Author Topic: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment  (Read 42788 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline muratfan

Think it would be better to wait for the whole story to appear

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.

He must be really pissed at being named as a suspect by members of the tapas 9.  It must have damaged his business interests no end and after he went out of his way to assist them?  There's gratitude for you?

That could be a motive. Alternatively he may have got wind that they are once again interested in him as a suspect. We can but guess at this stage.

Or maybe the papers have got wind of something  ...  is there a possibility, do you think,  that Scotland Yard are already considering doing a reconstruction ?

Offline muratfan

Oh dear some ......... arwe getting in a tizz over this. Wonder how they will react when they read the story? Wonder why he speaks out now??

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Oh dear some ......... arwe getting in a tizz over this. Wonder how they will react when they read the story? Wonder why he speaks out now??

And why is the Express quoting him now ? 

It's been years since there was a front page headline as  'McCann unfriendly'  as that !

debunker

  • Guest
Looks like that was an early edition Front Page Filler. Current article is completely different emphasis:

http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle




Police must keep up effort to solve Madeleine riddle

SIX years have now passed since Madeleine McCann went missing during a family holiday in Portugal.

Published: Sun, May 5, 2013


It is now six years since Madeleine McCann went missing

Despite their unimaginable suffering, parents Kate and Gerry have campaigned without rest to keep their daughter's case in the public eye and maintain pressure on the police for that vital resolution.

So we can only hope that the couple are justified in their current belief that a significant breakthrough in the case is just around the corner.

In two years, the £4.5million case review by homicide detectives at Scotland Yard has failed to shed new light on events of that evening in 2007 or to persuade the Portuguese authorities to reopen the investigation.

No one expects Operation Grange to provide a running commentary on its review but revelations that Scotland Yard has yet to interview key witness and former suspect Robert Murat must surely raise questions.

The search must continue for Madeleine McCann

No matter how terrible the case, Scotland Yard must account for the public money being spent in pursuit of the truth.

Mr Murat has rebuilt his life since he was cleared of all suspicion over Madeleine's disappearance and stands ready and willing to help.

He cannot understand why a full reconstruction of the night has not been conducted and believes other key witnesses have also not been reinterviewed.

No matter how terrible the case, Scotland Yard must account for the public money being spent in pursuit of the truth.

Questions must be asked as to whether all key witnesses will be reinterviewed and, if not, why not? The passage of time must not render the search for Madeleine any less exhaustive.


http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle
« Last Edit: May 05, 2013, 08:32:13 AM by John »

Offline gilet

Not so.

Oddly the Express have put up three separate McCann stories within the last two hours.  Yours was just the first of the three to be posted.

The headline story begins exactly as the front page shown last night did.



http://www.express.co.uk/comment/expresscomment/397203/Police-must-keep-up-effort-to-solve-Madeleine-riddle



http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397235/McCanns-light-candles-for-April-Jones-at-emotional-service



http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397244/Bring-them-all-back-to-Portugal

ferryman

  • Guest
He [murat] cannot understand why a full reconstruction of the night has not been conducted and believes other key witnesses have also not been reinterviewed.

Murat would not be privy to that information.

I think this is The Express fishing for a slant ...

Offline gilet

http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/397244/Bring-them-all-back-to-Portugal

'Bring them all back to Portugal’

ROBERT MURAT today appeals for Scotland Yard to stage a filmed reconstruction of all the events surrounding the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

By: James Murray
Published: Sun, May 5, 2013


 Robert Murat was cleared as a suspect long ago (Sunday Express photographer Mark Kehoe)

Marking the sixth anniversary of her abduction, the Algarve-based businessman says a 48-hour timeline would help police conducting a £4.5million review of the case.

Mr Murat, who was cleared as a suspect, said: “They need to start from the beginning.” So far the two-year review by more than 20 detectives in London has not led to a breakthrough.

Portugal’s authorities have not been persuaded to reopen the investigation, although Policia Judiciaria policewoman Helena Monteiro liaises regularly with officers from the Yard’s Operation Grange.

Mr Murat, 39, spoke to the Sunday Express while sipping tea in Casa ¬Liliana, his elderly mother Jenny’s villa 150 yards from apartment 5a of the Ocean Club where Madeleine vanished.

He said: “They need to speak to everybody, including myself, and they need to get the Portuguese involved in a much more constructive way.

“To get somewhere now they need to have a joint team working here together in Praia da Luz. This is where it happened. It didn’t happen in England.

“The reconstruction should cover the critical period just before and after the abduction.”

Madeleine was three when she disappeared from the apartment at about 9.15pm while her parents Kate and Gerry McCann and seven friends ate at a tapas bar nearby. When the Judiciaria named the McCanns as suspects, they and their friends chose not to take part in a PJ-led reconstruction. It would be different now that they have been cleared, said Mr Murat.

He said: “A reconstruction is a real necessity. I am sure it would fill in some of the missing pieces of the jigsaw. Even now after all this time, the timeline is still confused.”

Thirteen days after Madeleine’s disappearance Mr Murat was named as a suspect. His mother’s home, where he lived then, was searched, his computers were taken, he was questioned for 19 hours by Portuguese police and his property business was wrecked.

His eagerness to help with the original investigation, helping police with translations, aroused a journalist’s suspicions. Three of the McCanns’ friends believed they saw him on the night Madeleine vanished but his mother confirmed to police he was with her all night at Casa Liliana.

After being cleared as a suspect in July 2008 he won substantial damages from newspapers.

Despite his ordeal he believes Madeleine’s fate should be uppermost in everybody’s minds as another anniversary passes.

He said: “You cannot lose sight of the fact that a child was taken and we need to know what happened to her.”
He is still willing to be interviewed by the review team, which has made no effort to contact him. “I have no problem with that whatsoever,” he said emphatically.

“I am available to help on the proper legal basis. I think everybody who was around at that time, holidaymakers and people at the Ocean Club, should be interviewed again. The timeline needs to be made crystal clear because there is still so much confusion, such a mess.”


 Madeleine aged three in Everton shirt

“Police need to be here, not England “ - Robert Murat

Asked if he thought Madeleine’s fate would ever be known, he brushed back his thick dark brown hair, rubbed his tanned chin and said: “I hope so, I believe it will come out one day.” He said Portugal’s financial crisis means “if the British do want to get to the bottom of this, it is a case of funding the Portuguese”.

Mr Murat, who grew up in Devon and Portugal, now has a young family with wife Michaela. They were both victims of the relentless media frenzy when Madeleine vanished and it has left its scars. For the first time during the interview he became emotional and said in a whisper: “There is no way to describe the impact this has had on our lives. Six years later it still affects me. I wasn’t able to do much for years and years.

“It was difficult getting back on the horse, so to speak, and do the stuff I was doing before.”

His property business went, partly because his computers were held by the PJ for so long, but now he has built up Newteq, an Apple-authorised service provider on the Algarve. He said he and Michaela live a quiet life, staying away from some events because people still come up to him and say: “You’re that Mr Murat.”

Before 2007 he says he was one of those people who was always eager to help others, to get involved in the community. Now he is more guarded.

When the original police investigation was at its height, he bumped into a British man, Steve Carpenter, who persuaded him to meet the McCanns because they needed his language skills. He said: “I met Gerry and said: ‘I don’t know what to say, there is nothing I can say but I do speak Portuguese and English and I will help in any way I can’.”

He helped Portugal’s GNR military officers to search the Ocean Club apartments and translated statements from key witnesses, giving him a unique inside perspective on the case.

He said: “From the experiences of the interviews there are some points that could be looked at.

“There needs to be much more transparency, much more openness to dissipate a lot of the stuff that has been talked about on the internet and on blogs.”

He does not believe the results of the Yard’s work should be made available to the public.

“The Yard needs to get together with the Portuguese police and ¬produce a final report,” he said. “They need to sit down together and come up with a final version, a structured report.

“The report should be done by the Portuguese with the support of the British.”

Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead.

On Friday night Kate and Gerry, both 45, gathered around a candle which burns night and day for Madeleine outside their home village of Rothley, Leicestershire. A 50-strong crowd supported them as they marked the anniversary with prayers with Madeleine’s ¬siblings, eight-year-old twins Sean and Amelie.

Mr Murat said: “It must be a ¬tremendously difficult time of year for them and of course as a human being you feel for them and for the loss of their daughter.

“At this time of year, like so many people on the Algarve, we have been thinking about this poor girl.

“I just hope in the months ahead the PJ are fully involved because in my view that is the best way of solving the mystery.”

At St Vincent’s church in Praia da Luz, where Kate and Gerry went regularly, worshippers also prayed for Madeleine, whose 10th birthday is on May 12.

Clarence Mitchell, the McCanns’ spokesman, declined to comment on Mr Murat’s views last night, saying the couple were happy with how Scotland Yard is conducting the review.

« Last Edit: May 05, 2013, 08:24:38 AM by gilet »

Offline gilet

He [murat] cannot understand why a full reconstruction of the night has not been conducted and believes other key witnesses have also not been reinterviewed.

Murat would not be privy to that information.

I think this is The Express fishing for a slant ...

He is probably simply referring to other people he personally knows from the PDL area. If they told him that they had not been contacted by the review team it would be reasonable for him to suppose that they were telling him the truth.

As for your second point about fishing for a slant. I agree but not for the reason you have suggested.


Offline John

Icabodcrane.   You mentioned something about Scotland Yard earlier.  Just for clarity, Scotland Yard has nothing to do with Scotland.  Scotland Yard relates to the headquarters of the Metropolitan Police Service, the territorial police force responsible for policing most of London.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scotland_Yard   
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline John

My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline gilet

It looks like the Express were determined to fill today's paper with McCann stories. They managed three separate angles and put them all up within an hour and a half this morning. Interesting.

The headline (front page of the print edition) story about Murat is one angle. They have gone out to PDL to interview him about his current position on the case.

HIs view seems to be that the Review done solely in London is not sufficient, that the PJ should be involved, that the UK police should work with the PJ in Portugal, that the UK should pay for the PJ to become involved and that a full videoed reconstruction should be part of their involvement.

I don't think anyone can really argue against any of those propositions. It probably is the best way forward.

It is a great shame that the PJ refused point blank to conduct such a reconstruction when people would have been available, when the events were uppermost in the minds of all involved and when far more people were present in PDL who could participate just a few weeks after the disappearance.

I have a recollection of an interview Murat gave previously in which he suggested he was not enamoured of the methods of the PJ in this case and I wonder if his desire to have UK police involvement relates to this?  I wonder if he would prefer them to be involved in questioning of the witnesses, in the organisation of a reconstruction etc. I suspect the McCanns would have similar views too.

One interesting point they stress twice (in the article and in the photo tag) is that he was cleared. As the only clearing occurred in the Archival Dispatch when all three arguidos had that title lifted from them it would appear to mean that the Express believe that the McCanns were also cleared at the same time.

And another interesting point is that there was no attempt to get any comment from the PJ or SY about the story.

debunker

  • Guest
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Offline gilet

"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

debunker

  • Guest
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.