at about 9.15pm while her parents Kate and Gerry McCann and seven friends ate at a tapas bar nearby. When the Judiciaria named the McCanns as suspects, they and their friends chose not to take part in a PJ-led reconstruction. It would be different now that they have been cleared, said Mr Murat.

He said: “A reconstruction is a real necessity. I am sure it would fill in some of the missing pieces of the jigsaw. Even now after all this time, the timeline is still confused.”

Thirteen days after Madeleine’s disappearance Mr Murat was named as a suspect. His mother’s home, where he lived then, was searched, his computers were taken, he was questioned for 19 hours by Portuguese police and his property business was wrecked.

His eagerness to help with the original investigation, helping police with translations, aroused a journalist’s suspicions. Three of the McCanns’ friends believed they saw him on the night Madeleine vanished but his mother confirmed to police he was with her all night at Casa Liliana.

After being cleared as a suspect in July 2008 he won substantial damages from newspapers.

Despite his ordeal he believes Madeleine’s fate should be uppermost in everybody’s minds as another anniversary passes.

He said: “You cannot lose sight of the fact that a child was taken and we need to know what happened to her.”
He is still willing to be interviewed by the review team, which has made no effort to contact him. “I have no problem with that whatsoever,” he said emphatically.

“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again. The timeline needs to be made crystal clear because there is still so much confusion, such a mess.”

(http://images.dailyexpress.co.uk/img/dynamic/1/590x/secondary/31839.jpg)
 Madeleine aged three in Everton shirt

“Police need to be here, not England “ - Robert Murat

Asked if he thought Madeleine’s fate would ever be known, he brushed back his thick dark brown hair, rubbed his tanned chin and said: “I hope so, I believe it will come out one day.” He said Portugal’s financial crisis means “if the British do want to get to the bottom of this, it is a case of funding the Portuguese”.

Mr Murat, who grew up in Devon and Portugal, now has a young family with wife Michaela. They were both victims of the relentless media frenzy when Madeleine vanished and it has left its scars. For the first time during the interview he became emotional and said in a whisper: “There is no way to describe the impact this has had on our lives. Six years later it still affects me. I wasn’t able to do much for years and years.

“It was difficult getting back on the horse, so to speak, and do the stuff I was doing before.”

His property business went, partly because his computers were held by the PJ for so long, but now he has built up Newteq, an Apple-authorised service provider on the Algarve. He said he and Michaela live a quiet life, staying away from some events because people still come up to him and say: “You’re that Mr Murat.”

Before 2007 he says he was one of those people who was always eager to help others, to get involved in the community. Now he is more guarded.

When the original police investigation was at its height, he bumped into a British man, Steve Carpenter, who persuaded him to meet the McCanns because they needed his language skills. He said: “I met Gerry and said: ‘I don’t know what to say, there is nothing I can say but I do speak Portuguese and English and I will help in any way I can’.”

He helped Portugal’s GNR military officers to search the Ocean Club apartments and translated statements from key witnesses, giving him a unique inside perspective on the case.

He said: “From the experiences of the interviews there are some points that could be looked at.

“There needs to be much more transparency, much more openness to dissipate a lot of the stuff that has been talked about on the internet and on blogs.”

He does not believe the results of the Yard’s work should be made available to the public.

“The Yard needs to get together with the Portuguese police and ¬produce a final report,” he said. “They need to sit down together and come up with a final version, a structured report.

“The report should be done by the Portuguese with the support of the British.”

Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead.

On Friday night Kate and Gerry, both 45, gathered around a candle which burns night and day for Madeleine outside their home village of Rothley, Leicestershire. A 50-strong crowd supported them as they marked the anniversary with prayers with Madeleine’s ¬siblings, eight-year-old twins Sean and Amelie.

Mr Murat said: “It must be a ¬tremendously difficult time of year for them and of course as a human being you feel for them and for the loss of their daughter.

“At this time of year, like so many people on the Algarve, we have been thinking about this poor girl.

“I just hope in the months ahead the PJ are fully involved because in my view that is the best way of solving the mystery.”

At St Vincent’s church in Praia da Luz, where Kate and Gerry went regularly, worshippers also prayed for Madeleine, whose 10th birthday is on May 12.

Clarence Mitchell, the McCanns’ spokesman, declined to comment on Mr Murat’s views last night, saying the couple were happy with how Scotland Yard is conducting the review.

Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 08:23:15 AM
He [murat] cannot understand why a full reconstruction of the night has not been conducted and believes other key witnesses have also not been reinterviewed.

Murat would not be privy to that information.

I think this is The Express fishing for a slant ...

He is probably simply referring to other people he personally knows from the PDL area. If they told him that they had not been contacted by the review team it would be reasonable for him to suppose that they were telling him the truth.

As for your second point about fishing for a slant. I agree but not for the reason you have suggested.

Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: John on May 05, 2013, 08:36:44 AM
Icabodcrane.   You mentioned something about Scotland Yard earlier.  Just for clarity, Scotland Yard has nothing to do with Scotland.  Scotland Yard relates to the headquarters of the Metropolitan Police Service, the territorial police force responsible for policing most of London.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scotland_Yard   
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: John on May 05, 2013, 08:40:01 AM
My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 08:54:12 AM
It looks like the Express were determined to fill today's paper with McCann stories. They managed three separate angles and put them all up within an hour and a half this morning. Interesting.

The headline (front page of the print edition) story about Murat is one angle. They have gone out to PDL to interview him about his current position on the case.

HIs view seems to be that the Review done solely in London is not sufficient, that the PJ should be involved, that the UK police should work with the PJ in Portugal, that the UK should pay for the PJ to become involved and that a full videoed reconstruction should be part of their involvement.

I don't think anyone can really argue against any of those propositions. It probably is the best way forward.

It is a great shame that the PJ refused point blank to conduct such a reconstruction when people would have been available, when the events were uppermost in the minds of all involved and when far more people were present in PDL who could participate just a few weeks after the disappearance.

I have a recollection of an interview Murat gave previously in which he suggested he was not enamoured of the methods of the PJ in this case and I wonder if his desire to have UK police involvement relates to this?  I wonder if he would prefer them to be involved in questioning of the witnesses, in the organisation of a reconstruction etc. I suspect the McCanns would have similar views too.

One interesting point they stress twice (in the article and in the photo tag) is that he was cleared. As the only clearing occurred in the Archival Dispatch when all three arguidos had that title lifted from them it would appear to mean that the Express believe that the McCanns were also cleared at the same time.

And another interesting point is that there was no attempt to get any comment from the PJ or SY about the story.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 09:11:55 AM
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 09:24:37 AM
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 09:28:06 AM
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: sika on May 05, 2013, 09:29:20 AM
My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
You would think that Mr Murat would want to disappear into obscurity.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Chinagirl on May 05, 2013, 09:31:02 AM
Why?  He's done nothing wrong.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 09:35:13 AM
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.

It is the kind of risk that the Express and a few other papers seem perfectly willing to take. Its not the kind of libel that will ever cost them money so what is the issue?

I don't treat the content of papers by rules. I simply mistrust the content if they don't provide evidence for the claims they make. I have the same attitude to posts on forums and blogs too.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: sika on May 05, 2013, 09:38:06 AM
Why?  He's done nothing wrong.
I formed that opinion having read the news paper article. It sounds like Murat has been to hell and back. Therefore, I would have thought that he would want to disappear into obscurity.
Unfortunately, whether its true or not, his participation in this article, looks like a money making enterprise.
Perhaps he was not paid or simply donated his fee to charity. Would be nice to know.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 09:38:59 AM
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.

It is the kind of risk that the Express and a few other papers seem perfectly willing to take. Its not the kind of libel that will ever cost them money so what is the issue?

I don't treat the content of papers by rules. I simply mistrust the content if they don't provide evidence for the claims they make. I have the same attitude to posts on forums and blogs too.

Scepticism is one thing, distrust is another. If we are to interpret the political world, inferences need to be drawn from incomplete information.

Potentially deniable but undenied statements are at least worthy of initial belief. Not convincing but certainly directive.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 09:51:05 AM
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.

It is the kind of risk that the Express and a few other papers seem perfectly willing to take. Its not the kind of libel that will ever cost them money so what is the issue?

I don't treat the content of papers by rules. I simply mistrust the content if they don't provide evidence for the claims they make. I have the same attitude to posts on forums and blogs too.

Scepticism is one thing, distrust is another. If we are to interpret the political world, inferences need to be drawn from incomplete information.

Potentially deniable but undenied statements are at least worthy of initial belief. Not convincing but certainly directive.

Clearly we disagree on this issue. My scepticism/distrust (however you prefer to look upon it) stems from a very long interaction with the UK media. Articles about my own father's career, for example, which range over a number of decades back as far as the 1950s and in which there was no real desire on the part of the journalists even of some of the more reputable papers to be accurate in their stories.  Though the stories were almost always favourable towards him, there were invariably exaggerations and inaccuracies which could easily have been corrected but were not because they made for a better story.

I am open-minded as to the possibility of such a meeting between the McCanns and Cameron but without evidence I won't be accepting it as fact.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Angelo222 on May 05, 2013, 09:54:51 AM
My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
You would think that Mr Murat would want to disappear into obscurity.

Clearly the Express have taken a throw away comment by Murat about a possible reconstruction and spun it into a front page sensation in order to flog their tainted product. 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: gilet on May 05, 2013, 10:03:38 AM
My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
You would think that Mr Murat would want to disappear into obscurity.

Clearly the Express have taken a throw away comment by Murat about a possible reconstruction and spun it into a front page sensation in order to flog their tainted product.

I think that is an excellent summary of the article.

I am still wondering though whether the motive for Murat talking to the journalist about his desire for UK police involvement in the investigation in Portugal is related to what he said last April.  I know under the circumstances I would prefer a UK cop to be around during interviews.



Approx 10.50 - 12.50
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 12:47:15 PM
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.

He must be really pissed at being named as a suspect by members of the tapas 9.  It must have damaged his business interests no end and after he went out of his way to assist them?  There's gratitude for you?

He wasn't named as a suspect, by the Tapas 9, though John. They didn't know his name, for one, and the 3 that said he was there that night, did not include Jane.
IMO, Amaral pushed and pushed, for Jane Tanner to be framed as pointing him out, when she did not.
He lied about her pointing him out, in his book.

Don't forget he's good at getting to the (cough) truth as Murat says. He was gonna get him one way or another.

Quote
ROBERT MURAT: He basically told me it was a game of two halves and as the night before I hadn’t confessed, erm, then, he would get me on the second half and he just kind of turned his back on me. He didn’t… He just… It seemed he didn’t care about the truth. That was the, thats how I felt.

As for his business interests

Quote
His property business went, partly because his computers were held by the PJ for so long, but now he has built up Newteq, an Apple-authorised service provider on the Algarve.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 01:10:22 PM
IMO, Amaral pushed and pushed, for Jane Tanner to be framed as pointing him out, when she did not.
He lied about her pointing him out, in his book.


Agreed!

I think a concerted effort was made to push Murat off the agenda and (as Amaral hoped!) leave all paths clear that led to the McCanns' door.

I believe that included corrupting Martin Smith's statement so that it did not contradict Murat's alibi of spending the night with his mother.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 01:42:09 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Eleanor on May 05, 2013, 01:47:58 PM

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 01:48:49 PM
My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?

It is a long time ago now, and IIRC SY have made appeals last year on Crimewatch to anyone who was around at the time to come forward. We are not privy to that information and what has transpired. Robert Murat has a point, attempting a reconstruction with as many people as possible as were there on the night, or as Murat says the previous two days might be fruitful.

In the Stephen Lawrence case, they are still making appeals 20 years later. There are other cases where reconstructions were done years after as well and yielded new information.

If SY, who are on an unlimited budget of millions, and timescale, recommend this, it will not look good if the Tapas group refuse to go back IMO, that is if a reconstruction is part of SY's remit.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 01:56:23 PM

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 02:04:22 PM

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

Why would they need to be   'forced'   

The McCanns have expressed their full confidence in Scotland Yard and the progress they are making with the review.  If a reconstruction were to be advised and requested by the Yard,  then the McCanns, and their friends,  would surely have no grounds on which to object and refuse

Why did Clarence Mitchell not confirm that when the story was run past him ?  ...  why did did he say No comment ? 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 02:22:37 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter

There is nothing remarkable about it - it's a way of selling papers and about as far as the Express dares go to publish a story with an angle that will appeal to those with an appetite for McCann-related scandal, gossip and intrigue.

Well it is remarkable Martha ...  the fact that you are  'remarking' on it is testimony in itself

Something else that I find remarkable is that having already spent four and a half million pounds on this review, Scotland Yard have not even spoken to Robert Murat

Four and a half  million pounds later  ...  and they havn't even spoken to the man who was an official suspect and Arguido !
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 02:28:01 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter

Does seem odd, doesn't it?

Considering how scared he was of the PJ, Amaral mainly, seems odd he's opened his mouth now, when he's got to live there.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Eleanor on May 05, 2013, 02:47:38 PM

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

Let's put it this way.  It ain't going to happen.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 03:21:09 PM

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

Let's put it this way.  It ain't going to happen.

There is something not sitting right with me about that interview - after all, why would the Yard interview Murat? He wasn't there, he saw nothing due to being in his mum's kitchen. So how could he be in a reconstruction?
 
IMO, he's acting almost as he did 6 years ago when he ended up being likened to Ian Huntley.
 
He's been cleared, he SHOULDN'T have been able to see anything, so why is he attracting attention to himself again?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 03:30:09 PM

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

Let's put it this way.  It ain't going to happen.

There is something not sitting right with me about that interview - after all, why would the Yard interview Murat? He wasn't there, he saw nothing due to being in his mum's kitchen. So how could he be in a reconstruction?
 
IMO, he's acting almost as he did 6 years ago when he ended up being likened to Ian Huntley.
 
He's been cleared, he SHOULDN'T have been able to see anything, so why is he attracting attention to himself again?

Maybe  he isn't attracting attention to himself ...  maybe  he was actively persued by Express reporters  ( the reporter was in Murat's mother's home afterall  )

Maybe the Express wanted to  'get it out there'  that the Yard have spent a fortune and not even done the most fundemental investigation on the ground to justify that expense

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 03:33:53 PM
Perhaps he is expressing an opinion on the case and its current status. He was after all made an arguido at the time, and was in the thick of everything for months if not more, he has as much right as anyone else to do so and probably more right than scores of outside  commentators who probably knew diddly squat.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 04:02:30 PM

Maybe  he isn't attracting attention to himself ...  maybe  he was actively persued by Express reporters  ( the reporter was in Murat's mother's home afterall  )

Maybe the Express wanted to  'get it out there'  that the Yard have spent a fortune and not even done the most fundemental investigation on the ground to justify that expense

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction

Maybe  he isn't attracting attention to himself ...  maybe  he was actively persued by Express reporters  ( the reporter was in Murat's mother's home afterall  )

If he was pursued by the Express, why not decline comment, like he has for 6 years. Being in his mothers villa, makes it even more suspect. Murray would have to have been invited in, its like Fort Knox, getting into that villa.

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction

Do you think Murat, is that dumb?  Unless the Euro's were high, why would the Express need him as their mouth piece. Have you thought that maybe SY have been denied being allowed to do a reconstruction

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction.

Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 04:16:09 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 04:22:23 PM

 

If he was pursued by the Express, why not decline comment, like he has for 6 years. Being in his mothers villa, makes it even more suspect. Murray would have to have been invited in, its like Fort Knox, getting into that villa.



Why on earth should Robert Murat   'decline'  an invitation from the press to offer his opinion ?

Is he expected to keep his mouth shut for some reason ?

...  and what is 'suspicious'  about him having taken the opportunity to express an opinion on a suject that has so affected his life ?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 04:32:33 PM
 8((()*/
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Benice on May 05, 2013, 04:37:35 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.


Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 04:39:24 PM

 

If he was pursued by the Express, why not decline comment, like he has for 6 years. Being in his mothers villa, makes it even more suspect. Murray would have to have been invited in, its like Fort Knox, getting into that villa.



Why on earth should Robert Murat   'decline'  an invitation from the press to offer his opinion ?

Is he expected to keep his mouth shut for some reason ?

...  and what is 'suspicious'  about him having taken the opportunity to express an opinion on a suject that has so affected his life ?

One answer to your 3 questions, Why now?  8-)(--)
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 04:43:33 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ? 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 04:50:40 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Yes and apparently Metado3 gave them some good info, that was not acted upon, by Amaral.

But he's not a key witness, is he? He wasn't there, remember!
So if he suddenly knows something, that might help SY now, he's lied for 6 years. He can't have it both ways!
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 04:57:09 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Yes and apparently Metado3 gave them some good info, that was not acted upon, by Amaral.

But he's not a key witness, is he? He wasn't there, remember!
So if he suddenly knows something, that might help SY now, he's lied for 6 years. He can't have it both ways!

He acted as translator in those early police interviews didn't he ?  ...  he knows plenty

And as to the criminal Metado 3 crew ...  whatever they turned over to Scotland Yard wasn't that  good was it ?  ...  certainly not good enough to get the case re-opened in Portugal   
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 05:00:24 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.
It was a rhetorical question to DCI suggesting he is a nobody in the case, and being so indignant about him having the temerity to dare speak LOL  that is all
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 05:03:37 PM


Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Crooked shower, well said
 8((()*/

Well crooked and also proven liars

I hope SY have the remit to interview Kevin Halligen as well and asking him what he did with the half a million pounds the Mccanns say they gave him
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 05:52:49 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 05:56:55 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

 8((()*/
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 05:58:15 PM
I presume he knows that he can contact SY any time he wants?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 06:02:28 PM
He could have flown back with James Murray could'nt he?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 06:03:57 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Where do you think SY got, eight important new leads, from?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 06:07:20 PM
Quote
Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

they went to collect the information that they held.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 06:08:12 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Where do you think SY got, eight important new leads, from?

...  and where, exactly, did those 'important'  leads,  lead  them  ?

That's right ....  no-where
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 06:09:50 PM
Quote
Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

so should everyone involved after the event be interviewed - all the translators etc? Everyone who searched etc?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 06:13:20 PM
Should everyone who were in their kitchen sitting with Mum be re-interviewed?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 06:14:05 PM
 He is speaking out now cos it is the anniversary, the Express wanted to cover it and they probably paid him for the interview.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 06:24:40 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Where do you think SY got, eight important new leads, from?

...  and where, exactly, did those 'important'  leads,  lead  them  ?

That's right ....  no-where

AH, but how do you know that? Have SY informed you?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 07:00:20 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Where do you think SY got, eight important new leads, from?

...  and where, exactly, did those 'important'  leads,  lead  them  ?

That's right ....  no-where

AH, but how do you know that? Have SY informed you?

They would have informed the Portuguese police  ...  who would have re-opened the case if the  'leads'   had been of significance at all 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Carana on May 05, 2013, 07:46:01 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter


I'm not sure that the Express and the McCanns are the best of friends...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 07:49:22 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter


I'm not sure that the Express and the McCanns are the best of friends...

I think I'm right that The Express has to tread carefully with the McCanns because, having libelled them once, the editor could actually go to prison if the paper transgresses a second time.

I think that's the case, an impression I gained from somewhere. 

Perhaps Jean Pierre could help us out here?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 07:51:30 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter


I'm not sure that the Express and the McCanns are the best of friends...

I think I'm right that The Express has to tread carefully with the McCanns because, having libelled them once, the editor could actually go to prison if the paper transgresses a second time.

I think that's the case, an impression I gained from somewhere. 

Perhaps Jean Pierre could help us out here?


LOL nice try no cigar, mccanns got an out of court settllement so any talk of prison is a joke
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 07:58:16 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 08:01:36 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 08:03:24 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

and you've asked them lately?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:05:31 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

The McCanns and friends were more than happy to do a recon in May 2007 when events would have been fresh in their minds... it was kyboshed by the PJ.  When the holiday friends were asked to return in 2008 it had become clear that the PJs motives were to stitch up Kate and Gerry McCann, so the holiday party quite rightly refused.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 08:12:07 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

The McCanns and friends were more than happy to do a recon in May 2007 when events would have been fresh in their minds... it was kyboshed by the PJ.  When the holiday friends were asked to return in 2008 it had become clear that the PJs motives were to stitch up Kate and Gerry McCann, so the holiday party quite rightly refused.

The point,   is that it is Murat who is asking for a reconstruction 'now'  ( under Scotland Yard's auspices )  ...  the McCanns and their buds are not   
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Benice on May 05, 2013, 08:15:17 PM
Quote from Andy Redwood.

''We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to have been removed from that apartment alive.''

End quote

I presume they have conducted a computer simulated reconstruction and therefore will not be requiring a physical one.
No doubt they have shared this information with their counterparts in Portugal.


Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:15:27 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

The McCanns and friends were more than happy to do a recon in May 2007 when events would have been fresh in their minds... it was kyboshed by the PJ.  When the holiday friends were asked to return in 2008 it had become clear that the PJs motives were to stitch up Kate and Gerry McCann, so the holiday party quite rightly refused.

The point,   is that it is Murat who is asking for a reconstruction 'now'  ( under Scotland Yard's auspices )  ...  the McCanns and their buds are not


And? Murat has no business asking for a reconstruction - he wasn't there when Madeleine went missing, so what has it got to do with him?. It's not for him to ask for a recon.  The McCanns and the holiday party were more than willing in May 2007 but the ever-bungling PJ put the brakes on it. 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:16:45 PM
Quote from Andy Redwood.

''We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to have been removed from that apartment alive.''

End quote

I presume they have conducted a computer simulated reconstruction and therefore will not be requiring a physical one.
No doubt they have shared this information with their counterparts in Portugal.


 8@??)(
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 08:23:05 PM
Had Madeleine been abducted from the OC

it would have taken someone with local knowledge
to carry this out

John Stalker stated this

and who am I to argue with that guy? 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 08:26:38 PM
Had Madeleine been abducted from the OC

it would have taken someone with local knowledge
to carry this out

John Stalker stated this

and who am I to argue with that guy?

Is that the same one who said the mccanns are hiding a big sexret? Surely not
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-490254/McCanns-hiding-big-secret-police-chief-claims.html




Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 08:29:45 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

The McCanns and friends were more than happy to do a recon in May 2007 when events would have been fresh in their minds... it was kyboshed by the PJ.  When the holiday friends were asked to return in 2008 it had become clear that the PJs motives were to stitch up Kate and Gerry McCann, so the holiday party quite rightly refused.

The point,   is that it is Murat who is asking for a reconstruction 'now'  ( under Scotland Yard's auspices )  ...  the McCanns and their buds are not


And? Murat has no business asking for a reconstruction - he wasn't there when Madeleine went missing, so what has it got to do with him?. It's not for him to ask for a recon.  The McCanns and the holiday party were more than willing in May 2007 but the ever-bungling PJ put the brakes on it.

I agree that the  "Bring them all back to Portugal" command does sound arrogant and accusary,  and that he has no right to be making such a demand

The Express gave him a flatform from which to it though,  for some reason 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 08:31:06 PM
I guess John didn't know about the secrecy laws ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 08:32:33 PM
Had Madeleine been abducted from the OC

it would have taken someone with local knowledge
to carry this out

John Stalker stated this

and who am I to argue with that guy?

Is that the same one who said the mccanns are hiding a big sexret? Surely not
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-490254/McCanns-hiding-big-secret-police-chief-claims.html

SEXRET?????  PAMPAS GRASS????

oh not that old chestnut again Redblossom
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 08:35:34 PM
I always wonder, why Murat apparently told journalists, his daughter was called Madeleine.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 08:39:44 PM
I always wonder, why Murat apparently told journalists, his daughter was called Madeleine.

I don't think he exactly said that.

I seem to recall he made some comparison between Madeleine and his own daughter Kate took exception to.

But I don't recall exactly what he said ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 08:40:03 PM
I always wonder, why Murat apparently told journalists, his daughter was called Madeleine.

I did not know that - I recall how Bob stated that his own child looked an awful lot like Madeleine

But that was in the early days - six years ago
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 08:41:20 PM
I always wonder, why Murat apparently told journalists, his daughter was called Madeleine.

I did not know that - I recall how Bob stated that his own child looked an awful lot like Madeleine

But that was in the early days - six years ago

Ah, maybe that was it ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 05, 2013, 08:52:02 PM
I always wonder, why Murat apparently told journalists, his daughter was called Madeleine.

I did not know that - I recall how Bob stated that his own child looked an awful lot like Madeleine

But that was in the early days - six years ago

Ah, maybe that was it ...

Not according to Paolo Reiss.

by Paolo Reiss - Gazeta Digital

"20.5.07 Madeleine McCann’s abduction - Special Report (05:05 am, May 20 - 2007)

Robert Murat was under close police surveillance since the morning of May 4, the day after Madeleine was abducted.
The main suspect (and only one, until now) in the Madeleine McCann abduction, Robert Murat, was under close police surveillance since the morning of May 4, the following day to the child disappearance. From that moment on, all of his movements and contacts were monitored by investigators of Polícia Judiciária (PJ - Portuguese Criminal Investigation Department).

On the early hours of that day, after the first journalists arrived at the local, Murat was near the Ocean Club and talked with several of them. Casually dressed, with jeans, blue plastic sandals and a blue and white chequered shirt, Murat took the initiative to talk with two Portuguese journalists, saying that he knew very well Madeleine’s parents, that they were both doctors, and he was “deeply disturbed with the abduction, because he had a three year old daughter who, by coincidence, was also called Madeleine”.
His daughter, as was later revealed, is called Sophia.


During that day, Murat seemed to be everywhere, helping British journalists with translations, buying water in Batista supermarket to take to the GNR policemen guarding the area, asking if there was any news about Madeleine and even giving some predictions, like: “They will never find the child, probably she is already in Spain”, one the first Portuguese journalists at the crime scene told Gazeta Digital. These kinds of comments were also reported by British journalists.

Next day, May 5, Saturday, he followed the same pattern.
That day, around 7:00 pm, a Portuguese journalist saw him sitting at a table of Batista’s supermarket terrace, chatting with a young man – the Russian computer expert Sergei Malinka who was also questioned by police and is a witness in this case. Murat and Malinka were here, sitting side by side, on Saturday May 5.

But on Sunday, according to Portuguese journalists, Murat seemed to have vanished. Most of them say they never saw him, but some say that he was there, sporadically, and adopting a lower profile. After Sunday, May 6, he didn’t showed up, at all. British Press reported that he went to UK, for a couple of days, and then back to Portugal. Gazeta Digital has learned that Portuguese police was able to get extensive and detailed footage of Murat’s movements and contacts, while he was among journalists and police officers or inside the Ocean Club, during those days. "
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 09:12:30 PM
Is he saying that Scotland should bring them back for a reconstruction  ?

where did you get that from?

Why, six years down the line, have none of you got anything? The dogs, the attacks on the Mccanns, the rubbish about blood and scents, the finding of death in a car that they rented after she was taken? Can't you all see how crazy this all is? Can anyone of you look at Kate and consider, for a single moment, that she was involved in the loss of her child?

I agree with all of the above

and I would have abandoned posting many moons ago - what's the point - only characters on a screen?

But that would leave the h a t e rs/jealous types/disenfranchised/bottom feeders

with an open playing field for their malice and abuse

And that must not happen - the ugly people will not win on this issue

I'm in this for the long run

If not on here - than elsewhere
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 09:15:32 PM
Paolo Reiss

cough

we are going into the trivial now

from here to Macau
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: debunker on May 05, 2013, 09:16:32 PM
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter


I'm not sure that the Express and the McCanns are the best of friends...

I think I'm right that The Express has to tread carefully with the McCanns because, having libelled them once, the editor could actually go to prison if the paper transgresses a second time.

I think that's the case, an impression I gained from somewhere. 

Perhaps Jean Pierre could help us out here?


LOL nice try no cigar, mccanns got an out of court settllement so any talk of prison is a joke

And you don't understand the law about torts either. It was not an 'out ofcourt' settlement, it was a settlement agreed brfore a judge- a different thing entirely.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 09:27:56 PM
Quote
LOL nice try no cigar, mccanns got an out of court settllement so any talk of prison is a joke

I cite Mccanns -v- Bennett
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 09:29:30 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

At least they won't have to close the airspace (quote from amaral) to watch him chat to Mum in the kitchen
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 09:31:52 PM
I was with my mum in the kitchen all night chatting

while that is endearing ---  naarrrrrrr   --- Botox - writ large
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 09:38:26 PM
And I have yet to come across ANYONE who can explain Jenny Murat's

VW van on the seaside - inviting folks to give info about Madeleine's disappearance

who would not go to the police

THAT, frankly does not compute on any level
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 09:41:23 PM
And you don't understand the law about torts either. It was not an 'out ofcourt' settlement, it was a settlement agreed brfore a judge- a different thing entirely.

***

So sorry debunker I dont understand tort, I havent studied it, but do pls explain if the express journalists would face jail after an out of court settlement which was the question if they printed another unhelpful story
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 09:52:45 PM
And I have yet to come across ANYONE who can explain Jenny Murat's

VW van on the seaside - inviting folks to give info about Madeleine's disappearance

who would not go to the police

THAT, frankly does not compute on any level

and what information did she get and what did she do with it - no mention of it anywhere!
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 10:30:04 PM
And I have yet to come across ANYONE who can explain Jenny Murat's

VW van on the seaside - inviting folks to give info about Madeleine's disappearance

who would not go to the police

THAT, frankly does not compute on any level

and what information did she get and what did she do with it - no mention of it anywhere!

Yep just like Antonio Cardoso's testimony (the cab driver) certain facets have been expunged down the Algarve
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: Redblossom on May 05, 2013, 10:35:27 PM
And I have yet to come across ANYONE who can explain Jenny Murat's

VW van on the seaside - inviting folks to give info about Madeleine's disappearance

who would not go to the police

THAT, frankly does not compute on any level

and what information did she get and what did she do with it - no mention of it anywhere!

Yep just like Antonio Cardoso's testimony (the cab driver) certain facets have been expunged down the Algarve

Which one? The original one that he saw her evening 3rd May or the revised version printed years later that he saw her 4th May, all in context of Pj doing nothing about it of course pffft
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 05, 2013, 11:03:16 PM
Did Murat do an interview with the Express about Birch?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 06:42:14 AM
And you don't understand the law about torts either. It was not an 'out ofcourt' settlement, it was a settlement agreed brfore a judge- a different thing entirely.

***

So sorry debunker I dont understand tort, I havent studied it, but do pls explain if the express journalists would face jail after an out of court settlement which was the question if they printed another unhelpful story

The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

But your comment about the McCann Express Case is wrong in fact.

If an action is brought in court and started, it becomes a concern of the court- the court nneds to ensure that the matter is settled once it is raised. In this case the Express decided not to defend the case and in orser to bring the action to a close, their lawyers went before the judge in open court, admitted that the complained about items were defamatory and described the offer they had made to the McCanns of Apology and Compensation.

Your statement that 'the McCanns got an out of court settlement' is in error. It is a myth promulgated by the [ censored word ]s in order to ameliorate the damage done to their cause by the Express judgement which showed that the headlines and stories were libel.

If a case is settled following a solicitors letter, that is an out of court settlement. This ettlement was a finding of defamation before a court- with the admission by the Express being comparable to a guilty plea in a criminal case.

Words matter.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 07:31:13 AM
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 07:45:39 AM
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

The original proceedings were for libel (a tort). He settled this by giving undertakings to the court. He breached these undertakings which is a criminal offence of contempt of court. He was given a susended sentence for this criminal offence.

I am open to correction but I believe that you cannot be imprisoned for a tort, only for the further criminal offence of contempt if you do not meet the requirements of the court.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 07:47:53 AM
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

The original proceedings were for libel (a tort). He settled this by giving undertakings to the court. He breached these undertakings which is a criminal offence of contempt of court. He was given a susended sentence for this criminal offence.

I am open to correction but I believe that you cannot be imprisoned for a tort, only for the further criminal offence of contempt if you do not meet the requirements of the court.

The case would have been heard in the Crown Court (criminal) if it had been a criminal matter.

It was heard in the High Court which is civil ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 07:54:35 AM
The Law of Tort is the law of civil action. Libel is a civil action; imprisonment is not a possible result in any case.

Proceedings against Bennett were civil and he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence.

The original proceedings were for libel (a tort). He settled this by giving undertakings to the court. He breached these undertakings which is a criminal offence of contempt of court. He was given a susended sentence for this criminal offence.

I am open to correction but I believe that you cannot be imprisoned for a tort, only for the further criminal offence of contempt if you do not meet the requirements of the court.

The case would have been heard in the Crown Court (criminal) if it had been a criminal matter.

It was heard in the High Court which is civil ...

Wrong. In almost every aspect.

The High Court has three parts: Chancery, Queens Bench Division, and the Family Division.

Part of the Queen's Bench Division is Criminal appeals, and QBD Judges travel to Crown Courts to hear the most important criminal Trials.

Crown Courts are local courts which replaced the previous circuit courts and hear most criminal matters above the Magistrates competence.

Cite:

http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/you-and-the-judiciary/going-to-court/high-court

I do not believe that you can any longer be imprisoned for a non criminal offence.


Corrected cite URL
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 08:02:26 AM
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 08:11:29 AM
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench

He was sentence for the CRIMINAL OFFENCE of contempt of court.

As noted above, the High Court covers both criminal and civil  cases.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 08:12:16 AM
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench

He was sentence for the CRIMINAL OFFENCE of contempt of court.

As noted above, the High Court covers both criminal and civil  cases.

No he was not!
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 08:19:13 AM
Madeline McCann's parents Gerry and Kate chat with a reporter
A RETIRED solicitor who published claims that Madeleine McCann’s parents caused her death received a suspended jail sentence today.

Mr Justice Tugendhat said 65-year-old Tony Bennett deliberately flouted legal undertakings, given in November 2009, not to repeat allegations about the couple.

He said his conduct was so serious that nothing less than a custodial sentence of three months suspended for one year would reflect the harm he had done.

Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court, the judge added: “I am sure that he intended to allege that the claimants are to be suspected of causing the death of their daughter, and did in fact dispose of her body, lie about what happened and covered up what they had done.”


The judge, at London’s High Court, said he was satisfied that Bennett, of Harlow, Essex, was in breach of the undertakings in each of the 13 representative instances before the court – out of 153 publications complained of.

He was not asked to make findings in relation to the other alleged breaches.

He commented: “It is essential for the rule of law that injunctions and court orders be obeyed. It can’t be an answer that the person who is giving an undertaking or subject to an injunction can ignore it with impunity while it is in force.”

Bennett, who was ordered to pay the costs of the litigation, apologised to the court.

He added: “I recognise the distress I have caused on a number of occasions to the claimants. I would like to apologise to them for that distress.”

The judge said that Gerry and Kate McCann, who have not attended court, had suffered injury to their reputations and feelings and resorted to legal action not to punish Mr Bennett – but to put a stop to his repeated conduct.

Later, Clarence Mitchell, the McCann family spokesman, said: “Kate and Gerry McCann brought these committal proceedings very much as a last resort.

“Mr Bennett has pursued an incessant campaign against them, repeatedly making false accusations against them, and ignoring the fact that the Portuguese authorities confirmed there was simply no evidence to implicate them in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.”

He added: “Kate and Gerry McCann are pleased with the Court’s decision today and hope that it finally marks an end to Mr Bennett’s campaign against them. The McCanns continue to focus their efforts on the ongoing search for their daughter Madeleine.”



Read more: Liverpool Echo http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/uk-world-news/2013/02/21/solicitor-who-claimed-madeleine-mccann-s-parents-caused-her-death-gets-suspended-jail-sentence-100252-32854630/#ixzz2SUemjxN6

Tugendhat is a High Court judge, not a Crown Court judge.

http://www.5rb.com/newsitem/Tugendhat-QC-appointed-to-the-Bench

He was sentence for the CRIMINAL OFFENCE of contempt of court.

As noted above, the High Court covers both criminal and civil  cases.

No he was not!

From your own quote of the Liverpool Echo:

"Finding Bennett guilty of contempt of court...."

Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 08:23:24 AM
Contempt of court

April 2004

13.28 Contempt of court - background and description

The term "contempt of court" is of ancient origin having been used in England certainly since the thirteenth century and probably earlier. At common law, a contempt is an act or omission calculated to interfere with the due administration of justice.

A person guilty of contempt is described as a contemnor.

 

13.29 Types of contempt


Contempt may be civil or criminal. The criminal standard of proof i.e. beyond reasonable doubt, applies to both (Dean v Dean [1987] 1 FLR 517 CA). A typical civil contempt might be conduct involving a breach, or assisting a breach, of a court order. Criminal contempts include assaulting a judge, or anyone else in court.
Failure to co-operate in the course of a public examination despite attendance at it may also constitute a contempt (Official Receiver v Cummings-John [2000] BPIR 320).

 

13.30 Penalties for contempt

The court's power to punish for contempt of court may be exercised by an order for committal to prison or by other means including a fine.

[Contempt of Court Act 1981]

Superior courts, e.g. the High Court can imprison for a fixed period of up to two years. The county and magistrates’ courts can imprison for up to one month.

 

13.31 Application for committal


Where a contempt occurs at court (sometimes called in the face of the court), the judge involved will generally deal with it. The High Court has jurisdiction to make an order of committal for contempt in the face of the court by its own motion , as does a judge of the county court. A district judge only has the power to make a committal order where it is specifically provided for under an enactment.
Notes: [CPR98 sch 1 RSC order 52 and practice direction RSC 52, CPR 98 sch 2 CCR order 29]

[County Court Act 1984 s118]

Otherwise, a written application must be made for committal (for contempt) on which the official receiver should consult Technical Section.

The application must state exactly what the alleged contemnor has done or omitted to do which constitutes a contempt of court with sufficient detail to enable him to meet the charge. The necessary information must be given in the notice itself. If lengthy particulars are required it is permissible to include them in a schedule or addendum to the notice, provided that they form part of the notice itself. It is not permissible to refer in the notice to a witness statement or other separate document for particulars which ought to be in the notice (Chiltern District Council v. Keane [1985] 1 W.L.R. 619, Harmsworth v. Harmsworth [1987] 1 W.L.R. 1676).

 

13.32 Purging

When a person is in contempt of court, he/she may cease to be so by apologising to the court, or "purging the contempt".

 

[Back to Part 2 - Persons required to co-operate] [Onto Part 4 - Public examination]


http://www.insolvencydirect.bis.gov.uk/freedomofinformation/technical/technicalmanual/Ch13-24/Chapter13/part3/part_3.htm
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 08:49:49 AM
A little learning is a dangerous thing.

There are two 'forms' of contempt- civil and criminal, but only one disposal- criminal.

The question to ask yourself is "Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record"
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 08:51:48 AM
A little learning is a dangerous thing.

There are two 'forms' of contempt- civil and criminal, but only one disposal- criminal.

The question to ask yourself is "Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record"

No.  Because his transgression was a civil one, for which he received a suspended prison sentence.

13.30 Penalties for contempt

The court's power to punish for contempt of court may be exercised by an order for committal to prison or by other means including a fine.

[Contempt of Court Act 1981]

Superior courts, e.g. the High Court can imprison for a fixed period of up to two years. The county and magistrates’ courts can imprison for up to one month.


Further Edit: the County Court is also civil (lower than the High Court).  It also has power to pass custodial sentences.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 09:00:03 AM
Exactly.

Now answer the question- Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 09:01:16 AM
Exactly.

Now answer the question- Does Tony Bennett have a criminal record?

No.  Because he was handed a (suspended) prison sentence for a civil violation.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 09:03:45 AM
"There are both civil and criminal components to the Act. The criminal offence of Contempt of Court carries a gaol sentence of up to two year and an unlimited fine."

http://www.inbrief.co.uk/legal-system/contempt-of-court-act.htm
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 09:06:33 AM
"Contempt of court is a criminal offence and carries severe penalties: an unlimited fine and/or up to two years imprisonment"

http://www.independentproducerhandbook.co.uk/72/5b-contempt-and-reporting-legal-proceedings/contempt-or-subjudice-rules.html
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 09:10:54 AM
"There are both civil and criminal components to the Act. The criminal offence of Contempt of Court carries a gaol sentence of up to two year and an unlimited fine."

http://www.inbrief.co.uk/legal-system/contempt-of-court-act.htm

That is all about breach of sub judice in active proceedings.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 09:19:07 AM
"There are both civil and criminal components to the Act. The criminal offence of Contempt of Court carries a gaol sentence of up to two year and an unlimited fine."

http://www.inbrief.co.uk/legal-system/contempt-of-court-act.htm

That is all about breach of sub judice in active proceedings.

Which is civil contempt- punishable by two years in gaol. The 'Civil' distiction merely separates background contempt (refusal to comply with court orders) from contempt in the face of the court. Both may be dealt with formally or informally. If dealt with formally they may involve criminal sanction such as fines or imprisonment that are not available for torts!

There is a good quote that I cam across that sums up the problem you have:

"As birds go, contempt of court is a strange one. Perhaps rather than birds, one should think platypus, that peculiar Australian mammal that lays eggs. That's because contempt of court quacks like a civil duck but walks like a criminal one."

Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 09:25:43 AM
I was (originally) of the same view as you.

It was actually (of all people!) Tony Bennett himself in debate who corrected me.

I researched it, discovered he as right and conceded the point.

You should do the same ...

And yes, the platypus is (I think) the only exception of a mammal that lays eggs.

It is still an egg-laying mammal

Same as prison for (civil) contempt is a prison sentence, for a civil violation ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 10:04:05 AM
I was (originally) of the same view as you.

It was actually (of all people!) Tony Bennett himself in debate who corrected me.

I researched it, discovered he as right and conceded the point.

You should do the same ...

And yes, the platypus is (I think) the only exception of a mammal that lays eggs.

It is still an egg-laying mammal

Same as prison for (civil) contempt is a prison sentence, for a civil violation ...

I think you will find that Tony Bennett was splitting hairs to save face (as usual). It is a principle of English Law for over a century that you cannot be detained or fined for a tort. Imprisonment is a coercive response to breaches of the criminal law. Although there are two 'types' of contempt, there is only one disposal if detention is necessitated.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 02:53:41 PM
I've finally sussed the source of Debunker's confusion

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_difference_between_civil_offense_and_criminal_offense

(sic)

2. The loser in a civil case cannot be imprisoned, even if he or she cannot pay the damages.

One small problem: Debunker is citing American law, not English.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 03:25:20 PM
I've finally sussed the source of Debunker's confusion

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_difference_between_civil_offense_and_criminal_offense

(sic)

2. The loser in a civil case cannot be imprisoned, even if he or she cannot pay the damages.

One small problem: Debunker is citing American law, not English.

I am not citing American Law.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 03:31:28 PM
I've finally sussed the source of Debunker's confusion

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_difference_between_civil_offense_and_criminal_offense

(sic)

2. The loser in a civil case cannot be imprisoned, even if he or she cannot pay the damages.

One small problem: Debunker is citing American law, not English.

I am not citing American Law.

One dead give-away is the spelling of offence (standard British English) as offense (standard US English)

Here's the other (from the link)

3. State or federal statutes always establish criminal law.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: DCI on May 06, 2013, 03:47:13 PM
Can I ask, what all this has got to do with the title of the thread?.  >@@(*&)
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 03:58:05 PM
Fair question.

The diversion stemmed from this series of exchanges:

What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter


I'm not sure that the Express and the McCanns are the best of friends...


(my post):

I think I'm right that The Express has to tread carefully with the McCanns because, having libelled them once, the editor could actually go to prison if the paper transgresses a second time.

I think that's the case, an impression I gained from somewhere. 

Perhaps Jean Pierre could help us out here?


Then Debunker insisted there could not be imprisonment for civil matters and it went from there ...
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 04:03:58 PM
Have checked all my cites. No legal ones were US ones.

You also mis-state the use of 'offence' between US and UK (and other) usage. It is far more complicated than that. I write and speak both received southern English and Standard American English and am quite aware of the differences.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Jean-Pierre on May 06, 2013, 04:04:48 PM
My understanding of the position is that in the case of contempt of court occasioned by breach of an undertaking (in this case the proceedings must be triggered by the offended party, as opposed to the court itself), the court does not seek to punish the contemptnor, merely to do whatever is necessary to prevent further breaches.

One of the remedies is a term of imprisonment.  However, all the contemptnor has to do to be released is to agree to comply with the undertaking - he is therefore held to be "in possession of the keys to his own cell".

Thereforer Bennett does not have a criminal record. 
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 04:12:52 PM
My understanding of the position is that in the case of contempt of court occasioned by breach of an undertaking (in this case the proceedings must be triggered by the offended party, as opposed to the court itself), the court does not seek to punish the contemptnor, merely to do whatever is necessary to prevent further breaches.

One of the remedies is a term of imprisonment.  However, all the contemptnor has to do to be released is to agree to comply with the undertaking - he is therefore held to be "in possession of the keys to his own cell".

Thereforer Bennett does not have a criminal record.

According to the current review of the Law of Comtent, the case law has become so complicated that it no longer makes any sense and is difficult to decide what is in fact the case.

http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/criminal/docs/invitation-to-comment.pdf
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactm
Post by: faithlilly on May 06, 2013, 04:33:21 PM
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Where do you think SY got, eight important new leads, from?

I presume from the same place they got the 195 from last year that didn't come to anything.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: faithlilly on May 06, 2013, 04:39:35 PM
Quote
“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again.

Is Bob saying that he has information that he has not given previously?

Call the McCann's party timeline labyrinthine?

Bob's movements on that night are labyrinthine with a Hampton Court maze thrown in

NOTHING fits

Let's hope he'll explain

Yet he's happy to do a reconstruction

... unlike the Tapas crew

The McCanns and friends were more than happy to do a recon in May 2007 when events would have been fresh in their minds... it was kyboshed by the PJ.  When the holiday friends were asked to return in 2008 it had become clear that the PJs motives were to stitch up Kate and Gerry McCann, so the holiday party quite rightly refused.

The point,   is that it is Murat who is asking for a reconstruction 'now'  ( under Scotland Yard's auspices )  ...  the McCanns and their buds are not


And? Murat has no business asking for a reconstruction - he wasn't there when Madeleine went missing, so what has it got to do with him?. It's not for him to ask for a recon.  The McCanns and the holiday party were more than willing in May 2007 but the ever-bungling PJ put the brakes on it.

Who says the McCanns were willing to do a reconstruction in 2007 ? Perhaps it was simply fortuitous for them that the PJ did decline to do one just after the disappearance ?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 05:18:31 PM
My understanding of the position is that in the case of contempt of court occasioned by breach of an undertaking (in this case the proceedings must be triggered by the offended party, as opposed to the court itself), the court does not seek to punish the contemptnor, merely to do whatever is necessary to prevent further breaches.

One of the remedies is a term of imprisonment.  However, all the contemptnor has to do to be released is to agree to comply with the undertaking - he is therefore held to be "in possession of the keys to his own cell".

Thereforer Bennett does not have a criminal record.

From Debuker's link:

b. civil contempt involves disobedience of a court order or undertaking by a
party who is bound by it. The court’s sanction in civil contempt has been seen
primarily as coercive or remedial. Civil contempt has largely arisen in respect
of an order or undertaking made in civil litigation. However, as some civil
orders now are made in criminal cases, for example the restraint order
considered in R v M, a civil contempt may occur in the course of proceedings
in a criminal court.
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 05:25:58 PM
Quote
Faithlilly

Who says the McCanns were willing to do a reconstruction in 2007 ? Perhaps it was simply fortuitous for them that the PJ did decline to do one just after the disappearance ?

thankyou for confirming that the PJ declined to do one just after the disappearance - you know - the time when it would have had maximum effect!
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 05:28:09 PM
Quote
Faithlilly

Who says the McCanns were willing to do a reconstruction in 2007 ? Perhaps it was simply fortuitous for them that the PJ did decline to do one just after the disappearance ?

thankyou for confirming that the PJ declined to do one just after the disappearance - you know - the time when it would have had maximum effect!

Of "establishing guilt or innocence"?

"Maximum effect"?

Is there anywhere else that uses reconstructions for such a purpose?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 05:28:49 PM
For some reason the tapas group are criticised for not going back to do a reconstruction - to prove their innocence.

Where is the criticism of the PJ for declining to do a reconstruction to help trying to find a missing child shortly after the event?
Title: Re: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 06:10:34 PM
For some reason the tapas group are criticised for not going back to do a reconstruction - to prove their innocence.

Where is the criticism of the PJ for declining to do a reconstruction to help trying to find a missing child shortly after the event?

It's them blooming planes, you know.  The ones that fly over Praia da Luz all the blooming time.  Don't know how The PJ were going to stop that in 2008.
Although as far as I can remember, Amaral said that The PJ didn't DO Reconstructions, possibly due to all them blooming planes.

And at what point in time did the Tapas Group have to prove their innocence?  None of them were ever made Arguidos.

And if I had received the sort of Email replies that The Tapas Group got from Rebelo, you wouldn't have seen me on the same Continent as Portugal.  The Tapas Group were refused any assurances, and could have been Arguidos the minute they landed. 
No thank you.